Hash Hardware Performance Study
Hash Hardware Performance Study
24365(387$9;:<9!=6>@?BADCFE896GIH)38JLKM9!E8NOH)38P)9;CLQSRT=U9;VF?XWY?
Z$RTV89;>@[\:&R%E6[-];^-_]`:&VFKI[\RT>bacQd?YRTE8QdR
2O?BQeCF?Yfg9;E+a [e9![\RihjEF?Xk RT>eAD?Y[Dl
H9UAm[onp9;E8AD?YEFfIGq2+rtsgu`u`v!s
w >e9!:<96G ^xKFR GFy89!C8QSRT=U9;V{z`|bQdV8AS3}:<AmKp3}R!N6K
&~ S!!F`
b9UAmCF?XEFf4?BA K8AmR!NRTc[\RTE8AD?Yk RTWXl?XEC89;>N6)9!>\R9!VFVFWY?QT9;[@?Y]UE8AADK8QeC9`AV89!f`R+[9;yFWXR!A^x]`>
9UNFN6>\RA\A[@>e9!E8AmW9;[\?X]`Ep3CFRT>@R(?BAbEF]`[i:KLQC<WY?X[\RT>9;[@KF>\R(?XE[@CF?BAb>\R%f 9;>N9!WY[@CF]`KFfUC4C89UAmCF?XEFf
C89UAy8RTRTERTc[\R%E8Am?Xk RTWYlAm[@K8N6?YRN1^x]`> 8WYRM]`>\fg9;EF?X!9;[@?Y]UEp32O]`>@RAmV8R!QS?QT9;WXWYl G[\CIRT>\RM?BAEF]
AD[\K8N6lM];^-[\CIR(VF>e9UQS[\?QT9;WV8RT>m^x]U>\:<9!E8QSR]!^-C89`ADCF?YEFf&^xKFELQS[\?X]`E8A)K8AmRNq3rEM[\CFR(WX?Y[\R%>e9;[@KF>\RiR
8ELNyF?Y[ RTc[\>e9UQS[\?X]`E9;E8NRTIQSWXK8Am?Xk ROo7 ?XEFf4C89UAmCF?XEFf^xKFE8Qd[\?Y]UE8AK8ADR!NqG)yFKF[ [\CIRT>\RM?BAEF]
:&R%E6[@?Y]`EM];^[\CFR V8RT>m^x]U>\:<9!E8QSR(];^[\CFRAmR^xKFE8Qd[\?Y]UE8AS32O]`>@RT]!k RT>TGq[@CFR(V8RT>m^x]U>\:<9!E8QSR(]!^)[\CIR
C89UAmCF?XEFf&^xKFE8QS[@?Y]UE8Ab?YE+>\R%WB9;[@?Y]UE+[\]&[@CFR[@CFRT]U>\RT[@?BQT9!W V8RT>D^x]`>\:¡9;E8QSRi];^C89`ADCF?YEFfMA@QCFR%:&R!A?BA
EF]U[&9UNFN6>@R!A\ADR!Nq3rE[\CF?AV89;V8RT> RMAm[@K8N6l[\CIRVI>e9`Qd[\?BQ%9;WV8RT>D^x]`>@:<9;E8QdR&];^i9OVL9;>\[@?BQSKIWB9;>
QSW9`A@Aj];^C89`ADCF?YEFf&^xKFELQS[\?X]`E8Ad3$KF>>\R!ADKFWY[AbAmCF]!¢[\C89![ycl+QeCF] ]gAm?YEIf¡^xKIE8QS[\?X]`E8A$>e9;ELN6]`:&WXl
^x>@]`:£[\CI?BAtQSW9`A@A¤]!^pC89UAmCF?XEFf^xKIE8QS[\?X]`E8AdG )CF?BQeC QT9;E y8Rj>@R!9`Nc?YWYl?X:&VFWYR%:&RSEc[\RN¥?XE(C89;>N6)9!>\R G
