Mas. Ang. 783
Mas. Ang. 783
Title
Board of Examiners :
June, 2024
I
Dedications
A special feeling of gratitude to my dear parents, sisters, family, close friends, and binomial.
Tinhinane
To my beloved parents, sisters, brother, friends, binomial, and two cats. Your support has
Ilham
II
Acknowledgments
We would like to express our thanks to our supervisor Dr. Berbar Katia, for her
guidance, advice, patience, and feedback throughout the preparation of this dissertation. It
We are deeply thankful to Mr. Aouine, for his encouragement, support, and insightful
the University of Tizi-Ouzou for their collaboration. Without their participation, this
We extend our thanks to the board of examiners for their willingness to read and
examine this dissertation. Their feedback and insightful comments are essential to ensure the
Special thanks go to everyone who contributed and made our dissertation journey
memorable.
III
Abstract
The present study explored teachers’ and students’ views on the impact of self-belief on the
dissertation journey, taking the Department of English at the University of Tizi- Ouzou as a
case study. It aimed to investigate and understand the perspectives of both Master 2 students
and dissertation supervisors regarding the impact of self-belief on the dissertation journey,
using Bandura’s Reciprocal Determinism framework (1977) within his Social Cognitive
Theory as a theoretical foundation. It also attempted to identify the factors that contribute to
the development and maintenance of students’ self-belief during the dissertation process.
Moreover, it endeavoured to uncover the strategies students and teachers use to enhance self-
belief throughout this dissertation journey. To achieve these aims, a mixed- methods approach
was employed, combining both quantitative and qualitative methods of data collection and
analysis. To collect quantitative data, an online questionnaire was designed using Google
Forms and distributed to Master 2 students; the collected data were analyzed using descriptive
statistics. In addition, qualitative data were collected relying on interviews conducted face-to-
face and via email with teachers or dissertation supervisors, and analyzed using Qualitative
Content Analysis (QCA). The results revealed that self-belief has a significant positive impact
on Master 2 students during the preparation of their dissertations, highlighting various factors
influencing self-belief according to both students and teachers. Moreover, the findings
throughout the dissertation process. This study provided insights into how self-belief affects
Keywords: dissertation journey, self-belief, social cognitive theory, students’ and teachers’
views.
IV
List of Abbreviations
List of Tables
Table2. Factors Contributing to the Enhancement Self-belief during the Dissertation Journey
34
Journey 39
Journey 40
VI
List of Diagrams
Dissertation Completion 31
Dissertation Completion 32
Diagram12. Students’ Perception of the Impact of the Working Environment on Self- belief
Table of Contents
Dedications I
Acknowledgments II
Abstract III
List of Abbreviations IV
List of Diagrams V
List of Tables VI
General Introduction
Introduction 6
[Link]-belief 6
[Link] of Self-belief 6
I.1.2. Self-belief and the Related Constructs of Self-efficacy and Self- confidence 7
I.2.2.1. Motivation 10
I.2.2.2. Anxiety 11
I.2.2.5. Procrastination 12
Dissertation Journey 14
I.3. Previous Studies on the Impact of Self-belief and the related Constructs of
I.4.3.3. Behaviour 18
Conclusion 19
Introduction 21
[Link] 22
[Link] 23
[Link] Analysis 24
Conclusion 25
Introduction 26
Dissetation Journey 27
Journey 31
Conclusion 47
Introduction 49
[Link] of Students’ and Teachers’ Views Regarding the Impact of Self-belief on the
Dissertation Journey 49
IV.2 Discussion of the Factors Affecting Students’ Self-belief during the Dissertation
Journey 53
[Link] of the Strategies from Students and Teachers to Enhance Self-Belief During the
Dissertation Journey 58
Conclusion 61
XI
General Conclusion 63
References 66
Appendices
The dissertation is the last requirement for obtaining a master’s degree. It is one of the
most rewarding experiences a graduate student can have, but it is a challenging and
demanding process that requires students to be perseverant and resilient. Indeed, according to
Murray (2001), writing a dissertation “is a far bigger project than most students will ever have
undertaken before. It requires more independent study, more self-motivation” (p. 2). In
Self-belief refers to the confidence and faith that a person has in himself and his
abilities. This belief in one’s skills, knowledge, and potential is crucial for succeeding in
various aspects of life, especially in the academic context, providing students the push and
motivation they need to succeed. Moreover, self-belief helps students overcome self-doubt
and fear of failure, allowing them to fully engage with their academic work. It helps to
navigate through the ups and down of the academic journey and stay focused on their goals.
Murray (2006) states that “if you are confident about something you don’t worry about its
outcomes; you just take for granted that it will go well” (p.53). A strong sense of self-belief
often leads to higher level of self efficacy, which is vital in educational endeavours. In his
book Self-efficacy: The Exercise of Control, Albert Bandura (1997) brought attention to the
with high self efficacy tend to approach challenges with confidence, persistence, and a belief
in their abilities to succeed. Overall, self-belief is the key element for a successful academic
career.
Some studies have investigated the role of self belief in the academic context. One of
these studies Students’ Self-confidence during the COVID-19 Pandemic: The Case of Third-
year EFL Students in the Department of English at Mouloud Mammeri University of Tizi-
Ouzou which was conducted by Farid Bouhadad and Nawal Oukaci in 2022. The study
2
examined teachers’ and students’ perceptions of the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on
students’ self-confidence. The findings revealed that the pandemic did not impact students’
self-confidence, implying that their confidence levels remained constant prior to the pandemic
outbreak.
In the context of writing dissertations, Asma Arab and Fatna Abdelmalek (2018)
delved into Master 2 students’ anxiety in the preparation of their dissertations at Tlemcen
University, Students’ Anxiety in the Preparation of their Dissertation: Case of EFL Master II
Students at Tlemcen University. According to the findings, the majority of Master 2 students
experienced a certain level of anxiety. Various factors, such as lack of knowledge, lack of
confidence, fear of failure, time constraints, and discussion with supervisors, contributed to
Previous research primarily focused on other psychological factors, like anxiety, that
could affect the dissertation journey or just investigated self-belief in other areas of research.
However, to our knowledge, no research has studied the impact of students’ self-belief on the
dissertation journey. EFL Master 2 students at the University of Tizi-Ouzou conduct research
and write a dissertation as a prerequisite for a master’s degree. This journey is challenging,
requiring students to manage their time and remain motivated and confident. The importance
helping and guiding students during their dissertation journey, there is a lack of research on
their perceptions of the role and impact of self-belief on the dissertation process. Therefore,
the main issue of this study is the necessity of exploring teachers’ and Master 2 students’
This study aims to investigate and understand the views of both EFL Master 2 students
and teachers (supervisors) regarding the impact of self-belief on the dissertation journey,
using Banduras’ Social Cognitive Theory as a theoretical foundation. More specifically, the
study strives to determine how teachers and Master 2 students in the Department of English at
the University of Tizi-Ouzou view the role and impact of self-belief on the dissertation
journey. In addition, it attempts to identify the factors that contribute to the development and
reveal the strategies students and teachers use to enhance self-belief throughout this journey.
