Neutron Detection Methods and Instruments
Neutron Detection Methods and Instruments
Alex Lorenz
September 5, 1973
LEFT BLANK
t?
PREFACE
Abstract- . ..
Introduction
C h a r a c t e r i s t i c s of Neutron-Induced Reactions .
Elasticscattering .
Exoergic Charged P a r t i c l e Reactions .
7
1 ° ~ ( n , c r )Li
3 ~ e ( np)T
, .
Fission Reactions
. . Capture
Radiative . . .
Endoergic Reactions
Neutron Detector Types . . .
Ionization Chambers . .
Proportional Counters .
Proton Recoil Proportional c o u n t e r s .
BF3-filled Proportional Counters
Boron-lined Proportional Counters
3 ~ e - f i l l e dProportional Counters .
Semiconductor Detectors . . .
Scintillation Counters
P a s s i v e Detectors .
Foil Detectors .
P a r t i c l e Track Detectors . .
Moderated Activation Detectors .
Thermoluminescent Detectors
Miscellaneous Detector Types
Applications of Neutron Detecting Instruments .
Relative Intensity Measurements .
Total Source Strength Measurements .
Neutron Flux Measurements .
F a s t Ncutron Flux .
Intermediate Neutron Flux
Slow Neutron Flux .
I
Neutron Spectrometry
Neutron Dosimetry .
Appendix A. Commercially Available Neutron Detectors and T h e i r
Characteristics ..
REVIEW OF NEUTRON DETECTION METHODS AND INSTRUMENTS
INTRODUCTION
Elastic Scattering
This reaction has long been used in the detection of low energy neutrons. The
1°B c r o s s section has a value of 3837 b a r n s a t 0.025 eV and d e c r e a s e s according to
7
the l / v relationship with increasing energy up to 100 Lev. The 10J3(n,n) L i reaction
7
proceeds both to the ground and f i r s t excited (0.4774 MeV) s t a t e s of ' L i a s follows:
7 ~ + ia + 2.792 MeV
loB +n/
1 7 "
LiT + cr + 2.31 MeV
7 Li*
7 ~ + i7 + 0.4774 MeV.
F o r thermal neutrons, only -6% of the reactions lead t o the ground state, s o that in
94% of the capture events a 480 keV prompt g a m m a r a y is emitted from the decay of
the excited s t a t e of 7 ~ i .
The high t h e r m a l c r o s s section and the simultaneous emission of the alpha
particle, 7 ~ recoil,
i and gamma r a y offer a number of possibilities for neutron
detection techniques. In addition, the o c c u r r e n c e of boron in a variety of f o r m s m a k e s
i t v e r s a t i l e for application in low energy neutron detection. At higher neutron energies,
however, this reaction yields a m o r e complex distribution of reaction products that,
together with the existence of competing reactions [e.g., (n, p), (n, t), and (n, d)], m a k e s
its application t o higher energies m o r e difficult.
This reaction has a limited application to neutron detectors because of its low
c r o s s section and the competing 14PJ(n,a)11B reaction a t higher neutron energies. It
i s used p r i m a r i l y in the detection of neutrons with photographic plates in which nitrogen
occurs naturally. In a d d i t i o n , 1 4 ~i s commonly included in a counter gas a s a s m a l l
impurity to provide an energy calibration point.
Fission Reactions
2 3 8 ~ ,and 2 3 7 ~ p ) whose
j fission thresholds occur above 0.4 MeV. One aspect that
puts a limit on the use of fissionable m a t e r i a l s in fission detectors i s their natural
6.
alpha decay activity; if the alpha half-life i s <10 yr, the m a t e r i a l i s difficult t o use a s
a detector because of the alpha particle buildup during the a v e r a g e pulse. However,
6
i f the alpha activity does not exceed that of a 10 - y r ha1.f-life, it i s possible to s e t
discriminating levels of the detectors high enough to eliminate detection of the alpha
particles. The fissionable nuclides that fall into t h i s category and r e q u i r e m o r e c a r e
in their [Link] as neutron detector's a r e 2 3 1 ~ a j2 3 3 ~ ,2 3 4 ~ ,and 2 3 9 ~ u . In
general, [Link] of the undesirable properties of their gaseous compounds, f i s s i u r ~
detectors use the metallic o r oxide form of the fissionable m a t e r i a l s .
Radiative Capture
Endoerpic Reactions
Ionization Chambers
Ionization chambers, probably the m o s t widely known and used particle detectors,
usually consist of a gas-filled chamber containing a cathode and a collector anode, o r
plate. Most ionization chambers operate in the range of 200 to 4000 V, while high
p r e s s u r e chambers may r e q u i r e up to 20,000 V.
Ionization chambers work because a charged particle passing through a g a s
leaves in its wake a l a r g e number of ion p a i r s whose c h a r g e i s collected and measured
on the collector plate. In the specific application to neutron detection, the charged
particles originate from neutron interactions either in the chamber gas itself o r in a
r a d i a t o r located within the chamber. Depending on the neutron r e a c t i v e element used,
ionization c h a m b e r s detect either f a s t o r slow neutrons. Depending on their construc-
tion and associated electronics, they can a l s o b e used a s either integrating chambers
o r pulse counters. T h e f o r m e r m e a s u r e the average ionization c u r r e n t produced by
many events; the l a t t e r r e c o r d the number and magnitude of individual ionization ever~ts.
Integrating ionization chambers have been used to m e a s u r e the fast. neutron flux
by observing the d i r e c t c u r r e n t caused by recoil protons in a hydrogenous gas. The
homogeneous ionization chamber is one such chamber; it was originally developed by
E r e t s c h e r and French (BR44)and subsequently used by L a r s s o n (LA54). This technique,
however, has two inherent problems: l o s s e s in the chamber wall and the effect of
background ionizing radiation.
To compensate for those protons that l o s e p a r t of their energy outside the sensitive
volume of the chamber, the chamber walls of s o m e detectors have been coated with a
hydrogenous m a t e r i a l having a composition s i m i l a r to that of the gas. Effectively,
t h e r e i s no discontinuity in m a t e r i a l a t the gas boundary; to the neutrons the chamber
appears to b e an infinite volume of gas. T h e effect of gamma r a y s and other,ionizing
radiation h a s been suppressed by comparing the c u r r e n t f r o m two identical chambers .
having the s a m e sensitivity to ionizing radiation but filled and lined with hydrogenous
m a t e r i a l having' different r e s p o n s e to neutrons.
Pulsed ionization chambers a r e designed to detect individual ionization events
' originating either in the filling gas o r caused by particles ejected from a radiator. .
P r o ~ o r t i o n a lCounters
BF3 -filled
- Proportional Counters
The BF3 -filled proportional counters have been the m o s t widely used of all neu-
tron counters. Although primarily designed f o r slow neutrons, the B F 3 counter has been
adapted to fast neutron detection by surrounding it with a block of shaped neutron
moderating material, such a s paraffin o r polyethylene. One such design, known a s
the Long Counter, i s robust, insensitive to gamma r a y s , reasonably directional, and
not sensitive to variations in the power supply (HA47, ALGOB). It i s a relatively
efficient detector, and within the neutron energy r a n g e of 25 keV to 5 MeV the response
of the Long Counter is flat to within about f80/o. Another design, for detecting a highly
collimated neutron beam, combines the use of a l a r g c numbcr of BF3 counters in
paraffin surrnunding a centrally situated s c a t t e r e r (LA52A). This detector achieves
efficiencies of 20% for fast neutrons. To improve i t s efficiency in detecting slow
neutrons, the BF3 gas of proportional counters can be enriched in 'OB, increasing the
sensitivity of the detector by about a factor,of 5 over that of natural boron BF3 gas.
Nowadays m o s t commercially available BF3 counters contain enriched boron. One of
the important advantages of the BF3 c o u n t e r i s that the alpha and 7 ~p air t i c l e s a r e n o t
slowed down by the solid boron lining and, having the s a m e energy, they therefore
produce the s a m e pulse heights for all slow neutrons.
