Q.

1 Role of Intellectual Property in Economic Development of a Country

Introduction
Intellectual Property (IP) refers to the legal rights granted to creators and inventors over their
creations of the mind. These creations may include inventions, literary and artistic works,
trademarks, industrial designs, trade secrets, geographical indications, and software. Intellectual
Property Rights (IPRs) protect these creations from unauthorized use and provide exclusive rights
to the owner for a certain period.
In the modern knowledge-based economy, intellectual property plays a vital role in promoting
innovation, creativity, industrial growth, international trade, and technological advancement.
Countries with strong IP protection systems generally experience higher economic growth because
innovation and investment are encouraged.
The main forms of intellectual property include:
1. Patents
2. Copyrights
3. Trademarks
4. Industrial Designs
5. Geographical Indications
6. Trade Secrets

Meaning of Intellectual Property

Intellectual Property means property created by human intellect. Unlike physical property, IP is
intangible in nature. The owner of IP gets exclusive legal rights to use, sell, license, or transfer the
creation.
According to the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), intellectual property includes
creations such as inventions, literary and artistic works, symbols, names, images, and designs used
in commerce.

Role of Intellectual Property in Economic Development

1. Encouragement of Innovation and Creativity
The primary role of IP is to encourage innovation. Inventors and creators spend time, money, and
effort developing new products and technologies. IP protection assures them that their work will not
be copied without permission.
For example:
• Pharmaceutical companies invest heavily in research and development of medicines.
• Software developers create new applications and technologies.
• Authors and artists produce creative works.
Patent and copyright protection motivate such creators by granting exclusive rights and financial
rewards.
Economic Impact
• Increase in research and development (R&D)
• Growth of innovative industries
• Creation of new products and services
• Technological advancement

2. Promotion of Industrial Growth

Strong IP laws support industrial development by protecting business inventions, trademarks, and
designs. Companies become more willing to invest in manufacturing and production when their
products are legally protected.
For example:
• Automobile industries protect their technologies through patents.
• Fashion companies protect designs and trademarks.
• Technology firms protect software and inventions.
Economic Impact
• Expansion of industries
• Higher industrial productivity
• Better quality products
• Increased competitiveness
3. Attraction of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI)
Foreign investors prefer countries where intellectual property rights are effectively protected.
Strong IP laws create confidence among multinational companies that their inventions and brands
will remain secure.
Countries with efficient patent and trademark systems attract:
• Foreign technology companies
• Pharmaceutical firms
• Entertainment industries
• Manufacturing businesses
Economic Impact
• Increase in foreign investment
• Employment opportunities
• Transfer of technology
• Development of infrastructure

4. Generation of Employment
IP-intensive industries generate large-scale employment opportunities. Industries such as
entertainment, information technology, pharmaceuticals, publishing, biotechnology, and fashion
depend heavily on intellectual property.
For example:
• Film industries employ actors, editors, musicians, and technicians.
• Software industries employ programmers and developers.
• Research laboratories employ scientists and engineers.
Economic Impact
• Reduction in unemployment
• Growth of skilled workforce
• Better income generation

5. Promotion of International Trade

Trademarks, geographical indications, and patents increase the global reputation of products.
Protected products gain consumer trust in international markets.
Examples:
• Darjeeling Tea GI tag
• Champagne from France
• Nike trademark
IP protection also prevents counterfeiting and piracy in international trade.
Economic Impact
• Increase in exports
• Expansion of global markets
• Improvement in trade relations
• Growth in foreign exchange earnings

6. Technology Transfer and Development

Patent systems encourage disclosure of inventions. When inventors publish patent details, society
gains technical knowledge. Other researchers can further improve existing technologies after patent
expiry.
Technology transfer occurs through:
• Licensing agreements
• Joint ventures
• Franchising
• Research collaborations
Economic Impact
• Scientific progress
• Modernization of industries
• Development of domestic technology
7. Protection of Consumers
Trademarks help consumers identify genuine products and maintain quality standards. Consumers
trust branded goods because trademarks indicate the origin and quality of products.
For example:
• Consumers trust branded medicines and electronic goods.
• Counterfeit products are reduced through trademark protection.
Economic Impact
• Consumer confidence
• Fair competition
• Better product standards

8. Development of Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs)

Small businesses can use trademarks, patents, and designs to compete in the market. IP rights help
startups protect innovative ideas and attract investors.
For example:
• A startup with patented technology gains market value.
• Local artisans can protect traditional products through geographical indications.
Economic Impact
• Entrepreneurship development
• Startup growth
• Increase in business opportunities

9. Growth of Cultural and Creative Industries

Copyright protection promotes literature, music, films, paintings, and digital content. Creative
industries contribute significantly to national income.
Examples:
• Film industry
• Music industry
• Publishing industry
• Gaming industry
Economic Impact
• Preservation of culture
• Revenue generation
• Export of creative content

Challenges in Intellectual Property System

Despite its advantages, IP systems also face several challenges:
1. Piracy and counterfeiting
2. High cost of patent protection
3. Misuse of monopoly power
4. Lack of awareness among creators
5. Balancing public interest and private rights
6. Access to medicines in developing countries
Developing countries must balance innovation incentives with public welfare.

Important Case Law

Novartis AG v. Union of India
Citation:
(2013) 6 SCC 1

Facts of the Case

Novartis AG applied for a patent in India for the cancer medicine “Glivec.” The Indian Patent
Office rejected the application under Section 3(d) of the Indian Patents Act, 1970, stating that the
modified version of the drug did not show enhanced therapeutic efficacy.
Novartis challenged the rejection before the courts.
Judgment
The Supreme Court of India upheld the rejection of the patent application.
The Court held that:
• Minor modifications of existing medicines cannot receive patents without significant
improvement in efficacy.
• Patent law must balance innovation with public interest.
• The decision prevented “evergreening” of patents.

Conclusion
Intellectual property plays a crucial role in the economic development of a country. It promotes
innovation, industrial growth, technology transfer, employment generation, international trade, and
foreign investment. Strong intellectual property protection creates an environment where creativity
and entrepreneurship can flourish.
At the same time, IP laws must maintain a balance between the rights of creators and public interest.
A well-regulated intellectual property system contributes not only to economic growth but also to
technological progress, cultural development, and global competitiveness.
Therefore, intellectual property is considered one of the most valuable assets in the modern
economy and an essential tool for national development.

Q.2 Grounds for Refusal of Registration of a Trademark

Introduction
A trademark is a mark capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one person from those of
others. It may include a word, logo, symbol, design, label, signature, shape, color combination, or
slogan. Trademark registration gives the owner exclusive legal rights over the mark and protects it
from unauthorized use.
However, every trademark cannot be registered. The law provides certain grounds on which the
Registrar of Trademarks may refuse registration. These grounds are mainly provided under the
Trade Marks Act, 1999.
The grounds for refusal are broadly divided into:
1. Absolute Grounds for Refusal
2. Relative Grounds for Refusal
These are contained under Sections 9 and 11 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.

Meaning of Refusal of Registration

Refusal of registration means rejection of a trademark application by the Registrar when the mark
does not satisfy the legal requirements for registration.
The purpose of refusal is:
• To prevent confusion among consumers
• To protect public interest
• To protect existing trademark owners
• To maintain fairness in trade and commerce

I. Absolute Grounds for Refusal of Trademark Registration

(Section 9 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999)
Absolute grounds relate to the inherent nature and characteristics of the trademark itself.
1. Lack of Distinctive Character
[Section 9(1)(a)]
A trademark must be capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one person from those of
others. If the mark is common, ordinary, or incapable of identifying a particular source, registration
may be refused.
Examples:
• “BEST QUALITY” for clothes
• “SUPER” for soap
Such words are common and do not identify a unique business source.
Purpose:
To ensure that trademarks perform their primary function of distinguishing products.
2. Descriptive Marks
[Section 9(1)(b)]
Marks that directly describe:
• Quality
• Quantity
• Purpose
• Value
• Geographic origin
• Characteristics of goods or services
cannot generally be registered.
Examples:
• “SWEET” for sugar
• “COLD AND CREAMY” for ice cream
Reason:
No trader should get exclusive rights over ordinary descriptive words.

3. Customary or Common Trade Expressions

[Section 9(1)(c)]
Words or signs commonly used in trade practices or everyday language cannot be monopolized.
Examples:
• “Premium”
• “Deluxe”
These are commonly used terms in business.

4. Deceptive or Confusing Marks

[Section 9(2)(a)]
A trademark shall be refused if it is likely to deceive or confuse the public.
Examples:
• Using “Pure Silk” for synthetic fabric
• Using false medicinal claims
Objective:
To protect consumers from fraud and misrepresentation.

5. Marks Hurtful to Religious Feelings

[Section 9(2)(b)]
Marks containing words, symbols, or images that may offend religious sentiments are refused
registration.
Examples:
• Sacred symbols used offensively
• Religious names used improperly for commercial purposes
Purpose:
To maintain public morality and religious harmony.

6. Scandalous or Obscene Marks

[Section 9(2)(c)]
Marks containing vulgar, obscene, immoral, or scandalous matter cannot be registered.
Purpose:
To protect public morality and decency.

7. Prohibited Emblems and Symbols

[Section 9(2)(d)]
Marks prohibited under the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act, 1950 cannot be
registered.
Examples:
• National flag
• Government seals
• Names of international organizations
8. Shape Marks
[Section 9(3)]
The shape of goods cannot be registered if it:
1. Results from the nature of the goods themselves
2. Is necessary to obtain a technical result
3. Gives substantial value to the goods
Example:
The functional shape of a screwdriver cannot be monopolized.

II. Relative Grounds for Refusal of Trademark Registration

(Section 11 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999)
Relative grounds relate to conflicts with existing trademarks or earlier rights.

1. Identical or Similar Marks

[Section 11(1)]
A trademark may be refused if:
• It is identical or similar to an earlier trademark, and
• It is likely to cause confusion among the public.
Example:
“NIKKE” for shoes may be refused because it resembles “NIKE.”
Purpose:
To prevent consumer confusion and unfair competition.

2. Similar Goods or Services

Even if marks are not exactly identical, registration may be refused when similar marks are used for
related goods or services.
Example:
“PUMAA” for sportswear may confuse consumers with “PUMA.”

3. Protection of Well-Known Trademarks

[Section 11(2)]
A trademark may be refused if it takes unfair advantage of a well-known trademark or harms its
reputation.
Examples:
• “Google Tea”
• “Tata Fashion” without authorization
Objective:
To protect famous trademarks from dilution and misuse.

4. Passing Off Rights

[Section 11(3)]
Registration may be refused if the use of the trademark is prevented by the law of passing off or
copyright law.
Meaning of Passing Off:
Passing off occurs when one person misrepresents goods or services as those of another.

Other Grounds for Refusal

1. Bad Faith Application
If the application is made dishonestly or fraudulently, registration may be refused.
Example:
Applying for a famous foreign brand before the real owner enters the market.

2. Lack of Honest Use

If the applicant cannot prove genuine intention to use the mark, refusal may occur.

Important Case Law

Cadila Health Care Ltd. v. Cadila Pharmaceuticals Ltd.
Citation:
(2001) 5 SCC 73

Facts
Both companies used similar names:
• “Falcigo”
• “Falcitab”
These medicines were used for treatment of malaria.
Judgment
The Supreme Court of India held that even a small similarity in medicinal products may create
dangerous confusion among consumers.
The Court laid down factors for determining deceptive similarity.

Conclusion
The grounds for refusal of trademark registration are essential for maintaining fairness, consumer
protection, and healthy competition in the market. The Trade Marks Act, 1999 prevents registration
of marks that are deceptive, descriptive, immoral, non-distinctive, or conflicting with existing
trademarks.

Q.3 Rights of Broadcasting Organisations and Performers

Introduction
The rights of broadcasting organisations and performers are known as “neighbouring rights” or
“related rights” under copyright law. These rights protect the interests of persons and organizations
who contribute to the communication and performance of creative works.
In India, these rights are protected under the Copyright Act, 1957. Broadcasting organisations are
granted special rights over their broadcasts, while performers are granted rights over their
performances.
These rights help:
• Prevent unauthorized use of broadcasts and performances
• Protect economic interests
• Encourage artistic and entertainment industries
• Promote creativity and investment in media and entertainment
I. Rights of Broadcasting Organisations
Meaning of Broadcasting Organisation
A broadcasting organisation is an entity that transmits audio or visual content to the public through:
• Television
• Radio
• Satellite
• Cable
• Internet broadcasting
Examples include television channels, radio stations, and digital broadcasters.
Under Section 37 of the Copyright Act, broadcasting organisations are granted “Broadcast
Reproduction Rights.”
Broadcast Reproduction Right
(Section 37)
Every broadcasting organisation has a special right called the Broadcast Reproduction Right in its
broadcasts.
Duration
This right subsists for:
• 25 years
from the beginning of the calendar year following the year in which the broadcast is made.
Rights of Broadcasting Organisations
The broadcasting organisation has the exclusive right to prohibit the following acts without
permission:
1. Re-broadcasting of Broadcast
No person can rebroadcast the original broadcast through:
• Television
• Radio
• Cable
• Internet
Example:
A cable operator cannot retransmit a sports channel without authorization.
2. Recording the Broadcast
Unauthorized recording of broadcasts is prohibited.
Example:
Recording a live television program without permission for commercial use.
3. Reproduction of Recording
Copies of unauthorized recordings cannot be made or distributed.
Example:
Selling copied DVDs of television broadcasts.
4. Communication to the Public
The public exhibition or communication of a broadcast without authorization is prohibited.
Example:
Showing a live sports broadcast in a commercial establishment without a license.
5. Commercial Exploitation
No person can commercially exploit the broadcast without consent.
Example:
Uploading copyrighted television content online for pro t.
Infringement of Broadcast Reproduction Right
Under Section 37(3), broadcast rights are infringed when a person:
• Rebroadcasts without permission
• Makes unauthorized recordings
• Sells or hires copies
• Uses broadcasts for commercial gain
Exceptions
Certain acts are permitted:
• Private use
• Research
• Reporting current events
• Educational purposes
• Fair dealing
II. Rights of Performers
Meaning of Performer
Under Section 2(qq) of the Copyright Act, a performer includes:
• Actors
• Singers
• Musicians
• Dancers
• Acrobats
• Jugglers
• Lecturers
• Magicians
• Other entertainers
A performance means any live visual or acoustic presentation.
Performer’s Rights
(Section 38)
A performer has special rights over his/her performance.
Duration
fi
Performer’s rights exist for:
• 50 years
from the beginning of the calendar year following the year in which the performance is
made.

Exclusive Rights of Performers

A performer has the right to:
1. Make Sound or Visual Recording
No one can record the performance without the performer’s consent.
Example:
Recording a live concert without permission.
2. Reproduce the Performance
Unauthorized copying of recorded performances is prohibited.
Example:
Duplicating concert videos illegally.
3. Broadcast the Performance
Broadcasting a live performance requires permission of the performer.
Example:
Televising a stage performance without consent.
4. Sell or Rent Copies
Commercial sale or rental of performance recordings requires authorization.
5. Communication to the Public
The performer controls public communication of the performance.
Example:
Streaming a performer’s live show online without permission.
Performer’s Moral Rights
(Section 38B)
Performers also enjoy moral rights similar to authors.
These include:
1. Right of Attribution
The performer has the right to be identi ed and credited for the performance.
Example:
Mentioning the singer’s name in a music program.
2. Right Against Distortion
The performer can object to any distortion or modi cation that harms reputation.
Example:
Editing a performance in a defamatory manner.
Assignment of Performer’s Rights
A performer may:
• License rights
• Assign rights through agreement
• Receive royalties for commercial use
Even after assignment, certain moral rights remain protected.
Infringement of Performer’s Rights
Performer’s rights are infringed when someone:
• Records performances illegally
• Broadcasts without consent
• Sells unauthorized copies
• Communicates performance publicly without permission
Important Case Law
fi
fi
 Indian Performing Right Society Ltd. v. Eastern Indian Motion Pictures Association
Citation:
AIR 1977 SC 1443
Facts
The dispute involved rights relating to musical works and performances in cinematograph lms.
Judgment
The Supreme Court of India discussed the protection available to performers and creators under
copyright law and clari ed ownership and exploitation of rights in lms and musical works.

Conclusion
The rights of broadcasting organisations and performers play an important role in protecting the
entertainment and media industries. These rights prevent unauthorized reproduction, broadcasting,
recording, and commercial exploitation of broadcasts and performances.
The Copyright Act, 1957 ensures legal protection to broadcasters and performers by granting
economic and moral rights. Such protection promotes creativity, artistic expression, investment in
media industries, and fair compensation for talent and effort.