-RQT9;E¡9`QeCF?YRTk Ro9;EL9;WYlc[\?QT9;WXWYliVF>\R!Nc?BQS[@R!NV8RT>D^x]`>@:<9;E8QdRb];^C89UAmCF?XEFf A\QeCFRT:R!A )?Y[@C<>\R!9!W¦WX?§^xR
NF9![e9c3
Proc. ICCI’94, 1621-1636 1994 Int. Conf. on Computing and Information
¡ tO$T&
b9UAmCF?XEFf4?A9)?N6RTWXl4K8AmRN [\RQCFEI? KFR<];^i]`>@f 9;EI?YT?XEFf[9;yFWXR!A)CF?QC 9!WBAm]8E8NFA&ADRTk RT>9;W
9!VFVFWY?QT9;[@?Y]UE8A?YE C89;>N6)9!>\R 3 JF]`> RTF9!:&VFWXR G C89UAmC [e9;yIWYR!A(9!>\ROKLAmR!N[\]+?Y:VFWYRT:RSEc[V89;fUR
9!WYWYR%W)C89`ADCF?YEFfC89!>eN69;>@R s 3 jWX[\CF]UKFf`CCL9`AmCI?YEFf4?A)?BNcRTWYl4KLAmR!N?XEC89!>eN69;>\RgGj[\CIRT>\R
9!E6l&VL9;V8RT>$N6R!9!WY?XEFf()?Y[@C[@CFRV8RT>m^x]U>\:<9!E8QSRb]!^tC89UAmCF?XEFf(^xKFE8QS[@?Y]`ELA)AmKF?X[e9;yIWYRj^x]U>jC89!>eN69;>@R
?X:&VFWYR%:RTEc[@9;[@?Y]`E{3)rE+9;WXW [@CFRCL9;>eNc)9;>@R 9;VFVIWY?BQ%9;[\?X]`E8A)];^-C89UAmCF?XEFf&-RC89Tk RRTE8QS]UKFEc[\RT>@R!NqG
C89UAmC 9UNFN6>\RA\A ?Aq]`yF[9;?YEIR!Ny6l¥Am?Y:VFWYRtyI?Y[RT6[@>e9UQS[\?X]`E]`>RTIQSWYK8AD?Yk Ro7)?YEFf$];^LyF?Y[ AmRTfU:&RTEc[eAd3
CFR%>\R?A EF]b>@RTV8]`>@[t];^[\CIR)V¦R%>m^x]`>@:<9;ELQSR];^{9;Ecl]!^q[@CFRCL9`AmCI?YEFfb^xKFE8Qd[\?Y]UE8AS3 CF?BA?BApC89;>N6WYl
ADKF>\VF>@?BAD?YEFfIGtAm?XE8QSR RTk RTEO^x]U>AD];^x[D)9!>\R<9!VFVFWX?BQT9![\?Y]UE[@CFRT>@R?A¥EI]`[: K8QeCOWX?Y[\R%>e9;[@KF>\R(]UE4[\CIR
V8RT>D^x]`>\:¡9;E8QSR ];^IC89`ADCF?YEFf)^xKFE8Qd[\?Y]UE8A G 3 rE[\CI?BAqV89!V¦R%>TG!RAD[\K8N6lo[\CFRV8RT>m^x]U>\:<9!E8QSRt]!^89
V89!>\[@?BQSKFW9;>QdWB9`A@At];^pCL9`AmCI?YEFfb^xKFE8Qd[\?Y]UE8A )CF?QC Q%9;E y¦R$>\R9`N6?XWYl?Y:&VIWYRT: RTEc[\R%N¥?XE(C89;>N6)9!>\R 3
RTI9`Qd[\WYl([@CFR$[\CFRT]U>\RT[@?BQT9!WYWXlVF>@R!N6?BQd[\R!N(V8RT>m^x]U>\:<9!E8QSR)];^CL9`AmCI?YEFfI3 RbVF>@];kc?BNcRbQS]U:&V89!>\?BAD]`E
21 /
[@RT>\:&?XEF]`WX]`fUl G u 3