This study is worth investigating since it examines how self-belief impacts the
dissertation journey and strives to understand how both students and teachers view this
influence. Moreover, it provides insights into the elements that lead to a successful
dissertation which is an advance to the field of education. This research can also inform
To achieve the stated objectives, the following research questions need to be answered:
1. How do teachers and master 2 students in the Department of English at the University of
3. What strategies do teachers and Master 2 students use to enhance self-belief during the
dissertation journey?
1. Teachers and Master 2 students in the Department of English at the University of Tizi-
contribute to the development and maintenance of students’ self-belief during the dissertation
journey.
3. Teachers and Master 2 students use strategies, such as seeking and providing frequent and
constructive feedback, setting achievable goals, time management, and positive self-talk, to
In order to reach the above-mentioned objectives, answer the research questions, and
test the study hypotheses, a mixed-method approach that combines quantitative and
qualitative methods of data collection and analysis is used. Quantitative data are collected
Department of English at the University of Tizi-Ouzou, whereas qualitative data are gathered
using face-to-face and email interviews conducted with eight teachers who have experience
supervising master’s dissertations. The quantitative data are analyzed using descriptive
statistics, such as percentages, and presented in diagrams and tables. The qualitative data are
analyzed using Qualitative Content Analysis (QCA), allowing for the identification of key
The dissertation is structured following the traditional simple model, with four main
general introduction that provides an overview of the topic and includes the statement of the
problem, aims and significance of the study, research questions and hypotheses, research
techniques and methodology, and the structure of the dissertation. The first chapter, labelled
‘Review of the Literature’, is theoretical in nature. It identifies the key concepts related to our
research and presents the theoretical framework of the study. The second chapter is concerned
5
with the ‘Research Design and Methodology’; it provides information about the procedures of
data collection and data analysis. The third chapter, ‘Presentation of the Findings’, presents
the results of the study, and includes the analysis of data gathered via questionnaire and
interview. The last chapter, ‘Discussion of the Findings’, is a discussion and interpretation of
the results. The dissertation ends with a general conclusion that summarizes the main study
findings, highlights the main limitations of the study, and suggests new areas for research.
The dissertation is structured and formatted following APA style dissertation guidelines,
Introduction
This chapter is concerned with the review of the literature related to this research. It is
divided into four sections. The first section defines self-belief, differentiates it from the
in the language learning process, and clarifies the relationship between self-belief and
academic performance. The second section is concerned with self-belief in the dissertation
journey. The third section deals with the review of the literature about the impact of self-
belief and the related constructs of self-confidence and self-efficacy on students’ learning.
Finally, the fourth section is devoted to the theoretical framework of the research, which is
I.1. Self-belief
[Link] of Self-belief
from a motivational point of view is student self-belief” (p. 61). They defined self-belief as
the conviction that an individual has in his/her own capacities and attributes, both personally
and academically. Self-belief is the conviction in one’s own abilities; it is the belief that a
person has enough knowledge and possesses the necessary skills to achieve goals. It is the
trust individuals have in themselves; it plays a vital role in their success in general. In the
educational context, Brown (2001) says that “at the heart of all learning is a person’s belief in
his or her ability to accomplish the task” (p.61). Self-belief is one of the key elements that
play a vital role in academic pursuit and empowers students to trust their full potential and
overcome obstacles during their educational journey and achieve success. When students
believe in their ability to accomplish a task, they develop the capability to perform it
effectively.
7
Self-belief, self-efficacy, and self-confidence are related concepts; however, they have
different meanings. Self-belief refers to the core or fundamental belief in one’s capacities to
succeed in general. For instance, an individual with a strong self-belief has a strong
(1994) states: “perceived self-efficacy comes from the trust in one’s capacity to accomplish
the required courses of action to manage different life situations” (p.2). Self-efficacy depends
on the task or context, which means an individual can show high self-efficacy in their ability
in a specific domain or activity while showing low self-efficacy in another. Indeed, as stated
refers to beliefs that are much more specific and situational judgments of capabilities”
(p.121).
Self-confidence is the trust in one’s ability to succeed. Malureanu et al. (2021) define
without leaning on others and to have constructive self-evolution” (p.3). In summary, we can
say that self-confidence is a boader concept that includes both self-belief and self-efficacy.
That is to say, self-belief and self-efficacy are specific concepts that contribute to the overall
self-confidence.
component in learning. Someone who doubts his/her capability or ability may not succeed in
accomplishing a given task” (p.288). In the process of language learning, self-belief plays an
important role. It can contribute to students’ progress and success. To master a new language,
a strong belief in one’s abilities can serve as a powerful motivator and can have a positive
8
impact on students’ language learning journey. When it comes to learning a new language,
self-belief helps students face various difficulties. Moreover, it provides learners with the
strength and motivation needed to push through the ups and downs of the academic journey,
enabling them to stay determined and engaged. Indeed, Akbari and Sahibzada (2020) found
that students who believe in themselves tend to be more active participants in class, enjoy the
learning process, do not stress too much about tests, feel more comfortable with their teachers
and classmates, and are not shy about sharing their opinions. The researchers also found that
low self-belief can lead to fear, timidity, and reluctance to express opinions. Furthermore,
self-belief helps students overcome the fear of making mistakes and motivates them to
embrace the idea that mistakes are essential when learning a new language.
predicting academic success” (p.59). Indeed, research has shown a positive connection
Purkey (1970), research has revealed a definite relationship between a student’s achievement
in school subjects and his/her level of self-concept. Students with high levels of self-belief
tend to have high grades and perform better in exams. On the other hand, students with low
self- belief may doubt their abilities, feel anxious about their performance, and may be more
likely to give up when faced with difficulties. Wiggins et al. (1994). The connection between
Self-belief plays a big role in how well students do in school. Students who believe in
themselves and their abilities tend to do better academically compared to those who doubt
themselves. This is because self-belief affects many aspects of a student’s academic journey,
like their motivation, determination, ability to set goals, and their overall attitude towards
learning. For instance, motivation, which is an important element in the academic journey,
9
depends on the belief students have in their capabilities and capacities. Additionally, self-
belief helps students set goals that push their boundaries as it enables them to tackle different
academic tasks effectively. Finally, it impacts resilience and persistence. For example,
students who have a high sense of self-belief view failure as an opportunity to start over with
new techniques and effectively persist in their efforts. All these combined components of self-
belief impact students positively during their academic journey. In a study by Iqbal Bhat
(2022) about the impact of self-confidence on students academic achievements, he argued that
positive way, as it affects their way of planning, anticipating and the outcomes.
academic journey. Students have to complete and submit their dissertations within a limited
time. To overcome the encountered challenges, students need to have a strong sense of self-
belief. As stated by Bandura (1977a), the belief in one’s own capacities to perform
successfully can help a person to achieve his/her goals. Therefore, we can say that self-belief
is a key factor that plays a crucial role during the dissertation process, from selecting a
Zhao et al. (2021) assert that “Students who are confident in their academic abilities
will put more effort into academic tasks, while those who lack self-confidence will be less
engaged in their studies and are more likely to give up.” (p. 2). In the context of master’s
dissertations, a strong sense of self-belief can provide students with the motivation needed to
avoid fear of failure, self-doubt, and obstacles in general. Moreover, self-belief can cultivate
resilience, empowering students to overcome obstacles and helping them stay focused during
the complexities and difficulties of the dissertation journey. On the contrary and based on
10
what is said by Zhao et al. (2021), students who do not believe in themselves
andtheiracademic abilities will put less effort, become less engaged in their dissertation
I.2.2.1. Motivation
The first factor that can influence self-belief is motivation. Schunk et al. (2014) state
that “motivation is the process whereby goal-directed activities are investigated and
combination of effort plus desire to achieve a goal plus favourable attitudes towards the goal
helps students keep a positive mindset and acts as a push to overcome challenges, which in
turn enhance their self-belief. Self-belief is closely related to motivation (Pintrich& Schunk,
2002). In the context of master’s dissertations, motivation plays a vital part in enhancing
challenging journey. The dissertation journey can be lengthy and demanding, and motivation
keeps students focused, committed, and engaged in this process, reinforcing their beliefs in
their abilities.