Q.4 Procedure for Registration of Trademarks

Introduction
A trademark is a distinctive mark, symbol, logo, word, phrase, design, or combination used by a
business to identify and distinguish its goods or services from those of others. Trademark
registration provides legal protection and grants exclusive rights to the owner over the mark.
In India, trademarks are governed by the Trade Marks Act, 1999 and the Trade Marks Rules, 2017.
The registration process is administered by the Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade
Marks through the Trademark Registry.
Registration of a trademark is not compulsory, but it gives statutory protection and several legal
advantages to the proprietor.
Meaning of Trademark Registration
Trademark registration is the legal process through which a trademark is of cially recorded in the
Register of Trademarks maintained by the Trademark Registry.
After registration, the owner gets:
• Exclusive right to use the trademark
• Right to sue for infringement
• Legal recognition and protection
• Goodwill and brand value
Objectives of Trademark Registration
1. To identify the origin of goods or services
2. To distinguish products from competitors
3. To protect consumers from confusion
4. To protect business goodwill and reputation
5. To prevent unauthorized use of the mark
Procedure for Registration of Trademark
The procedure for registration of trademarks involves several stages:
1. Trademark Search
Before ling an application, the applicant should conduct a trademark search to determine whether
a similar or identical trademark already exists.
Purpose
• Avoid con ict with existing marks
• Reduce chances of rejection
• Ensure uniqueness of the trademark
The search can be conducted through the of cial trademark database.
2. Selection of Appropriate Class
Goods and services are classi ed under different classes according to the Nice Classi cation
system.
Examples:
• Class 3 – Cosmetics and perfumes
fi
fl
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 • Class 25 – Clothing
• Class 35 – Advertising and business services
The applicant must choose the correct class for registration.
3. Filing of Trademark Application
The application for registration is led before the Trademark Registry in the prescribed form along
with the required fees.
Important Details in Application
• Name and address of applicant
• Description of trademark
• Class of goods/services
• Date of use (if already used)
• Power of attorney (if led through agent)
Forms Used
• TM-A (commonly used application form)
The application may be led:
• Physically
• Electronically (online)
4. Allotment of Application Number
After ling, the Trademark Registry issues:
• An application number
The applicant can use the symbol “™” after ling the application.
Importance
The application number helps track the status of the application.
5. Examination of Application
The Registrar examines the trademark application to determine whether it satis es legal
requirements.
The Registrar checks:
• Distinctiveness
• Similarity with existing trademarks
• Compliance with Sections 9 and 11 of the Trade Marks Act
6. Examination Report
After examination, the Registrar issues an Examination Report.
The report may contain:
1. Acceptance of application
2. Objections to registration
Grounds for Objection
• Descriptive mark
• Lack of distinctiveness
• Similarity with existing trademark
• Deceptive or prohibited mark
7. Reply to Examination Report
If objections are raised, the applicant must le a written reply within the prescribed period.
The applicant may:
• Submit explanations
• Provide evidence of use
• Argue legal grounds for acceptance
8. Hearing Before Registrar
If the Registrar is not satis ed with the written reply, a hearing may be conducted.
The applicant or advocate presents arguments supporting registration.
After hearing, the Registrar may:
• Accept the mark
• Reject the application
• Impose conditions or limitations
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 9. Publication in Trademark Journal
If accepted, the trademark is published in the Trademark Journal.
Purpose
To invite objections from the public.
Publication allows third parties to oppose the registration if they believe the trademark affects their
rights.
10. Opposition Proceedings
Any person may le opposition within:
• 4 months from the date of publication.
Grounds for Opposition
• Similarity with existing mark
• Bad faith
• Lack of distinctiveness
• Prior use by another person
Procedure
1. Notice of opposition
2. Counter statement by applicant
3. Evidence by parties
4. Hearing
5. Decision by Registrar
11. Registration of Trademark
If:
• No opposition is led, or
• Opposition is decided in favor of the applicant,
the trademark is registered.
The Registrar issues:
• Certi cate of Registration
The owner can now use the symbol “®”.
12. Duration and Renewal
Duration
Trademark registration is valid for:
• 10 years
Renewal
It can be renewed inde nitely for successive periods of 10 years upon payment of renewal fees.
Rights Acquired After Registration
The registered proprietor gets:
1. Exclusive right to use the trademark
2. Right to sue for infringement
3. Right to assign or license the mark
4. Statutory protection throughout India
5. Creation of goodwill and brand value
Refusal of Registration
The Registrar may refuse registration on:
• Absolute grounds (Section 9)
• Relative grounds (Section 11)
Examples:
• Descriptive marks
• Deceptive marks
• Similar trademarks
Important Case Law
N.R. Dongre v. Whirlpool Corporation
1996
Facts
Whirlpool Corporation sought protection of its trademark “WHIRLPOOL” in India against
unauthorized use by another company.
fi
fi
fi
fi
 Judgment
The Supreme Court of India recognized the trans-border reputation of the trademark and protected
the well-known mark even though it had limited direct sales in India at that time.
Conclusion
The procedure for registration of trademarks under the Trade Marks Act, 1999 is designed to ensure
that only genuine, distinctive, and lawful trademarks receive protection. The registration process
includes application, examination, publication, opposition, and nal registration.
Trademark registration helps businesses protect their identity, goodwill, and reputation in the
market. It also safeguards consumers from confusion and unfair trade practices. Therefore,
trademark registration is an essential legal tool for modern commercial and industrial development.

Q.5 Note on Opposition of Patents

Introduction
A patent is an exclusive legal right granted to an inventor for a new invention that is capable of
industrial application and involves an inventive step. Patent protection gives the inventor the
exclusive right to make, use, sell, and distribute the invention for a limited period.
However, not every patent application should be granted automatically. To prevent wrongful or
invalid patents, the law provides a mechanism called “Opposition of Patents.”
Opposition proceedings allow interested persons to challenge the grant of a patent on speci c legal
grounds. In India, patent opposition is governed by the Patents Act, 1970.
The purpose of patent opposition is:
• To ensure only genuine inventions receive patents
• To prevent misuse of patent rights
• To protect public interest
• To maintain fairness and innovation in the patent system

Meaning of Opposition of Patents

Patent opposition means a legal procedure through which a person challenges the grant of a patent
before or after it is granted.
The opposition may be based on grounds such as:
• Lack of novelty
• Obviousness
• Wrongful obtaining
• Non-patentable subject matter
• Insuf cient disclosure

Types of Patent Opposition in India

Under the Patents Act, 1970, there are two types of opposition:
1. Pre-Grant Opposition
2. Post-Grant Opposition

I. Pre-Grant Opposition
(Section 25(1))
Meaning
Pre-grant opposition is led before the patent is granted.
Who Can File?
• Any person
This means even a third party or public interest group can oppose the patent application.
When Can It Be Filed?
• After publication of the patent application
• Before grant of patent
fi
fi
fi
fi
 Grounds for Pre-Grant Opposition
A patent application may be opposed on the following grounds:
1. Wrongful Obtaining
If the applicant wrongfully obtained the invention from another person.
Example:
An employee steals another scientist’s invention and les a patent.

2. Prior Publication
If the invention was already published before the priority date.
Purpose:
A patent is granted only for new inventions.

3. Prior Claim
If the invention is already claimed in another earlier patent application.

4. Publicly Known or Publicly Used

If the invention was publicly known or used in India before ling.

5. Lack of Inventive Step

If the invention is obvious to a skilled person and does not involve innovation.

6. Non-Patentable Subject Matter

If the invention falls under non-patentable categories under Section 3 of the Patents Act.
Examples:
• Discovery of scienti c principle
• Traditional knowledge
• Mathematical methods
7. Insuf cient Disclosure
If the complete speci cation does not clearly describe the invention.

8. Failure to Disclose Information

If the applicant fails to disclose information relating to foreign patent applications.

9. Convention Application Filed Late

If the convention application was not led within the prescribed period.

10. Traditional Knowledge

If the invention is based on traditional knowledge already known within communities.
Example:
Patenting traditional medicinal uses of turmeric or neem.

Procedure for Pre-Grant Opposition

1. Filing representation against grant
2. Examination by Controller
3. Notice to applicant
4. Reply and evidence by applicant
5. Hearing (if required)
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 6. Decision by Controller
The Controller may:
• Refuse patent
• Require amendment
• Grant patent

II. Post-Grant Opposition

(Section 25(2))
Meaning
Post-grant opposition is led after the patent has been granted.
Who Can File?
• Any “person interested”
Meaning of Person Interested
A person engaged in:
• Research
• Manufacturing
• Business related to the patented invention

Time Limit
Post-grant opposition must be led within:
• 1 year from the date of publication of grant of patent.

Grounds for Post-Grant Opposition

The grounds are almost similar to pre-grant opposition:
1. Wrongful obtaining
2. Prior publication
3. Prior claim
4. Public use or knowledge
5. Obviousness
6. Non-patentable invention
7. Insuf cient disclosure
8. Failure to disclose foreign information
9. False disclosure
10. Traditional knowledge

Procedure for Post-Grant Opposition

1. Filing Notice of Opposition
The opponent les a notice before the Controller.

2. Constitution of Opposition Board

The Controller forms an Opposition Board consisting of members with technical expertise.
Function
The Board examines:
• Documents
• Evidence
• Patent claims
and submits recommendations.
3. Reply by Patentee
The patent holder les a counter-statement and evidence.
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
4. Hearing
Both parties are given an opportunity to present arguments.

5. Decision of Controller
The Controller may:
• Maintain patent
• Amend patent
• Revoke patent

Importance of Patent Opposition

1. Prevents Invalid Patents
Ensures only deserving inventions receive protection.

2. Protects Public Interest

Stops monopolies over non-genuine inventions.

3. Encourages Genuine Innovation

Promotes real scienti c and technological development.

4. Prevents Exploitation of Traditional Knowledge

Protects indigenous and traditional knowledge from wrongful patents.

5. Maintains Patent Quality

Improves reliability and credibility of the patent system.

Important Case Law

Novartis AG v. Union of India
(2013)
Facts
Novartis AG applied for a patent for the cancer drug “Glivec.” The patent was opposed on the
ground that the modi ed drug lacked enhanced ef cacy and was merely a new form of a known
substance.
Judgment
The Supreme Court of India rejected the patent claim under Section 3(d) of the Patents Act.

Conclusion
Opposition of patents is an important safeguard in patent law. It ensures that patents are granted
only for genuine, novel, and inventive inventions. The Indian patent system provides both pre-grant
and post-grant opposition mechanisms to protect public interest and maintain the integrity of the
patent regime.
Patent opposition promotes fair competition, prevents abuse of monopoly rights, protects traditional
knowledge, and encourages true innovation. Thus, it plays a vital role in balancing private rights
and societal welfare.
fi
fi
fi
 Q.6 Absolute and Relative Grounds for Refusal of Trademark Registration
Introduction
A trademark is a mark, symbol, logo, word, label, design, or combination used to distinguish the
goods or services of one person from those of others. Trademark registration provides exclusive
legal protection and prevents unauthorized use.
However, not every trademark can be registered. The law provides certain grounds on which the
Registrar may refuse registration of a trademark. These grounds are contained in the Trade Marks
Act, 1999.
The grounds for refusal are divided into two categories:
1. Absolute Grounds for Refusal — Section 9
2. Relative Grounds for Refusal — Section 11
These provisions protect:
• Public interest
• Consumers
• Existing trademark owners
• Fair competition in trade
Meaning of Refusal of Registration
Refusal of registration means rejection of a trademark application by the Registrar when the mark
does not satisfy the legal conditions prescribed under the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
The Registrar examines whether:
• The trademark is distinctive
• It is lawful
• It con icts with earlier trademarks
• It may deceive or confuse consumers
I. Absolute Grounds for Refusal of Trademark Registration
(Section 9 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999)
Absolute grounds relate to the inherent nature or characteristics of the trademark itself. Even if no
earlier trademark exists, registration may still be refused because of the nature of the mark.
1. Lack of Distinctive Character
[Section 9(1)(a)]
A trademark must be capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one person from those of
others.
If the mark is ordinary, common, or incapable of identifying a particular source, registration is
refused.
Examples:
• “BEST”
• “SUPER QUALITY”
• “GOOD PRODUCT”
These words are too common and cannot identify one trader’s goods.
Purpose:
To ensure trademarks perform their basic function of identi cation.
2. Descriptive Marks
[Section 9(1)(b)]
Marks that directly describe:
• Quality
• Quantity
• Purpose
• Value
• Geographical origin
• Characteristics of goods/services
cannot generally be registered.
Examples:
• “SWEET” for sugar
• “FAST DELIVERY” for courier services
• “COLD” for refrigerators
Reason:
No person should get monopoly over ordinary descriptive words.
fl
fi
3. Customary or Common Trade Expressions
[Section 9(1)(c)]
Words or signs commonly used in current language or trade practice cannot be registered.
Examples:
• “Premium”
• “Deluxe”
• “Standard”
These expressions are widely used in trade.
4. Deceptive or Confusing Marks
[Section 9(2)(a)]
A trademark shall be refused if it is likely to deceive or confuse the public.
Examples:
• “Pure Wool” for synthetic fabric
• “Herbal” for chemically manufactured products
Purpose:
To protect consumers from false representation.
5. Marks Hurtful to Religious Feelings
[Section 9(2)(b)]
Marks likely to hurt religious sentiments of any class or community are not registrable.
Examples:
• Misuse of sacred symbols
• Offensive use of religious names
Objective:
To maintain public harmony and morality.
6. Scandalous or Obscene Marks
[Section 9(2)(c)]
Marks containing vulgar, immoral, obscene, or scandalous matter are prohibited.
Purpose:
To protect public decency and morality.
7. Prohibited Emblems and Symbols
[Section 9(2)(d)]
Marks prohibited under the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act, 1950 cannot be
registered.
Examples:
• National Flag
• Ashoka Chakra
• Government seals
• Names of international organizations
8. Shape of Goods
[Section 9(3)]
Registration is refused if the shape:
1. Results from the nature of goods
2. Is necessary to obtain technical result
3. Gives substantial value to goods
Example:
The functional shape of a tool cannot be monopolized.
II. Relative Grounds for Refusal of Trademark Registration
(Section 11 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999)
Relative grounds arise when the proposed trademark con icts with existing trademarks or prior
rights of others.
The purpose is to prevent:
• Consumer confusion
• Unfair competition
• Damage to reputation of existing trademarks
fl
1. Identical or Similar Trademark
[Section 11(1)]
Registration may be refused if:
• The mark is identical or similar to an earlier trademark, and
• It is likely to create confusion among the public.
Example:
“NIKKE” for shoes resembling “NIKE.”
Objective:
To avoid confusion regarding origin of goods.
2. Similar Goods or Services
Even if the marks are not exactly identical, registration may be refused if:
• Goods/services are similar, and
• Consumers may assume association.
Example:
“PUMAA” for sportswear resembling “PUMA.”
3. Protection of Well-Known Trademarks
[Section 11(2)]
A trademark may be refused if it:
• Takes unfair advantage of a well-known mark, or
• Damages its distinctive character or reputation.
Examples:
• “Google Café”
• “Tata Electronics” by unrelated person
Purpose:
To protect famous trademarks from dilution and misuse.
4. Passing Off and Copyright Protection
[Section 11(3)]
Registration may be refused if use of the trademark is prohibited by:
• Law of passing off
• Copyright law
Meaning of Passing Off
Passing off occurs when one trader falsely represents goods/services as those of another.

Important Case Law

Cadila Health Care Ltd. v. Cadila Pharmaceuticals Ltd (2001)
Facts
The dispute involved two medicinal trademarks:
• “Falcigo”
• “Falcitab”
Both medicines were used for treatment of malaria.
Judgment
The Supreme Court of India held that even minor similarity between medicinal trademarks may
create dangerous confusion among consumers.
The Court laid down principles for determining deceptive similarity.
Conclusion
Absolute and relative grounds for refusal of trademark registration are essential safeguards under
the Trade Marks Act, 1999. Absolute grounds protect public interest by preventing registration of
non-distinctive, deceptive, immoral, or prohibited marks. Relative grounds protect earlier trademark
owners and prevent confusion in the market.
Together, these provisions ensure that only lawful, distinctive, and genuine trademarks receive
protection, thereby promoting fair trade, consumer con dence, and healthy business competition.
fi
Q.7 Grounds for Pre-Grant Opposition to Patent
Introduction
A patent is an exclusive legal right granted to an inventor for a new invention that is capable of
industrial application and involves an inventive step. Patent protection allows the inventor to
prevent others from making, using, selling, or distributing the invention without permission.
However, before granting a patent, the law provides an opportunity to challenge the patent
application through a process called “Pre-Grant Opposition.” This mechanism helps prevent the
grant of invalid or undeserving patents.
In India, pre-grant opposition is governed by Section 25(1) of the Patents Act, 1970.

Meaning of Pre-Grant Opposition

Pre-grant opposition means opposition led against a patent application before the patent is granted.
It acts as a safeguard to:
• Prevent wrongful patents
• Protect public interest
• Maintain quality of patents
• Encourage genuine innovation

Who Can File Pre-Grant Opposition?

Under Section 25(1),:
• “Any person” may le pre-grant opposition.
This means:
• Competitors
• Researchers
• Companies
• Public interest groups
• Individuals
can oppose the patent application.

Time for Filing Pre-Grant Opposition

Pre-grant opposition may be led:
• After publication of the patent application
• Before grant of the patent

Grounds for Pre-Grant Opposition

(Section 25(1) of the Patents Act, 1970)
The Act provides several grounds on which a patent application may be opposed.

1. Wrongful Obtaining of Invention

[Section 25(1)(a)]
The patent may be opposed if the applicant wrongfully obtained the invention from another person.
Example:
An employee steals research data from another scientist and les a patent application.
Purpose:
To protect the true inventor.
fi
fi
fi
fi
2. Prior Publication
[Section 25(1)(b)]
A patent can be opposed if the invention was already published before the priority date of the
application.
Publication may occur through:
• Books
• Journals
• Research papers
• Internet publications
• Earlier patent documents
Reason:
A patent is granted only for novel inventions.

3. Prior Claim in Earlier Patent

[Section 25(1)(c)]
Opposition can be led if the invention is already claimed in another earlier patent application led
in India.
Objective:
To avoid duplicate patents for the same invention.

4. Publicly Known or Publicly Used

[Section 25(1)(d)]
If the invention was publicly known or publicly used in India before ling the patent application,
opposition may be led.
Example:
A machine already used in factories before patent ling.
Reason:
Publicly available inventions are not considered new.

5. Obviousness or Lack of Inventive Step

[Section 25(1)(e)]
A patent may be opposed if the invention:
• Is obvious to a skilled person, or
• Does not involve an inventive step.
Meaning of Inventive Step
The invention must show technical advancement or economic signi cance beyond existing
knowledge.
Example:
Minor modi cation of an existing product without real innovation.

6. Non-Patentable Subject Matter

[Section 25(1)(f)]
Opposition may be led if the invention is not patentable under the Patents Act.
Non-Patentable Inventions Include:
• Discoveries of scienti c principles
• Mathematical methods
• Business methods
• Traditional knowledge
• Methods of agriculture
• Mere admixture of substances
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 These are mentioned under Section 3 of the Patents Act.