/
]UEOC89UAmCF?XEFf)?X[\C
9 : <;
>=
?@BACEDF.F5G7HJI3KLCMKNKO6DQP<RNKDSOTKDFVUXWYW)D<AZS[\AC^]#RU<_ND<_AZF5AZS`GQSa[!KU<RGbI9[!KCI3Kdcfe Kg[hDeN[ji
1622
[!KRNKZW)U<RtKe)mNDS SXKRneS%U<RDPTKLIU<c<F5O _ KQAChD ]<]#RuU ]#RADSXKYW)U<Rnm KtRtS`D<ACRtKDF2i%S`AklKdD ]<]!F5AmNDS`AU<C e
eF5AsKue0D<RtKvDS3eS`D<K
pn 9;[@RT>?XE Uu `G $]UEFEFRT[-AmCI];-R!N([\C89![)AmKLQC(^xR!9;>AtRT>@R)y89`ADRTWYR!A@AAm?YELQSR)[\CFR$VF>@]`y89!yF?YWX?Y[Dl
e)cjmt[^DegD<ARS%RDXopm mNU<CTS`RuUFH3I9[!KRtK{]!KU ]!FZK
Q
1623
:&R%:&]`>@l49UNFN6>\RA\AmRA[\]4]cQ%QSKF>&>9;E8N6]U:&WYly8RT[DR%RTE[@CFR+[D]:&RT:&]U>\lQT9;>NFAS3PRTEIC89`ADR
N6RA\QS>@?Yy8R!AtK8AmRo];^C89UAmCMQS?Y>QSKF?X[eAt9!E8N<N6?Y>@R!QS[\]U>\l^x]U>)NF9![e99UQTQSR!A@A¤^x>@]`: 9Am[@]`>9;f`RCF?XRT>e9!>eQeC6l
Tv 3 AD?Y:&?XWB9!> eo9`AmC9;E8N+QeC89!?YE ([\R!QeCFEF? KIRb?Y:&VIWYRT: RTEc[\R%N?XEOC89!>eN69;>\R([@]&9UNFN6>@R!A\Ab9
QT9UQCIRb]`EZj?Y>@R!QS[ 9`Q%QSR!A\A)AD[\]U>e9;fUR(N6R%k6?QSR!A9`A)K8AmRN¡ycl<7)]`yF?XE8Am]UE+9!E8NO9Tl6WX]`> 3
5 {
?XE6[@]49+V89;fUR+N6?X>\R!Qd[\]`>@l4[e9!yFWYRg3 CFRTE9:<9;[QC?BA^x]`KFE8N[\CFRQS]`>@>\R!ADV8]`E8N6?XEFf4VFCclIAm?BQ%9;W
Q
1624
ADKFf`fUR!Am[@R!N C89UAmC xyF?X[(RT6[@>e9UQS[\?X]`E^x]U>([\CFR<C89UAmCF?XEFf ^xKIE8QS[\?X]`E9!E8N K89UN6>e9![\?BQ VF>\]UyF?YEFf+^x]`>
QS]UWYWX?BAm?X]`E4>@R!Am]UWYKF[@?Y]UEp3 j]+>\R!ADR!9;>QC19;y8]`KF[ [\CIR&V8RT>m^x]U>\:<9!E8QSR&]!^b[@CFR&C89UAmCF?XEFf ^xKIE8QS[\?X]`E8A
E
^xKFELQS[\?X]`Ep3
rE([\CFR-EFRTc[AmRQS[\?X]`E-R?XE6[@>\]cN6K8QdR$9bQSWB9UA\A ]!^C89`ADCF?YEFfb^xKFELQS[\?X]`E8AdG QT9;WXWYR!N #%y6l(_-9;>@[\RT>
9!E8N R%f`:<9!E 3 R(ADCF]![\C89![by6l¡QCF] ]gAm?XEFf&^xKFE8QS[@?Y]`ELA >9;E8N6]U:&WYl ^x>\]`:,[@CF?BA$QSWB9UA\Aj]!^
