Process Dynamics and Control - Compiled Notes
Process Dynamics and Control - Compiled Notes
Note : Automation Systems may include Control Systems but the reverse is not true.
Control Systems may be parts of Automation Systems. The main function of control
systems is to ensure that outputs follow the set points.
Advantages -
● Consistency and accuracy in rate of production
● More economic use of power (may be fuel of electric energy)
● Reduction of physical effort
● Qualitative and quantitatively better product
Process Variables -
● Control Variable - The variable
of the process plant which is
controlled in order to achieve the
best performance of the Process.
(Temp of heat exchanger Outlet)
● Load Variable - The variable of
the process plant which causes
the deviation of control variable
from set value (Feed flow rate, oil feed temp, ambient temp)
● Manipulated Variable - The variable of the process plant which needs to be
manipulated in order to adjust the deviation [deviation may occur due to load
variables] to achieve set values. (Steam flow)
● Set Points - Desired value of the output.
● Deviation / Error - Difference between Set points and control variables.
● Signal
1. 2.
3.
Time Lag -
1. Overall Process 2. Distance - Velocity 3. Transfer
Example -
A pressure vessel of capacitance C is being pressurized from zero initial pressure
through a valve of process resistance R. Find the expression for dynamic characteristics
of the system.
1. When the pressure vessel is being pressurized from a constant pressure source.
2. When it is being pressurized from a constant speed pump.
Case I - Pressure vessel is being pressurized from a constant Pressure. So P1(t) =Pc
=> =>
Case II - P1(t)=Kt, K is the rate of increase of pressure at the outlet of the pump.
And we know .
Class - 2
Feedback Control System (Control
variation measurement) - The control
system in which the control variation is
measured by measuring unit and this
measured value is fed back to the controller
which compares the measured value with
the desired value and accordingly sense a common signal or control action signal to the
final control element or correcting it in order to counteract any deviation produced.
● In many processes there exists a finite delay between the manipulated variable
and its effect on the control variables. For a larger delay the process may be
subject to frequent disturbances during delay time and hence it is very difficult to
restore perfect balance by the feedback control system.
● Since a deviation in a control variation must appear before any correcting action
can start, a perfect control is not possible during the feedback control system.
● The value of the manipulated variables needed to balance the load must be
obtained by trial and error method in a feedback control system.
● The load variables can be divided into various components such as feed rate,
feed composition, feed temperature etc. Hence there must always be at least one
manipulated variable for each independent control load variable.
If we want to select the feedforward transfer function, such that the effect of disturbance
at the output is zero, then the coefficient of N(s) is set to 0. Thus,
or,
Proportional Controller -
● m (Change in Manipulated Variable) ∝ e (Error Signal or Deviation)
m=Kce; where Kc, Proportional sensitivity or Gain.
● PB (Proportional Band) is the change in control variable expressed in terms of %
of maximum span for which the final control element traverses its full path.
Say if the controller ranges from 1000C to 10000C, and if 10% PB is set i.e controllable
range is 10% of(1000-100)0C=900C i.e ±450C about set value. So, if the set value is
5000 C then the controller works between the range of (500-45)0 C to (500+45)0 C.
Valve is initially 50% open condition.
Relation Between PB and Proportional sensitivity -
Kc = change in manipulated Variable/ change in error
Kc = %change in manipulated Variable/%change in control variable
Kc = 100/PB
● Offset - Minimum Steady State error that cannot be eliminated by the controller.
Cannot Eliminate Offset - The error signal gets smaller as the controller is trying to
eliminate it. As manipulating signal m ∝ error, m gets so less that it cannot change the
control valve position, hence a small error (steady state) always exists.
Minimizing Offset -
• Increasing Gain of Proportional Controller
• Selecting Proportional Band
• Shifting the set point
• Using integral control action
Mathematical Modeling -
Integral or Reset Control Action -
Integral control action or reset control action is the control action where rate of change
in manipulating Variable is proportional to error.
=> =>
Damping Constant is :
In the same way as in integral control, we can conclude that the steady state error
would be zero for P-I action. Besides, the closed-loop characteristic equation for P-I is -
; ; for which we obtain the damping constant as:
Proportional + Derivative Control Action (PD) -
Since the derivative action is proportional to rate of change of deviation or error, it is not
used alone in a control system. Since during step change of deviation it will produce an
infinitely large change in manipulating variable producing large overshoot and
undershoot which may be dangerous to the process plant. m = Kce + KcTd (de/dt) +M
e=0 for t<0 and e = Et for t>=0.