7. Insuf cient Disclosure of Invention

[Section 25(1)(g)]
The complete speci cation must clearly and fully describe:
• The invention
• Method of performing the invention
Opposition may be led if disclosure is insuf cient or unclear.
Purpose:
To ensure public knowledge and transparency.

8. Failure to Disclose Information Regarding Foreign Applications

[Section 25(1)(h)]
The applicant must disclose details of corresponding foreign patent applications.
Opposition may be led if:
• Information is concealed, or
• False information is provided.

9. Convention Application Not Filed Within Prescribed Time

[Section 25(1)(i)]
If a convention application is not led within the prescribed time limit under the Act, it may be
opposed.
Purpose:
To maintain procedural compliance.

10. Non-Disclosure or Wrong Disclosure of Biological Material

[Section 25(1)(j)]
Where biological material is used in the invention, the source and geographical origin must be
disclosed properly.
Opposition can be led if such disclosure is absent or incorrect.
Example:
Use of plant or microorganism material without proper disclosure.

11. Traditional Knowledge

[Section 25(1)(k)]
Opposition may be led if the invention is anticipated by traditional knowledge available within
local or indigenous communities.
Examples:
• Turmeric healing properties
• Neem-based medicinal uses
Objective:
To prevent biopiracy and exploitation of indigenous knowledge.

Procedure for Pre-Grant Opposition

1. Filing Representation
The opponent les a representation before the Controller of Patents.

2. Examination by Controller
The Controller examines:
• Grounds of opposition
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 • Evidence submitted

3. Notice to Applicant
The patent applicant receives notice of opposition.

4. Reply by Applicant
The applicant may:
• Submit counter-statement
• Provide evidence
• Defend the invention

5. Hearing
The Controller may conduct a hearing for both parties.

6. Decision
The Controller may:
• Reject opposition and grant patent
• Require amendment
• Refuse patent

Importance of Pre-Grant Opposition

1. Prevents Grant of Invalid Patents
Ensures only deserving inventions receive patents.

2. Protects Public Interest

Prevents monopolies over non-genuine inventions.

3. Encourages Genuine Innovation

Promotes real technological advancement.

4. Prevents Biopiracy
Protects traditional and indigenous knowledge.

5. Maintains Patent Quality

Improves reliability of the patent system.

Important Case Law

Novartis AG v. Union of India
(2013)
Facts
Novartis AG sought a patent for the cancer medicine “Glivec.” Opposition was led on the ground
that the invention lacked enhanced ef cacy and was merely a modi ed form of an existing drug.
Judgment
The Supreme Court of India rejected the patent application under Section 3(d) of the Patents Act.
Importance
• Prevented evergreening of pharmaceutical patents
• Strengthened India’s opposition system
• Protected access to affordable medicines
fi
fi
fi
 Q.8 Works in Which Copyright Subsists
Introduction
Copyright is a legal right granted to the creator of original literary, artistic, musical, dramatic, and
other intellectual works. It protects the expression of ideas and gives the owner exclusive rights to
reproduce, publish, adapt, communicate, and commercially exploit the work.
In India, copyright is governed by the Copyright Act, 1957. The Act speci es the categories of
works in which copyright subsists under Section 13.
Copyright protection encourages creativity, innovation, literature, art, music, lms, and
technological development by rewarding creators for their efforts.

Meaning of Copyright
Copyright means the exclusive legal right given to the creator or owner of an original work to:
• Reproduce the work
• Publish or distribute it
• Perform or communicate it to the public
• Adapt or translate the work
• Prevent unauthorized use
Copyright protects only the expression of ideas, not the ideas themselves.

Works in Which Copyright Subsists

(Section 13 of the Copyright Act, 1957)
According to Section 13, copyright subsists in the following classes of works:
1. Original Literary Works
2. Original Dramatic Works
3. Original Musical Works
4. Original Artistic Works
5. Cinematograph Films
6. Sound Recordings
The work must:
• Be original
• Be xed in a tangible form
• Not violate any law

1. Literary Works
Meaning
Literary work includes works expressed in writing, printing, typing, or digital form.
Under the Act, literary work includes:
• Books
• Novels
• Articles
• Computer programs
• Tables
• Compilations
• Databases
Examples:
• A novel written by an author
• Educational textbooks
• Software programs
• Research articles
• Website content
fi
fi
fi
Important Point
Literary work does not require literary quality. Even technical or scienti c writings are protected.

Copyright Protection in Computer Programs

Computer software is treated as literary work.
Example:
• Mobile applications
• Accounting software
• Gaming software
The owner has exclusive rights to:
• Reproduce software
• Sell copies
• License usage

2. Dramatic Works
Meaning
Dramatic work includes:
• Plays
• Scripts
• Screenplays
• Choreographic works
• Stage performances
It does not include cinematograph lms.
Examples:
• Theatre play scripts
• Dance choreography
• Dialogues written for stage performances
Requirement
The dramatic work must be written or otherwise recorded.

3. Musical Works
Meaning
Musical work means a work consisting of music and includes musical notation.
It does not include words or actions intended to be sung or performed with music.
Examples:
• Instrumental compositions
• Piano compositions
• Musical notation written by composers
Important Point
Lyrics are protected separately as literary works.

4. Artistic Works
Meaning
Artistic work includes:
• Paintings
• Sculptures
• Drawings
• Engravings
• Photographs
fi
fi
 • Architecture
• Works of artistic craftsmanship
Artistic quality is not necessary.

Types of Artistic Works

A. Paintings and Drawings
Examples:
• Portraits
• Sketches
• Cartoons

B. Sculptures
Examples:
• Stone statues
• Clay models

C. Photographs
Examples:
• Wedding photographs
• Wildlife photography

D. Architectural Works
Examples:
• Building designs
• Structural blueprints

E. Artistic Craftsmanship
Examples:
• Jewelry designs
• Handicrafts

5. Cinematograph Films
Meaning
A cinematograph lm means any visual recording produced through a process from which moving
images can be produced.
It includes:
• Motion pictures
• Movies
• Web series
• Documentaries
• Video recordings
Examples:
• Bollywood lms
• Television serials
• OTT platform content
• YouTube lms

Rights in Cinematograph Films

The owner has exclusive rights to:
• Make copies
fi
fi
fi
 • Sell or rent copies
• Communicate lm to public
• Broadcast lm

6. Sound Recordings
Meaning
Sound recording means recording of sounds from which sounds may be reproduced.
Examples:
• Songs
• Audiobooks
• Podcasts
• Recorded speeches

Rights of Owner
The owner can:
• Reproduce recordings
• Sell copies
• Communicate recordings to public
• License commercial use

Conditions for Copyright Protection

For copyright to subsist:
1. Originality
The work must originate from the author and involve skill, labor, and judgment.

2. Fixation
The work must be expressed in a material form.
Example:
An unwritten speech may not get protection unless recorded or written.

3. Lawful Work
The work should not violate any law or public morality.

Works Not Protected by Copyright

Copyright does not subsist in:
• Ideas
• Facts
• Discoveries
• Titles
• Names
• Common symbols
• Government noti cations (subject to exceptions)

Ownership of Copyright
Generally, the author is the rst owner of copyright.
However, exceptions exist:
• Employer in case of employment
• Producer in lms
• Newspaper proprietor for journalistic work
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 Important Case Law
Eastern Book Company v. D.B. Modak
(2008)
Facts
Eastern Book Company claimed copyright in copy-edited judgments published in law reports.
Judgment
The Supreme Court of India held that copyright subsists where suf cient skill, labor, and creativity
are involved.
The Court adopted the “modicum of creativity” standard.
Importance
• Clari ed originality requirement in India
• Recognized copyright in compilations and edited works
• Strengthened protection for literary works

Importance of Copyright Protection

1. Encourages Creativity
Creators receive recognition and nancial reward.

2. Protects Economic Rights

Owners can commercially exploit their works.

3. Prevents Unauthorized Use

Stops piracy and illegal copying.

4. Promotes Cultural Development

Supports literature, art, music, and entertainment industries.

5. Supports Innovation and Knowledge Economy

Protects software, digital content, and research works.

Q.9 Rights of Patent Holder and Exceptions & Limitations to Those Rights
Introduction
A patent is an exclusive legal right granted to an inventor for a new invention that is capable of
industrial application and involves an inventive step. The patent system encourages innovation by
rewarding inventors with monopoly rights for a limited period.
In India, patents are governed by the Patents Act, 1970. Once a patent is granted, the patent holder
obtains certain exclusive rights over the invention. However, these rights are not absolute. The law
also provides several exceptions and limitations in order to balance private rights with public
interest.
The patent system aims to:
• Encourage innovation
• Promote technological development
• Protect inventors
• Ensure public access and welfare

Meaning of Patent Holder

A patent holder or patentee is a person whose name appears on the patent register as the owner of
the patent.
The patent holder may be:
fi
fi
fi
 • Inventor
• Assignee
• Legal representative
• Company or organization

Rights of Patent Holder

(Section 48 of the Patents Act, 1970)
The rights of a patent holder are called exclusive rights because the patent holder alone can exploit
the invention during the patent period.
The rights differ slightly depending upon whether the patent relates to:
1. Product patent
2. Process patent

I. Rights in Respect of Product Patent

When a patent is granted for a product, the patentee has the exclusive right to:
1. Make the Product
Only the patent holder can manufacture the patented product.
Example:
A pharmaceutical company holding a patent for a medicine has exclusive manufacturing rights.

2. Use the Product

The patentee can exclusively use the patented invention.

3. Sell the Product

The patent holder can market and sell the patented product.

4. Offer for Sale

Even offering the patented product for commercial sale without permission amounts to
infringement.

5. Import the Product

The patent holder controls importation of the patented product into India.

II. Rights in Respect of Process Patent

When a patent is granted for a manufacturing or technological process, the patentee has exclusive
rights to:
1. Use the Process
Only the patentee may use the patented process.

2. Use, Sell, or Import Products Obtained Directly Through That Process

Products directly produced by the patented process are also protected.
Example:
A patented chemical manufacturing process protects both the process and products directly made
from it.

Additional Rights of Patent Holder

1. Right to License
The patent holder may grant licenses to others for use of the invention.
Types:
• Exclusive license
 • Non-exclusive license
• Compulsory license

2. Right to Assign Patent

The patent can be transferred or sold to another person.

3. Right to Sue for Infringement

The patentee can le legal proceedings against unauthorized users.
Remedies Include:
• Injunction
• Damages
• Account of pro ts
• Seizure of infringing goods

4. Right to Surrender Patent

The patent holder may voluntarily surrender the patent.

Duration of Patent Rights

Patent protection lasts for:
• 20 years
from the ling date of the patent application.
After expiry, the invention enters the public domain.

Exceptions and Limitations to Patent Rights

Patent rights are not unlimited. The law imposes restrictions to balance public interest, research,
education, and access to essential technologies.

I. Government Use
(Sections 99–103)
The government may use a patented invention for governmental purposes without prior permission
of the patentee.
Examples:
• Defense purposes
• Public health emergencies
Purpose:
To protect national interest and public welfare.

II. Compulsory Licensing

(Section 84)
A compulsory license may be granted when:
1. Public requirements are not satis ed
2. Patented product is not available at affordable price
3. Patent is not worked in India
Example:
Compulsory license for life-saving medicines.
Importance:
Ensures access to essential products.

III. Research and Experimental Use

(Section 47)
fi
fi
fi
fi
 Use of patented inventions for:
• Scienti c research
• Experiment
• Educational purposes
is permitted without infringement.
Example:
Universities conducting laboratory research on patented technology.

IV. Bolar Exception

(Section 107A)
Manufacturers of generic medicines may use patented inventions for obtaining regulatory approval
before expiry of the patent.
Purpose:
To ensure immediate availability of generic drugs after patent expiry.

V. Parallel Importation
(Section 107A)
Importation of patented products legally sold in another country is permitted under certain
conditions.
Objective:
Prevent excessive pricing and encourage competition.

VI. Use on Foreign Vessels and Aircraft

(Section 49)
Patented inventions used temporarily in foreign vessels, aircraft, or vehicles entering India are
exempted.

VII. Prior Use Rights

A person who was already using the invention before the patent date may continue such use under
certain circumstances.

VIII. Revocation of Patent

Patent rights may be revoked if:
• Patent obtained fraudulently
• Lack of novelty
• Non-patentable subject matter
• Failure to disclose information

IX. Public Interest Limitation

Patent rights cannot be exercised against public morality, health, or national security.

X. Non-Patentable Inventions
(Section 3)
Certain inventions are excluded from patentability itself.
Examples:
• Mathematical methods
• Scienti c discoveries
• Traditional knowledge
• Methods of agriculture
fi
fi
 Important Case Law
Bayer Corporation v. Natco Pharma Ltd.
2012
Facts
Bayer Corporation held a patent for the cancer drug “Nexavar.” The medicine was extremely
expensive and inaccessible to most Indian patients.
Natco Pharma Ltd. applied for a compulsory license.
Decision
The Indian Patent Of ce granted the compulsory license to Natco Pharma.
Importance
• First compulsory license granted in India
• Ensured affordable access to life-saving medicines
• Balanced patent rights with public health interests

Conclusion
The patent holder enjoys important exclusive rights such as manufacturing, using, selling, licensing,
and protecting the patented invention. These rights encourage innovation, industrial growth, and
technological advancement.
However, patent rights are not absolute. The Patents Act, 1970 provides several exceptions and
limitations such as compulsory licensing, government use, research exemptions, and public interest
safeguards. These limitations ensure a balance between the interests of inventors and the welfare of
society.
Thus, the patent system seeks to promote innovation while ensuring accessibility, competition, and
public bene t.

Q.10 Procedure for Obtaining a Patent under Indian Patent Law

Introduction
A patent is an exclusive legal right granted to an inventor for a new invention that is capable of
industrial application and involves an inventive step. The patent system encourages innovation and
technological development by granting monopoly rights to inventors for a limited period.
In India, patents are governed by the Patents Act, 1970 and the Patent Rules, 2003. The authority
responsible for granting patents is the Indian Patent Of ce functioning under the Controller General
of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks.
The procedure for obtaining a patent involves several stages from ling the application to grant of
patent.

Meaning of Patent
A patent is a statutory right granted to an inventor to:
• Make
• Use
• Sell
• Manufacture
• Distribute
the invention exclusively for a speci c period.
The patent is granted only if the invention is:
1. Novel
2. Involves inventive step
3. Capable of industrial application
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 Types of Patent Applications
Under Indian law, patent applications may be:
1. Ordinary Application
2. Convention Application
3. PCT International Application
4. Divisional Application
5. Patent of Addition

Procedure for Obtaining a Patent

The following are the major steps involved in obtaining a patent in India:

1. Conception of Invention
The process begins when an inventor develops a new invention.
The inventor should ensure that the invention:
• Is novel
• Is non-obvious
• Has industrial applicability

2. Patent Search
Before ling, a patent search is conducted to determine whether a similar invention already exists.
Purpose
• Check novelty
• Avoid duplication
• Assess patentability
The search may include:
• Patent databases
• Scienti c journals
• Published patent applications

3. Drafting of Patent Speci cation

The patent application must contain a speci cation describing the invention.
There are two types of speci cations:
A. Provisional Speci cation
Filed when the invention is not fully completed.
Purpose
• Secure priority date
• Provide temporary protection
The complete speci cation must be led within 12 months.

B. Complete Speci cation

Contains full details of the invention, including:
• Title of invention
• Field of invention
• Background
• Detailed description
• Claims
• Abstract
• Drawings (if required)
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 Importance
Claims de ne the scope of patent protection.

4. Filing of Patent Application

The application is led before the Indian Patent Of ce in the prescribed form along with fees.
Important Forms
• Form 1 – Application for patent
• Form 2 – Speci cation
• Form 3 – Statement regarding foreign applications
• Form 5 – Declaration of inventorship
Modes of Filing
• Physical ling
• Online ling

5. Publication of Patent Application

(Section 11A)
The patent application is published in the Patent Journal:
• After 18 months from ling or priority date.
Early Publication
The applicant may request early publication through Form 9.
Effect of Publication
After publication:
• Application becomes open to public inspection.
• Applicant gets provisional rights.

6. Request for Examination

(Section 11B)
Patent examination does not occur automatically.
The applicant must le:
• Request for Examination (RFE)
Time Limit
Within:
• 48 months from ling or priority date.
Without RFE, the application is deemed withdrawn.

7. Examination by Patent Of ce
The Controller refers the application to an Examiner.
The Examiner checks:
• Novelty
• Inventive step
• Industrial applicability
• Patentable subject matter
• Compliance with legal requirements

8. First Examination Report (FER)

After examination, the Patent Of ce issues the FER containing:
• Objections
• De ciencies
• Requirements for amendment
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 Common Objections
• Lack of novelty
• Obviousness
• Insuf cient disclosure
• Non-patentable subject matter

9. Response to FER
The applicant must respond to objections within the prescribed period.
The response may include:
• Clari cations
• Amendments
• Legal arguments
• Technical explanations

10. Hearing Before Controller

If objections remain unresolved, the Controller may conduct a hearing.
The applicant or patent agent presents arguments in support of patentability.

11. Pre-Grant Opposition

(Section 25(1))
Any person may oppose the patent application after publication and before grant.
Grounds Include:
• Prior publication
• Lack of novelty
• Obviousness
• Traditional knowledge
• Wrongful obtaining

12. Grant of Patent

(Section 43)
If the Controller is satis ed that:
• All requirements are ful lled, and
• No valid opposition exists,
the patent is granted.
The grant is published in the Patent Journal.

13. Post-Grant Opposition

(Section 25(2))
After grant, a “person interested” may challenge the patent within:
• 1 year from publication of grant.

14. Renewal and Maintenance Fees

Annual renewal fees must be paid to maintain the patent.
Duration of Patent
• 20 years from ling date.
Failure to pay renewal fees may result in lapse of patent.