Boron-lined P r o ~ o r t i o n a lCounters
The boron-lined proportional counters' coated with enriched boron have been
developed to provide a high s'ensitivity to thermal neutrons compared to the B F
3
proportional counter. hey have the additional advantage of operating a t higher
temperatures. Proportional counters lined with l0I3 a r e effectively used in high proton
fields. Their sensitivity is proportional to the lining thickness, but self-absorption of
the alpha particles prevents significant i n c r e a s e s in sensitivity a t the g r e a t e r
thicknesses. These counters a r e insensitive to gamma r a y s and a r e capable of
neutron-sensitive operation in gamma-ray'fields a s high a s l o 4 o r 105 R/hr. Typically,
they a r e filled with argon o r COZ. Their operating voltage i s usually lower than that
of the BF3 o r 3 He chambers, and they [Link] produce l a r g e r output pulses with
s h o r t e r r i s e times.
3 ~ e - f i l l e dProportiorfa1 Counters
The 3He-filled
-
proportional counters employ the 3He(n, p)T reaction, which has
a smooth response with no resonances over a wide r a n g e in the low neutron energy
range. These counters, unlike BF3-filled chambers, c a n b e used effectively for
neutron spectrometry. Very high sensitivity can be achieved by increasing gas p r e s -
s u r e , which increase does not r e q u i r e much i n c r e a s e in operating voltage. F o r two
reasons, many of the reactions n e a r the counter wall do not contribute their full energy
to the output pulse. F i r s t i s the kinematics of the reaction, which produces two product
particles emitted in different directions, and second i s the relatively low stopping power
3 3
of He. The wall effect, however, has been minimized in all commercial He detectors
by increasing the counter diameter s o that the proportion of events n e a r the wall is
small; also, an i n c r e a s e of the helium p r e s s u r e o r the addition of s m a l l amounts of a
heavier gas improves the stopping power of the gas. Batchelor h a s developed a 3 ~ e -
filled proportional counter containing krypton and C 0 2 that i s useful in the region of
100 to 1000 keV (BA55). F o r a comprehensive review of 3 ~ neutron
e spectrometers,
s e e (BAFiO).
Table 2 i s s u m m a r y of proportional counters.
Semiconductor Detectors
Scintillation Counters
detector using a dispersion of ZnS in Lucite; ' another proposed design consisted in
embedding s m a l l pieces of plastic phosphor in Lucite o r quartz (MC54). Numerous
s i m i l a r detectors consist of ZnS o r KI suspension in paraffin, polystyrene, o r other
organic m a t e r i a l s (FR50, RM54, SE54, BR54). In addition, either neutrons o r g a m m a
r a y s in mixed radiation fields can be discriminated by pulse shape analysis (BI60,
KU71). A review of organic scintillation m a t e r i a l s and an experimental comparison of
these detectors was published by Koontz, Keepin, and Ashley (K055).
In general, the versatility of the scintillator technique m a k e s it adaptable t o the
detection of both slow and fast neutrons. Among the m o s t sensitive scintillators a r e
0 G
thallium-activated NaI [NaI(Tl)], europium-activated LiI [ Li(Eu)], 'ti-loadcd
cerium-aclivated silicate glass, and ZnS c r y s t a l s . T h e s i z e of the detecting scintillator
is critical in that it can significantly perturb the neutron field being measured. Except
f o r this flux perturbation effect and self-shielding effects, the scintillator h a s negligible
detection anisotropy. F o r m o r e detailed descriptions of scintillation detectors, s e e
4
.
-2-
Foil ~ e t e c t v r s
cross"section shown. Since the total number of isotopes that can be activated by neutron
irradiation i s very large, we listed only those isotopes in which (1) the isotope in its
natural s t a t e is nongaseous, ( 2 ) the product nucleus i s gamma-emitting, 13) the half-life
of the product nucleus i s >1 min, and (4) the macroscopic activation c r o s s section
(equal to the microscopic activation c r o s s section multiplied by the atomic density
weighted by the natural abundance) i s >0.01 em-'.
~ e s o n a n c efoil detectors, which like activation foil detectors u s e the radiative
capture process, a r e suited to neutron detection in the intermediate energy r a n g e
because of the existence of pronounced resonances in their radiative capture c r o s s
section. Resonance detectors can be used to m e a s u r e the flux density of decelerating
neutrons from the cadmium cut-off energy of 0.4 eV up to -1 keV. Even though t h e i r
Table 4. Isotopic radiative capture reactions amenable t o thermal neutron activation
detection.
2200 m/sec absorption
c r o s s section Half-life
Isotopic of Beta and gamma radiation
abundance M ~ C ~ O S C O
~ a~c~r oCs~c o p i c ~
Product product emitted by product nucleus c
Isotope (%) (barns) (cm-1) nucleus . nucleusc (MeV)
a
lo3~h 100.00 4.4 m i n 1.257 656 -0.5
1 1 SIn 54.0 m i n 1.457 3480 f 120 0.55 b
95.72
a
lalTa 99;99 115.0 d 4.28 ' 1558 -0.5
e
6 5 ~ u 30.91 5.1 m i n 227.0 2.3 rt 0.23 0.5
%
--.- -
100.00 15.0 h r 2850.0 0.3 f 0.01 0.5
f
a
R . A. C h a r p i e , e t al., Eds., P h y s i c s arid M a t h e m a t i c s ( M c G r a w - H i l l Book CO.,
New T o r k , 1356), Ch. 6. .
. B e c k h u r t s , e t al., Nucl. S c i . Eng. -
b ~ H. 17, 329 (1963).
'F. J. Jutlriston, e t al., J. Nucl. E n e r g y -
A l l , 9 5 (1960).
. M a c k l i n and nH.- s
d ~ L. P r o c . ~ o n ' f .nn P e a c e f u l U s e s of A t o m i c
E n e r g y , Geneva, 1955 (United Nations, Geneva, 1955), vol. 5, p. 96.
e ~ P.
. H a r r i s , C . D. ~ u e l h a u s e , and G. E. T h q m a s , P h y s . Rev. 5,11 (1950).
'R. Dahlberg, K . J i r l o w , and E. Johansson, R e a c t o r Sci. Technol. -14. . 33 (1961):
g ~ F.e i n e r , K n o w l e s A t o m i c P o w e r L a b o r a t o r y , Rept. K A P L 2000-16 (1961).
Table 6. Threshold reaction's applicable to the detection of fast neutrons.
Threshold Fission spectrum.
energy averaged c r o s s section Product P r o d u c t nucleus
Isotope Reaction (MeV) (mbarns) Reference nucleus half -life
+
2 3 ~ a
Mg
(n, P)
(n. p )
(n, P)
3.75
4.93
3.17
0.7
1.62
2 .0
2
3
2
2 3 ~ e
24 Na
2 5 ~ a
37.6 s e c
15.0 h r
60.0 s e c
27
2 7 ~ 1 (n. P) 1.90 4.32 f 0.2 1 Mg 9.46 m i n
% (n, P) 4.00 4 .O 2 28~1 2.31 m i n
29~i (n, P) 3 .OO 2.7 2 'A1 6.6 m i n
P (n. P) 0.73 30.5 f 1.2 4 31~i , 2.6 s e c
% ( 4P) 0.96 73 It 3 1 3 2 ~ 14.28 d
%I (n. P) (-0.62)~ 16.0 2 5~ 87.9 d
3 7 ~ ~ (n, P) 4.18 0.24 2 3 7 ~ 5.07 m i n
4 6 ~ i (n, P) 1.62 13.0 3 4 6 ~ c 83.9 d
b 3 5 4 ~ n 303.0 d
F e (n, P) (-0.09) 89.0
56Fe (n, P) . 2.97 1.15 f 0.04 1 5 6 ~ n 2.58 h r
58N1 (n, P) (-0.40)~ 120.0 f 6.0 1 5 8 ~ 0 71.3 d
9Be (n, a ) 0.67 10.0 2 . 6 ~ e 0.8 s e c
l~ h a ) 7.24 0.085 2 ~i 0.84 s e c .
"F (n, a ) 1.60 4.5 2 16N 7.2 s e c
20$ 11.5 s e c
2 3 ~ a (n, a ) 4.03 0.4 2
"Al 3.25 0.78 f 0.03 1 24 Na 15.0 hr
-. 2.01 1.43 2 28~1 2.31 m i n
3 4 ~ 1.37 3 .O 2 31~i 2.62 h r
5~~ (n, a ) (-0.94)~ 3 .O 2 3 2 ~ 14.28 d
51v .(n, a ) 2.09 0.08 2 48~c 1.83 d
1ZC.