So m = KcEt + KcTdE+ M or m-M = KcE(t+Td )
At Td = 0, m-M = KcEt & At t = Td ,m-M = 2 KcTd E
PIDD-1 -
The inverse derivative control action is a special type of control action which is used in
very fast processes & is defined as the control action in which the change in man. var. is
inversely prop. to the rate of change of the deviation.
PI m(t) = Kce(t)+ Kc/Ti ∫edt +M. m(s)= Kc /Ti s (1+ Tis )e(s)
PD m(t) = Kce(t)+ KcTd de/dt +M. m(s)= Kc (1+ Td s )e(s)
PID m(t) = Kce(t)+ Kc/Ti ∫edt + KcTd m(s)= Kc (1+ 1/Ti s + Tds) e(s)
de/dt +M.
PIDD-1 m(t) = Kce(t)+ Kc/Ti ∫edt + KcTd m(s)= Kc /Tis (1+ Tis )( (1+
de/dt +Kc/Td/α de/dt+M. Tds) /(1+ (Td s / α )))e(s)
Selection of Controller -
In a particular process plant control loop func. depends on modes of control action and
process characteristics. selected by considering following parameters:
• Max deviation: PD<PID<P<PI<I
• Offset: P>PD
• Proportional sensitivity: PD>PID>P>PI
• Stabilization time: PD<PID<PI<I
Class - 3
Pneumatic Controller -
The major advantages of using pneumatic systems are
(i) they are intrinsically safe and can be used in hazardous atmospheres,
(ii) cheap compared to hydraulic systems (air costs nothing) and
(iii) a pneumatic actuator can generate more torque (force) to its own weight and thus
have a better torque-weight ratio compared to an electrical actuator.
Disadvantage - Slow in response.
Self Operating Controller -
Since air leaked to the atmosphere through a cylindrical gap of diameter d2 and length
x. At steady state
=>
=>
=>
Pneumatic Relay -
• The major limitation of a flapper nozzle amplifier is its limited air handling capacity.
The variation of air pressure obtained cannot be used for any useful application,
unless the air handling capacity is increased.
• An air relay serves the similar purpose as a power amplifier. It is used after the
flapper nozzle amplifier to enhance the volume of air.
θf θI
θi
Let the deflection of the flapper due to the deviation of the control variable on the
desired signal is BB1 = θi , so that the deflection of the flapper is θn’ due to feedback
action by feedback below.
AA1 = θf , so that the deflection of flapper away from nozzle due to feedback action is
CC2 = θn”
And due to integral action, the displacement of end A of the motion beam is AA1 = θI so
that the deflection of flapper towards nozzle due to integral action is CC3 = θn’’’ , so net
depression of flapper towards nozzle is θn = θn’ - θn’’ + θn’’’
Electronic Controllers -
Analog PID Controller - these controllers are Integrated Circuit (IC) based.
Digital Controller - In the digital control mode, the error signal is first sampled and the
controller output is computed numerically through a digital processor. The above
Analog PID Controller Digital PID Controller
This algorithm is
known as Position
Algorithm
Our objective is to find out the optimum settings of the P,I,D parameters, namely
The basic criteria which are to be satisfied in order to obtain the best performance of the
process by an automatic control loop are :
● Decay Ratio: Ratio of 2nd peak overshoot to 1st peak overshoot should be 1/4th.
(In most Industrial applications, this is the most important point)
P mode only
PI mode
PID mode
Damped Oscillation method by Harriot - The controller is placed in a closed loop and
is initially set to proportional mode only. Let Kd be the proportional gain setting for
obtaining 1/4th decay ratio.
Open loop method by Cohen & Coon - the process is assumed to be a stable first
order system with time delay. From the process reaction curve the point of maximum
rate of change of process variable is determined at the point of tangent.
Process Gain K
= Final change in steady state value in %/ Step
change in controller output
= (Final steady state value-initial value)%/(Step
change in controller output)
= Final steady state value in % due to unit step
change of final control element - initial steady
state value (%)
Finding Rr, Lr and K, the index of self regulation is defined by Cohen & Coon as
μ= RrLr/K.
● P mode only
● PI mode
● PID mode
Class - 5
Special Control Schemes -
Ratio Control - Ratio control is a special type of feedforward control where the
disturbance is measured and the ratio of the process output and the disturbance is held
constant. It is mostly used to control the ratio of flow rates of two streams. Flow rates of
both the streams are measured, but only one of them is controlled.