Rights Granted After Patent

The patentee gets exclusive rights to:
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 • Make the invention
• Use the invention
• Sell the invention
• License the invention
• Sue for infringement

Important Documents Required

1. Patent application form
2. Speci cation
3. Drawings
4. Abstract
5. Declaration of inventorship
6. Power of attorney (if led through agent)

Important Case Law

Novartis AG v. Union of India(2013)
Facts
Novartis AG sought patent protection for the cancer medicine “Glivec.”
Judgment
The Supreme Court of India rejected the patent application under Section 3(d), holding that the
invention lacked enhanced therapeutic ef cacy.
Importance
• Clari ed standards of patentability
• Prevented evergreening of patents
• Strengthened Indian patent law

Importance of Patent Procedure

1. Encourages Innovation
Protects inventors and motivates research.

2. Ensures Disclosure of Technology

Patent publication spreads technical knowledge.

3. Prevents Wrongful Patents

Examination and opposition improve patent quality.

4. Promotes Economic Growth

Supports industrial and technological development.

Conclusion
The procedure for obtaining a patent under Indian patent law involves several carefully regulated
stages including ling, publication, examination, opposition, and grant. The Patents Act, 1970
ensures that only genuine, novel, and useful inventions receive protection.
The patent procedure balances the interests of inventors and society by promoting innovation while
safeguarding public interest and technological progress.
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
Q.11 Important Conventions that Led to the Growth of Intellectual Property Rights
Introduction
Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs) are legal rights granted to creators and inventors over their
intellectual creations such as inventions, literary works, artistic works, trademarks, industrial
designs, and geographical indications. With the growth of international trade, industrialization,
science, and technology, the need for global protection of intellectual property became essential.
Different countries had different laws relating to intellectual property, which created dif culties for
inventors, authors, artists, and businesses seeking protection internationally. To solve these issues,
several international conventions and treaties were adopted.
These international conventions played a signi cant role in:
• Harmonizing intellectual property laws
• Protecting creators internationally
• Encouraging innovation and trade
• Promoting economic and technological development
Many of these conventions are administered by the World Intellectual Property Organization
(WIPO).

1. Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property, 1883

Introduction
The Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property was the rst major international
agreement relating to industrial property.
It came into force in:
• 1884
India is also a member of this Convention.

Scope of Protection
The Convention protects:
• Patents
• Trademarks
• Industrial designs
• Utility models
• Trade names
• Geographical indications

Important Principles
A. National Treatment
Foreign nationals receive the same protection as citizens of the member country.
B. Right of Priority
An applicant ling in one member country gets priority rights for ling in other member countries
within a speci ed time.
C. Independence of Patents
Patents granted in different countries are independent of each other.

Importance
• Encouraged international patent and trademark protection
• Facilitated international trade
• Reduced discrimination against foreign inventors

2. Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works, 1886
Introduction
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
The Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works is the most important
international treaty relating to copyright.
It protects:
• Literary works
• Artistic works
• Musical works
• Dramatic works
India is a member of the Berne Convention.

Main Principles
A. Automatic Protection
Copyright protection is automatic and does not require registration.
B. National Treatment
Authors receive the same rights in foreign countries as local authors.
C. Minimum Rights
The Convention prescribes minimum copyright standards.

Rights Protected
• Right of reproduction
• Right of translation
• Public performance rights
• Adaptation rights

Importance
• Strengthened international copyright protection
• Encouraged literary and artistic creativity
• Protected authors worldwide

3. Universal Copyright Convention (UCC), 1952

Introduction
The Universal Copyright Convention was adopted under the supervision of UNESCO.
It was created as an alternative to the Berne Convention.

Objective
To provide international copyright protection for countries not willing to join the Berne Convention.

Importance
• Expanded international copyright cooperation
• Increased global copyright recognition

4. Rome Convention, 1961

Introduction
The Rome Convention for the Protection of Performers, Producers of Phonograms and
Broadcasting Organisations protects neighboring or related rights.

Rights Protected
A. Performers’ Rights
Protection for singers, actors, musicians, etc.
B. Producers of Phonograms
Protection for sound recordings.
 C. Broadcasting Organisations
Protection against unauthorized rebroadcasting.

Importance
• Recognized neighboring rights
• Strengthened entertainment industry protection

5. Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT), 1970

Introduction
The Patent Cooperation Treaty simpli es the process of obtaining patent protection internationally.
It is administered by WIPO.
India became a member in:
• 1998

Features
• Single international patent application
• International search and examination
• Simpli ed ling procedure

Importance
• Reduced complexity in foreign patent ling
• Encouraged international patent protection
• Saved time and costs

6. Budapest Treaty, 1977

Introduction
The Budapest Treaty on the International Recognition of the Deposit of Microorganisms for the
Purposes of Patent Procedure deals with patent procedures involving microorganisms.

Importance
• Simpli ed patenting of biotechnological inventions
• Facilitated biotechnology research

7. Trademark Law Treaty (TLT), 1994

Introduction
The Trademark Law Treaty harmonized trademark registration procedures internationally.

Importance
• Simpli ed trademark ling procedures
• Reduced procedural dif culties

8. Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS), 1994

Introduction
The TRIPS Agreement is one of the most important international agreements on intellectual
property.
It forms part of the World Trade Organization (WTO) Agreement.
India became bound by TRIPS in:
• 1995

Scope of TRIPS
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
TRIPS covers:
• Copyright
• Patents
• Trademarks
• Industrial designs
• Geographical indications
• Trade secrets

Important Features
A. Minimum Standards
Member countries must maintain minimum standards of IP protection.
B. Enforcement Mechanism
Provides effective enforcement procedures.
C. Dispute Settlement
WTO dispute settlement mechanism applies to IPR disputes.

Importance
• Globalized intellectual property protection
• Strengthened enforcement of IP rights
• Promoted international trade and investment

9. WIPO Copyright Treaty (WCT), 1996

Introduction
The WIPO Copyright Treaty addressed copyright protection in the digital environment.

Protection Includes
• Computer programs
• Databases
• Digital communication

Importance
• Strengthened digital copyright protection
• Addressed internet piracy issues

10. WIPO Performances and Phonograms Treaty (WPPT), 1996

Introduction
The WIPO Performances and Phonograms Treaty protects performers and producers of sound
recordings in the digital age.

Importance
• Enhanced performers’ rights
• Protected digital music and sound recordings

Role of International Conventions in Growth of IPR

1. Harmonization of Laws
Created uniform standards among countries.

2. Promotion of Innovation
Inventors gained con dence to protect inventions globally.
fi
 3. Growth of International Trade
IP protection encouraged foreign investment and commerce.

4. Protection of Authors and Artists

Creative individuals received worldwide recognition and protection.

5. Technological Advancement
Strong IP systems encouraged scienti c research and development.

Important Case Law

Novartis AG v. Union of India (2013)

Conclusion
International conventions and treaties have played a major role in the growth and development of
intellectual property rights throughout the world. Conventions such as the Paris Convention, Berne
Convention, Rome Convention, PCT, and TRIPS Agreement established international standards for
protection and enforcement of intellectual property.
These agreements promoted innovation, creativity, technological advancement, cultural
development, and international trade. They also helped harmonize national laws and strengthened
global cooperation in the eld of intellectual property rights.

Q.12 Trademark and Infringement of Trademark

Introduction
In modern commerce and business, trademarks play an important role in identifying and
distinguishing the goods or services of one business from those of others. A trademark represents
the goodwill, reputation, and quality associated with a business or product.
Trademark law protects both:
• Business owners from unfair competition, and
• Consumers from confusion and deception.
In India, trademarks are governed by the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
One of the most important protections provided under trademark law is protection against
infringement. Trademark infringement occurs when an unauthorized person uses a mark that is
identical or deceptively similar to a registered trademark.

Meaning and De nition of Trademark

De nition
According to Section 2(zb) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999:
A trademark means a mark capable of being represented graphically and capable of distinguishing
the goods or services of one person from those of others.
A trademark may include:
• Word.
• Name
• Signature
• Symbol
• Logo
• Label
• Design
• Letter
• Numeral
fi
fi
fi
fi
 • Shape of goods
• Packaging
• Combination of colors

Examples of Trademarks
• Nike “Swoosh” logo
• Apple logo
• McDonald’s golden arches
• Tata trademark
• Amul logo
These marks help consumers identify the source of goods or services.

Functions of Trademark
1. Identi cation of Origin
Helps consumers identify the manufacturer or service provider.

2. Distinction of Goods and Services

Distinguishes one trader’s products from competitors.

3. Protection of Goodwill
Protects business reputation and market identity.

4. Advertising Function
Acts as a marketing and promotional tool.

5. Consumer Protection
Prevents public confusion and deception.

Meaning of Trademark Infringement

Trademark infringement means unauthorized use of a registered trademark or a deceptively similar
mark in relation to goods or services in a manner that causes confusion among the public.
Trademark infringement is dealt with under Section 29 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
The purpose of infringement law is:
• To protect trademark owners
• To prevent unfair competition
• To protect consumers from deception

Essentials of Trademark Infringement

To establish infringement, the following elements are generally required:
1. Existence of a registered trademark
2. Unauthorized use by another person
3. Use in course of trade
4. Identical or deceptively similar mark
5. Likelihood of confusion or association

Acts Which Amount to Infringement of Trademark

The following acts may amount to infringement under Section 29 of the Trade Marks Act, 1999:

1. Use of Identical Mark for Identical Goods or Services

[Section 29(1)]
fi
Infringement occurs when a person uses a mark identical to a registered trademark for the same
goods or services.
Example:
Using “NIKE” on sports shoes without permission.

2. Use of Deceptively Similar Mark

[Section 29(2)]
If a mark is similar enough to create confusion among consumers, it amounts to infringement.
Example:
“NIKKE” for shoes resembling “NIKE.”
Test:
Whether an average consumer is likely to be confused.

3. Use for Similar Goods or Services

Even if marks are not exactly identical, infringement occurs when:
• Goods/services are similar, and
• Consumers may believe there is association.
Example:
“PUMAA” for sportswear resembling “PUMA.”

4. Use of Well-Known Trademark

[Section 29(4)]
Unauthorized use of a famous trademark even for unrelated goods may amount to infringement if:
• It takes unfair advantage, or
• Damages the reputation of the well-known mark.
Examples:
• “Google Café”
• “Tata Electronics” by unrelated trader

5. Applying Registered Trademark on Packaging or Labels

Using another’s registered trademark on:
• Wrappers
• Packaging
• Labels
• Containers
amounts to infringement.

6. Importing or Selling Infringing Goods

Importing, selling, distributing, or stocking goods bearing infringing trademarks is infringement.

7. Advertising that Harms Trademark Reputation

[Section 29(8)]
Advertising may amount to infringement if it:
• Takes unfair advantage of trademark reputation
• Is dishonest
• Damages distinctive character of trademark
Example:
Misleading comparative advertisements.

8. Use as Trade Name or Business Name

[Section 29(5)]
Using a registered trademark as part of a business or trade name without authorization may amount
to infringement.
Example:
Opening a business named “Apple Electronics” without permission from Apple.

What is “Deceptive Similarity”?

A mark is deceptively similar if it resembles another mark so closely that it is likely to deceive or
confuse consumers.
Factors Considered:
• Visual similarity
• Phonetic similarity
• Nature of goods
• Consumer class
• Overall impression

Defences Against Trademark Infringement

The defendant may defend the case on grounds such as:
1. Honest Concurrent Use
Use made honestly without intention to deceive.

2. Descriptive Use
Use merely describing quality or characteristics.

3. Fair Use
Use for comparative or informational purposes.

4. Prior Use
Prior user rights may prevail even against registered owner.

Remedies for Trademark Infringement

The trademark owner may seek:
1. Injunction
Court order restraining unauthorized use.

2. Damages
Monetary compensation for loss suffered.

3. Account of Pro ts
Recovery of pro ts earned by infringer.

4. Delivery Up and Destruction

Seizure and destruction of infringing goods.

Important Case Law

Cadila Health Care Ltd. v. Cadila Pharmaceuticals Ltd.(2001)
Facts
Two pharmaceutical companies used similar trademarks:
• “Falcigo”
• “Falcitab”
fi
fi
Both medicines were used for malaria treatment.

Judgment
The Supreme Court of India held that even slight similarity in medicinal trademarks may create
dangerous confusion.
The Court laid down factors for determining deceptive similarity.

Conclusion
A trademark is an important form of intellectual property that protects business identity, goodwill,
and consumer con dence. Trademark infringement occurs when an unauthorized person uses a
registered trademark or a deceptively similar mark in a manner likely to cause confusion.
The Trade Marks Act, 1999 provides strong legal protection against infringement through civil and
criminal remedies. Trademark law thus promotes fair competition, protects consumers, and
preserves the reputation and value of businesses.

Q.13 What Cannot Be Patented under the Indian Patent Act

Introduction
A patent is an exclusive legal right granted to an inventor for a new invention that involves an
inventive step and is capable of industrial application. The patent system encourages scienti c and
technological innovation by granting monopoly rights for a limited period.
However, not every invention or discovery is patentable. Certain inventions are excluded from
patent protection in order to:
• Protect public interest
• Prevent misuse of monopoly rights
• Preserve morality and public order
• Ensure free access to basic knowledge and natural discoveries
In India, non-patentable inventions are mainly provided under Sections 3 and 4 of the Patents Act,
1970.

Meaning of Non-Patentable Invention

A non-patentable invention is an invention or subject matter that the law excludes from patent
protection even if it appears to be new or useful.
The Indian Patent Act prevents patents over:
• Mere discoveries
• Abstract ideas
• Natural phenomena
• Traditional knowledge
• Inventions harmful to society

Inventions That Cannot Be Patented under the Indian Patent Act

I. Frivolous Inventions
[Section 3(a)]
An invention that is frivolous or contrary to well-established natural laws cannot be patented.
Examples:
• Perpetual motion machine
• Machine claiming to operate without energy
Reason:
fi
fi
 Such inventions lack scienti c validity.

II. Inventions Contrary to Public Order or Morality

[Section 3(b)]
Inventions whose use or commercial exploitation may:
• Harm public order
• Cause serious prejudice to human, animal, or plant life
• Harm environment
• Be immoral
cannot be patented.
Examples:
• Harmful biological weapons
• Dangerous chemical inventions

III. Mere Discovery of Scienti c Principle or Natural Substance

[Section 3(c)]
The following are not patentable:
• Scienti c principles
• Abstract theories
• Discovery of living or non-living substances occurring in nature
Examples:
• Discovery of gravity
• Discovery of naturally occurring minerals
• Discovery of a plant in forest
Reason:
Discoveries are not inventions.

IV. Mere Discovery of New Form of Known Substance

[Section 3(d)]
A mere discovery of a new form of a known substance without enhanced ef cacy is not patentable.
Examples:
• Minor modi cation of existing medicine
• Slight change in chemical composition
Purpose:
To prevent “evergreening” of patents.

Important Explanation
Enhanced therapeutic ef cacy must be proved in pharmaceutical inventions.

V. Mere Admixture
[Section 3(e)]
A mere mixture of known substances resulting only in aggregation of properties is not patentable.
Example:
Mixing two known medicines without producing new effect.

VI. Mere Arrangement or Re-arrangement of Devices

[Section 3(f)]
Simple arrangement or duplication of known devices functioning independently is not patentable.
Example:
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
A torch attached with a pen without producing new technical result.

VII. Methods of Agriculture or Horticulture

[Section 3(h)]
Agricultural and horticultural methods are excluded from patentability.
Examples:
• Method of cultivating crops
• Irrigation techniques
Reason:
Agriculture should remain freely accessible.

VIII. Medical, Surgical, Curative, and Diagnostic Methods

[Section 3(i)]
Methods for treatment of humans or animals are not patentable.
Includes:
• Surgical methods
• Therapy methods
• Diagnostic methods
Examples:
• Surgical operation technique
• Method of treating cancer
Reason:
Medical treatment should remain accessible to public.

IX. Plants and Animals

[Section 3(j)]
Plants and animals in whole or part are not patentable except microorganisms.
Not Patentable:
• Seeds
• Plant varieties
• Animal breeds
Exception:
Genetically modi ed microorganisms may be patentable.

X. Mathematical or Business Methods and Computer Programs

[Section 3(k)]
The following are not patentable:
• Mathematical methods
• Business methods
• Algorithms
• Computer programs per se
Examples:
• Accounting method
• Pure software algorithm
Reason:
These are abstract intellectual concepts.

XI. Literary, Artistic, Dramatic, Musical Works

[Section 3(l)]
fi
Creative works protected under copyright law are not patentable.
Examples:
• Novels
• Songs
• Paintings

XII. Mental Acts or Playing Games

[Section 3(m)]
Schemes, rules, or methods of:
• Mental acts
• Playing games
cannot be patented.
Examples:
• Chess rules
• Memory improvement techniques

XIII. Presentation of Information

[Section 3(n)]
Methods of presenting information are excluded.
Example:
Formats of displaying advertisements or charts.

XIV. Topography of Integrated Circuits

[Section 3(o)]
Layouts of semiconductor integrated circuits are not patentable under patent law.
They are separately protected under semiconductor laws.

XV. Traditional Knowledge

[Section 3(p)]
Traditional knowledge or duplication of known properties of traditionally known substances cannot
be patented.
Examples:
• Turmeric healing properties
• Neem medicinal uses
Purpose:
To prevent biopiracy.

XVI. Atomic Energy Inventions

[Section 4]
Inventions relating to atomic energy are not patentable.
Reason:
National security and public safety.

Important Case Law

Novartis AG v. Union of India (2013)
Facts
Novartis AG sought patent protection for the cancer medicine “Glivec.”
Judgment
The Supreme Court of India held that the modi ed version of the medicine did not show enhanced
therapeutic ef cacy and therefore was not patentable under Section 3(d).
fi
fi
Q.14 Various Kinds of Intellectual Properties with Illustrations
Introduction
Intellectual Property (IP) refers to creations of the human mind such as inventions, literary works,
artistic works, symbols, names, designs, and commercial innovations. Intellectual Property Rights
(IPRs) provide legal protection to creators and owners over their intellectual creations and prevent
unauthorized use by others.
In the modern economy, intellectual property has become an important asset for individuals,
industries, and nations. It promotes:
• Innovation
• Creativity
• Economic development
• Fair competition
• Technological advancement
In India, different forms of intellectual property are protected under various laws such as the Patents
Act, Copyright Act, Trade Marks Act, and Designs Act.
According to the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), intellectual property includes
creations such as inventions, literary and artistic works, symbols, names, and designs used in
commerce.