(n, a n ) 20.28 (200)~ l lc 20.4 m i n
6 3 ~ u (n, 2n) ' 11.02 0.123 f 0.009 5 'j2cu 9.76 m i n
% (n, 2n) 12.41 (1100)~ 5 7 ~ i 36.0 h r
9 2 ~ 0 (n, a n ) 12.83 (1000)~ "MO 15.5 m i n
127[ 9.21 (1300)' 126[
(n, 2n) 12.8 d
2 0 3 ~ ~ (n, 2n) 7.76 (1000)~ 202~1 12.0 d ,
232Th
(n, f ) 1 .25d 87.5 f 3.5 1 F l s s l o n products -
a- (n, f ) 0.42~ -a F i s s i o n products -
23?u (n,f) ' 0.26 d a F i s s i o n products -
236u
(n, f )
0.70~ -a Fission products -
23au
- (n, f )
2 3 7 ~ ~ (n. f )
1.25~
0.32 d
325 f 19
1365 f 95
5
5
Fission products
Fission products .
-
-
-
'A. F a b r y , . e t al., in P r o c . IAEA Conf. on Nucl. Data f o r R e a c t o r s , Helsinki. 1970 (IAEA, Vienna,
1970). vol. 2, p. 535.
2 ~ J.. Hughes, P i l e Neutron R e s e a r c h (Addison- Wesley, 1953 ), p. 100.
3 ~ Fabry,
, p r i v a t e communication quotcd in (IC60).
4 ~M
. . Boldeman, J. Nucl. E n e r g y A/B 18,417 (1964).
5 ( ~ ~ 6 8 )
a ~ informatinn
o availahle.
b ~ x o e r g i creaction: Q-value i s given in p a r e n t h e s e s . Effective t h r e s h o l d i s in t h e MeV r a n g e .
'NO f i s s i o n - a v e r a g e d c r o s s s e c t i o n value available; value in p a r e n t h e s e s i s t h e a v e r a g e c r o s s s e c t i o n . ,
n e a r peak.
d ~ f f e c t i v e( e x t r a p o l a t e d ) threshold.
In this system, foils of 2 3 9 ~ u(shielded with 'OB), 237
to acceptable accuracies. Np,
2 3 8 ~ ,and 3 2 a~r e used a s threshold detectors. The f i r s t t h r e e foils use the fission
reaction and the l a s t uses the 3 2 ~ ( np)
, reaction.
Some of the advantages of threshold detectors a r e t h e i r insensitivity to gamma
r a y s o r thermal neutrons, their suitability f o r extremely high flux intensities, their
ruggedness, and their independence of temperature, humidity, o r p r e s s u r e .
P a r t i c l e Track Detectors
The nuclear emulsion (CH54, BE63B, HA63, BE66A) and fission track (BE66B,
' PR68) techniques use nuclear particle t r a c k s to detect neutrons. They have an
advantage over other passive detection techniques, because (1) the permanent t r a c k
r e c o r d left by the particles allows a c c u r a t e range, angle, and ionization m e a s u r e m e n t s
to be made, and (2) g r e a t e r discrimination is possible against backgrounds of scattered
neutrons, electrons, and gamma r a y s . However, considerable labor i s involved in
reading the tracks.
The nuclear emulsion technique m e a s u r e s the flux and energy of incident neutrons
by detecting reaction products in a photographic emulsion. It can be applied in t h r e e
different ways: (1) observation of proton r e c o i l s that originate in the emulsion (R053),
(2) observation of Peaction products originating in nuclides with which the emulsion was
impregnated (KE50), and (3) observation of reaction products originating in an external
radiator. T h e nuclear emulsion technique can b e used in monodirectional b e a m s o r in
multidirectional neutron fields, either a s an integral neutron detector o r a s a
2
spectrometer. A typical emulsion plate consists of a 1-cm piece of emulsion, 600 p
thick, mounted on a glass plate. The t r a c k s can b e m e a s u r e d with a microscope of
magnification 500. A 5 MeV proton track h a s a track length of -I80 p, measurable
with high accuracy; accuracy deteriorates considerably a t proton energies below
500 keV, with 100 keV the approximate limit of measurement.
The photographic emulsion has the advantages that' i t is a very compact detector
with exceller.11:resolution and i t provides a permanent r e c o r d of the results, even in
low neutron density fields. In addition, it does not perturb the local neutron spectrum,
it r e q u i r e s no associated electronic equipment, and it allows for multiple simultaneous
m e a s u r e m e n t s (IC71). The disadvantage of the method i s t h e laborious nature of the
scanning p r o c e s s (IC69). Moreover, this method fails to detect effectively neutrons
with energies between -10 eV and 0.5 MeV (C058, CH54). Protons m u s t have an energy
of 0.25 MeV, corresponding on the a v e r a g e to a neutron energy of 0.5 MeV, to generate
a track a t the limit of recognition.
At the upper end of the energy scale, s y s t e m s with hydrogenous r a d i a t o r s can be
used up to -20 MeV (BE63). Although such detectors have a low gamma-ray sensitivity,
gamma-ray doses of 1 to 10 r a d will complicate interpretation, and higher gamma-ray
intensities will usually make track counting impossible.
A comprehensive review of the nuclear emulsion technique i s given by White
(WH60).
Fission track detectors, which r e c o r d fission events by fission fragment etching
of glass, mica, o r plastic, offer an attractive alternative to counting fission product
gamma activity. This technique can detect both low energy neutrons (using 2 3 5 o
~r
2 3 9 ~ u )and fast neutrons (using any of the fast fissionable elements, e.g., 2 3 8 ~ ,2 3 7 ~ p ,
o r 2 3 2 ~ h ) Fission
. track detectors can be made to give absolute values and a r e totally
insensitive to gamma r a y s below the photofission threshold. Recent development of
traclc registration technirliies in g l a s s e s and plastics has opened a new possibility for.
fission (and alpha emitting) foil analysis (KE66). In this technique, thin fission foils
a r e placed in close contact with a g l a s s o r plastic surface, allowing the fission
fragments to intercept the surface; the g l a s s o r plastic i s then etched to r e n d e r the
t r a c k s visible under a microscope. ~ h e ' f i s s i o ntrack detection technique i s readily
adaptable t o longterm integrating measurements. In addition, (1) milligram r a t h e r
than g r a m quantities of f i s s i l e m a t e r i a l a r e sufficient, (2) t h e technique has very good
sensitivity, (3) e a r l y recovery of s a m p l e s is unnecessary a s the t r a c k s a r e permanent
a t normal temperature, and (4) complex and expensive electronics a r e not required
(IC7 1).
Thermoluminescent Detectors
The use and application of specific neutron detecting instruments and the
techniques used to determine the intensity and energy of neutrons encompasses
practically the whole field of neutron physics.
Although no one instrument exists that can perform all neutron detection func-
tions, many detectors and the principles on which they a r e based have been adapted
to m o r e than one type of detection. T h e five general categories of neutron detector
applications a r e relative intensity measurements, total s o u r c e strength measurements,
flux measurements, neutron spectrometry, and neutron dosimetry.
Neutron Flux ~ e a s u r e m e n t s
rentially in either the fast, the intermediate, o r the slow energy ranges, the description
of t h e i r application t o neutron flux m e a s u r e m e n t s i s considered by energy range.
F a s t Neutron F l u x
The slow neutron flux covers a much wider range, both in energy and intensity, than
the f a s t neutron flux. It i s sometimes accompanied by higher energy neutrons and
gamma r a y s that r e q u i r e discrimination.
In a nuclear r e a c t o r the slow neutron flux i s composed of two components. The
t h e r m a l o r Maxwellian component, between 0 and 0.1 eV, h a s an energy spectrum in
thermal equilibrium ,with the t e m p e r a t u r e of the r e a c t o r . T h e epithermal component
consiSts of a continuous energy spectrum between 0.1 and 0.4 eV and has a dependence
proportional to the neutron energy.
A wide variety of detectors is available to m e a s u r e the slow neutron flux; the .
specific application of any one of these d,epends on the conditions of the experiment.