I.2.2.2. Anxiety
Anxiety can impact students’ self-belief during the dissertation journey. Anxiety can
be situation-specific, which means being anxious in a particular situation, for instance, while
High anxiety levels can negatively affect students’ self-belief during this challenging
performance. Therefore, students with high level of anxiety show a low level of academic
achievement.” (p.32).During the dissertation journey, students can experience high anxiety
due to time constraints and pressure, leading to self-doubt. Managing anxiety is crucial to
manage their time effectively. According to Kenneth (2001), “time management is a set of
principles, practices, skills, tools, and systems that help us use time to accomplish what we
want” (p. 2). When students have limited time to complete their dissertations, they become
anxious about the deadlines and doubt themselves. That is why managing time effectively
throughout the dissertation journey is important; it helps students avoid pressure and to finish
their work on time. In addition, effective time management is important for organizing and
planning the dissertation writing process. By dividing the work into smaller and more
achievable parts, students can foster their self-belief and tackle the dissertation journey with
confidence, knowing that they have a plan to guide them throughout the process.
Feedback and support play a crucial role in shaping an individual’s self-belief during
“proper feedback assists students in realising their full potential at various training
levels, increases their knowledge of their strengths and possible growth areas, and
In the context of master’s dissertations, supervisors’ constructive feedback can help students
improve their work, reinforcing their belief in their abilities. In addition, receiving support
from family friends and supervisor can enhance students’ self-belief. Schwenger (2016)
12
asserts that “appropriate support at every level is essential for students to acquire literacy
competencies and scaffold learning” (p. 73). This support can be reassuring, especially during
the dissertation process. Knowing that there is someone out there to offer assistance,
encouragement, and advice can significantly strengthen students’ belief in their ability to
I.2.2.5. Procrastination
journey, procrastination can have a detrimental impact on students’ self-belief. Reska and
Taufik (2019) assert that “One of the factors that influence academic procrastination is self-
confidence and academic procrastination.” (p. 1). Procrastination often stems from self-doubt
and fear of failure. Students may delay starting their research, writing, or seeking feedback
The dissertation process requires students to possess good writing skills. This writing
journey can be challenging because students have to convey complex ideas, summarize
existing research, bring new contributions to their field, and follow academic standards, all
this within a limited timeline. Indeed, according to tardy (2010), students are required to
select, evaluate, report, summarize, paraphrase, conclude, argue, select words and
Building self-belief starts from the person himself that is why students need to use
strategies to foster their self-belief during the dissertation process. One of the most effective
strategies students can use is to set clear and attainable goals. More specifically, students can
build their self-belief by dividing the dissertation process into manageable tasks and set
13
achievable goals. Indeed, Bandura (1997) states that setting realistic goals can enhance self-
belief. In addition, they can use time-management strategies. According to Arumugam et al.
(2021), time management refers to the “behaviours that aim to achieve an effective use of
time while performing certain goal-directed activities.” (p. 331). Managing time effectively
can help students stay focused and track their progress during the dissertation process.
belief and help students stay focused during the dissertation journey, by prioritizing tasks,
avoiding procrastination, and staying on track. Furthermore, seeking feedback and guidance
can boost students’ self-belief to tackle difficult tasks and remain motivated throughout the
dissertation journey. Positive or constructive feedback can boost self-belief (Ryan &Deci,
(Carver &Scheier, 1998). In order to develop and maintain self-belief, students should
stable psychological state by managing stress can lead to the enhancement of self-belief.
Stallman (2010) highlights the importance of identifying the levels of stress that may
contribute to students’ success, compared with the harmful levels of stress that ultimately lead
to poor academic performance or mental health issues. By using these strategies, students can
foster their self-belief and face challenges during the dissertation journey.
Dissertation Journey
to Mhunpiew (2013), “The success of a thesis or a dissertation for a graduate student relies
upon the roles of their supervisor.” (p. 119). Similarly, Barnes and Austin (2009) state that the
14
supervisor is “one of the most important persons if not the single most critical person” (p.
should offer constructive feedback and encourage students’ progress. Indeed, as stated by
Jensen and Austin (2017), regular constructive feedback can impact students’ confidence.
During the dissertation process, students may face various challenges or self-doubt, and a
supportive and caring supervisor can provide reassurance and foster self-belief. Barnes and
Austin (2009) suggest that supervisors should be supportive and caring by providing students
“with the emotional and psychological encouragement that they need to sustain them” (p.
305). In addition, creating a supportive environment and building positive relationships are
important because they encourage communication between supervisor and student, which is
I.3. Previous Studies on the Impact of Self-belief and the Related Constructs of Self-
Many studies have shed light on the impact of self-belief and the related constructs of
was conducted by Honicke and Broadbent (2016). This review summarizes 12 years of
and the factors that contribute to this relationship. The results showed that academic self-
Another study was conducted by Pajares and Schunk (2001), who investigated the
findings revealed that students with high levels of self-efficacy tend to set attainable goals and
show persistence when faced with difficulties, leading to better academic outcomes. In
addition, the results showed that positive beliefs are associated with higher academic
achievement. That is to say, students who perceive themselves as competent are more likely
to perform better.
foreign language at Fatma Nsoumer secondary school located in Amizour (Béjaia, Algeria),
Bensalem and Idri (2022) used a five-point Likert questionnaire to collect data from 289
learners. The research findings showed that ‘learners’ level of confidence in their writing
there is a gap in how it impacts the dissertation journey. The dissertation process is a unique
academic journey that requires students to maintain motivation, perseverance, and belief in
themselves and their capacities. However, little research has examined how self-belief
impacts students’ completion of their dissertations. Therefore, the present study aims to
address this gap by exploring teachers’ and Master 2 students’ views on the impact of self-
belief on the dissertation journey, taking the Department of English at the University of Tizi-
The social learning theory is based on the idea that learning occurs through imitation,
observation, and social interactions (Nabavi&Bijandi, 2011). This theory is derived from the
Bobo doll experiment conducted by Bandura in 1965, involving children aged between 42 and
71 months. The experiment aimed to investigate children’s behaviour and whether they
imitate people around them or not. To this end, Bandura’s study involved three groups of
16
children. The first group watched a video showing a model hitting the Bobo doll (aggressive
model group); the second group watched a video where a model did not show any aggressive
behaviour towards the doll (non-aggressive model group); and the third group served as a
control group, meaning that children did not watch any video and were not exposed to any
model behaviour related to the Bobo doll (Bandura, 1965). The results of the study showed
that the children who saw the aggressive behaviour were more likely to imitate the same
actions of hitting, kicking, and throwing the Bobo doll. Nabavi and Bijandi (2011) indicate
that “The children received no encouragement or incentives to beat up the doll; they were
simply imitating the behaviour they had observed.” (p. 8). In contrast, the children in the non-
aggressive model group and the control group showed less aggression towards the doll. This
investigation demonstrated that children can learn aggressive behaviour through observation
and imitation, which has implications for the formation of self-belief and the development of
In the 1980s, Bandura developed his social learning theory further, evolving it into
what is now known as social cognitive theory, which emphasizes the role of cognitive aspects
in learning and behaviour (Nabavi&Bijandi, 2011). That is to say, this theory focuses “on how
children and adults operate cognitively on their social experiences and how these cognitions
then influence behavior and development.” (Nabavi&Bijandi, 2011, p. 11). In his Social
environmental influences.