Meaning of Intellectual Property

Intellectual Property means intangible property created through human intellect, skill, labor, and
creativity.
Unlike physical property, IP exists in ideas and creative expressions.

Various Kinds of Intellectual Property

The major kinds of intellectual property are:
1. Patents
2. Copyright
3. Trademarks
4. Industrial Designs
5. Geographical Indications
6. Trade Secrets
7. Plant Varieties Protection
8. Layout Designs of Integrated Circuits

1. Patents
Meaning
A patent is an exclusive legal right granted for a new invention that:
• Is novel
• Involves inventive step
• Is capable of industrial application
Patents are governed in India by the Patents Act, 1970.

Rights Granted
The patent holder gets exclusive rights to:
• Make
• Use
• Sell
• Import
• License the invention
for a limited period.
Duration
• 20 years from ling date

Illustration
Example:
A pharmaceutical company invents a new cancer medicine.
The company receives a patent and can exclusively manufacture and sell the medicine for 20 years.

Importance
• Encourages innovation
• Promotes scienti c research
• Facilitates industrial growth

2. Copyright
Meaning
Copyright protects original literary, artistic, dramatic, musical works, cinematograph lms, and
sound recordings.
In India, copyright is governed by the Copyright Act, 1957.

Works Protected
• Books
• Songs
• Paintings
• Films
• Software
• Photographs

Rights Granted
The owner can:
• Reproduce work
• Publish work
• Adapt or translate work
• Communicate work to public

Illustration
Example:
An author writing a novel automatically gets copyright protection over the book.
Another person cannot copy or publish the novel without permission.

Importance
• Encourages creativity
• Protects authors and artists
• Prevents piracy

3. Trademarks
Meaning
A trademark is a mark capable of distinguishing goods or services of one business from another.
It is governed by the Trade Marks Act, 1999.
fi
fi
fi
Forms of Trademark
• Word mark
• Logo
• Label
• Signature
• Symbol
• Color combination

Illustration
Examples:
• Nike “Swoosh”
• Apple logo
• Tata trademark
These marks identify the source and quality of products.

Importance
• Protects business goodwill
• Prevents consumer confusion
• Promotes fair competition

4. Industrial Designs
Meaning
Industrial design protects the visual appearance, shape, con guration, pattern, or ornamentation of
an article.
Governed by the Designs Act, 2000.

Illustration
Example:
A uniquely designed perfume bottle or mobile phone shape.
The design owner gets exclusive rights over the appearance of the product.

Importance
• Encourages aesthetic creativity
• Enhances commercial value of products

5. Geographical Indications (GI)

Meaning
A Geographical Indication identi es goods originating from a speci c geographical area where
quality or reputation is linked to that place.
Governed by the Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999.

Illustration
Examples:
• Darjeeling Tea
• Banarasi Sarees
• Kanchipuram Silk
These products derive reputation from their place of origin.

Importance
• Protects traditional products
fi
fi
fi
 • Promotes rural economy
• Prevents misuse of regional names

6. Trade Secrets
Meaning
Trade secrets include con dential business information that provides commercial advantage.
Examples include:
• Manufacturing formulas
• Customer lists
• Marketing strategies

Illustration
Example:
The secret formula of Coca-Cola.
The formula is kept con dential and protected as a trade secret.

Importance
• Protects con dential business information
• Maintains competitive advantage

7. Protection of Plant Varieties

Meaning
Protection is granted to breeders who develop new plant varieties.
Governed by the Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmers’ Rights Act, 2001.

Illustration
Example:
Development of a high-yield wheat variety by agricultural scientists.

Importance
• Encourages agricultural innovation
• Protects breeders and farmers

8. Layout Designs of Integrated Circuits

Meaning
Protection is granted to semiconductor integrated circuit layout designs.
Governed by the Semiconductor Integrated Circuits Layout-Design Act, 2000.

Illustration
Example:
Layout design of computer microchips.

Importance
• Encourages electronics and semiconductor innovation

Important Case Law

Novartis AG v. Union of India (2013)
Facts
Novartis AG sought patent protection for a modi ed cancer medicine.
fi
fi
fi
fi
Judgment
The Supreme Court of India refused patent protection under Section 3(d) of the Patents Act because
enhanced ef cacy was not proved.

Importance of Intellectual Property Rights

1. Encourages Innovation and Creativity
Creators receive recognition and economic rewards.

2. Promotes Economic Development

IP industries contribute signi cantly to national economy.

3. Attracts Investment
Strong IP protection encourages domestic and foreign investment.

4. Prevents Unfair Competition

Protects businesses from imitation and piracy.

5. Protects Consumers
Ensures authenticity and quality of goods.

Q.15 Deceptive Similarity

Introduction
In trademark law, the main purpose of a trademark is to distinguish the goods or services of one
trader from those of others. Consumers identify products through trademarks, logos, labels, names,
and symbols. Therefore, the law protects trademarks from imitation or misuse that may confuse the
public.
One important concept under trademark law is “deceptive similarity.” A trademark is deceptively
similar when it resembles another trademark so closely that it is likely to deceive or confuse
consumers regarding the origin of goods or services.
In India, deceptive similarity is governed by the Trade Marks Act, 1999.

Meaning of Deceptive Similarity

According to Section 2(1)(h) of the Trade Marks Act, 1999:
A mark shall be deemed deceptively similar to another mark if it so nearly resembles that other
mark as to be likely to deceive or cause confusion.
Thus, deceptive similarity exists when:
• Two marks are not exactly identical,
but
• Their resemblance is likely to confuse an average consumer.

Essentials of Deceptive Similarity

For deceptive similarity, the following elements are generally considered:
1. Similarity between marks
2. Likelihood of confusion or deception
3. Similarity of goods or services
4. Possibility of association by consumers

Types of Similarity
fi
fi
 1. Visual Similarity
When two trademarks look alike in appearance, shape, style, or design.
Examples:
• “PUMAA” and “PUMA”
• Similar logos or packaging

2. Phonetic Similarity
When trademarks sound alike when pronounced.
Examples:
• “NIKKE” and “NIKE”
• “Falcigo” and “Falcitab”

3. Structural Similarity
Similarity in arrangement of letters, words, or design structure.
Example:
• “Quick x” and “Kwik x”

4. Conceptual Similarity
When trademarks create the same idea or impression in the minds of consumers.
Example:
Two trademarks both conveying the idea of speed or strength.

Test for Deceptive Similarity

Courts apply the test of:
“Likelihood of confusion among average consumers.”
The question is:
Would an ordinary consumer with imperfect memory likely be confused?
The comparison is based on:
• Overall impression
• General appearance
• Sound and meaning
• Nature of goods
• Consumer class

Factors Considered by Courts

1. Nature of Marks
Whether marks are:
• Word marks
• Label marks
• Composite marks

2. Degree of Similarity
Similarity in:
• Appearance
• Pronunciation
• Meaning

3. Nature of Goods or Services

Confusion is more likely when goods are similar.
fi
fi
Example:
Similar trademarks for medicines create greater risk.

4. Class of Consumers
Courts consider:
• Education level
• Intelligence
• Purchasing habits

5. Mode of Purchase
Whether goods are purchased:
• Carefully
• Quickly
• By ordinary public

6. Surrounding Circumstances
Market conditions and trade practices are also considered.

Importance of Deceptive Similarity

1. Protection of Consumers
Prevents public confusion regarding product origin.

2. Protection of Business Goodwill

Safeguards reputation and market identity of trademark owner.

3. Prevention of Unfair Competition

Stops dishonest traders from bene ting from another’s reputation.

• Legal Provisions Relating to Deceptive Similarity

Section 11
Registration may be refused if a mark is deceptively similar to an earlier trademark.

Section 29
Use of deceptively similar marks amounts to trademark infringement.

• Remedies Against Deceptive Similarity

The trademark owner may seek:
1. Injunction
Court order restraining unauthorized use.

2. Damages
Compensation for nancial loss.

3. Account of Pro ts
Recovery of pro ts earned by infringer.

4. Destruction of Infringing Goods

fi
fi
fi
fi
Seizure and destruction of copied products.

Important Case Law

Cadila Health Care Ltd. v. Cadila Pharmaceuticals Ltd. 2001
Facts
Two pharmaceutical companies used similar trademarks:
• “Falcigo”
• “Falcitab”
Both medicines were used for malaria treatment.

Judgment
The Supreme Court of India held that even minor similarity in medicinal products may create
dangerous confusion.
The Court laid down factors for determining deceptive similarity, including:
• Nature of marks
• Degree of resemblance
• Nature of goods
• Consumer class

Q.16 Intellectual Property Rights (IPR): Nature, Forms, Scope and Features
Introduction
Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs) are legal rights granted to individuals or organizations over
creations of the human mind. These creations may include inventions, literary works, artistic
creations, trademarks, industrial designs, software, and other innovative products of intellect.
In the modern world, intellectual property has become an important economic and commercial
asset. IPR protection encourages innovation, creativity, industrial growth, scienti c research, and
fair competition.
The concept of IPR is recognized internationally through agreements such as the TRIPS Agreement
and conventions administered by the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO).
In India, different forms of intellectual property are protected under laws such as:
• Patents Act, 1970
• Copyright Act, 1957
• Trade Marks Act, 1999
• Designs Act, 2000

Meaning of Intellectual Property Rights

Intellectual Property Rights are exclusive legal rights granted to creators and owners over their
intellectual creations for a limited period.
These rights allow the owner to:
• Use the intellectual property
• Sell or license it
• Prevent unauthorized use
• Receive economic bene ts

Nature of Intellectual Property Rights

The nature of IPR refers to its legal and commercial characteristics.
fi
fi
1. Intangible Property
IPR relates to creations of the mind and not physical objects.
Example:
• Software
• Music
• Brand names
The physical object may be tangible, but the intellectual creation is intangible.

2. Exclusive Rights
IPR grants exclusive rights to the owner to use and exploit the property.
Example:
A patent holder alone can manufacture the patented invention.

3. Statutory Rights
IPRs are created and protected by statutes or laws.
Example:
Patent rights arise under the Patents Act.

4. Territorial Nature
IPR protection is generally limited to the country where protection is granted.
Example:
A patent granted in India is valid only within India unless protected internationally.

5. Limited Duration
IPRs are not perpetual and exist only for a speci ed time.
Examples:
• Patent: 20 years
• Trademark: Renewable inde nitely
• Copyright: Lifetime of author + 60 years

6. Transferable Rights
IPRs can be:
• Assigned
• Licensed
• Sold
• Transferred

7. Commercial Value
IPRs are valuable business assets and generate revenue.
Example:
Famous trademarks like Apple or Nike have enormous commercial value.

8. Balance Between Private and Public Interest

IPR law protects creators while also safeguarding public interest.
Example:
Compulsory licensing in patents for essential medicines.
fi
fi
Forms of Intellectual Property Rights
The major forms of IPR are:
1. Patents
2. Copyright
3. Trademarks
4. Industrial Designs
5. Geographical Indications
6. Trade Secrets
7. Plant Variety Protection
8. Semiconductor Layout Designs

1. Patents
Meaning
Patent protects inventions involving:
• Novelty
• Inventive step
• Industrial applicability
Illustration:
A new pharmaceutical drug.
Governing Law
Patents Act, 1970

2. Copyright
Meaning
Protects original literary, artistic, musical, and dramatic works.
Illustration:
Books, songs, lms, software.
Governing Law
Copyright Act, 1957

3. Trademarks
Meaning
Protects symbols or marks identifying goods or services.
Illustration:
Nike logo, Apple symbol.
Governing Law
Trade Marks Act, 1999

4. Industrial Designs
Meaning
Protects visual appearance and aesthetic features of products.
Illustration:
Unique perfume bottle design.
Governing Law
Designs Act, 2000

5. Geographical Indications (GI)

Meaning
Protects products associated with speci c geographical origin.
fi
fi
Illustration:
Darjeeling Tea, Banarasi Saree.
Governing Law
Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999

6. Trade Secrets
Meaning
Protects con dential business information.
Illustration:
Coca-Cola formula.

7. Plant Variety Protection

Meaning
Protects new plant varieties developed by breeders.
Governing Law
Protection of Plant Varieties and Farmers’ Rights Act, 2001

8. Semiconductor Layout Designs

Meaning
Protects layout designs of semiconductor integrated circuits.
Governing Law
Semiconductor Integrated Circuits Layout-Design Act, 2000

Scope of Intellectual Property Rights

The scope of IPR refers to the extent and application of intellectual property protection.

1. Protection of Creativity and Innovation

IPR protects intellectual efforts in:
• Science
• Literature
• Art
• Technology

2. Economic Development
IPR contributes to:
• Industrial growth
• Employment generation
• Technology transfer

3. Promotion of Research and Development

Inventors and researchers are encouraged through legal protection.

4. Consumer Protection
Trademarks and GI tags help consumers identify genuine products.

5. International Trade
Strong IP protection promotes foreign investment and trade.
fi
 6. Cultural Development
Copyright protects literature, music, lms, and cultural expressions.

Features of Intellectual Property Rights

1. Monopoly Rights
Owners enjoy exclusive rights for a limited time.

2. Encouragement of Innovation
IPR motivates inventors and creators.

3. Legal Protection
Provides remedies against infringement and piracy.

4. Recognition of Ownership
Acknowledges creators’ contribution and ownership.

5. Economic Reward
Creators receive nancial bene ts through commercialization.

6. Public Disclosure
Patent law requires disclosure of inventions to society.

7. Dynamic and Evolving Nature

IPR laws adapt to technological developments such as:
• Arti cial intelligence
• Digital content
• Biotechnology

Important Case Law

Novartis AG v. Union of India
(2013)
Facts
Novartis AG sought patent protection for a modi ed cancer drug.
Judgment
The Supreme Court of India refused the patent under Section 3(d) of the Patents Act due to lack of
enhanced ef cacy.
Importance
• Balanced innovation with public interest
• Clari ed scope of patent protection
• Prevented evergreening of patents
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
Q.17 “Copyright is a Bundle of Rights”
Introduction
Copyright is one of the most important forms of Intellectual Property Rights (IPR). It protects the
original expression of ideas in literary, artistic, musical, dramatic, and other creative works.
Copyright law gives legal recognition and protection to creators for their intellectual efforts.
The expression “Copyright is a bundle of rights” means that copyright does not consist of a single
right. Instead, it includes several exclusive rights given to the owner of the copyrighted work. These
rights may be exercised separately, transferred individually, licensed, or jointly exploited.
In India, copyright is governed by the Copyright Act, 1957.

Meaning of Copyright
Copyright means the exclusive legal right granted to the creator or owner of an original work to:
• Reproduce the work
• Publish the work
• Communicate the work to the public
• Adapt or translate the work
• Commercially exploit the work
Copyright protects:
• Literary works
• Artistic works
• Musical works
• Dramatic works
• Cinematograph lms
• Sound recordings
• Computer programs

Meaning of “Bundle of Rights”

The term “bundle of rights” means a collection of several independent rights vested in the copyright
owner.
Each right can:
• Exist independently
• Be assigned separately
• Be licensed individually
• Be enforced independently
Thus, copyright is not one single right but a group of rights related to the use and exploitation of the
work.

Rights Included in Copyright

(Section 14 of the Copyright Act, 1957)
Section 14 de nes copyright as the exclusive right subject to the provisions of the Act.
The bundle of rights varies according to the type of work.

1. Right of Reproduction
Meaning
The owner has the exclusive right to reproduce or copy the work in any material form.
Examples:
• Printing copies of a book
• Photocopying study material
• Copying software
• Reproducing songs
fi
fi
 Unauthorized copying amounts to infringement.

2. Right of Publication and Distribution

Meaning
The owner has the right to issue copies of the work to the public.
Examples:
• Selling books
• Distributing DVDs
• Publishing magazines
The copyright owner controls commercial circulation.

3. Right of Communication to the Public

Meaning
The owner can communicate the work to the public through:
• Broadcasting
• Internet streaming
• Television
• Radio
• Public performance
Examples:
• Streaming movies on OTT platforms
• Broadcasting songs on radio

4. Right of Public Performance

Meaning
The owner has the right to publicly perform the work.
Examples:
• Stage performance of drama
• Public singing of copyrighted songs
• Screening lms in theatres
Permission is generally required for public performance.

5. Right of Adaptation
Meaning
The owner can adapt the work into another form.
Examples:
• Novel converted into lm
• Book adapted into play
• Story adapted into comic
Adaptation rights are commercially valuable.

6. Right of Translation
Meaning
The owner has exclusive rights to translate the work into another language.
Examples:
• English novel translated into Hindi
• Legal textbook translated into Marathi
fi
fi
Unauthorized translation infringes copyright.

7. Right to Make Cinematograph Film or Sound Recording

Meaning
The owner can convert the work into:
• Film
• Audio recording
• Video production
Example:
Making a movie based on a copyrighted novel.

8. Right to Store in Electronic Form

Meaning
Digital storage of copyrighted works is also protected.
Examples:
• Uploading books as PDFs
• Saving software digitally
• Storing music les

9. Right to Sell or Commercially Exploit

Meaning
The owner may commercially exploit the work by:
• Licensing
• Assignment
• Royalty agreements
Example:
Music companies licensing songs to streaming platforms.

10. Moral Rights of Author

(Section 57)
Apart from economic rights, authors also enjoy moral rights.

A. Right of Paternity
Right to claim authorship of the work.

B. Right of Integrity
Right to prevent distortion or mutilation of the work.

Why Copyright is Called a Bundle of Rights

Copyright is called a bundle of rights because:
• Multiple rights exist together
• Rights may be separately transferred
• Different persons may own different rights
Example:
• Author may assign lm rights to producer
• Translation rights to publisher
• Audio rights to music company
Each right operates independently.
fi
fi
Illustration
Suppose an author writes a novel.
The author may:
• Publish printed copies
• Sell movie adaptation rights
• License translation rights
• Permit audiobook recording
• Allow digital publication
Thus, one copyrighted work creates multiple rights.