A l a r g e fraction of these detectors use radiative capture, fission, and exoergie charged
particle reactions.
A significant characteristic of s o m e of these reactions is t h a t t h e i r c r o s s sections
a r e inversely [Link].1, to the neutron velocity, s o detectors that use t h e s e reactions
a r e called 1 /v detectors. Since the flux (4) in the epithermal energy range in a
r e a c t o r i s proportional to the neutron density (n) and the reaction velocity (v), i.e.,
4 = nv, the reaction r a t e per atom of detecting m a t e r i a l in a pure 'l/v detector i s
independent of velocity ( o r .energy) and proportional only to the total neutron density.
If the slow flux is accompanied by a significant number of higher energy neutrons, the
cadmium r a t i o method can b e applied to discriminate neutrons h a v ~ n genergies higher
than t h e cadmium cut-off energy of 0.4 eV.
Reactions m o s t commonly used in the m e a s u r e m e n t of the slow neutron flux a r e
3
l 0 g ( n , n), ' ~ i ( n , a ) , He(n, p), Mn(n, y), Au(n, y ) , and 2 3 5 ~ ( nf ),. The l 0 ~ ( n , a reaction
)
is probably used m o s t extensively. It i s used in gas-filled proportional and ionization
3
chambers both in gaseous (BF3) and solid form. The He gas proportional counter,
s i m i l a r to the BF3 counter, i s another commonly used thermal flux detector. Still
another gas proportional counter to detect slow neutrons is the fission chamber, in
which 2 3 5 o
~ r another fissionable m a t e r i a l is coated on the counter walls. This
detector i s very efficient in this low energy range and can operate a t temperatures a s
high a s 700°C and in extreme gamma-ray fluxes.
Scintillation c r y s t a l [Link] incorporating 6 ~ i such
J a s [ 6LiI(Eu)], ' ~ i - l o a d e d
cerium-activated silicate glass, and 6 Li-loaded ZnS, a s well a s activation c r y s t a l s
such a s NaI(Tl), a r e a l s o widely used to m e a s u r e the slow neutron flux.
Two passive methods, which provide a time-integrated neutron-flux m e a s u r e -
m ent, a r e foil activatior~and thermolum ines cenc e detectors.
Neutron S ~ e c t r o m e t r v
Neutron Dosimetry
-
reactions dependent. on the energy of the .incident neutrons. The relative biological ,
effectiveness (RBE) of the neutron radiation dose therefore has a specific nonlinear
energy dependence. As a result, neutron detecting instruments designe.d specifically
to m e a s u r e the neutron dose equivalent directly should ideally have an energy response
proportional to the RBE of neutrons .absorbed in tissue. ,
Useful
energy
range Method of recording
Type Resolution Efficiency (MeV) and analyzing r e s u l t s Remarks
6 ~ loaded
i plates 0.2 MeV half- - 0-1.3 Range of a and -, and angle It i s not n e c e s s a r y f o r incident neutrons
~ ~ ~ ti ) l(Hne , width betwe n i s m e a s u r e d f o r t o be collimated o r t o come f r c m known
reaction] 8 .
each L L ( ~t ), 4 ~ event
e direction.
3 ~ propor
e
3'~onal 15% a t 0.5 MeV - - Pulse-height analysis B ck round from slow neutron c a p t u r e and
c o u n t e ~[ He(n, p)T 8% a t 2.0 MeV r e c o i l s from high energy neutrons.
reactiy]
. 6 ~ andi 'He solid s t a t e 60% a t 0.5 MeV -
spectrometers 6% a t 5.0 MeV
& Low p r e s s u r e cloud 0.2 MeV half- - 0.5-3.5 [Link]
0 c h a m b e r [n-p width direction of r e c o i l prcton
I r,ecoils in H2] t r a c k s from cloud chamber
photographs
Nigh . p r e s s u r e cloud 0.2 MeV half- 2-8.5 -
c h a m b e r In-p. width
r e c o i l s in methane]
Proportional counter 5 5 a t 1 5 MeV - 2.5-20 Integral r a n g e s p e c t r u m
t e l e s c o p e with counted
r a d i a t o r and
absorbers
Holt-Litherland 570 5-25 Analysis of phctographic Only p a r t of energy r a n g e m a y be studied
t r i p l e ionization r e c o r d of oscillograph a t any given chamber p r e s s u r e (range
c h a m b e r . T i m e of sweeps of 5 MeV o r l e s s in neutron e n e r g i e s ) .
a r r i v a l of ions f r o m Resolution i s not affected by high
end of proton r e c o i l '
g a m m a - r a y backgrounds.
track
Single a n t h r a c e n e 0.4 MeV High 1-3 Multichannel pulse-height
crystal analysis giving integral
spectrum
6 ~ (Eu)
i c r stal 670 a t 14 MeV 1-20 Pulse-height analysis No collimation required. F o r good
6
I Li(n. t ) Heg resolution the c r y s t a l m u s t b e cooled
reaction] to t h e temperatcr: of Liquid nitrogen.
Table 8. (Continued).
Useful
energy
range Method of recording
Resolution Efficiency (MeV) and analyzing r e s u l t s Remarks
~- - - - - - - -- - - -
P l a s t i c phosphor Plastic phosphor >20 p r e m / h r 0.4 MeV t o Instrument used with a multichannel analyzer WI52, WI57
scintillation sandwiched between 14 MeV f o r the m e a s u r e m e n t of absolute proton
counter two s l a b s of poly- recoil t i s s u e dose in a i r from fast neutrons.
vinyltoluene. Lightweight and s m a l l size. Suitable f o r
Pulse counter. radiobiological r e s e a r c h but analysis o r
r e s u l t s i s complex. Nondirectional response.
Moderate gamma sensitivity. .
Fission track F i s s i o n threshold > 10 p r e m t h e r m a l to Method is completely insensitive t o g a m m a , BE66B, PR68
detectors detectors mounted (thermal 10 MeV r a y s . By choice of suitable fissionable
on plastic, m i c a neutrons) m a t e r i a l s will yield approximate spectrum.
o r glass. T r a c k s Potentially suitable f o r radiological
a r e observed by protection monitoring. Simple readout.
selective etching. Longterm stability.
Threshold Threshold detector >I00 r e m low MeV Accuracy f o r fission s p e c t r a f15q0 limited by HU56, RE58B,
detectors foils of 2 3 9 ~ ~ 1 , range finite threshold slope. G r o s s uncertainty MG62, R 0 6 5
2 3 7 ~ p ,2 3 8 ~ ,and where neutrons of energies g r e e t e r than
3 2 a~r e used f o r s e v e r a l MeV a r e present. Suitable f o r
f a s t neutron fluence criticality and high dose r a t e s . Negligible
m e a s u r e m e n t above gamma response.
respective thresholds.
Gold and gold plus
cadmium a r e used
f o r t h e r m a l neutron
measurements.
Solid s t a t e High resolution .lo0 rern/hr For 6 ~ i : Accurate flux and energy measurement. L061, AR64,
spectrometer s p e c t r o m e t r y of 0.7 to Instrument subject t o t h e r m a l neutron DE62 '
reaction products 3.0 MeV interference and to (n, p) and (n,cu) back-
from thin l a y e r s For 3 ~ e : ground in silicon, which can be reduced
of 6 ~ i ( n , aand ) 0.3 to by coincidence techniques. Good gamma
3 ~ e ( np, ) sandwiched 7.0 MeV d i s c r i m ination.
between silicon
diodes. Pulses a r e
summed t o give
energy spectrum.
Nuclear Packaged photographic >20 m r e m 0.5 MeV t o Valid f o r neutron detection over f a s t energy CH54, BE63B,
emulsions emulsions. Recoil 20 MeV range. Subject t o fading l o s s e s due t o HA63, BE66A
proton t r a c k s a r e humidity, temperature, and emulsion
counted per unit type. Not applicable in gamma d o s e s
a r e a of film. >10 r a d because of fogging. Tedious
measurement. Gives permanent r e c o r d .
'
No electronics required.
REFERENCES
-
R. C. Allen, Phys. Rev. 105, 1796 (1957).
W. D. Allen, Neutron Detection (George Newness, Ltd., London, 1960).
W. D. Allen, " F l a t Response c o u n t e r s , " in F a s t Neutron Physics,
J. B. ~ a r i d nand J. L. F o w l e r , E d s . (Interscience, [Link], 1960),
Pt. 1, p. 361.