17
Learning Theory’ published in 1977. It consists of three reciprocal factors, which are
Personal, environmental, and behavioural; each one has an influence on the other in a
continuous manner. Bandura (1977b) explains that “the term reciprocal is used in the sense of
mutual action between events rather than in the narrower meaning of similar or opposite
counterreactions” (p. 194). The three factors interact to determine or cause one another.
Reciprocal determinism recognizes that individuals’ belief in their abilities has a significant
role in shaping the behaviour and the outcomes of the actions and how they perceive and
processes that help instigate and sustain motivational outcomes.”(p. 7). These personal
determinism, self-efficacy is a crucial personal factor (Schunk & DiBenedetto, 2019). For
instance, in the context of master’s dissertations, self-efficacy beliefs can help students
The environmental influences include not only the physical but also the social
environment (Devi et al., 2017). These influences refer to the external factors that impact the
behaviour of a person. For instance, the social environment includes “family members, friends
and colleagues”, while the physical environment refers to “the availability of certain foods”
(Devi et al., 2017, p. 722). In the context of master’s dissertations, the social environment can
involve the supervisor’s support and feedback and the academic learning environment,
18
whereas the physical environment can denote the availability of resources. In summary,
environmental influences are based on different factors that influence directly the individual’s
I.4.3.3. Behaviour
Behaviour refers to the different actions that individuals make as a response to their
environment; it is a dynamic and complex human process influenced by several factors such
as environment, social interaction, and learning. During the dissertation journey, students
exhibit actions and behaviours, such as actively seeking feedback, dedicating time to work on
each factor influences and is influenced by the others. It highlights the different factors that
shape the individual in general and the student specifically. Schunk and DiBenedetto (2019)
gave the following example to show how these three factors constantly influence each other:
Students who feel competent about performing well in mathematics (high self-
efficacy- personal) are apt to engage in activities that will help them learn, such as
remark to them how well they are learning (environmental), this remark may
(personal) and motivate them to continue to engage in productive behaviours. (p. 6).
In the context of master’s dissertations, students’ belief in their research and writing
lack of resources or feedback (environmental factor) may reduce students’ self-belief and
motivation (personal factor), negatively influencing their behaviours. Figure 1 shows the
p. 15)
Conclusion
This chapter has reviewed the literature related to the topic under investigation,
belief and the related constructs of self-confidence and self-efficacy, highlighted the
importance of self-belief in the process of language learning, and explained the relationship
between self-belief and academic performance. It has then discussed self-belief in the
dissertation journey, including its significance, influencing factors, and nurturing strategies.
Afterwards, it has reviewed past research on self-belief and related constructs with the aim to
locate the research gap. Finally, it has presented the theoretical framework of this research.
Introduction
This chapter is a description of the research design and methodology of the study. It
contains foursections. First, it presents the research method used in this study which is
amixed-method approach. Second, it provides information about the context of the study and
the sample population. The third sectionis dedicated to the research instruments used to
collect data, namely aquestionnaire and the teachers’ interview. The final part explains the
method research approach is essential to examine the attitudes of both students and teachers
regarding the impact of self-belief onthe dissertation journey. According to Creswell (2009),
the mixed-method approach is a research method that combines both qualitative and
quantitative techniques of data collection and analysis in one single study. Creswell and Clark
(2018) explain that this research approach is valuable because “by combining qualitative and
quantitative research methods, the Mixed Method allows researchers to gain a more
captured by a single method” (p.3). In other words, this strategy permits covering all the
aspects and givingmore insights about the study. By using a mixed-methodapproach, we can
gain a comprehensive understanding of how teachers and students view the impact of self-
belief on the dissertation journey that cannot be obtained by using a quantitative or qualitative
University of Tizi-ouzou (MMUTO). Two research instruments were used in the two phases
of the data collection process. This study targeted Master Two students who were working on
22
their dissertation and their supervisors. Ultimately, according to Pilot and Beck (2004),
sampling is “the process of selecting a portion of the population for a study to represent the
entire population.” (p.291). The study sample involved seventy-three EFL students and seven
questionnaire, sixty one were female and twelve were male. In addition, students from each
specialism responded to the questionnaire. Among them, twenty-seven students were from
Didactics of Foreign Languages, fifteen from Language and Communication, fourteen from
Literature and Interdisciplinary Approaches, eleven from Literature and Civilization, and six
and closed-ended questions from the questionnaire, and teachers answered the open-ended
questions from the [Link] the answerswerestudied carefully and treated with
anonymity.
To confirm or refute the validity of the hypotheses, data are gathered from different
sources through two research tools. The first tool is an onlinequestionnaire sent to master
2students, and the second research instrument is aninterview designedfor the teachersor
supervisors.
II.3.1. Questionnaire
The questionnaire comprised aset of questions addressed to master two students. Taherdoost
(2021) defines a questionnaire as “one of the common devices for collecting information and
a form or instrument including a set of questions and secure answers that respondents (from a
specific population) fill to give the researcher information needed for the study.” (p. 14).In
other words, a questionnaire is an important tool usedto gatherdata about a specific topic.
There are various ways to administer a questionnaire. It can be done face-to-face or in person,
via email, over the phone, or online (Taherdoost, 2021). In the present study, an online
23
questionnaire was designed using Google Forms, and the link was sent to the participants via
messenger groups of each speciality, students accessed the questionnaire via the
link[Link]
online questionnaire is a cost-efficient option; however, you should consider the possibility of
missing samples due to problems with internet access.” (p. 15). In other words, even though
online questionnaires are more affordable, there are chances of lost samples due to internet
connectivity issues.