Importance of Bundle of Rights

1. Economic Bene ts
Creators can earn revenue from different forms of exploitation.

2. Encourages Creativity
Legal protection motivates authors and artists.

3. Commercial Flexibility
Rights can be licensed separately for different uses.

4. Protects Creative Expression

Prevents unauthorized copying and exploitation.

Assignment and Licensing of Rights

The copyright owner may:
• Assign rights permanently
• Grant licenses temporarily
Different rights may be transferred to different parties.
Example:
• Film rights to producer
• Publishing rights to publisher
• Music rights to record label

Infringement of Copyright
Violation of any right in the bundle amounts to infringement.
Examples:
• Unauthorized copying
• Illegal streaming
• Pirated movies
• Unauthorized translation

Important Case Law

Indian Performing Right Society Ltd. v. Eastern India Motion Pictures Association 1977
Facts
The dispute concerned ownership of music and lyric rights in cinematograph lms.
Judgment
The Supreme Court of India explained that copyright consists of several distinct rights capable of
separate ownership and exploitation.
fi
fi
Q.18Passing Off under Trademark Law
Introduction
In the modern business world, trademarks are very important for identifying goods and services.
Customers recognize products through names, logos, labels, packaging, and symbols. A business
spends many years building its goodwill and reputation in the market.
Sometimes dishonest traders copy the trademark, packaging, or business style of another company
to confuse customers and earn pro t. This unfair practice is called passing off.
Passing off is a common law remedy that protects the goodwill and reputation of businesses. It
prevents one trader from presenting his goods or services as those of another trader.
The main objectives of passing off are:
• To protect business reputation,
• To prevent customer confusion,
• To stop unfair competition,
• To protect consumers from deception.

Meaning of Passing Off

Passing off means:
“Representing one person’s goods or services as those of another person.”
In simple words, when a person copies another company’s trademark, name, packaging, or
appearance to make customers believe that both products belong to the same company, it is called
passing off.
Passing off mainly protects:
• Goodwill,
• Reputation,
• Business identity,
• Consumer con dence.
It protects even unregistered trademarks.

Legal Provision
Passing off is recognized under:
Section 27(2) of the Trade Marks Act 1999
This section states that:
Even if a trademark is not registered, the owner can le a suit against any person who passes off his
goods or services as those of another person.

Essential Elements of Passing Off

The plaintiff must prove the following elements:

1. Goodwill or Reputation
The plaintiff must prove that his business or products are well known in the market.
Example:
Customers trust a famous brand because of its reputation.

2. Misrepresentation
The defendant falsely represents his goods or services as those of the plaintiff.
This may happen by:
• Similar trademark,
• Similar packaging,
• Similar logo,
• Similar trade name.
fi
fi
fi
 3. Damage
The plaintiff must suffer actual or possible loss because of the defendant’s actions.
Damage may include:
• Loss of customers,
• Loss of pro t,
• Harm to reputation,
• Market confusion.

Modes of Passing Off

Passing off can happen in different ways. The important modes are explained below.

1. Trademark Passing Off

This happens when a trader uses a trademark similar to another trader’s trademark.
Example:
Using “Adibas” instead of “Adidas”.
Effect:
Customers may think both products belong to the same company.

2. Trade Name Passing Off

This occurs when a person uses a business name similar to a famous company name.
Example:
Using the name “Tata Electronics” without permission.
Effect:
Customers may believe the business is connected with the original company.

3. Trade Dress or Packaging Passing Off

Trade dress means the overall appearance of goods such as:
• Colour combination,
• Shape,
• Packaging,
• Design,
• Label style.
Example:
Using the same bottle shape and colour as another soft drink company.
Effect:
Customers become confused because the products look similar.

4. Domain Name Passing Off

This occurs when a person uses a similar website or domain name.
Example:
“[Link]” instead of Yahoo.
Effect:
Internet users may visit the wrong website.

5. Personality Passing Off

This occurs when a person uses a celebrity’s name, image, or identity without permission for
commercial bene t.
Example:
Using a famous actor’s photo in advertisements without consent.
fi
fi
Landmark Case Law
Cadila Health Care Ltd. v. Cadila Pharmaceuticals Ltd. (2001)
Facts of the Case
Two pharmaceutical companies were manufacturing medicines for malaria treatment.
• The plaintiff used the trademark “Falcigo”
• The defendant used the trademark “Falcitab”
The plaintiff argued that:
• The names sounded very similar,
• Doctors and patients could become confused,
• Wrong medicines could be dangerous to human life.
The plaintiff led a passing off case against the defendant.

Judgment
The Supreme Court held that:
• Similar sounding medicine names can create confusion,
• Confusion in medicines may endanger human life,
• Greater care is required in pharmaceutical products.
The Court restrained the defendant from using the trademark “Falcitab”.

Remedies for Passing Off

1. Injunction
The court may stop the defendant from using the deceptive mark.

2. Damages
The plaintiff may receive compensation for losses suffered.

3. Account of Pro ts
The defendant may be ordered to hand over pro ts earned illegally.

4. Delivery Up
Fake goods, labels, and packaging may be destroyed.

Conclusion
Passing off is an important remedy under trademark law that protects the goodwill and reputation of
businesses. It prevents dishonest traders from misleading customers and taking unfair advantage of
another company’s reputation.

Q.19 Revocation of Patent

Introduction
A patent gives exclusive rights to an inventor over his invention for a limited period. The patent
holder can use, sell, manufacture, or license the invention. However, a patent is granted only when
the invention satis es the legal requirements under patent law.
Sometimes a patent may be granted wrongly or obtained unfairly. In such situations, the law allows
cancellation of the patent. This cancellation is called revocation of patent.
Revocation is an important safeguard under patent law because it prevents misuse of patent rights
and protects public interest.

Meaning of Revocation of Patent

Revocation of patent means:
fi
fi
fi
fi
“Cancellation or withdrawal of a patent by the competent authority.”
When a patent is revoked:
• The patent holder loses all rights over the invention,
• The invention becomes open for public use,
• The patent is treated as invalid.

Legal Provision
Revocation of patents in India is governed by:
Section 64 of the Patents Act 1970
A patent may be revoked:
• By the High Court,
• On a petition by any interested person,
• Or as a counterclaim in an infringement suit.

Grounds for Revocation of Patent

A patent may be revoked on the following grounds:

1. Wrongful Obtaining of Patent

If the patent was obtained wrongfully from the true inventor, it may be revoked.
Example:
An employee steals another scientist’s invention and les a patent in his own name.

2. Lack of Novelty
A patent can be revoked if the invention is not new.
If the invention was already:
• Published,
• Used,
• Known to the public,
before the patent application, the patent becomes invalid.

3. Prior Publication
If the invention was published in India or abroad before ling the patent application, the patent may
be revoked.
Example:
The invention was already described in a journal or research paper.

4. Prior Public Use

If the invention was publicly used in India before the patent application date, the patent may be
revoked.

5. Obviousness or Lack of Inventive Step

The invention must involve an inventive step and should not be obvious to a skilled person.
If the invention is simple or obvious, the patent may be cancelled.

6. Non-Patentable Subject Matter

A patent may be revoked if the invention falls under non-patentable categories under Section 3 of
the Patents Act.
Example:
• Discovery of scienti c principles,
• Mathematical methods,
fi
fi
fi
 • Traditional knowledge.

7. Insuf cient Description

The patent speci cation must clearly explain:
• The invention,
• Method of use,
• Best mode of performing it.
If the description is incomplete or unclear, the patent may be revoked.

8. False Suggestion or Misrepresentation

If the patent was obtained by giving false information or fraud, it may be revoked.

9. Failure to Disclose Information

The applicant must disclose information regarding foreign patent applications related to the same
invention.
Failure to disclose such information can lead to revocation.

10. Patent Contrary to Public Interest

A patent may be revoked if the invention is:
• Harmful to public health,
• Morally wrong,
• Dangerous to society.

Who Can Apply for Revocation?

The following persons may le for revocation:
1. Any interested person,
2. Central Government,
3. Defendant in a patent infringement suit.

Procedure for Revocation

Step 1 – Filing Petition
An interested person les a petition before the High Court or appropriate authority.

Step 2 – Grounds Mentioned

The petitioner must clearly state the grounds for revocation.

Step 3 – Evidence
Both parties submit evidence and documents.

Step 4 – Hearing
The court hears arguments from both sides.

Step 5 – Decision
The court may:
• Revoke the patent,
• Partly amend the patent,
• Or dismiss the petition.

Effects of Revocation
When a patent is revoked:
fi
fi
fi
fi
 • Patent rights come to an end,
• The invention enters the public domain,
• Anyone can use the invention freely.

Landmark Case Law

Novartis AG v. Union of India (2013)
Facts of the Case
Novartis AG applied for a patent for a cancer medicine called Glivec.
The company claimed that the new version of the drug was an invention.
The Government argued that:
• The medicine was only a modi ed form of an existing drug,
• It did not show signi cant improvement in effectiveness.

Judgment
The Supreme Court rejected the patent claim.
The Court held that:
• Minor modi cations cannot be patented,
• Evergreening of patents is not allowed,
• Patent protection should not block access to affordable medicines.

Q.20 Registration of Geographical Indication

Introduction
Certain goods become famous because of the place where they are produced. The quality,
reputation, or characteristics of such goods are connected with their geographical origin. For
example, Darjeeling Tea, Banarasi Sarees, and Alphonso Mangoes are famous because they come
from particular regions.
To protect such products from misuse and imitation, the law provides protection through
Geographical Indications (GI).
Registration of Geographical Indication helps producers protect the identity and reputation of their
products and prevents unauthorized persons from using the geographical name.

Meaning of Geographical Indication

A Geographical Indication (GI) is:
“An indication which identi es goods as originating from a particular geographical area where a
speci c quality, reputation, or characteristic of the goods is essentially connected with that place.”
In simple words, GI is a sign used on products that have a special connection with a particular
region.

Examples of Geographical Indications

Some famous Indian GIs are:
• Darjeeling Tea
• Alphonso Mango
• Banarasi Saree
• Kanchipuram Silk Saree
• Nagpur Orange

Legal Provision
Geographical Indications in India are protected under:
Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act 1999
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
The Act came into force in 2003.
The main objectives of the Act are:
• To protect GI goods,
• To prevent misuse,
• To promote rural and traditional products,
• To protect consumer interests.

Meaning of Registration of GI
Registration of GI means of cially recording a geographical indication under the law to provide
legal protection.
After registration:
• Only authorized users can use the GI,
• Others cannot misuse the name,
• Legal action can be taken against infringement.

Who Can Apply for Registration?

The following persons may apply:
• Association of persons,
• Producers,
• Organizations,
• Authorities representing the interests of producers.
The applicant must represent the producers of the concerned goods.

Goods Covered under GI

GI protection is available for:
1. Agricultural goods,
2. Natural goods,
3. Manufactured goods,
4. Handicrafts,
5. Food products,
6. Textile products.

Procedure for Registration of Geographical Indication

Step 1 – Filing of Application

The application is led before the:
Geographical Indications Registry
The application must contain:
• Name of the GI,
• Geographical area,
• Quality and characteristics of goods,
• Proof of origin,
• Class of goods.

Step 2 – Examination
The Registrar examines:
• Whether the application satis es legal requirements,
• Whether the GI is capable of protection.
If there are objections, the applicant must respond.
fi
fi
fi
Step 3 – Publication in GI Journal
If accepted, the application is published in the GI Journal.
This allows the public to oppose the registration if necessary.

Step 4 – Opposition
Any person may le opposition within the prescribed period if they believe the registration should
not be granted.

Step 5 – Registration
If no opposition is led, or if opposition is decided in favour of the applicant, the GI is registered.
The Registrar issues a certi cate of registration.

Duration of Registration
A GI registration is valid for:
• 10 years
It can be renewed again for further periods of 10 years.

Rights Conferred by Registration

Registration gives the following rights:
1. Exclusive Right to Use
Only authorized users can use the GI.

2. Right to Sue for Infringement

Legal action can be taken against unauthorized users.

3. Protection of Goodwill
The reputation and uniqueness of the product are protected.

Infringement of Geographical Indication

Infringement occurs when:
• Unauthorized persons use the GI,
• False geographical origin is indicated,
• Consumers are misled regarding the product.
Example:
Selling ordinary tea as “Darjeeling Tea”.

Landmark Case Law

Tea Board of India v. ITC Limited 2011
Facts
The dispute involved the use of the famous GI:
Darjeeling Tea
The Tea Board sought protection against misuse of the Darjeeling name and logo.

Judgment
The court recognized the importance of protecting geographical indications and the reputation
associated with regional products.
fi
fi
fi
Q.21 Defences Available to the Defendant in a Suit for Infringement of Trademark
Introduction
A trademark is an important intellectual property right that helps consumers identify the goods or
services of a particular business. When a person uses a registered trademark without permission, it
amounts to trademark infringement. In such cases, the trademark owner can le a suit against the
infringer.
However, the defendant is not always liable. Trademark law provides certain legal defences that can
protect the defendant from liability. These defences help maintain a balance between the rights of
trademark owners and fair use by others.
The defendant can avoid liability by proving that his use of the trademark is lawful, honest, or
permitted under the law.

Meaning of Trademark Infringement

Trademark infringement means:
“Unauthorized use of a registered trademark or a deceptively similar mark in relation to goods or
services.”
Infringement occurs when:
• The mark is identical or deceptively similar,
• It causes confusion among consumers,
• It affects the rights of the trademark owner.

Legal Provision
Trademark infringement is governed by:
Trade Marks Act 1999
The defences available to the defendant are mainly provided under:
• Section 30,
• Section 34,
• Other general legal principles.

Defences Available to the Defendant

1. Honest and Bona Fide Use

The defendant can argue that he used the mark honestly and in good faith without any intention to
deceive consumers.
Example:
Using one’s own name honestly in business.

2. Descriptive Use
If the trademark is used only to describe:
• Quality,
• Quantity,
• Purpose,
• Value,
• Characteristics of goods,
it may not amount to infringement.
Example:
Using the word “Sweet” merely to describe taste.
fi
3. Use of Own Name
A person may use his own personal name or business name honestly in trade.
Example:
A person named “Kapoor” may use his surname in business if done honestly.

4. Prior Use Defence

Under Section 34, a person who has been continuously using a trademark before the plaintiff’s
registration may continue using it.
Principle:
Prior user rights are superior to registration rights.

5. Nominative Fair Use

The defendant may use another person’s trademark only for identi cation or reference purposes.
Example:
A repair shop stating:
“We repair Samsung phones.”
This does not mean association with Samsung.

6. No Likelihood of Confusion
The defendant may argue that:
• The marks are different,
• Consumers are unlikely to be confused,
• Goods or services are different.
If there is no confusion, infringement may not exist.

7. Invalid Registration of Trademark

The defendant may challenge the validity of the plaintiff’s trademark registration.
Grounds may include:
• Lack of distinctiveness,
• Generic mark,
• Fraudulent registration.

8. Non-Use of Trademark
If the plaintiff has not used the trademark for a long period, the defendant may raise the defence of
non-use.
Unused trademarks may lose protection.

9. Permitted Use or Consent

If the plaintiff permitted or authorized the defendant to use the trademark, infringement cannot be
claimed.
Example:
Licensed use of trademark.

10. Comparative Advertising

A defendant may compare his goods with another brand if:
• The comparison is honest,
• It does not damage the reputation of the trademark owner.

11. Exhaustion of Rights / Parallel Import

fi
Once goods are lawfully sold by the trademark owner, resale of those goods may not amount to
infringement.
This is called the doctrine of exhaustion.

Landmark Case Law

N.R. Dongre v. Whirlpool Corporation (1996)
Facts
Whirlpool Corporation owned the trademark “Whirlpool” for washing machines.
The defendants started using the same mark in India even though Whirlpool products were not
widely sold in India at that time.

Judgment
The Supreme Court held that:
• Whirlpool had acquired international reputation,
• Use of the same mark by the defendant could mislead consumers,
• The defendant could not claim honest use.
The Court granted protection to Whirlpool.

Q.22 Acts Which Do Not Constitute Infringement under Copyright Law

Introduction
Copyright law protects the original work of authors, artists, musicians, lmmakers, and creators.
The owner of copyright has exclusive rights over the use, reproduction, publication, and distribution
of his work.
If any person uses copyrighted work without permission, it generally amounts to copyright
infringement. However, the law also recognizes certain exceptions where the use of copyrighted
work is allowed without permission. Such acts are treated as lawful and do not amount to
infringement.
These exceptions are important because they balance:
• Rights of copyright owners, and
• Public interest, education, research, and freedom of expression.

Meaning of Copyright Infringement

Copyright infringement means:
“Unauthorized use of copyrighted work in violation of the rights of the copyright owner.”
It includes:
• Copying,
• Reproducing,
• Publishing,
• Distributing,
• Performing copyrighted work without permission.

Legal Provision
The acts which do not constitute infringement are mainly provided under:
Section 52 of the Copyright Act 1957
Section 52 contains the principle of fair dealing and other exceptions to copyright infringement.

Acts Which Do Not Constitute Copyright Infringement

1. Fair Dealing for Private or Personal Use

fi
Use of copyrighted material for:
• Personal study,
• Research,
• Private use,
does not amount to infringement.
Example:
A student photocopying a few pages for examination preparation.

2. Fair Dealing for Criticism or Review

A person may use copyrighted work for:
• Criticism,
• Review,
• Comment,
• Analysis.
Example:
Reviewing a movie by showing short clips.

3. Reporting of Current Events

Use of copyrighted material while reporting:
• News,
• Current affairs,
• Public events,
is allowed.
Example:
Showing brief video clips in news reporting.

4. Judicial Proceedings
Use of copyrighted work in:
• Court proceedings,
• Judicial reports,
• Legal processes,
does not amount to infringement.