Few examples are:
• fuel-air ratio control in burners,
• control of ratio of two reactants entering a reactor at a desired ratio,
• maintaining the ratio of two blended streams constant in order to maintain the
composition of the blend at the desired value.
Override Control -
F/B flow control with override control of level -
We are maintaining the upper and lower
level of the tank by controlling the flow
control system along with that there is a
level measuring system and there is a
level controller(LIC), it may choose flow
controller or level controller depending
on requirement, say when level goes
below the upper set value the pressure
at the column will decrease, accordingly
the flow rate will be changed so in turn
the path will get closer and the flow rate
will decrease but the selector switch
instantaneously selects the level controller first as it changes the level so this will take
the corrective action instead of the flow controller, and the the selector will transmit the
controller output to the control panel. This function is called overriding. It is used for
delicate systems where due to small change of say level or other parameter it may get
affected. For these systems, along with the existing control system there is an overriding
element for selecting the controller output in order to get faster or quick response.
Override Control of Level for Min/Max Position -
For say maximum position there is a level
one controller (LIC1) for minimum position
and there is a level two (LIC2) controller.
And there is another selector switch.
Normally, there is a selector which selects
the flow controller path, but if level change
just suddenly then the selector will transfer
the level controller output to the control bar
and if it is for upper level then it will choose
the upper level controller output and if it is
for lower level then it will choose the lower
level controller response. So in order to
choose lower or upper level there is another selector controller FYC1. So for delicate
systems where minute changes in process variables may affect the production, we use
this arrangement.
The standard range of actuator input signal or controlled output signal is 0.2 to 1 Kg/cm2
and this stroke length of the valve stem is generally lies between ¼’’ or 3’’ or 6 or 75 mm
but the standard allowable stroke length is generally limited to 1’’ or 25 mm. The
performance of the spring actuator will be satisfactory if the following conditions are
maintained :
● The force on the stem should not be high such that the material of the stem may
operate within elastic limit.
● The natural frequency of vibration should not be much greater than 25 Hz where
natural frequency is determined by the relation , where K = Spring
constant and M = Mass of the whole system.
● The static frictional force must be limited to a low value such that the effective
hysteresis loss is very small. If mr is the range of the input pneumatic signal, then
the hysteresis loss will be less than 1% of full travel when the static frictional
force satisfies the relation .
Note :- This is a very serious limitation since it produces a limiting value of the
frictional force which may not be achieved in practical cases. E.g for control
signal of 3 to 15 psi and actuator diaphragm of effective area 100 inch2, the
maximum value of frictional force that should be maintained to obtain hysteresis
loss 1% of full travel is only.
● The total thrust force due to the process fluid acting in one direction should be
less than m0A, where m0 be the input signal at zero stroke and also this force
should be constant throughout the whole range of the controller, otherwise the
input signal will not be linearly related with the stem movement.
● The characteristics of the spring and diaphragm should be within the elastic limit
and the effective area of the diaphragm and spring constant should remain
constant throughout the full stroke of the valve stem, otherwise linear relation
between input signal and valve stroke cannot be maintained.
Valve Positioner - When static friction, hysteresis and unbalance thrust force acting on
the motion of stem of a control valve are large or the response of the actuator
diaphragm is too slow especially in the case of single seated valve the simple spring
actuator cannot position the plug at the desired position with an accuracy as desired by
the control loop. In this case a valve positioner is used with the spring actuator. A valve
positioner is a device which is used to position the valve stem at the desired position
with high accuracy. It is generally of two types-the valve positioner without booster relay
and valve positioner with booster relay. (Booster relay acts as an amplifier)
Spring Actuator with Positioner with booster relay - In the positioner of booster
relay, as the feedback pressure of flapper-nozzle system is further amplified by the
booster relay such that the desire volume of air may
be supplied to the actuator for producing a certain
movement of the valve stem. With the increase of
input signal the flapper moves towards the nozzle such
that nozzle flapper pressure increases and so the
bellows element of the booster relay connected to the
nozzle chamber moves the pilot valve towards the
exhaust port. This increases the feedback pressure of
the relay chamber and so the pressure in the actuator
increases and the stem moves downward until it
attains the correct desired position.
Advantages of Positioner -
• It helps in overcoming the stem friction through high open loop gain.
• It accurately positioned the control valve stem at the desired value irrespective
of the bench-range or unbalance force on the valve stem.
• The hysteresis effect is reduced by the positioner and is linear between the
valve movement and control signal is improved by the action of a positioner.
Since the effect of static friction is counterbalanced by the amplified signal
produced by the positioner.
