Magic School Educational Design Project
Evaluation Rubric
Component Weight Excellent (4) Good (3) Satisfactory (2) Needs Improvement
(1)
Lesson Plan 30% Clear, well-structured, aligned Mostly clear and Basic structure present Incomplete, unclear,
Quality objectives, engaging activities, organized with minor but lacks depth, poorly organized, weak
strong pedagogy, complete gaps in alignment or alignment, or clarity. instructional design.
timing/resources. detail.
Worksheets 20% Highly engaging, visually clear, Well-designed Functional worksheets Poorly designed,
Design aligned to objectives, promotes worksheets with but limited creativity or unclear, or unrelated
critical thinking. moderate engagement weak alignment. worksheets.
and alignment.
Assessment 30% Strong formative and summative Good assessments with Basic assessments with Incomplete or
Tools tools, valid, clear, aligned with minor issues in clarity limited variety or weak ineffective assessment
learning outcomes. or alignment. alignment. tools.
AI-Resistance 10% Innovative authentic task that Effective task with Some attempt made, Weak or no AI-
Assessment strongly limits AI misuse and reasonable resistance to but limited originality resistance strategy
promotes genuine learning. AI overuse. or effectiveness. included.
Rubric 10% Clear criteria, measurable levels, Good rubric with Basic rubric with vague Incomplete, unclear, or
Quality fair descriptors, highly usable for minor gaps in clarity or criteria or uneven ineffective rubric.
grading. detail. descriptors.