foursections: Personal Information, Students’ Views on the Impact of Self-belief during the
Dissertation Journey, Factors Affecting Students’ Self-belief during the Dissertation Journey,
and Strategies to Enhance Students’ Self-belief during the dissertation Journey (See
Appendix A). The questionnaire included eighteen closed-ended questions and one open-
ended question. Closed-ended questions encompassed yes/no (Q4, Q6, Q8, and Q9), multiple
choices (Q1, Q2, Q3, Q5, Q7, Q10, Q11, Q17, and Q18), and scaled questions (Q12, Q13,
Q14, Q15, and Q16). On the other hand, the qualitative question (Q19) allowed participants to
provide their answers in their own words and to express themselves freely. More specifically,
the question was optional as it offered students the opportunity to provide additional
information they deemed relevant to the topic under study. The questionnaire was
II.3.2. Interview
Gillham (2000) “An interview is a conversation, usually between two people. But it is a
conversation where one person-the interviewer-is seeking response for a particular purpose
from the other person-in the interviewee.” (p. 1). In this study, both online and face-to-face
24
interviews were conducted to gather data since some teachers have a busy schedule and
cannot do it face to face. Fourteen teachers participated in the interviews; with eleven being
asynchronous online interviews consisting of twelve questions each. However, only four
Before administering the questionnaire and interview, both instruments were first
piloted with a small sample. According to In (2017), “A pilot study is the first step of the
entire research protocol and is often a smaller-sized study assisting in planning and
modification of the main study.” (p. 601). The piloting phase is an important stage because it
enables the researcher to locate any problems in the questionnaire or interview before
intendedmessage, a pilot test was conducted on May 2nd in the Department of English at the
University of Tizi-Ouzou with five master 2 students; one student from each specialism was
randomly [Link] feedback received was positive, indicating that the questionnaire is
well-structured and easy to understand. On the other hand, the interview questions were sent
to one teacher on May 2nd before starting the data collection, to ensure the clarity and
relevance of the questions. The feedback received was positive despite the need for slight
changes in the introduction to clarify the topic and avoid any confusion.
The collected data were analysed using both quantitative and qualitative data analysis
methods.
Quantitative analysis is the process of analyzing numerical data gathered from closed-
ended questions using descriptive statistics like frequencies and percentages in order to draw
in research by serving as a tool for designing studies, analyzing data, and deriving
conclusionsto examine and analyze the data obtained from the closed-ended questions in the
questionnaire, a quantitative data analysis was employed. It involves the use of statistical
techniques to interpret the collected data. During our analysis, the Google Forms software
helped us to process the gathered data and generated diagrams that summarized the main
findings.
The qualitative data gained from the open-ended questions were analyzed using
Qualitative Content Analysis. Scheier (2012) defines Qualitative Content Analysis (QCA) as
“a research method for the subjective interpretation of the content of text data through the
systematic classification process of coding and identifying themes or patterns” (p. 3). In other
words,QCA is the process of interpreting and analyzing the textual data gathered from open-
ended questions. It involves organizing and categorizing the content of those data to identify
the patterns and themes. In our study, the answers of each question of the interview was
mainly divided into two categories based on the similarity of responses provided by the
teachers, and by examining how often a category is mentioned, themes are identified.
Conclusion
This chapter has provided a comprehensive explanation of the research design and
methodology employed in the present study. In addition, it has provided details concerning
the sample population and the research instruments used to collect the relevant information to
answer the research questions and test the study hypotheses. Finally, it has explained the
Introduction
This chapter focuses on the practical part of the present study. It aims to present the
research findings about students’and teachers’ views regarding the impact of self-belief on the
dissertation journey. Itis divided into two parts. The firstpart reports the results of the online
questionnaire administered to Master 2 students, and the second part presents the findings
obtained from the interviews conducted with teachers or dissertation supervisors. To ensure
clarity, the quantitative results from the questionnaire are analyzed using percentages and
presented in pie charts, bar graphs, and [Link] the other hand, the qualitative findings from
the interviews are analyzed qualitatively using qualitative content analysis and presented in
textual form.
The first section of the questionnaire aims to gather general personal information
The first question aims to collect data about the gender of students. The results of this
Female Male
17%
83%
Diagram 1 displays the gender of the research participants. The results show that the
majority of the students are female with a percentage of 83%, while males represent a small
The second question asked the students to specify their area of study. The results are
exhibited in Diagram 2.
According to the findings presented inDiagram 2, 37% of the students are enrolled in
Foreign Languages Didactics, 20.5% are specializing in Language and Communication, 8.2%
in General and Comparative Literature, 15.1% in Literature and Civilization, and 19.2% in
IV.1.2. Section Two: Students’ Views on the Impact of Self-belief during the Dissertation
Journey
Question (03):How would you describe your overall experience working on your dissertation
so far?
28
This question aims to collect data about students’ overall experience working on their
master’s dissertations. The students are asked to rate their experience from ‘very bad’ to ‘very
70,00%
63%
60,00%
50,00% Very Bad
40,00% Bad
28.8%
30,00% Average
20,00% Good
10,00% 2.7% 4.1% 1.4% Very Good
0,00%
Very Bad Bad Average Good Very Good
experience working on their dissertations so [Link] findings reveal that 63% of students rated
their experience as average, 28.8% as good, 4.1% as bad, 2.7% as very bad, and 1.4% as very
good. This indicates that the majority of students found their dissertation experience to be
Question (04):Do you think that self-belief contributes to your academic success?
This yes/no question aims to collect data about students’ views regarding the role of
Yes No
100%
Diagram 4 shows the percentages of students who were asked if they think that self-
belief contributes to their academic success. All students affirmed that they perceive self-
while working on their dissertations. Students were asked to rate their level of self-belief from
70,00%
60.3%
60,00%
Very high
50,00%
High
40,00%
Average
30,00% 23.3% Low
20,00% Very low
8.2% 6.8%
10,00% Série 1
1.4%
0,00%
Very low Low Average High Very high
As shown in Diagram 5, the majority of the students, that is 60.3%, claimed to have an
average level of self-belief; 23.3% indicated a high level; 6.8% reported a very high level;
8.2% registered a low level; and 1.4% noted a very low level.
Question (06): Do you think that high levels of self-belief positively influence your progress
This yes/no question is asked to explore students’ perceptions regarding the impact of
self-belief on their progress during the process of completing their dissertations. By asking
this question, we seek to understand whether students attribute their progress during the
dissertation journey to their own levels of [Link] results are reported in Diagram 6.
30
Yes No
1%
99%
Diagram 6 reveals students’ opinions about the influence of having a strong belief
during the dissertation journey. Nearly all the students answered in the affirmative, while only
1 percent denied that high levels of self-belief do influence positively the dissertation writing.
Question (07): If the answer is yes, how much do you think that high levels of self-belief
This question asked the students who selected the ‘yes’ option in the previous question
to specify how much they think that high levels of self-belief influence their progress during
the dissertation process. Students had four options to select from: ‘slightly’, ‘moderately’,
70,00%
63.9%
60,00%
50,00%
Slightly
40,00%
Moderately
30,00%
Significantly
18.1%
20,00% 12.5% Extremely
10,00% 5.6%
0,00%
Slightly Moderately Significantly Extremely
Delving deeper into students’views on the impact of a high sense of self-beliefon their
progress during the dissertation journey, diagram7 shows a range of responses. The majority,
31
representing 63.9% of students, stated that high self-belief has a significant impact on their
dissertation progress. 18.1% admitted that self-belief plays an ‘extremely’ influential role.
slight influence.
Question (08): Do you think that maintaining high levels of self-belief positively influences
between self-belief and motivation. By asking this question, we aim to understand whether
students believe that maintaining high levels of self-belief contributes to their motivation and
Yes No
3%
97%
inDissertation Completion
Diagram 8 shows students’ responses about the impact of maintaining high levels of
students strongly believe that high self-belief positively affects their motivation and
IV.1.3. Section Three: Factors Affecting Students’ Self-belief during the Dissertation
Journey
This third section of the questionnaire aims to identify thevarious factors that can
Question (09):Have you faced any challenges that negatively impacted your self-belief
The aim of this question is to know whether students have faced any challenges that
negatively impacted their self-belief during the dissertation journey. The findings of this
Yes No
12%
88%
Diagram 9 shows students’ responses who were asked whether they have faced
challenges that negatively impacted their self-belief throughout their dissertation journey.