• The positioner with booster relay can handle much frictional force of a large
control valve.
• The variable thrust forces acting on the stem cannot disturb the accurate
position of the stem due to the action of the positioner.
• The speed of response of a control valve is increased by the action of booster
relay in a positioner.
Depending on the several conditions of the pipelines a large variety of control valve
body has been designed. But they can be broadly divided into three categories:
• Sliding stem or globe body - has straight or angle configuration and also it may
have different types of end connections to meet the requirement.
• Rotating stem body - the stem rotates about an axis and the plug of the control
valve also rotates about that axis in order to close or open the valve port, e.g.,
butterfly valve, ball valve etc.
• Specialized body - a special structure of the body is designed in order to handle
slurry of very low flow, very high pressure of the order of 2500 psi e.g., weir type
valve, gate valve etc.
The parts of the control valve which are in contact with the process fluid are together
called trim of control action. The control valve plug, stem, seat and cage are together
called the trim of the control action. Control valves can also be characterized in terms of
the number of plugs present, as single-seated valve and double-seated valve.
• Single-seated valve has only one seat area. The advantage is that it can more
tightly close the valve than the double seated valve. But the disadvantage is that,
the thrust on the plug due to flowing fluid is very high and so a large diaphragm
area of the actuator is required to produce a force greater than the thrust.
• Double seated plug - In this type of plug, the fluid enters the valve body between
two seats and is thus divided into two streams. As the surface area of the upper
and lower plug are almost equal the thrust force due to the differential pressure
existing across the plug in the process fluid is almost equal and opposite for the
two plugs and so the net force which should be applied to the plug stem is
negligibly small. So the area of the actuator required to produce a force greater
than the net thrust force may be very small. So the valve may be accurately
positioned without the help of a positioner. That is why double seated valves are
widely used in 3-term controllers. The disadvantage of double seated valve is that
since the force applied on the plug by the actuator is small so the tight shut off
condition of the valve at low flow condition cannot be easily obtained.
The single or double seated plug may be of three types depending on process
condition, which are:
• The Poppet type plug is used for ON-OFF controllers, where the movement of
valve stem is small and the stem is positioned between maximum and minimum
and orifice area increases almost linearly with the valve lift.
• V-port and Contour type plugs are used for proportional and other modes of
controller and the choice of the particular plug depends on the flow characteristics
of the control valve.
Poppet Type
(Double Seated)
V-port Type Poppet Type (Single Seated)
Flow Characteristics - It describes how the flow rate changes with the movement or
lift of the stem. The shape of the plug primarily decides the flow [Link] flow
characteristic of a valve is normally defined in terms of (a) inherent characteristics and
(b) effective characteristics.
An inherent characteristic is the ideal flow characteristics of a control valve and is
decided by the shape and size of the plug. On the other hand, when the valve is
connected to a pipeline, its overall performance is decided by its effective
characteristics.
Ideal Characteristics - The control valve acts like an orifice and the position of the plug
decides the area of opening of the orifice. Recall that the flow rate through an orifice can
be expressed in terms of the upstream and downstream static pressure heads as:
Now the area of the control valve opening (a) is again dependent on the stem position,
or the lift. So if the upstream and downstream static pressure heads are somehow
maintained constant, then the flow rate is a function of the lift (z), i.e.
The shape of the plug decides how the flow rate changes with the stem movement, or
lift; and the characteristics of q vs. z are known as the inherent characteristics of the
valve. Let us define
where, qmax is the maximum flow rate, when the valve is fully open and zmax is the
corresponding maximum lift. So equation can be rewritten in terms of m and x as:
The valve sensitivity is defined as dm/dx, or the slope of the curve m vs. x. All the
characteristics are to be determined after maintaining constant pressure difference
across the valve. In this way, the control valves can be classified in terms of their m vs x
characteristics, and three types of control valves are normally used are:
For an equal percentage valve, the flow characteristics are mathematically expressed
as: dm/dx=βx, where β is a const. The expression indicates that the slope of the flow
characteristics is proportional to the present flow rate, justifying the term equal
percentage. This flow characteristic is linear on a semilog graph paper. The minimum
flow rate m0 (flow rate at x=0) is never zero for an equal percentage valve and m can be
expressed as: m=m0eβx
In this type of valve a tight shut off condition is not possible even at the extreme
minimum position of the stem movement. As a result at the minimum position of the
stem there is a leakage.. So for this type of valve a term called Rangeability (R) is
defined as follows:
Effective Characteristics -
The ideal characteristics of a control valve is decided by the shape of the plug, and the
pressure drop across the valve is assumed to
be held constant. But in practice, the control
valve is installed in conjunction with other
equipment, such as heat exchanger, pipeline,
orifice, pump etc. The elements will have their
own flow vs. pressure characteristics and
cause additional frictional loss in the system
and the effective characteristics of the valve
will be different from the ideal characteristics.