5. Educational Use
Use of copyrighted work for teaching and education is permitted.
Example:
Teachers using extracts from books in classrooms.

6. Performance in Educational Institutions

Performance of literary, dramatic, or musical works:
• In schools,
• Colleges,
• Educational institutions,
for educational purposes is not infringement.

7. Library Use
Public libraries may:
• Store copies,
• Preserve books,
 • Supply limited copies for research.

8. Use by Government
The government may reproduce copyrighted work:
• For of cial purposes,
• Public interest,
• Legislative functions.

9. Making Backup Copies of Computer Programs

The lawful owner of computer software may make backup copies for protection against damage or
loss.

10. Transient or Incidental Storage

Temporary storage of copyrighted material during electronic transmission does not amount to
infringement.
Example:
Internet caching and buffering.

11. Adaptation for Disabled Persons

Conversion of copyrighted work into accessible formats for disabled persons is allowed.
Example:
Converting books into Braille.

12. Amateur Performance

Performance of copyrighted works in:
• Religious ceremonies,
• Non-pro t activities,
• Family functions,
may not amount to infringement.

Doctrine of Fair Dealing

Fair dealing means limited use of copyrighted material without permission for socially bene cial
purposes.
The court considers:
• Purpose of use,
• Nature of work,
• Amount copied,
• Effect on market value.

Landmark Case Law

R.G. Anand v. Deluxe Films (1978)
Facts
The plaintiff wrote a play and alleged that the defendant copied it in a lm.
The plaintiff claimed copyright infringement.

Judgment
The Supreme Court held that:
• Ideas cannot be copyrighted,
• Only the original expression is protected,
• Mere similarity of ideas is not infringement.
fi
fi
fi
fi
 Conclusion
Copyright law protects the rights of creators, but it also recognizes certain exceptions where use of
copyrighted work is legally permitted. Section 52 of the Copyright Act 1957 provides acts which do
not constitute infringement, such as fair dealing, educational use, reporting of current events,
judicial use, and library use.
These exceptions ensure that copyright protection does not become an obstacle to education,
research, criticism, and public access to knowledge. Therefore, the law maintains a proper balance
between the rights of copyright owners and the interests of society.

Short Notes:

Q.1 Patent of Addition

Introduction
Sometimes after obtaining a patent for an invention, the inventor makes certain improvements or
modi cations to the original invention. These improvements may not be entirely new inventions,
but they increase the usefulness or ef ciency of the original invention.
To protect such improvements, patent law provides a special type of patent called a Patent of
Addition.
A patent of addition allows the inventor to obtain protection for improvements related to the main
invention without ling a completely separate patent.

Meaning of Patent of Addition

A Patent of Addition means:
“A patent granted for an improvement or modi cation of an invention already patented by the same
inventor.”
It is granted for:
• Improvement,
• Modi cation,
• Development,
• Addition,
made to the original patented invention.
The patent of addition remains connected with the main patent and cannot normally exist
independently.

Legal Provision
Patent of Addition is governed by:
Sections 54 to 56 of the Patents Act 1970
These provisions deal with:
• Grant of patent of addition,
• Rights of patentee,
• Term of patent,
• Revocation and conversion.

Features of Patent of Addition

1. Improvement on Existing Invention

It is granted only for an improvement or modi cation of the main invention.
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 2. Same Applicant
The applicant for the patent of addition must be:
• The same inventor,
or
• Legal representative of the original patentee.

3. No Separate Renewal Fee

No separate renewal fee is payable during the term of the main patent.

4. Dependent on Main Patent

The patent of addition depends upon the existence of the main patent.

5. Same Expiry Date

The patent of addition expires along with the original patent.

Conditions for Grant of Patent of Addition

The following conditions must be satis ed:
1. There must already be a main patent or patent application.
2. The invention must be an improvement or modi cation of the original invention.
3. The applicant must be the same person as the original patentee.
4. The invention must have practical utility.

Procedure for Obtaining Patent of Addition

Step 1 – Filing of Application

The inventor les an application mentioning:
• Details of the main patent,
• Nature of improvement or modi cation.

Step 2 – Examination
The Patent Of ce examines whether:
• The invention is truly an improvement,
• Legal requirements are ful lled.

Step 3 – Grant of Patent

If satis ed, the Controller grants the patent of addition.

Revocation of Patent of Addition

A patent of addition may be revoked if:
• The main patent is revoked,
• The invention is not actually an improvement,
• Legal conditions are not ful lled.
In some cases, it may be converted into an independent patent.

Landmark Case Law

Biswanath Prasad Radhey Shyam v. Hindustan Metal Industries (1979)
Facts of the Case
The dispute related to an invention concerning a device used for improving the ef ciency of utensils
in industrial use.
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
The plaintiff claimed patent rights over the improvement and alleged infringement by the defendant.
The defendant argued that:
• The invention lacked inventive step,
• The improvement was obvious,
• It did not deserve patent protection.
Judgment
The Supreme Court held that:
• A patent can be granted only when the invention involves real invention and technical
advancement.
• Mere workshop improvement or ordinary modi cation is not enough.
• The invention must show novelty and inventive skill.

Q.2 World Trade Organization (WTO)

Introduction
International trade plays an important role in the economic development of countries. Different
nations exchange goods and services to improve business, employment, technology, and economic
growth. To regulate and promote smooth international trade, an international organization called the
World Trade Organization (WTO) was established.
The WTO is the most important international body dealing with global trade rules between nations.
It provides a platform for member countries to negotiate trade agreements, settle disputes, and
encourage free and fair trade.
The WTO has greatly in uenced international commerce, intellectual property rights, agriculture,
and industrial development across the world.

Meaning of World Trade Organization

The World Trade Organization (WTO) is:
“An international organization that regulates and promotes international trade among member
countries.”
It establishes rules for trade between nations and ensures that trade ows smoothly, predictably, and
freely.

Establishment of WTO
The WTO was established on:
1 January 1995
It was created under the:
Marrakesh Agreement
The WTO replaced the earlier organization called:
General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade
Headquarters
The headquarters of the WTO is located at:
Geneva

Objectives of WTO
The main objectives of the WTO are:
1. To promote free international trade,
2. To reduce trade barriers and tariffs,
3. To encourage fair competition,
4. To settle trade disputes peacefully,
fl
fi
fl
 5. To improve economic development,
6. To raise living standards and employment,
7. To ensure proper use of world resources.

Functions of WTO

1. Administration of Trade Agreements

The WTO administers international trade agreements among member countries.

2. Forum for Trade Negotiations

It provides a platform where countries negotiate trade rules and agreements.

3. Settlement of Trade Disputes

The WTO helps member countries resolve trade disputes peacefully through its dispute settlement
mechanism.

4. Monitoring Trade Policies

The WTO reviews and monitors trade policies of member countries.

5. Technical Assistance and Training

The WTO provides assistance and training to developing countries regarding international trade
matters.

6. Cooperation with International Organizations

The WTO cooperates with organizations like:
• International Monetary Fund
• World Bank

Principles of WTO
The WTO works on certain important principles:

1. Most Favoured Nation (MFN)

Every member country must treat all WTO members equally in trade matters.

2. National Treatment
Imported goods should be treated equally with domestic goods after entering the market.

3. Free Trade
Trade barriers like tariffs and quotas should be reduced.

4. Predictability
Trade policies should be stable and transparent.

5. Fair Competition
Countries should avoid unfair trade practices.

WTO and Intellectual Property Rights

One of the important agreements under the WTO is:
TRIPS Agreement
The TRIPS Agreement provides minimum standards for protection of:
 • Patents,
• Copyright,
• Trademarks,
• Geographical indications,
• Industrial designs.
It made intellectual property protection stronger at the international level.

Structure of WTO
The WTO has the following structure:

1. Ministerial Conference
It is the highest decision-making body of the WTO.

2. General Council
It manages the day-to-day functioning of the WTO.

3. Dispute Settlement Body

It settles trade disputes among countries.

4. Trade Policy Review Body

It reviews trade policies of member nations.

Advantages of WTO
1. Promotes international trade,
2. Encourages economic growth,
3. Reduces trade restrictions,
4. Protects smaller countries through legal rules,
5. Encourages foreign investment,
6. Provides dispute settlement mechanism.

Disadvantages of WTO
1. Developing countries may face dif culties competing with developed nations.
2. Strong countries may dominate negotiations.
3. Local industries may suffer due to foreign competition.
4. Strict intellectual property rules may affect access to medicines.

Landmark Case Law / Dispute

India — Patent Protection for Pharmaceutical and Agricultural Chemical Products (1997)
Facts
The United States challenged India’s patent laws before the WTO.
The U.S. argued that India failed to provide proper patent protection for pharmaceutical and
agricultural chemical products as required under the TRIPS Agreement.

Judgment
The WTO Dispute Settlement Body held that India must comply with TRIPS obligations and
provide a proper mechanism for patent applications.
fi
 Q.3 Copyright Societies
Introduction
Copyright law protects the rights of authors, musicians, artists, lmmakers, singers, and other
creators. These creators earn income when their works are used by the public. However, it is
dif cult for every creator to individually manage licenses, collect fees, and protect their rights.
To solve this problem, the law allows the formation of Copyright Societies. These societies work
collectively on behalf of copyright owners and manage their rights ef ciently.
Copyright societies play an important role in:
• Granting licenses,
• Collecting royalties,
• Protecting copyright owners,
• Preventing unauthorized use of works.

Meaning of Copyright Society

A Copyright Society means:
“A registered collective organization formed for the purpose of administering and protecting the
rights of copyright owners.”
It acts as a representative body of authors and copyright owners.
The society:
• Issues licenses,
• Collects royalty,
• Distributes royalty among members,
• Takes action against infringement.

Legal Provision
Copyright societies are governed by:
Sections 33 to 36 of the Copyright Act 1957
The Act provides rules regarding:
• Registration,
• Functions,
• Management,
• Control of copyright societies.

Registration of Copyright Society

A copyright society must obtain registration from the Central Government.
Registration is granted when:
• The society represents copyright owners,
• It works for collective administration of rights,
• It satis es legal conditions.
Normally, one copyright society is registered for one class of works.

Functions of Copyright Societies

1. Granting Licenses
The society grants licenses to users on behalf of copyright owners.
Example:
Granting permission to play songs in hotels, radio stations, or events.

2. Collection of Royalty
The society collects royalty fees from users of copyrighted works.
fi
fi
fi
fi
3. Distribution of Royalty
Collected royalty is distributed among members according to usage of their works.

4. Protection of Copyright
The society protects members against unauthorized use and infringement.

5. Maintaining Records
It maintains records of:
• Members,
• Licenses,
• Royalty collections,
• Distribution details.

6. Promotion of Authors’ Interests

The society safeguards the economic interests of creators and artists.

Rights Managed by Copyright Societies

Copyright societies manage rights relating to:
• Literary works,
• Musical works,
• Sound recordings,
• Artistic works,
• Films,
• Performers’ rights.

Important Copyright Societies in India

1. Indian Performing Right Society (IPRS)

It manages rights of:
• Lyricists,
• Composers,
• Music publishers.
It collects royalties for musical and literary works.

2. Phonographic Performance Limited (PPL)

It manages rights related to sound recordings and music labels.

3. Indian Reprographic Rights Organisation (IRRO)

It manages reprographic rights such as photocopying of literary works.

Duties of Copyright Society

A copyright society must:
• Act in the interest of members,
• Maintain transparency,
• Publish tariff schemes,
• Keep proper accounts,
• Distribute royalties fairly.
 Cancellation of Registration
The government may cancel registration if:
• The society violates legal provisions,
• Acts against public interest,
• Misuses its powers.

Advantages of Copyright Societies

1. Simpli es licensing process,
2. Ensures royalty collection,
3. Protects creators’ rights,
4. Helps artists earn income,
5. Reduces infringement.

Landmark Case Law

Indian Performing Right Society Ltd. v. Eastern Indian Motion Pictures Association (1977)
Facts
The dispute arose regarding ownership of copyright in songs used in lms.
The question was whether composers and lyricists retained separate copyright after incorporation
into cinematograph lms.

Judgment
The Supreme Court held that:
• Producers generally become owners of copyright in lm songs unless there is a contract
stating otherwise.
• Copyright law must balance interests of producers and creators.

Q.4 Functions of Trademark

Introduction
A trademark is an important form of intellectual property used in business and trade. It may consist
of:
• Name,
• Logo,
• Symbol,
• Design,
• Word,
• Label,
• Colour combination.
A trademark helps consumers identify the goods or services of a particular company and
distinguishes them from others in the market.
In today’s competitive world, trademarks are very valuable because they protect the reputation and
goodwill of businesses. They also help consumers choose products easily.

Meaning of Trademark
A trademark means:
“A mark capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one person from those of others.”
Trademark protection in India is governed by:
Trade Marks Act 1999

Functions of Trademark
A trademark performs many important functions in trade and commerce.
fi
fi
fi
fi
 1. Identi cation Function
The main function of a trademark is to identify the source or origin of goods and services.
It helps consumers know:
• Who manufactured the product,
• Which company provides the service.
Example:
The “Nike” logo identi es products of Nike company.

2. Distinguishing Function
A trademark distinguishes one trader’s goods from another trader’s goods.
It helps consumers differentiate products available in the market.
Example:
Different soap brands can be identi ed through their trademarks.

3. Quality Assurance Function

Consumers associate trademarks with a particular standard and quality.
A trademark assures customers that the goods will maintain consistent quality.
Example:
People trust branded products because of previous experience.

4. Advertising Function
A trademark acts as an advertisement and marketing tool.
Famous trademarks attract customers and increase sales.
Example:
Well-known logos and brand names create customer attention.

5. Goodwill Function
A trademark helps build goodwill and reputation of a business.
Over time, customers develop trust and loyalty towards the trademark.
Example:
Popular brands gain commercial value due to goodwill.

6. Economic Function
A trademark increases the commercial value of a business.
It can be:
• Sold,
• Licensed,
• Franchised.
Thus, trademarks become valuable business assets.

7. Consumer Protection Function

A trademark protects consumers from confusion and deception.
It helps buyers purchase genuine products instead of fake or duplicate goods.

8. Competitive Function
Trademarks encourage fair competition among businesses.
Companies try to improve quality and reputation to attract consumers.

9. Communication Function
fi
fi
fi
A trademark communicates information regarding:
• Product identity,
• Reputation,
• Quality,
• Brand image.
Consumers recognize products quickly through trademarks.

10. Legal Protection Function

A registered trademark gives legal rights to the owner.
The owner can:
• Prevent unauthorized use,
• File infringement suits,
• Protect business identity.

Importance of Trademark
Trademarks are important because they:
• Protect business identity,
• Build customer trust,
• Promote sales,
• Prevent unfair competition,
• Protect goodwill and reputation.

Landmark Case Law

Cadila Health Care Ltd. v. Cadila Pharmaceuticals Ltd. (2001)
Facts
Two pharmaceutical companies used similar sounding trademarks:
• “Falcigo”
• “Falcitab”
for medicines used to treat malaria.

Judgment
The Supreme Court held that:
• Similar trademarks may confuse consumers,
• In medicine-related products, confusion can be dangerous,
• Trademark law protects public interest and business goodwill.

Q.5 Different Types of Trademarks

Introduction
A trademark is an important form of intellectual property that helps identify and distinguish the
goods or services of one business from those of another. In the modern business world, trademarks
play a major role in building goodwill, reputation, and customer trust.
A trademark may consist of:
• Name,
• Word,
• Symbol,
• Logo,
• Shape,
• Colour,
• Sound,
 • Packaging.
Different businesses use different kinds of trademarks depending upon the nature of their products
and services.
Trademark protection in India is governed by:
Trade Marks Act 1999

Meaning of Trademark
A trademark means:
“A mark capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one person from those of others.”
It helps consumers identify the origin and quality of products.

Different Types of Trademarks

1. Product Mark
A product mark is used for identifying goods or products manufactured by a company.
It helps distinguish one company’s goods from another’s goods.
Example:
A trademark used on shoes, clothes, soaps, or electronics.
Purpose:
To identify the source of products.

2. Service Mark
A service mark is used to identify services instead of physical goods.
It distinguishes services provided by one business from another.
Example:
Banking, insurance, hotel, or transport services.
Symbol:
Generally represented by “SM”.

3. Word Mark
A word mark consists of:
• Words,
• Letters,
• Numbers,
• Names.
Protection is given to the word itself irrespective of style or design.
Example:
Brand names like company names or product names.
4. Device Mark / Logo Mark
A device mark includes:
• Logos,
• Symbols,
• Designs,
• Artistic features.
Protection is granted to the visual appearance of the mark.
Example:
Company logos and symbols.

5. Collective Mark
A collective mark is used by members of an association or organization.
 It indicates that the goods or services belong to members of a particular group.
Example:
Marks used by trade associations.
Purpose:
To show membership and maintain standards.

6. Certi cation Mark

A certi cation mark shows that goods or services meet certain standards regarding:
• Quality,
• Origin,
• Material,
• Method of manufacture.
Example:
Marks certifying quality or safety standards.
Purpose:
To assure consumers about product quality.

7. Shape Mark
A shape mark protects the unique shape of goods or packaging.
The shape must be distinctive and capable of identifying the product.
Example:
Special bottle shapes or packaging designs.

8. Sound Mark
A sound mark protects a unique sound associated with goods or services.
Example:
Musical tunes or special sounds used in advertisements.
The sound must be distinctive and easily recognizable.

9. Colour Mark
A speci c colour or colour combination may be protected if it identi es a business.
Example:
Unique colour combinations used in branding and packaging.

10. Well-Known Trademark

A well-known trademark is a mark recognized by the general public and enjoying widespread
reputation.
Such marks receive higher legal protection.
Example:
Famous international or national brands.

11. Certi cation Trademark

This trademark certi es that products meet speci c standards of quality, safety, or origin.
Example:
Quality certi cation marks.

12. Non-Conventional Trademark

These are modern forms of trademarks such as:
• Smell marks,
• Motion marks,
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 • Gesture marks,
• Hologram marks.
They are less common but recognized in some cases.