C89UAmCF?XEFf^xKFELQS[\?X]`E8AdGq[\CFRi[\CFR%]`>\R%[\?BQ%9;WYWXl&VF>@R!N6?BQd[\R!N&V8RT>m^x]U>\:<9!E8QSR];^-C89UAmCF?XEFf<A@QCFR%:&R!A)QT9!E
/ 21 /
w e"v ! Uz
;
jR%>\R ?A [@CFREcKF: y¦R%>)];^-yF?Y[A ?XEO[@CFR= RTl¡9;E8$N #&?A [@CFREcKF: y¦R%>)];^-yF?Y[A ?XEO[@CFR(9UNFN6>\RA\AS3
CFRiQSW9`A@A #%$?BA)N6Rd8EFR!N<9`A^x]`WXWY]!$A
g"
^xKFELQS[\?X]`E8A)9!E8NC89UAmC9`NFN6>@R!A\A$QT9!WBQSKFW9;[@?Y]`ELAS3
?A@4 BDCFEHG1I
1626
nqRT[ y8R(u 9;ELN$#&y¦R 63$CFRTEM[\CFRi9UNFN6>\RA\AbADV89`QSRi?BA! w v cz 9;E8NO[@CFR= RTl
ADV89`QSR?A w z 3 R>9;E8Nc]`:&WXl&QeCF] ] ADRi9;E+u$' (:<9![\>\?X$)
v" w ;
; 1 / b j=
;
; ;T
)
);T
;j
);;
; ;T
; ;;
1627
:<9![\>@?Y)&QT9!E+y¦R f`R%EFRT>e9![\R!N+?YEAD];^x[D)9!>\R 9!E8N[\CIRTE+WY]g9`N6R!N+?YEc[\][\CFR(y89!EF=+];^>\RTfU?BAD[\RT>AS3
CFRiQS?X>eQSKI?Y[?A)AmRTW^tR%6VFW9;E89![\]U>\l<9!E8N-R)?XWYWEF]`[)RTW9;y8]`>9;[@R^xKF>@[\CFRT>%3
x1 x2 x3
q1,1 q1,2
q2,1 q2,2
a1
q3,1 q3,2
a2
1628
8
$ KF>&CclcV¦]U[\CFRAm?BA ?BA[@C89;[&ycl QCI] ] Am?XEFfC89`ADCF?YEIf1^xKIE8QS[\?X]`E8A9;[&>9;E8N6]U: ^x>@]`: [@CFRQSW9`A\A
# % Gq[@CFR 9;EL9;WYlc[\?QT9;W V¦R%>m^x]`>@:<9;ELQSR]!^CL9`AmCI?YEFfMA\QeCFRT:R!A)QT9;Ey8R 9`QeCF?YR%k R!N?XEOVF>9`QS[@?BQSR(]UE
>@R!9;W-WY?§^xR(8WXR!AS3 R<QT9;E)>@?Y[\R¡9OWYRTEFfU[\Ccl+RTcVFWB9!E89;[@?Y]`E DK8Am[@?§QT9![\?X]`E $^x]`>([\CI?BASGtyIKF[(R
^xRTR%Wt[\C89![?BAj?X>\>\R%WYRTkU9;Ec[j^x]U>[@CF?BA$V89;V8RT> G 3(rE]`>N6RT>[\]<k RT>@?§^xl<[\CF?AjCcl6V8]`[@CFR!AD?BASGR
6/
QS]UE8N6K8Qd[\R!N(9bADRT>\?XR!Ap];^pR%6V8RT>@?Y:&RTEc[eA8]`E(>@R!9;WFWX?§^xRNF9;[9ADRT[eAd3$yck6?X]`K8ADWYlRN6]EF]`[tEIRTR!N[\]
1)
= RTlIA9;>@Rb[\CFR%EC89UAmCFRNK8Am?XEFf([\CIRjC89UAmCF?XEFf^xKFE8Qd[\?Y]UEp3tCIRAmR!9!>eQeCWXRTEFfU[\C8A-9;>\R¥QS]`:&VIKF[\R!N3