Let us consider a control valve connected with a pipeline of length L in between two
tanks. We consider the tanks are large enough so that the heads of the two tanks H0
and H2 can be assumed to be constant. We also assume that the ideal characteristic of
the control valve is linear. So where K is a constant and z is the stem
position or lift. The pipeline will experience some head loss that is again dependent on
the velocity of the fluid.
Control Valve Sizing - The proper size of the control valve is selected such that control
of flow over a wide range is possible. The pressure drop, flow and specific gravity
determines the selection of a control valve. In ideal condition the flow passing by a
control valve is where G = Specific gravity, A = Opening area of the control
valve port and K = Proportionality constant .
There are other characteristics such as type of the fluid i.e., gas or liquid, critical flows
condition for gasses and vapors, viscosity of the liquid also influences the valve sizing.
To select a valve the flow condition has to be such that the process characteristics and
the valve characteristics must match with each other so that non-linearity of the overall
control loop may be eliminated. e.g., if the control valve is oversized then the minimum
controllable flow is too large and if it is undersized then the required maximum flow of
the process may not be provided by the valve. Hence the proper sizing of the control
valve is always necessary and it is selected and designed by correcting the ideal
discharge constant K.
In order to sizing a control valve by this method a factor called the flow coefficient factor
or valve coefficient factor or factor is defined by the relation where
and K/ = corrected value of K.
This Cv factor is defined as the number of US gallons of water flowing per minute at
600F through a fully open control valve under pressure drop of 1 psi. For liquid, steam
and gas the correction factors due to temperature, specific volume and specific gravity
are considered and flow equation for these three types of fluids for a control valve
position Cv at a differential pressure ΔP is given by
For liquid:
For steam:
For gas:
● Step2 - Select the maximum flow rate which the control valve is to provide. This
is generally selected to be 1.4 times the normal maximum flow rate.
● Step3 - Select the type and style of control valve for best operation. For this
selection the rangeability of the valve has to be selected such that the minimum
controllable flow rate is generally smaller than the normal minimum flow rate.
● Step4 - Calculate the pressure difference at the control valve at the maximum
flow rate considering a pressure loss.
● Step5 - Determine the control valve size from the manufacturer monograph chart
or by calculating value from the flow equations of the control valve. Now if the
fluid viscosity is high or the velocity of fluid is exceptionally low then the size
coefficient will be low and the manufacturer should be asked to determine for
that condition of the process.
● Step6 -
In this step the characteristics coefficient, defined by
=diff. in pr. when cv is fully opened/ diff. in pr. when cv is fully closed.
If α<0.1 or
where, Q = normal flow rate and Qmin = normal minimum flow rate.
Then the control valve will be required to operate at less than 2% of total lift.
In this case the control valve should have a powerful actuator and accurate valve
seat and plug or the difference pressure head should be increased by selecting
the larger pumps, larger line size and minimizing the line loss.
Class - 7
Transmitter -
For pneumatic transmitters there is a flapper nozzle system and pneumatic amplifier or
relay. The transducing signal from the measuring device is sent to the flapper unit so
that the displacement of flapper nozzle can be changed and accordingly the nozzle
feedback pressure changes, that is the controller output or the transmitter output and
that sends to the pneumatic relay since the signal is very low. In order to amplify this
there is a Pneumatic relay and the signal sent to the receiver end is the pneumatic
signal of 0.2 to 1 kg per cm2 or 3 to 15 psi. There are two types of receiver called
receiver gauge at the receiver end which is typically of the range of 0.2 to 1 kg per cm2
or 3 to 15 psi and pressure gauge that may be of any range.
there is a transmitting Pot. Potentiometric circuit like say for a level control system for a
tank unit, if the level changes and say there is a float for measuring the level. Then if the
level changes accordingly the float Position will change and that will be connected as a
potentiometer circuit. So the electrical output from this potentiometer will change then
accordingly the current or voltage signal gets transmitted in terms of current signal, so
the measured electrical parameter will change. For electrical type transmitters there
exists a transmitting port in order to transmit the signal. The current signal is typically in
the 4 to 20 mA range.
Smart Transmitter -