Importance of Different Types of Trademarks

Different types of trademarks help:
• Identify products and services,
• Protect business reputation,
• Prevent consumer confusion,
• Promote fair competition,
• Increase commercial value.

Landmark Case Law

Yahoo! Inc. v. Akash Arora (1999)
Facts
The defendant used the domain name “[Link]” similar to Yahoo’s famous trademark.

Judgment
The Delhi High Court held that:
• Domain names are also protected like trademarks,
• Similar names can confuse internet users,
• Unauthorized use amounts to passing off.

Q.6 Permitted Use under Trademark Law

Introduction
A trademark is an important intellectual property right that gives exclusive rights to the owner to
use the mark in relation to goods or services. Normally, no person can use a registered trademark
without the permission of the owner.
However, trademark law allows certain authorized persons to use the trademark legally with the
consent of the registered proprietor. Such use is called permitted use.
Permitted use is important in modern business because trademark owners often allow others to use
their trademarks through:
• Licensing,
• Franchising,
• Business agreements.
This helps in expansion of business and commercial growth while maintaining the reputation of the
trademark.

Meaning of Permitted Use

Permitted use means:
“Use of a registered trademark by a person other than the registered proprietor with the permission
of the proprietor.”

The use must be:

• Lawful,
• Authorized,
• In accordance with the conditions imposed by the owner.
The person using the trademark is called a:
 • Registered user,
or
• Permitted user.

Legal Provision
Permitted use is governed by:
Section 2(1)(r) of the Trade Marks Act 1999
The Act recognizes use of a trademark by:
• Registered users,
• Authorized persons,
• Persons connected with the registered proprietor.

Essentials of Permitted Use

The following conditions are necessary:
1. The trademark must be registered.
2. Use must be authorized by the registered proprietor.
3. Use must comply with the agreement or conditions.
4. The proprietor must exercise control over the use of the mark.

Types of Permitted Use

1. Registered User
A registered user is a person whose name is entered in the trademark register as an authorized user.
The registered proprietor allows such person to use the trademark under certain conditions.
Example:
A company allowing another manufacturer to use its trademark under license.

2. Licensed Use
The owner may grant a license permitting another person to use the trademark.
The license agreement generally speci es:
• Duration,
• Territory,
• Nature of use,
• Quality standards.

3. Franchise Use
In franchise business systems, franchisees are permitted to use:
• Trademark,
• Business model,
• Trade name,
• Logo.
Example:
Restaurant and hotel franchises.

Rights of Registered User

A registered user may:
• Use the trademark legally,
• Enjoy protection under law,
• File infringement proceedings in certain situations.
However, ownership remains with the registered proprietor.
fi
 Restrictions on Permitted Use
Permitted use must not:
• Mislead consumers,
• Damage the reputation of the trademark,
• Violate conditions of authorization.
If misuse occurs, permission may be withdrawn.

Importance of Permitted Use

Permitted use is important because it:
• Helps business expansion,
• Promotes franchising and licensing,
• Increases commercial value of trademarks,
• Maintains quality control,
• Encourages trade and investment.

Landmark Case Law

Cycle Corporation of India Ltd. v. T.I. Raleigh Industries Pvt. Ltd.
Facts
The dispute involved use of a trademark by an authorized user under business arrangements.
The issue was whether the use amounted to valid permitted use under trademark law.

Judgment
The court held that:
• Use by an authorized person with the consent of the proprietor amounts to permitted use.
• Such use bene ts the proprietor and maintains trademark rights.

Q.7 Budapest Treaty

Introduction
In patent law, inventions relating to microorganisms are very important in elds such as:
• Biotechnology,
• Medicine,
• Agriculture,
• Pharmaceuticals.
For obtaining a patent relating to microorganisms, the inventor must disclose the invention properly.
However, microorganisms cannot always be fully described in written form. Therefore, it becomes
necessary to deposit the microorganism in a recognized scienti c institution.
To solve this problem at the international level, the Budapest Treaty was adopted. The treaty
simpli es the procedure for patent applications involving microorganisms by allowing a single
international deposit.
The Budapest Treaty plays an important role in promoting scienti c research and international
patent protection in biotechnology.

Meaning of Budapest Treaty

The Budapest Treaty is:
“An international treaty that provides for the recognition of the deposit of microorganisms for
patent procedure.”
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 Under this treaty, depositing a microorganism in one recognized international depository authority
is suf cient for patent purposes in all member countries.

Adoption and Enforcement

The treaty was adopted on:
Budapest Treaty on the International Recognition of the Deposit of Microorganisms for the
Purposes of Patent Procedure
• Adopted in: 1977
• Came into force in: 1980

Administered By
The treaty is administered by:
World Intellectual Property Organization

Objective of the Budapest Treaty

The main objectives are:
1. To simplify patent procedures relating to microorganisms,
2. To avoid multiple deposits in different countries,
3. To reduce costs and dif culties for inventors,
4. To promote biotechnology inventions,
5. To provide international recognition of microorganism deposits.

Need for the Budapest Treaty

Microorganisms:
• Cannot always be properly explained in writing,
• Need scienti c preservation,
• Must be available for examination.
Before the treaty:
• Inventors had to deposit microorganisms separately in every country where patent protection
was sought.
The treaty solved this problem by allowing:
One deposit with an International Depository Authority (IDA).

International Depository Authority (IDA)

An IDA is a scienti c institution recognized under the treaty to:
• Receive,
• Store,
• Preserve microorganisms.
The deposited microorganism is accepted by all member countries.

Functions of IDA
The IDA:
1. Accepts microorganism deposits,
2. Stores and preserves samples,
3. Issues receipts and reports,
4. Supplies samples to entitled persons.

Procedure under the Budapest Treaty

Step 1 – Deposit of Microorganism

fi
fi
fi
fi
 The inventor deposits the microorganism with an International Depository Authority.

Step 2 – Receipt Issued

The IDA issues an of cial receipt con rming the deposit.

Step 3 – Patent Application

The inventor les the patent application mentioning:
• Deposit number,
• Name of IDA,
• Details of microorganism.

Step 4 – International Recognition

The deposit is recognized by all member countries of the treaty.

Advantages of the Budapest Treaty

1. Single Deposit System

Only one deposit is needed for all member countries.

2. Reduction of Costs
Inventors save money and time.

3. Simpli ed Patent Procedure

Patent applications become easier and more ef cient.

4. Promotion of Biotechnology
The treaty encourages innovation in biotechnology and pharmaceuticals.

5. International Recognition
Deposits are accepted internationally.

India and Budapest Treaty

India became a member of the Budapest Treaty in:
2001
India recognizes microorganism deposits under the treaty for patent purposes.

Importance in Patent Law

The treaty is important because it:
• Facilitates patent protection for microorganisms,
• Encourages scienti c innovation,
• Promotes international cooperation,
• Supports biotechnology industries.

Landmark Case Law

Dimminaco AG v. Controller of Patents and Designs (2002)
Facts
The patent application involved a process for preparing a vaccine containing living microorganisms.
The Patent Of ce rejected the application arguing that living organisms were not patentable.
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
Judgment
The Calcutta High Court held that:
• A process involving living microorganisms may be patentable,
• Biotechnology inventions deserve protection if legal requirements are satis ed.

Q.8 Remedies for Infringement of Trademark

Introduction
A trademark is an important intellectual property right that helps identify and distinguish the goods
or services of one business from another. It protects the goodwill and reputation of businesses and
helps consumers identify genuine products.
When a person uses a registered trademark without permission or uses a deceptively similar mark, it
amounts to trademark infringement. Trademark infringement causes:
• Loss of reputation,
• Customer confusion,
• Financial loss,
• Unfair competition.
To protect trademark owners, the law provides various remedies against infringement.

Meaning of Trademark Infringement

Trademark infringement means:
“Unauthorized use of a registered trademark or a deceptively similar mark in relation to goods or
services.”
It occurs when:
• The mark is identical or similar,
• It creates confusion among consumers,
• It affects the rights of the trademark owner.

Legal Provision
Trademark infringement and remedies are governed by:
Trade Marks Act 1999
The Act provides:
• Civil remedies,
• Criminal remedies,
• Administrative remedies.

Types of Remedies for Trademark Infringement

1. Civil Remedies
Civil remedies are granted by civil courts to protect the rights of the trademark owner.

(a) Injunction
An injunction is the most important remedy in trademark cases.
It is a court order restraining the defendant from using the infringing trademark.
Types of Injunction
i. Temporary or Interim Injunction
fi
Granted during the pendency of the case to prevent immediate harm.

ii. Permanent Injunction

Granted after nal decision of the court permanently restraining the infringer.

iii. Anton Piller Order

The court allows search and seizure of infringing goods and documents.

iv. Mareva Injunction

The court freezes the defendant’s assets to prevent disposal of property.

(b) Damages
The court may award monetary compensation to the plaintiff for losses suffered due to
infringement.
Purpose:
• To compensate nancial loss,
• To protect business reputation.

(c) Account of Pro ts

The defendant may be ordered to hand over pro ts earned through unauthorized use of the
trademark.

(d) Delivery Up and Destruction

The court may order:
• Seizure,
• Delivery,
• Destruction,
of infringing labels, packaging, and goods.

2. Criminal Remedies
Trademark infringement may also result in criminal liability.
Punishment may include:
• Imprisonment,
• Fine,
• Seizure of goods.
These remedies prevent counterfeiting and fraud.

3. Administrative Remedies
The trademark owner may request:
• Removal of infringing marks,
• Customs action against counterfeit goods,
• Cancellation of fraudulent registration.

Passing Off Remedy

Even if a trademark is unregistered, the owner may le a passing off action to protect goodwill and
reputation.

Essential Conditions for Granting Remedies

The plaintiff must prove:
1. Ownership of trademark,
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 2. Unauthorized use by defendant,
3. Likelihood of confusion,
4. Loss or damage.

Importance of Remedies
Trademark remedies are important because they:
• Protect business goodwill,
• Prevent consumer confusion,
• Stop unfair competition,
• Protect economic interests,
• Encourage honest trade practices.

Landmark Case Law

Midas Hygiene Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. Sudhir Bhatia (2004)
Facts
The defendant used a trademark deceptively similar to the plaintiff’s registered trademark for
similar products.
The plaintiff led a suit seeking injunction against trademark infringement.

Judgment
The Supreme Court held that:
• In cases of trademark infringement, injunction should normally be granted immediately.
• Delay in ling the suit is not a suf cient reason to refuse injunction if infringement is clearly
proved.
The Court granted injunction in favour of the plaintiff.

Conclusion
Trademark infringement affects the goodwill, reputation, and commercial value of businesses.
Therefore, the law provides various remedies such as injunctions, damages, account of pro ts,
criminal punishment, and destruction of infringing goods.
The remedies under the Trade Marks Act 1999 help protect trademark owners and consumers from
deception and unfair competition. The case of Midas Hygiene Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. Sudhir Bhatia
strengthened the protection of trademark rights in India.

Q.9 Compulsory Licensing of Patent

Introduction
A patent gives exclusive rights to the inventor to make, use, sell, or distribute an invention for a
limited period. The main purpose of patent law is to encourage innovation and scienti c
development.
However, patent rights should not be misused against public interest. Sometimes patent holders:
• Charge very high prices,
• Fail to manufacture the product,
• Do not make the invention available to the public.
In such situations, the law allows the government or other persons to use the patented invention
without the permission of the patent holder through a system called Compulsory Licensing.
Compulsory licensing balances:
fi
fi
fi
fi
fi
 • Rights of inventors,
and
• Public interest.

Meaning of Compulsory Licensing

Compulsory licensing means:
“A license granted by the government or competent authority to a third party to use a patented
invention without the consent of the patent holder.”
The patent owner still remains the owner of the patent, but another person gets permission to use the
invention under certain conditions.

Legal Provision
Compulsory licensing in India is governed by:
Sections 84 to 92 of the Patents Act 1970
These provisions empower the Controller of Patents to grant compulsory licenses.

Objectives of Compulsory Licensing

The main objectives are:
1. To protect public interest,
2. To ensure availability of patented products,
3. To prevent abuse of patent monopoly,
4. To make products available at reasonable prices,
5. To encourage local manufacturing.

Grounds for Grant of Compulsory License

Under Section 84, compulsory license may be granted on the following grounds:

1. Reasonable Requirements of the Public Not Satis ed

If the patented invention is not available in suf cient quantity to the public.
Example:
Essential medicines not adequately supplied.

2. Non-Availability at Affordable Price

If the patented product is sold at excessively high prices making it inaccessible to the public.

3. Non-Working of Patent in India

If the patented invention is not manufactured or worked in India.

When Can Application Be Made?

An application for compulsory license can generally be made:
• After 3 years from the date of grant of patent.

Procedure for Obtaining Compulsory License

Step 1 – Filing Application

An interested person les an application before the Controller of Patents.

Step 2 – Grounds Must Be Proved

The applicant must prove:
• Public requirements are not met,
fi
fi
fi
 • Price is unreasonable,
• Patent is not worked in India.

Step 3 – Hearing
The Controller hears both parties.

Step 4 – Decision
If satis ed, the Controller grants compulsory license with terms and conditions.

Powers of Controller
The Controller may determine:
• Royalty amount,
• Duration of license,
• Conditions of use,
• Scope of license.

Special Compulsory Licenses

Under Section 92, compulsory licenses may be granted in situations such as:
• National emergency,
• Extreme urgency,
• Public health crisis.
Example:
Epidemics and life-saving medicines.

Rights of Patent Holder

Even after compulsory licensing:
• Ownership remains with the patent holder,
• The patentee receives reasonable royalty.

Advantages of Compulsory Licensing

1. Protects public health,
2. Ensures affordable medicines,
3. Prevents misuse of patent rights,
4. Promotes access to technology,
5. Encourages competition.

Disadvantages of Compulsory Licensing

1. May reduce pro ts of inventors,
2. May discourage investment in research,
3. Can create international trade disputes.

Landmark Case Law

Bayer Corporation v. Natco Pharma Ltd. (2012)
Facts
Bayer Corporation held a patent for a cancer medicine called “Nexavar”.
The medicine was extremely expensive and not affordable for most patients in India.
Natco Pharma Ltd. applied for compulsory license to manufacture a cheaper version.
fi
fi
Judgment
The Controller granted compulsory license to Natco Pharma because:
• The medicine was not reasonably affordable,
• Public requirements were not satis ed,
• The patent was not adequately worked in India.
Natco was allowed to sell the medicine at a much lower price while paying royalty to Bayer.

Q.10 Rights of Artistic Work Owner

Introduction
Artistic works are an important form of intellectual property and creativity. Artists spend time, skill,
and effort in creating original works such as paintings, drawings, sculptures, photographs, and
designs. Copyright law protects these creative expressions from unauthorized use.
The owner of copyright in an artistic work enjoys certain exclusive legal rights. These rights help
artists:
• Control the use of their work,
• Earn economic bene ts,
• Protect their reputation and creativity.
Protection of artistic works encourages creativity, culture, and artistic development in society.

Meaning of Artistic Work

Under copyright law, artistic work includes:
• Paintings,
• Drawings,
• Sculptures,
• Engravings,
• Photographs,
• Works of architecture,
• Artistic craftsmanship.
An artistic work need not possess high artistic quality to get copyright protection.

Legal Provision
Rights of the owner of artistic work are protected under:
Copyright Act 1957
Important provisions include:
• Section 14,
• Section 17,
• Section 57.

Meaning of Copyright Owner

The copyright owner is the person who has legal ownership over the artistic work.
Generally, the creator or artist is the rst owner unless the work is created:
• During employment,
• Under a contract,
• For valuable consideration.

Rights of Artistic Work Owner

1. Right of Reproduction
The owner has the exclusive right to reproduce or copy the artistic work in any form.
fi
fi
fi
Example:
Printing copies of a painting or photograph.

2. Right of Publication
The owner can publish the artistic work or authorize others to publish it.

3. Right of Communication to the Public

The owner may display or communicate the work to the public through:
• Internet,
• Television,
• Exhibitions,
• Social media.

4. Right of Adaptation
The owner can adapt the artistic work into another form.
Example:
Converting a drawing into a digital design.

5. Right of Distribution
The owner controls the sale, transfer, or distribution of copies of the work.

6. Right to License
The owner may grant permission to others to use the artistic work through licenses.
Example:
Allowing use of artwork in advertisements.

7. Right to Assign
The owner may transfer copyright ownership to another person through assignment.

8. Moral Rights
Under Section 57, the artist has moral rights such as:
(a) Right of Paternity
Right to claim authorship of the work.

(b) Right of Integrity

Right to prevent distortion, mutilation, or modi cation that harms the artist’s reputation.

9. Right to Seek Legal Remedies

The owner may le legal action against infringement and seek:
• Injunction,
• Damages,
• Destruction of infringing copies.

Duration of Copyright in Artistic Work

Copyright in artistic work generally lasts:
• During the lifetime of the author,
and
• 60 years after his death.

Infringement of Artistic Work

fi
fi
Infringement occurs when a person:
• Copies,
• Publishes,
• Sells,
• Displays,
the artistic work without permission of the owner.

Landmark Case Law

Amar Nath Sehgal v. Union of India (2005)
Facts
Amar Nath Sehgal created a mural for a government building.
The mural was later removed and damaged by government authorities without his permission.
The artist claimed violation of his moral rights.

Judgment
The Delhi High Court held that:
• Moral rights of artists must be protected,
• Destruction or mutilation of artistic work harms the reputation of the artist,
• The author has the right to preserve the integrity of the work.
Compensation was awarded to the artist.

Conclusion
The owner of an artistic work enjoys several economic and moral rights under the Copyright Act
1957. These rights allow the artist to control reproduction, publication, adaptation, and commercial
use of the work while also protecting the artist’s reputation and identity.
The case of Amar Nath Sehgal v. Union of India strengthened the protection of artistic and moral
rights in India. Therefore, copyright protection of artistic works plays a vital role in encouraging
creativity and preserving cultural heritage.