Y
8WXR!AS3
rER!9UQCRTcV8RT>\?X:&RTEc[TG]`EFRM];^[@CFRO= RTlIACL9`A[@CFROWX]`EFfUR!Am[AmR!9!>eQeCWYRTEFfU[\Cp3CFR+QS]U>
>@R!AmV8]`ELN6?YEFfkU9;WXKFR<?BAEF]U[\R!Nq3CIRO9Tk RT>9;fURkU9!WYKFR<];^o[\CIRWXRTEFfU[\C];^o[\CFR<WX]`EFfUR!Am[(VF>@]`y8R
u
,q, E* ;
1629
kU9;WXKFR!Aj)CIRTE+[\CFRiE6KI:y8RT>$];^-= RTlIA CL9`AmCIR!NO?BA L6R!NM9;[ cG 9!E8N+yFK8Qe= RT[$Am?XTR(9!E8N WX] 9UN
^ 9UQS[\]U>bQeC89;EIf`R 3$CFRiRT6V8RT>@?Y:&R%E6[9;W8>\R!ADKFWY[A^x]`> 9!>\Ri]`yF[9;?YEIR!N+9`QTQd]`>eNc?YEFfUWYl^x]U>j[9;yFWXR
L; ;;
c3
, , E*
J ?Xf`KF>@R vVFWX]`[A[\CIR&VF>\]Uy89;yI?YWY?X[DlN6?BAD[\>\?XyFKF[@?Y]`E];^$[\CIR&WYRTEIf`[\C];^$[\CIR&WY]UEFf`R!AD[VF>@]`y8R
{, , h* X, , E*
¡b0!%&
CFR%>\R?AEF]&WX?Y[\R%>e9;[@KF>\R !N6R!A@QS>\?XVF[\?X]`E&]!^-[\CFRV8RT>m^x]U>\:<9!E8QSR];^-C89UAmCF?XEFf(^xKFE8QS[@?Y]`ELAjADKF?Y[9;yFWXR
^x]U>)C89;>N6)9!>\R(9!VFVFWX?BQT9![\?Y]UE8AS3CIRT>\R9!>\R 9E6KF: y8RT>];^¤9;VFVIWY?BQ%9;[\?X]`E8A^x]U>jCL9`AmCI?YEFf ?YE&CL9;>eN
9;>\Rg3 RC89Tk RADCF]!)E[@C89;[$ycl&QeCF] ] AD?YEFf(^xKFE8Qd[\?Y]UE8A)9;[)>9;E8Nc]`: ^x>\]U: [\CFRiQSW9`A@A #%!G6[\CIR
j
^xKF>@[\CFR%>$9;y8]`KF[$C89UAmC+[e9!yFWYRA^x]`>)C89!>eN69;>\Rg3
{/
1630
y WY]g9`N c3 WY]g9`N 63 WY] 9UN 63 u WX] 9UN 63
RTcVF[\W9!E89;W RTcVF[\W9;E89!W RT6VI[\W9;E89!W RTcVF[\W9!E89;W
v; 2 v; 51 v; v;
`3 v `3 `3 !s u U3 U3 U3 s `3}s`s u `3 s
v `3 Tu `3 %u`v `3 v u U3 v `u U3 v U3 v `3 `v!s `3 ;s
j 2 ;; ; 2 2 ;; 2 1 <; ;; j f; ;
s `3 `3 `vUv `3 ds !s U3 ds U3 v Tv U3 v `3 v`u`u `3 v
. j1 Z Z T Z T; < f; T17 2j ;
`3 Uu `3 `3 U3 U3 %u U3 Tu `3 v `3 vUu
; T 2; Z < Z <; j T ; ; ;
`3 `v`v!s `3 Uv`v `3 Uv U3 U3 Ss u U3 `3 v !s `3 v
; 2; Z Z ; Z ; Z ; 17 ;
v `3 `3 Uu `3 Tu U3 Tu U3 `v U3 `3 Ss `3