P a p e r s P r e s e n t e d a t t h e Technical Briefing S e s s i o n on the Boiling Water
R e a c t o r P r o g r a m a n d t h e F a s t R e a c t o r P r o g r a m Held a t Idaho Falls, 1955,
Argonne National Laboratory, Argonne, Ill., Rept. TID-7 506, Pt. 1 (1956):
I. 0 . A n d e r s s o n and J. Braun, Nukleonik -
6 (5), 237 (1964).
R. J . A r m a n i , e t al., "Improved Techniques f o r Low F l u x M e a s u r e m e n t of
P r o m p t Neutron Lifetime, Conversion Ratio and F a s t Spectrum," in P r o c .
IAEA Symp. Exponential and C r i t i c a l Experiments, A m s t e r d a m , 1963
(IAEA, Vienna, 1963).
R. Aves, D. B a r n e s , and R. B. McKenzie, J. Nucl. E n e r g y 1, 110 (1954). -
P. Avivi and S. G. Cohen, P h y s . Rev. -
108, 972 (1957).
H. H. B a r s c h a l l and H. A. Bethe, Rev. Sci. I n s t r . -
18, 147 (1947).
~ a r s c h a l lRosen,
, Tashek, and Williams, Rev. Mod. Phys. -
24, 1 (1952).
R. B a t c h e l o r , H . Aves, and T . H. R. Skyrme, Rev. Sci. I n s t r . -
26, 1037
(1955).
11. H. B a r s c h a l l , "Detection of N,eutrons," in Handbuch d e r Physik
(Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1958), vol. 45, p. 437.
Bame, Haddad, P e r r y , and Smith, Rev. Sci. I n s t r . -
28, 997 (1957).
R. R. Bashkin, e t al., Phys. R,ev. 109, 434 (1958). -
R. B a t c h e l o r and G. C. M o r r i s o n , " ~ e l i u m - 3Neutron S p e c t r o m e t e r s , " in
F a s t Neutr.or1 Physics, J . 13. M a r i o n arid J. L. F o w l e r , Eds. (Interscience,
New York, 1960), Pt. 1, p. 413.
P. W. Benjamin, he U s e of Proton-Recoil Methods f o r M e a s u r i n g Neutron
S p e c t r a in a F a s t Reactor," in P r o c . Symp. on Neutron Dosimetry, Harwell,
-
1962 (IAEA, Vienna, 19631, vol. 2, p. 307.
K. B e c k e r , A t o l r ~ k e r n e n e r g i e-
8, 74 (1963).
E. F. Bennett, " ~ a s [Link]
t by 4 8 Recoil P r o p o r t i o n a l
~ o u n t i n g , "in P r o c . ANS Shielding Div.. Spec. S e s s . F a s t Neutron Spectroscopy,
San F r a n c i s c o , 1964 ( A m e r i c a n Nuclear Society, Hinsdale, Ill., 1964).
,. -34-
, . .
K. B e c k e r , P h o t o g r a p h i c F i l m D o s i m e t r y , ( T h e F o c a l P r e s s , London,
1966). ,
K. Becker, Nuclear T r a c k Registration Health Phys. -
12, 769 (1966).
E. F. Bennett, Nucl. Sci. Eng., 27, 16 (1967). -
J. B . B i r k s , Scintillation C o u n t e r s , ( P e r g a m o n Press, New York, 1960).
L. B l u m b e r g a n d S. I. S c h l e s i n g e r , L o s A l a m o s Scientific L a b o r a t o r y ,
Rept. LADC-2121 (1955). '
-.
S. D. Bloom, E. Reilly, and B. J. Toppel, A 'High P r e s s u r e P r o p o r t i o n a l
-C
.-----o u n t e r f o r F a s t Neutron S p e c t r o s c o p y , B r o o k h a v e n National L a b o r a t o r y ,
Rept. BNL-358 (T-66) (1955).
S . Block a n d K. P e t r o c k , Evaluation of a N e u t r o n r e m D o s i m e t e r , L a w r e n c e
L i v e r m o r e L a b o r a t o r y , Rept. UCRL-1'2 167 (1964 1.
T . W. B o n n e r , R. A. F e r r e l l , and M. C. R i n e h a r t , P h y s . Rev. -
87, 1032
(1952).
L. M. B o l l i n g e r and G. E. T h o m a s , Rev. Sci. I n s t r . -
28, 489 (1957).
L. M. B o l l i n g e r , G. E . T h o m a s , a n d J. G i n t h e r , Rev. Sci. I n s t r . -
30, 1135
(1959).
M. B o r m a n n , e t al., " F l u x M e a s u r e m e n t s of M e d i u m E n e r g y N e u t r o n s by
M e a n s of S t i l b e n e S c i n t i l l a t o r s and 6 ~ GLasses,"
i in P r o c . IAEA Symp. on
Neutron Monitoring, Vienna, 1966; (IAEA, Vienna, 19 67 ).
E. R r e t s c h e r and H. P. F r e n c h , Rept. BR-386 (1944).
B. Brown, Rev. Sci. I n s t r . 26, 970 (1954).
F. D. B r o o k s , C h a p t e r 5 in P r o g r e s s in N u c l e a r P h y s i c s , 0 . R . F r i s c h , Ed.
( P e r g a m o n Press, New York, 1956).
R. C. B r a m b l e t t , R. I. Ewing, a n d T. W. B o n n e r , Nucl. I n s t r . M e t h o d s -
9,
1 (1960).
P. R. B y e r l y , Jr., "Radioactivation M e t h o d s of D e t e r m i n i n g Neutron lux,"
in F a s t Neutron P h y s i c s , J . B. M a r i o n and J. L. F o w l e r , E d s . ( I n t e r s c i e n c e ,
New York, 1960), P t . 1, p. 657.
B. C a s s e n , T . C r o u g h and H. G a s s , Nucleonics -
1 3 (3), 58 (1955).
J. M. C a l v e r t and A. A. Jaffe, " ~ e u t r o nS p e c t r o s c o p y , " in Fast N e u t r o n
P h y s i c s , J. B . M a r i o n a n d J. L . F o w l e r , E d s . ( I n t e r s c i e n c e , New York,
1963), P t . 2, p. 1907.
-
J. S. Cheka, N1.1c1eoni.c~
1 2 (G), 4 0 (1954).
H. M . C h i l d e r s , Rev. Sci. I n s t . -
29, 1008 (1958).
M. R. Cleland, An Evaluation Study of a . F a s t - N e u t r o n S p e c t r o m e t e r B a s e d
o n t h e T o t a l A b s o r p t i o n P r i n c i p l e , National B u r e a u of S t a n d a r d s , G a i t h e r s b u r g ,
Md., Rept. 2036 (1952).
C. L. Cowan, Jr. and F. R e i n e s , T h e L a r g e Liquid S c i n t i l l a t o r D e t e c t o r
a s a Neutron S p e c t r o m e t e r , L o s A l a m o s Scientific L a b o r a t o r y , Rept.
LAMS-2100 (1056).
J. E. Cook, Fast Neutron D o s i m e t r y Using N u c l e a r E m u l s i o n s , U.K.. A t o m i c
.,
E n e r g y R e s e a r c h E s t a b l i s h m e n t , H a r w e l l , B e r k s England, Rept. A E R E -
HP/R-2744 (1958).
L. C r a n b e r g and L. R o s e n , C h a p t e r 3.4 in N u c l e a r S p c c t r o s c o p y ,
Ajzenberg-Selove, Ed. ( A c a d e m i c P r e s s , New York, 1957).
J. D e p a n g h e r a n d W. C. R o e s c h , P h y s . Rev. -
100, 1793 (1955).
-
G. D e a r n a l e y and A. T . G. F e r g u s o n , N u c l e o n i c s 20 (4), 84 (1962).
B . 0. ~ i v e n ,H. C. M a r t i n , R . F. T a s c h e k , a n d J. T e r r e l l , P h y s . Rev.
-
101, 1012 (1956).