Most students (88%) said they faced difficulties that affected their self-belief. A smaller group
Question (10): If the answer is yes, what are the main challenges you faced? (Select all
thatapply)
The aim of this question is to identify and understand the main challenges that Master
2 face during their dissertation journey that negatively impact their self-belief, allowing them
Table 1
Challenge Percentage
Other 8.30%
and stress as the primary challenge they encountered that negatively impacted their self-belief
during their dissertation journey. Perfectionism and fear of failure are also common, as
the students, while writing challenges are reported by 26%. Procrastination was another issue,
affecting 27.4% of the students. Three students (8.3%) added specific issues to this list:
difficulties communicating with team members, lack of relevant sources, and challenges in
Question (11): In your view, what factors contribute to your self-belief during the
The aim of this question is to collect data about the factors that contribute to students’
self-belief during their dissertation journey. More specifically, it aims to understand the
various factors that play a role in shaping students’ self-belief in the dissertation process. The
Table 2
Factor Percentage
Other 1.40%
Table 2 shows the responses of students when requested to identify the factors that
contribute to the development of their self-belief throughout the dissertation journey. The
feedback and guidance provided by supervisors stand out as the most influential factor, with a
encouragement from supervisors, peers, and family members were deemed crucial by 60.3%
management (45.2%), and access to academic resources and research material (46.6%) were
identified as further boosters of self-belief. Furthermore, one student (1.4%) highlighted the
role of motivation.
Question (12): The feedback and guidance provided by my supervisor foster my self-belief in
This statement aims to assess students’ perceived impact of the feedback and guidance
provided by their supervisors on their self-belief during the dissertation journey. It seeks to
measure the extent to which students feel that their supervisors’ feedback and guidance
35
positively impact their self-belief during the dissertation process. Students’ answers to this
100%
89%
80%
60%
40%
20% 11%
0% 0%
Agree Neutral Disagree
Diagram 10 shows students’ thoughts on how feedback and guidance from their
the statement On the other hand, 11% are neutral and none disagreed with the statement. It is
The aim of this Likert question is to determine whether students think that the quality
of their relationship with their supervisor and research partner is important in maintaining
high levels of self-belief during the dissertation journey. Students’ responses to this question
120%
100%
100%
80%
60%
40%
20%
0%
Agree Neutral Disagree
relationship with their supervisor and research partner to maintain a strong sense of self-
[Link] students(100%) agreed that their relationship with their supervisor and research
partner is vital in maintaining high self-belief. As shown in Diagram 11, there are noresponses
60,00%
40,00%
20,00% 13.70%
8.20%
0,00%
Agree Neutral Disagree
Diagram 12. Students’ Perception of the Impact of the Working Environment on Self-
percentage of 13.7% expressed neutrality on this matter, while 8.2% disagreed with the
statement.
contribute to my self-belief.
This statement aims to uncover the extent to which students believe that investing
time, staying engaged, and persisting in working on their dissertations contribute to their self-
100%
89%
80%
60%
40%
20%
11%
0%
Agree Neutral Disagree
Diagram 13. Students’ Perception of the Impact of Time Dedication, Engagement, and
Diagram 13 shows that 89% of the respondents expressed agreement with this
statement, while 11% remained neutral on the topic, and none of them selected the option
‘disagree.’This means that the majority of the students believe that dedicating time to work on
Question (16):My skills in research methodology and writing abilities contribute to my self-
methodology skills and writing abilities on their self-belief during the dissertation process.
100,00% 93.20%
80,00%
60,00%
40,00%
20,00% 6.80%
0,00%
Agree Neutral Disagree
Diagram 14. Students’ Perception of the Impact of Research Methodology Skills and Writing
of their research methodology skills and writing abilities on their self-belief during the
dissertation process. The majority(93.2%) of the respondents expressed agreement with the
statement above, while 6.8% remained neutral. None of them disagreed with the statement.
IV.1.4. Section Four: Strategies to Enhance Students’ Self-belief during the Dissertation
Journey
Question (17): What strategies do you use to develop and maintain your self-belief
The aim of question 17 is to understand how students develop and maintain self-belief
while working on their dissertations. The results can provide insights into the methods they
use to foster their self-belief during the challenging process of completing their master’s
Table 3
Strategy Percentage
Other 1.40%
strategies to cultivate their self-belief. One crucial strategy is setting clear and achievable
goals, which is prioritized by 67.1% of students. Seeking support and feedback from
in positive self-talk to foster their confidence, while 32.9% celebrate small achievements
along the way. It is noteworthy to mention that 1.40% of the students have personalized
approaches, such as recognizing the importance of small progress and advocating a tireless
work ethic. Others emphasized the significance of surrounding themselves with positivity and
engaging in activities that bring them joy to maintain focus and confidence.
Question (18):In your opinion, how can supervisors and universities help students build and
maintain self-belief during the dissertation journey? (Select all that apply).
The question aims to find out how supervisors and universities can help students build
and maintain self-belief while working on their dissertations. The findings obtained from this
question can help supervisors and universities better understand how to assist students
effectively during their dissertation journey. The results are displayed in Table 4.
40
Table 4
Strategy Percentage
Other 2.80%
Table 4 shows that students expressed their clear views on how supervisors and
universities can assist them in building self-belief during the dissertation journey. A majority
of encouraging open discussions about self-belief. Besides, two students (2.8%) added two
suggestions, including the need for early intervention and ongoing mental supportand that
efforts to promote self-belief should begin at the earliest stages of academic pursuit.
Question (19): Feel free to add any additional insights about the role and impact of self-belief
When students were asked to add whatever they wanted, here are the additional
self-belief provides a basis for maintaining a positive mindset and overcoming challenges. In
defending their ideas, dealing with criticism, and ultimately completing their dissertations
constructive criticism from their supervisors and emphasized that self-belief should be
driving force, providing the motivation, confidence, and resilience needed to overcome
To gather additional information on the topic, interviews were conducted with teachers
Tizi-Ouzou. The interview process involved both email interviews and face-to-face interviews
with eight teachers. Initially, the interview questions were sent via email to eleven teachers,
but only four responded, indicating a low response rate. Additionally, face-to-face interviews
were conducted with three teachers. So, in total, interviews were carried outwith eight
teachers. Despite the small sample size, the insights gathered from these interviews offered
valuable information on the topic. The first three interview questions are designed to collect
The first question aims to identify the academic degree the interviewed teachers hold.
Four main categories emerged from the data. Four of them are PhD holders; three others have
Question (02): How long have you been teaching in the Department of English?
The second question asked the teachers how long they have been teaching in the
Department of English. Their responses provided valuable insights. Two of the teachers
mentioned having a teaching experience of more than 20 years, while the other teachers said
that they have been teaching for more than 10 years. This means that they are all experienced
teachers.