); ; 2; 2; 2; ; Z Z); ; ; ;
`3 `u `3 `uUu `3 v %u U3 v `v U3 `u U3 `3 `3
. Z) ; ; 2 T 2 <1 ; 1 ;
s `3 Ss `3 ds `3 v !s U3 v U3 ;s U3 !s `3 `3
. j Z) T ; 2 2 ; ; 1 2 ; ;
`3 `3 `3 v %u U3 v U3 sgv U3 s v `3 Ts `3
. f Z) f ; h; E);; T 2 ; ;
v `3 `v Uv `3 Uv !s `3 !s U3 U3 U3 `3 u `3 u `u
); ; 1 <1 2;<117 ;T ;T; ; ; 511 f 1 1 ;
c3 s 63 sgu c3 %u 63 63 uUv 63 3 g3
2; 17 2; <; 2 2;<1 ;T) < ; ;
c3 `uUu 63 Uu`u c3 Uv 63 3Uv`u 3 u`u u63 u;s uc3 u`v
; 1 11 2; 1 f 1 1 1 ; Z)
`3 `3 `3 U3 U3 %u;s U3 Tu `3 ;s `3 !s
; T) 2; T Z <; Z) 1 ;
`3 Ss `3 Ss `3 !s U3 `v U3 !u U3 u `3 `3
;j 2; ; Z); Z);; Z E Z T17 2 T17
v `3 `v `3 `v `3 `u U3 `u`u U3 Uv U3 `v `3 `u Uu `3 Uu
); ;T f 2;j h 2; 2; 2;<1 2; 1 1 .117 Z 117
; ;; ; 2; ; ; 2; ; 2; ; 2; 2; ; ; 2;
; 1 2 Z 2;
1633
*+-, * .
.
.
. .
.
.... . . . .'... .
!#"$%'&)(
J ?YfUKF>\Rv63CIROVF>@]`yp3N6?Am[@>\?YyIKF[\?X]`E]!^[\CIROWYR%EFf`[@C];^i[@CFROWX]`EFfUR!Am[&VI>\]`y8RADR KIRTE8QSR G
: `v!sFGFWX] 9`N&^ 9`QS[@]`> c3 ucGFy >\RAmKFWX[eA^x>\]U: RTcV8RT>\?X:&RTEc[eA
g; ; g; ; ;
1634
$
g 389;EIRTE6yL9;KF:+G 3 t>\RTEc[\?QSRob9;WXWG6VIVp3
U OTKRCbU ]MKtRuDS`ACPle)G7eSxKkJe gG Uv63 >; ; 1
v i243p$]`K8N6R%=9;E8N i3 2O?X[eQeCFRTWXWG$ep>e9!E8AmW9;[@?YEFf9&WB9!>\fURkc?Y>@[\K89!W9`NFNc>\R!A@ASG
G8VFVp38vUv v;sFG u63
Gei
SxKk
KmN[! wKsKNF5U ]#klKtCTSae : 1
zvceS%RDF5AD<C
U<k|]#c<SXKR m)AqKCEm K U<CtW E 8 > T
%$
m KueNe)AC P :KNSqSxKRue E<1 T1 T
!j T
1635
Tv i243-PRTEFC89UAmR Ge7)R!AmRT[@[\?XEFf4AD[\]U>e9;fURKIEF?Y[N6?Y>@R!QS[@]`>\?XR!ASG -
Gpk ]`W3Iv cG¦EF]I3 !PbGFVFV{3 `G Uu`vc3
5 Kmt[hCEAmNDF gAe)m FUe)cTRNK
c [Link]`AC 1 ! 1 ; 1 j
h1< h1
-
Kmt[hChAmNDF
gAe)mF5Ue)cTRNK c [Link]`AC ! 1 1 T
> 8 T
1636