B. C. Diven, P h y s . R e v . 105, 1350 (1957).
J. E . D r a p e r , R e v . Sci. I n s t r . -
22, 543 (1951).
J. Duchene, J. L a v e r g n e , a n d J. Weill, J. Nucl. E n e r g y -
4 ( I ) , 26 (1957).
L. V. East and R . B. Walton, Nucl. I n s t r u m . ~ e t ' h o d -
s72, 161 (1969). '
-
V. I. Kukhtevich, L. A. T r y k o v , and 0. A , T r y k o v , S i n g l e C r y s t a l S c i n t i l -
l a t i o n S p e c t r o m e t e r with O r g a n i c P h o s p h o r , (Atomizdat, Moscow, 197 1 ).
J. L a b e y r i e , C. L a l l e m o n t , and J. Weill, J . P h y s . R a d i u m -
12, 32A (1951):
A. S. L a n g s d o r f , C. T. Hibdon, and R. E . Holland, P h y s . Rev. -
85, 5 9 5
(1952).
A. C . L a p s l e y , A C o m p a c t Neutron S e n s i t i v e T h e r m o p i l e , A r g o n n e National
L a b o r a t o r y , Argonne, Ill., Rept. ANL-4869 (1952).
K. E . L a r s s o n , A r k . F y s i k .-
9 , 293 (1954).
L a n g s d o r f , Lane, and Monahan, P h y s . R e v . -
107, 1077 (1957).
A . C. L a p s l e y , Nucleonics, -
1G (2), 106 (1958).
E . L a i s k , Nucleonics -
16, (7), 9 5 (1958).
R. W. L a m p h e r e , " F i s s i o n D e t e c t o r s , " in Fast Neutron P h y s i c s , J . B .
M a r i o n a n d J. L. F o w l e r , E d s . ( I n t e r s c i e n c e , New York, 1960), Pt. 1,
J. W., L e a k e , C a l i b r a t i o n of t h e N e u t r o n S u r v e y P r o b e 9510054, U. K. A t o m i c
E n e r g y R e s e a r c h E s t a b l i s h m e n t , H a r w e l l , B e r k s . , England, R e p t . A E R E -
J. W. L e a k e , " P o r t a b l e I n s t r u m e n t s f o r t h e M e a s u r e m e n t of N e u t r o n Dose-
E q u i v a l e n t R a t e in Steady-State a n d P u l s e d Neutron ~ i e l d s , " in IAEA S y m p .
on N e u t r o n Monitoring, Vienna, 1966 (IAEA, Vienna, 1967).
D. J. L i t t l e r , R e p o r t o n C o n f e r e n c e o n N e u t r o n S o u r c e P r e p a r a t i o n a n d
C a l i b r a t i o n , U.K. A t o m i c E n e r g y R e s e a r c h E s t a b l i s h m e n t , H a r w e l l ,
B e r k s . , England, Rept. NP/R-1577 (1955).
R. D. Lowde, Rev. S c i . I n s t r . -
21, 8 3 5 (1950).
T. A. L o v e and R . B . M u r r a y , I H E T r a n s . Nucl. Sci. -
8 ( I ) , 91 (1961 ).
H. S. M a c C r e a r y and R. T . B a y a r d , R e v . S c i . I n s t r . -
25, 161 (1954).
R. L. Macklin, Nucl. I n s t r . -
1, 3 3 5 (1957). .
R. L. M a c k l i n and J. H. Gibbons, P h y s . Rev. 109, 1 0 5 (1958).
D. M a t t h e w s and H. 0 . Menlove, Fast Neutron 4- H e D e t e c t o r ~ e v e l o p m e n t ,
L o s A l a m o s Scientific L a b o r a t o r y , Rept. LA-5091 - P R (1972).
M c C r a r y , T a y l o r , and B o n n e r , P h y s . Rev. -
94, 808 (1954).
J. D. C. Milton a n d J. S. F r a s e r , P h y s . Rev. -
96, 1508 (1954).
Nucleonics -
B. M o y e r , -.- 10 (5), 14 (1952).
,I. 'Moteff, Nucleonics -
20 (12), 56 (1962).
J. Moteff, Ed., Neutron F l u e n c e M e a s u r e m e n t s , I n t e r n a t i o n a l Atomic E n e r g y
Agency, Vienna, A u s t r i a , Rept. 107 (1970).
R. B. M u r r a y , Bull. A m e r . P h y s . Soc. -
2, 267 (1957).
R. B. M u r r a y , Nucl. I n s t r . -
2, 237 (1958).
C. 0. Muehlhause, " ~ e u t r o n ' ~ e t e c t i oby
n R e a c t i o n s Induced in S c i n t i l l a t o r s , "
in F a s t Neutron P h y s i c s , J. B. M a r i o n and J. L.. F o w l e r , E d s . ( I n t e r s c i e n c e ,
New York, 1960), Pt. 1, p. 387.
D. Nachtigall and F. Rohloff, Nucl. I n s t r . Methods -
50, 137 (1967).
J. H. N e i l e r and W. M. Good, "Time-of-Flight Techniques," in Fast Neutron
P h y s i c s , J. B. M a r i o n and J. L. F o w l e r , E d s . ( I n t e r s c i e n c e , New York,
1960). Pt. 1, p. 509.
R. G. Nobles and A. B. Smith, Nucleonics -
14 (1 ), 60 (1956).
J. A. N o r t h r o p and R. Nobles, Nucleonics -
1 4 (4), 36 (1956).
J. A. N o r t h r o p and J. C. Gursky, Nucl. I n s t r . -
3, 207 (19.58).
G. J. Perlow, Rev.. Sci. I n s t r . -
27, 460 (1956).
J. E . P e r r y , Jr., " ~ e u t r o nF l u x M e a s u r e m e n t s , " in F a s t Neutron P h y s i c s ,
J. B. M a r i o n and J. L. F o w l e r , Eds., ( I n t e r s c i e n c e , New York, 1960),
P t . 1, p. 623.
W. J. P r i c e , N u c l e a r Radiation Detection (McGraw-Hill Book Co., New
York, 1958).
S. P r e t r e , E. Tochilin, and N. Goldstein, "A S t a n d a r d i z e d Method f o r
Making Neutron F l u e n c e M e a s u r e m e n t s by F i s s i o n F r a g m e n t T r a c k s in
Plastics. A Suggestion f o r a n E m e r g e n c y Neutron D o s i m e t e r with Rad-
Response," in P r o c . Cong. Radiat. P r o t e c t i o n , f i r s t ( P e r g a m o n P r e s s ,
London, 19681, vol. 1, p. 491.
Reines, Cowan, H a r r i s o n , and C a r t e r , Rev. Sci. I n s t r . -
25, 1061 (1954).
W. E . R e d m a n and J. H. R o b e r t s , "Some T e c h n i q u e s of F a s t Neutron
S p e c t r u m M e a s u r e m e n t s , " in P r o c . Conf. P e a c e f u l U s e s of A t o m i c E n e r g y
2nd, Geneva, 1958 (United Nations, New York, 1058), vol. 12, p. 72.
P. W. R e i n h a r d t and F. J. Davis, Health P h y s . -
1, 169 (1958).
B. B . R o s s i and H. H. Staub, Ionization C h a m b e r s and C o u n t e r s , (McGraw-
Hill Book Co., New York, 1949).
L. Rosen, Nucleonics -
11, 32 and 38 (1953). .
T.,. Rosen, "Techniques f o r M e a s u r e m e n t of Neutron crdss Section and
E n e r g y S p e c t r a f o r S o u r c e s Which A r e Continuous in E n e r g y and Time," in
P r o c . Conf. P e a c e f u l U s e s A t o m i c Energy, Geneva, 1955 (United Nations,
New York, 1955), vol. 4, p. 97.
H . H. R o s s i and G. F a i l l a , Nucleoriics -
14 (2), 32 (1956).
B. Rose, A. E . T a y l o r , arld E . Wood, N a t u r e -
181, 1630 (1958).
H. H. R o s s i., "ionization c h a m b e r s in Neutron ~ o s i m e t r y , " in P r o c . IAEA
Conf. o n Neutron ~ o s i r n e t r ~Harwell,
, 1962 (IAEA, Vienna, 1963), vol. 2,
E. R o b e r t s , Jr., Health P h y s . -
11, 255 (1965).