42
The third question from the interview asked teachers about how long they have been
supervising master’s dissertations. Two categories emerged: the first one contains teachers
with more than 10 years of experience, whereas the other category mentioned that they have
master’s dissertation?
Six out of eight teachers think that self-belief is crucial for students working on their
master’s dissertations. They asserted that confidence and self-assurance significantly impact
the success and quality of master’s dissertations. They emphasized the positive influence of
Self-belief is important in all endeavours and all fields. However, in the academic
domain where research work is dotted with obstacles, self-belief is the core ingredient
for success. Many students give up after a short period of time because they lack self-
should be viewed purely as an academic piece of work detached from the student’s personal
attributes. According to this teacher, the primary focus should be on the content and
framework of the dissertation rather than on the individual characteristics of the student. It is
worth-mentioning that one teacher (Teacher H) did not provide an answer to this question.
Question (05): From your perspective, what impact does self-belief have on students’ overall
success in completing their dissertations? Please describe observed instances where self-belief
students’ success in completing their dissertations, they all agreed that self-belief has a
43
significant impact on this journey. They asserted that students with a strong belief in
themselves tend to find the dissertation process easier, while those lacking self-belief face
dissertation journey because it makes them conduct their dissertation journey with
enthusiasm and confidence. Also, throughout the dissertation process, students can
meet various challenges, such as difficulty with research methods, data analysis, or
literature review. Those with self-belief are better equipped to face these challenges
because they view them as opportunities for growth rather than insurmountable
obstacles.
Only two teachers delved into the details of their observations and cited two cases.
Teacher B shared that a majority of master’s students who submitted their final dissertations
after 10 months of work lacked self-belief. According to this teacher, these students struggled
because they did not trust their own abilities; this lack of self-belief made their progress more
difficult and made the journey more challenging for them. In addition, teacher C provided an
example from his own experience. He described a student who faced numerous rejections
throughout his master’s research. Despite the obstacles, this student persevered and publicly
Question (06): According to you, how can external factors or environmental influences (such
as supervisor feedback and support, the academic environment, and access to academic and
research material) contribute to shaping students’ self-belief during the dissertation journey?
shaping students’ self-belief during the dissertation journey, teachers highlighted the
significance of the environment in which students work. For example, teacher A declared that
“Positive and constructive feedback from supervisors can help students feel more confident
44
by validating their efforts and progress. Thus, Students can develop confidence in themselves
when they have a supervisor who is encouraging and helpful”. Besides, teacher D draws
attention to the mixture of all these factors that should be present during the dissertation.
Question (07): In your opinion, how can students’ behaviour (such as managing time,
actively seeking feedback, and setting goals) shape their self-belief during the dissertation
journey?
When asked about the impact of students’ behaviour on their self-belief during the
dissertation journey, the interviewed teachers emphasized that students ‘behaviour can
significantly influence their self-belief and ultimately impact their overall success. They
highlighted the importance of having a clear outline or plan to facilitate the dissertation
journey. They emphasized the effectiveness of time management by saying that it allows
students to set realistic goals, adhere to deadlines, and divide their work into manageable
tasks. By accomplishing these smaller tasks, students gain a sense of accomplishment, which
boosts their confidence in their abilities. Teacher C believed that if students understand the
concepts well and have insights about the theoretical framework, they may not need to
actively ask for feedback. This point is mentioned in the following declaration: “Do not seek
Question (08):According to you, how can personal factors (such as resilience, determination,
research skills, and writing abilities) shape students’ self-belief during the dissertation
journey?
When asked about how personal factors, such as resilience, determination, research
skills, and writing abilities, can shape students’ self-belief during the dissertation journey, the
teachers provided insightful opinions. The majority emphasized that personal factors play a
crucial role in shaping students’ self-belief, contributing to their overall success. They
recognized that self-confidence cannot come out of nothing. They stressed the significance of
45
certain personal qualities, like good writing and research skills, in building confidence.
Students who are skilled at writing tend to have more confidence since effective written
communication is important for dissertations. For example, teacher A said that “Strong
written communication skills can have a significant influence on students’ self-belief. This
means that strong writing abilities give confidence in students, allowing them to express
themselves clearly and persuasively in their dissertations.” Likewise, students who have
strong research skills and a genuine interest in their topic are more likely to feel more
confident. This is explained in the following assertion “Research skills and strategies help a
lot in addition to their motivation that can add more persistence and overcome their
challenges and weaknesses”. In addition, the teachers emphasized the importance of resilience
and determination. These personal qualities enable students to persevere through challenges,
ultimately building their self-belief. By maintaining focus on the objective of completing their
master’s dissertations, students can reinforce their self-belief and remain motivated
Question (09): According to you, what are the common challenges students face in
developing and maintaining high levels of self-belief during the dissertation journey?
When asked about the common challenges students face in developing and
maintaining high levels of self-belief during the dissertation journey, the teachers provided
some insights. Teacher A highlighted that negative feedback can be discouraging for students
and may lead them to doubt their abilities. Constructive criticism and feedback are essential
for growth, but students may struggle to maintain their self-belief when faced with criticism.
In addition, teacher D mentioned that time constraints can pose a challenge; the pressure to
meet deadlines and the competitive nature of the journey can impact students’ self-belief.
Question (10): How do you foster self-belief in your students during the dissertation journey?
When asked about how they foster self-belief in their students during the dissertation
journey, the interviewed teachers shared various strategies. Teacher D suggested the use of
graduates. Teacher B provided an example of a sentence he uses with students: “Well done,
that’s much better than last time, you really thought about how to write an introduction, but
there are few problems with punctuations.” The teacher uses this sentence to foster self-belief
in students by giving positive feedback even when the submitted work is not satisfactory.
Setting deadlines and explaining their purpose was another strategy mentioned by teacher F.
Teacher E said that she just let them be themselves knowing that they have different
personalities and different learning styles. She however tries to motivate them and make the
the idea that students are capable of completing the dissertation by reminding them that others
before them have accomplished this task. Finally, teacher A offers guidance and support and
equips students with the required tools and knowledge. It has to be noted that two teachers (C
Question (11): What advice would you give to supervisors and educational institutions to
help students build and maintain a high sense of self-belief throughout the dissertation
process?