P. Savel, C. R. H. Acad. Sci. -
234, 2596 (1952).
R. C. S a n g s t e r and J. W. I r v i n e , J. C h e m . P h y s . -
24, 670 (1956).
N. K . S a h a a n d N. Nath, Nucleonics -
1 5 (4), 94 (1957).
J. Schenck, --
N a t u r e 171, 518 (1953).
E. S e g r e , E x p e r i m e n t a l N u c l e a r P h y s i c s ( J o h n Wiley a n d Sons, Inc., New
York, 1953), vol. 2, pt. 6.
S e a g o n d o l l a r , E s c h , a n d ~ a r t w r i g h t ,Rev. ScC. I n s t r . -
25, 689 (1954).
T. H. R. S k y r m e , P. R . Tunnicliffe, and A. G. Ward, Rev. Sci. I n s t r . -
23,
204 (1952).
S. C . Snowdon, P h y s . Rev. -
78, 299 (1950).
A. H. Snell, Ed., N u c l e a r I n s t r u m e n t s and T h e i r U s e s . V o l u m e 1. (John
Wiley a n d Sons, Inc., New York,1969).
R . S. S t o r e y , W. J a c k , and A. Ward, " T h e F l u o r e s c e n t D e c a y of CsI(T1) f o r
P a r t i c l e s of D i f f e r e n t tonization ~ e n s i t y , "in P r o c . P h y s . Soc. (London)
vol. 72, 1 (1958).
-
R. S t e d m a n , Rev. Sci. I n s t r . 31, 1156 (1960).
- (7), 4 6 (1956).
K. H. Sun, P. R . M a l m b e r g , a n d F. A. P e c j a k , Nucleonics 14
A, H. Sullivan a n d J. B a a r l i , A n Ionization C h a m b e r f o r t h e E s t i m a t i o n of
t h e Biological E f f e c t i v e n e s s of Radiation, C e r n , Geneva, S w i t z e r l a n d ,
Rept. 63-17 (1963).
R . K. Swank, Annu. Rev. Nucl. Sci. -
4, 111 (1954).
C. D. S w a r t z , G. Owen, and 0. A m e s , U.S. A t o m i c E n e r g y C o m m i s s i o n ,
Rept. NYO-2053 (1 957).
M. J. wetn nick and N. G. Anton, Nucleonics -
1 5 (6), 93 (1957).
L. S z i l a r d and T. A. C h a l m e r s , --
N a t u r e 134, 462 (1934).
R . F. T a s h e k a n d A. H e m m e n d i n g e r , P h y s . Rev. -
74, 373 (1948).
D. T a y l o r and J. S h a r p e , F r o c . I. E . E. 98(II), 174 (1951).
G. E. T h o m a s , Jr. a n d C. 0. M u e l h a u s e , Nucleonics -
1 1 ( I ) , 44 (1953).
M . Walt a n d H. H. B a r s c h a l l , P h y s . Rev. -
93, 1062 (1954).
W a l t e r , Dabbs, and R o b e r t s , Bull. A m e r . P h y s . Soc. -
3, 181 (1958).
C. V. W e a v e r , C. K. Smith, a n d J. W. C h a s t a i n , E l e c . Eng. -
76 (8), 665
(1957).
H. W e r l e , S p e c t r u m M e a s u r e m e n t s of R a d i o a c t i v e N e u t r o n S o u r c e s i n t h e
10 keV-10 MeV E n e r g y Region with P r o t o n - R e c o i l P r o p o r t i o n a l C o u n t e r s ,
Oak R i d g e National L a b o r a t o r y , R ept. ORNL-TR-24 1 5 (1 970).
S. R . White, " P h o t o g r a p h i c Plate Detection," in F a s t N e u t r o n P h y s i c s ,
.J. B. M a r i o n and J. L. F o w l e r , E d s . ( I n t e ~ . s c i e n c e , New York, 1960).
WI 50 Wilson, Beghian, Collie, Halban, a n d Bishop, Rev. S c i . I n s t r . -
21, 699
(1950).
W152 .
D. H. Wilkinson, R e v . Sci. I n s t r . -
23, 414 (1952).
WI57 C. F. Williamson and E. L. Hudspeth, Bull. A m e r . Phys. Soc. -
11 (2), 101
(1957).
Z1 63 M. Zielczynski, "Recombination Method f o r Determination of L i n e a r E n e r g y
T r a n s f e r of Mixed Radiation," in P r o c . IAEA Conf. on Neutron Dosimetry,
Harwell, 1962 (IAEA, Vienna, '1963), vol. 2 , p. 397.
Z165 W. L. Zijp, Review of Activation Methods f o r t h e Determination of
1,ntennediate Neutron Spectra, R e a c t o r C e n t r u m Nederland, Petten, N H,
Netherlands, R e p t . RCN-40 (1965).
APPENDIX A
COMMERCIALLY AVAILABLE NEUTRON DETECTORS
AND THEIR CHARACTERISTICS
..
chambers (RSN-17A/326/
330/251/327)
92% 1°B lined, 95% A, R e u t e r Stokes 1 X 36 in. 800 300 1.1 X 1 0 - l 4 A/nv lo4 -
loll
5% N filled ionization (RSN-229A) . (thermal) (thermal)
chamber
10-.14 A/nv. lo4 - l o l l nv
Gamma-compensated R e u t e r Stokes 1 . 5 X 1 4 in. 800 300
92% 1 0 lined,
~ (RSN-234A-MI) (thermal) ( t h e r m a l1
N filled ionization
chamber
10B lined ionization R e u t e r Stokes 3 in. diam 100-1000 150/300 4.4 x 1 0 - l 4 to l o 3 - 1o1O nv
chambers (RSN-15A/304/ -
13 145 in. long 2 X 1 0 - l 3 Alnv
(thermal)
(thermal)
32513321306)
93% 2 3 5 f~i s s i o n R e u t e r Stokes 3 X 13 in. '.: .' 200-800 300 1.5 X 1 0 - l 3 A/nv lo3 -
1010 nv
ionization c h a m b e r (RSN-3 14A) . . .; (thermal) (thermal)
2 3 5 ~
fission ioniza- R e u t e r Stokes 0.25 o r 0.125 i'n. 20-150 <340 ' 3 X 1 0 - l 7 A/nv l o 8 - 1 0 l 4 nv
tion c h a m b e r s (RSN-186s-M2 diarx cable up to (thermal) (thermal)
.and 216s-M5) 200 i t long
~ ~ l i n ' a r i cA
a land LND 1 X 10 in. 500 200 3 decades
. C 0 2 filled f i s s i o n ( S e r i s s 30771)
chamber
13 6 decades t h e r m a l
Cylindrical A!CH4 LND 1 X 8,in. . 200-800 1 count/lO
filled. 23527 o r ( S e r i e s 3077) neuti-ons to (with 23%) o r f a s t
2 3 8 ~ fission c h a m b e r I countfl08 (with 2 3 8 ~ )
neutrons
Miniature 2 3 5 ~ LND 0.25 in. diam 200-500 I cbunt/1013 . T h e r m a l neutron
fission chamber (Series 3075) neutrons to
1 count/l08
neutrons
Table A-1. (Continued).
Gas fill
Manufacturer and operating Operating pressure
model o r ' voltage temperature range
Type s e r i a l number . Size range (v) ("(2) (ah) Sensitivity ' Detection r a n g e
G a s fill .
Ma?ufactu:er and Operating Operating pressure
model o r voltage temperature range
s e r i a l number Size range (V) ("C) (atm) Sensitivity Detection r a n g e
-- -- - - --
3 ~ filled
e cylindrical LKD -
0.3 2 in. diam 1000-4800 -5OtolOO 4-20 - t h e r m a l neutrons
and q u a d r i l a t e r a l . 5 - 23 in. long
proportional counters
4
3 ~ filled
e cylindrical Reuter Stokes -
0.3 1 in. diam 2000-3000 <loo-150 4-40 0.1 -.I 9 cps/nv to 5 x L O nv
proportional counters -
5 52 in. long (thermal) (thermal)
3 ~ filled
e cylindrical Harshaw 0.25 - 4 :.n. diam 400-2000 <I75 1-40 - t h e r m a l and f a s t
proportional counters (Series H3.) 1 - 24 in. long neutrons
B 9 9 0 7 ~1°B) lined Centronics 1 in. diam 800 <220 0.5 3 cps/nv 3 t o 3 x lo4 nv
+/COz filled pulsed IPNIZEB) 9 in, long (thermal) (thermal)
proportional counter
R (92% ~ O B )lined Reuter Stokes 1 in. diam 2000 <200 0.26 1 cps/nv i 0 - 2 t o l o 5 nv
A/C% filled propor- (RSN-127A/ 8 in. long (thermal (thermal)
tional c o u n t e r s RSN-250)
9270 'OB lined porpor- Harshaw 1 in. diam 700-2000 ' -40 t o 200 0.26 - -
tional counter (B10-LA and 4 o r 14.5 in.
510-11s) long
B Lined p r o p o r t i o n d Victor een . - - - - - t h e r m a l and f a s t
m counter with 1 in. ( T y p e 488A) neutrons
I thick polyethylene
m o d e r a t o r and
1/32 in. Ca shield
1 . 1 3 0 ~( 9 3 ~ 20 3 5 ~ ) Reuter Stokes 3 X 3 X l in. 300-700 150 1 cps/nv -
103 109 nv
coated, A F H + (RSN-312-M4) (thermal) , (thermal)
. .
filled p r o p o r t ~ o n a l
counter
U (93% 2 3 5 ~ l)i n e d ' ~ ! r ~ R e u t e r Stokes 1 in. diam 200-800 300 1 0.1 cps/nv 10-I -
l o 6 nv
filled proportional (RSN-34A-MI) 8 in. long (thermal) (thermal)
counters
[Link] proton recoil. Centronics 1 - 2 in. diam 1500-4400 <200 1-10
cpY"v
50 10- t o
thermal - i.25 MeV .
. spherical propor- (Model SP2) <6.5 in. long -
tional counter 5 x 10-3 cpslnv
(fast)
H filled proton r e c o i l LND 1.7 in. diam . i500-3200 -50to75 1-4 5X cps/nv f a s t neutrons
s p h e r i c a l counter ( S e r i e s 270 and (fast)
281)
. Hurst-type polyethylene
lined, A/CH filled
,[Link]
(Series 280)
2 in. diam
6.75-21 in.
1400 0-50 5.7 - 0.1 - 15,MeV
proton r e c o t propor- long
tional counter
Table A-3. C3mmercially available scintillation detectors.
Gas fill
Mznufacturer and Operating pressure
model o r voltage range
Type s e r i a l number Size range (v) (atm) Sensitivity Detection r a n g e
..
ZnS(Ag) loaded c r y a t a l L'udlum 2.25 in. diam 900 - 0.25 cps/nv f a s t neutrons
proton.recoi1 scintilla- (Model 42-2) 7.5 in. long '(5 MeV neutrons)
tion d e t e c t o r
Scintillation p r o b e . Eberline 2 in. diam 900-1200 - - slow o r f a s t neutrons
a s s e m b l y with (Model SPA-2) 8 in. long
different c r y s t a l s :
-Natural B with ZnS(Ag)
-Enriched E with ZnS(Ag)
-96% enriched 6 ~with i ZnS(Ag)
-ZnS(Ag) d i s p e r s e d in c l e a r plastic -. -
ZnS(Ag) dispers'ed Ludlum 2in. diam . 1 cps/nv 1/V f o r t h e r m a l neutrons -
in B g l a s s t h e r m a l (Model 42-1) 7 in. long
scintillation detector
P o r t a b l e polyethylene Kaman 10 in. s p h e r e 5 cp~/~rem/hr t h e r m a l and fast-
moderated, 8 X 4 c m (Model 0-300) 0-14 MeV
, *
I 6Li1 c r y s t a l , scintil-
I@ lation d o s i m e t e r
4
' P o r t a b l e polyethylene Ludlum 12 in. s p h e r e - -1 c p s / m r e m / h r tnermal - 12 MeV
moderated, 4 X 4 cm (Model 42-4)
6Li1 c r y s t a l scintil-
lation d o s i m e t e r
Multiple Bonner s p h e r e Ludlum Spheres r a n g e - - t h e r m a l and f a s t n'eutrons
polyethyl e m o d e r a t e d (Model 42-5) . f r o m 2 t o 12 in.
'3'.
4 X 4 c m LLI c r y s t a l
neutron s p e c t r c m e t e r . t
Gas fill
Manufacturer and Operating pressure
model o r temperature range
Type serialnumber . Sizerange (OC) (atm) Sensitivity Detection range
s em icon duct or neutron Ortec 1.4 in. diam A 3 ~ a et - .
spectrometer system. (System 5 2 5 ) 4 in. long 5 atm
(Two s u r f a c e b a r r i e r (detector head)
d e t e c t o r s in a face-to-
f a c e o r sandwich
geometry with neutron
sensitive material:
3 ~ o re ' L ~ F )
Self-powered neutron Reuter Stokes 0 . 0 6 2 5 in. diam - -
detectors: 4 in. sensitive
length
..
I
~ e u t r o nthermopile Nuclear Instr u- 0 . 5 in. diam - - 5 X 10'12 mV/nv linear betkeen
03
I m e n t s and Chem- 6 . 5 in. Long 107 and 1012 nv
ical Corp. . -
(Model 3 7 8 2 )
DISTRIBUTION
L L L Internal Distribution W. H. C h a m b e r s
G. R. Keepin
Roger E. B a t z e l , . L. J , Mullins, Jr.
H. H. B a r s c h a l l M. J. Katz
L o s A l a m o s Scientific
S. Block Laboratory
T . R. C r i t e s L o s Alamos, New Mexico
R. A . daRoza 40 . J. R. B e y s t e r
S . I;. E c c l e s . Science Applications, Inc.
.
. .
,
L a Jolla, California
F. F a i r b r o t h e r
H. C. F o r s b e r g E. J. Wesley
Naval u n d e r s e a C e n t e r
V. E. Hampel San Diego, California
W. Heckrotte
H. Lamonds
R. J. Howerton EWG
D. E. J o n e s Goleta, California .
A: L o r e n z 30
D. S. [Link] E WG-
L a s Vegas, Nevada
D. E. Nielsen
C. T. P r e v o M. T a b e r z a d e r
California Institute of Technology
J. F. Tinney ~ a s a d e n a ,California
J. T. Okada
R. B e l c h e r
N. D. Bailey University of ~ a r y l a n d ,
W. M. McClelland College P a r k , M a r y l a n d
C. L. Teevan J. J . Schmidt
K. C. Bandtel . . Intkrnational Atomic E n e r g y ''
Agency , .
G. F. Dickerson. Vienna, Austrta. . . ,
E. A. P l a t t
M a j o r ~ e n e r a F.
l A. C a m m
M. W. Knapp D. . I. 'Gale'
J. W. Hadley J . G. P o o r
U. S. Atomid E n e r g y C o m m i s s i o n
J. -L. McDonnel Washington, D. C.
W. J. Hogan
P. G. IvIcManigal
R. G. Olson E. H. Willis
TID F i l e 30 . Advanced R e s e a r c h P r o j e c t s , Agency
Agency
Arlington, Virginia
E x t e r n a l Distribution
J. W. R v s e a g r e n
S. P e a r l s t e i n Defense Nuclear Agency
H. J. KvuLs Washington, D. C.
Brookhaven National L a b o r a t o r y
IJpton, New Yvrk Technical Information C e n t e r
Oak Ridge
"This report was prcparcd as an accounl ol' work sponsored b y
thc United Stales (;overnmc~il. Neither llie Unilcd Slalcs nor
the Utiiled States Atomic Energy C'wnmission, nor any ol'their
e ~.n p. l ~ y nor
~ . any
~ ~ .o f llicir contr:lcturs, suhcunlr;~clors, or lhcir
cmployccr, ni:~kes any warranty. expros or i~nplic([Link] ;Issurncs
any legal liability or rcsponsibilily for Iltc acuur;[Link]
ur vscfulncss of any inli,rmalion, gpp;iratus, product or pruccss
disclosed. or rcprescnls tliai i l r usc wt,uld not inl'ringc privatcly-
owncd rigl~ts."