When teachers were asked this question, they provided valuable insights. Their
suggestions offer guidance on how supervisors and educational institutions can support
students in developing and sustaining self-belief during the dissertation journey. Teacher A
importance to the psychological aspect of the learner. Moreover, Teacher E stressed the
47
Furthermore, Teacher G claimed that recognizing self-belief should be nurtured even before
the dissertation journey begins and noted the significance of not breaking students’ spirits and
that supervisors and educational institutions should avoid actions or behaviours that
undermine students’ confidence and motivation. Instead, they should strive to uplift and
encourage students throughout the dissertation process. One teacher did not provide an answer
Question (12): Is there anything else you would like to add about the impact of self-belief on
psychological support, and effective supervision in fostering self-belief during the dissertation
challenges. Teacher F stressed the significance of not neglecting the psychological aspect of
the dissertation process because students need support and guidance from supervisors and
educational institutions to navigate the emotional challenges they may face. In addition,
entails. Teacher G said that she is a fan believer that self-belief comes before dissertation
journey, and that she wishes it is done at the level of high school, and that some students are
victims of some teachers, it is not allowed to hurt students in her opinion it is a sense of
relationship for her, never ever break the students’ spirit. Two teachers did not provide
Conclusion
In brief, this chapter has presented the research findings obtained from a questionnaire
administered to seventy-three Master 2 students and interviews conducted with eight teachers
48
in the Department of English at the University of Tizi-Ouzou. The following chapter deals
Introduction
This chapter aims to discuss and interpret the results of the study presented in the
previous chapter, provide answers to the research questions, and test the hypotheses stated in
the general introduction of this dissertation. The discussion is done in relation to the
This chapter contains three sections. The first section discusses the results related to
the views of teachers and students on the impact of self-belief on the dissertation journey. The
second section deals with the discussion of the factors affecting students’ self-belief during
the dissertation journey. As for the third section, it is concerned with the discussion and
interpretation of the different strategies provided by students and teachers to enhance Master 2
IV.1. Discussion of Students’ and Teachers’ Views Regarding the Impact of Self-belief
After analyzing the data obtained from the questionnaire, we discovered from the
results gained from question 4 that all Master 2 students (100%) in the sample group think
that self-belief contributes to their academic success (see Diagram 4), which means they
recognize the importance of self-belief and its impact. This strong agreement means that
students believe in the importance of self-belief in achieving academic success. This aligns
with Hailikari et al.’s (2008) statement that“academic self-belief may…play a key role in
predicting academic success” (p. 59). This quote suggests that academic self-belief is a
significant predictor of academic success. That is to say, students who trust their abilities are
more likely to succeed academically. This supports the findings that Master 2 students
the same context, Bandura (1977b) emphasized the importance of self-belief, also known as
50
‘self-efficacy’ in his Social Learning Theory, which is the core base for success in
accomplishing tasks as it affects the behaviour and the overall confidence of a student. In the
academic context, students with high self-efficacy are more likely to handle difficulties with
Despite students’ agreement with the fact that self-belief contributes to their academic
success, not all students have a high sense of self-belief during the dissertation journey,
according to the answers to the fifth question. To be more specific, the majority (60.3%)
claimed to have an average level of self-belief, while 23.3% and 6.8% rated it high and very
high, respectively (See Diagram 5). These findings entail that while the majority of students
have a moderate level of self-belief, there is a noticeable group who have higher levels of self-
belief. A moderate or average level of self-belief indicates that students have an reasonable
some of the students reported in question 19 about additional insignts, it is imlportant to have
a balanced level of self-belief because overconfidence can lead to mistakes and arrogance.
Besides, the questionnaire results show that the vast majority of students, nearly all of
them (99%), believe that a high level of self-belief positively influences their progress during
the dissertation journey (See Diagram 6). The fact that 99 % of the students support the
positive influence of high self- belief highlights its importance in facing the different
challenges of the dissertation journey. In this case, it is possible that students observed
successful peers who worked with a high sense of self-efficacy and believed in their abilities,
and that is why they all acknowledged that self-belief plays a crucial role in their academic
progress. Indeed, according to Bandura’s social learning theory, students learn by observing
and imitating others, and the influence of successful peers who demonstrated high self-belief
can affect their views about the role of self-belief in the dissertation process.
51
Moreover, when asked to specify how much they think that high levels of self-belief
influence their progress during the dissertation process, 63.9% of students emphasized that
high self-belief significantly influences their progress, 18.1% stressed its extreme influence,
and 12.5% highlighted its moderate influence, while a smaller group of (5.6%) attributed a
slight influence to high self-belief (See Diagram 7). In other words, students recognized the
crucial role of high self-belief and its effect on their dissertation progress. The findings
suggest a strong recognition among students about the significant influence that self-belief has
on their progress during the dissertation journey. This recognition emphasizes the importance
of enhancing self-belief among students to support their progress during the dissertation
process.
Furthermore, when asked about the impact of maintaining high levels of self-belief on
their motivation and commitment to completing their dissertations, 97% of students supported
the idea that high self-belief positively affects their motivation and commitment, while 3%
disagreed (See Diagram 8). This goes in line with the assertion made by Pintrich and Schunk
(2002) that self-belief and motivation are closely intertwined. In addition, the theoretical
framework of this study posits that when students maintain high levels of self-belief, they are
more likely to show behaviours that reflect this belief, such as motivation and perseverance.
We can conclude from the findings mentioned and discussed above that students think
that self-belief positively influences the dissertation journey. It is a core ingredient to achieve
academic goals and maintain motivation and commitment throughout the dissertation process,
Experienced supervisors within the same department were asked questions about their
views on the impact of Master 2 students’ self-belief on the dissertation journey. The results
from the interviews showed that the majority of teachers think that self-belief is a crucial
52
component that impacts the whole process of writing a dissertation; they emphasized its vital
role in the dissertation journey. This aligns with the results of Honicke and Broadbent’s
(2016), since the findings support the idea that believing in one’s capabilities can impact
academic performance. The interview findings also corroborate the results obtained from the
online questionnaire addressed to Master 2 students. This alignment makes the research
findings more reliable and believable because both teachers and students provided similar
views on the important role that self-belief plays during the dissertation journey.
As noted from teachers’ responses to the fifth interview question, it is clear that they
all agreed that students with a strong belief in themselves and their capacities tend to find the
dissertation process easier; they approach challenges and difficulties with a positive mindset.
Teachers confirmed this by describing observed instances where self-belief has impacted
one student who faced numerous rejections throughout his master’sresearch. Despite the
obstacles, this student persevered and publicly defended his work, showcasing belief in
himself and his research. This teacher thinks that self-belief was the reason why this student
never gave up and continued his journey until the end. Besides, Teacher B claimed that the
majority of students who submit their dissertations after ten months of work lack self- belief.
According to this teacher, these students struggled because they did not trust their own
abilities. This means that a lack of confidence can cause challenges forstudents when writing
their dissertations, as it can hinder their progress. Moreover, the observations made by the
supervisors highlight the significance of possessing a high sense of self-belief. The study
conducted by Pajares and Schunk (2001) mentioned in the literature review chapter about the
findings of this study align with the teachers’ observations, where students with strong self-
53
belief overcome all the challenges and complete their academic mission successfully. This is
further reinforced by Brown (2001), who suggested that a person’s belief in their abilities to
According to the collected data about the views of students and teachers on the impact
of self-belief on the dissertation journey, the findings confirmed our first hypothesis and
provided an answer to the first research question stated in the general introduction. That is to
say, both teachers and Master 2 students expressed positive views regarding the impact of
IV.2. Discussion of the Factors Affecting Students’ Self-belief during the Dissertation
Journey
This section aims at revealing and discussing the different factors that can impact self-
belief during the dissertation journey, according to Master 2 students. In this context, students
were asked to say whether they have faced any challenges that negatively impacted their self-
belief during the dissertation journey. 88% of students said they have faced difficulties that
affected their self-belief. A smaller group (12%) indicated that they did not face any
challenges that impacted their self- belief (See Diagram 9). This means that the majority of
students faced challenges that impacted their self-belief negatively and caused difficulties for
them to write high-quality dissertations. The fact that 88% of students reported facing
challenges that negatively affected how confident they felt about themselves highlights the
pervasiveness of self-confidence struggles within the sample group. These challenges could
When asked to specify which specific challenges impacted their self- belief during the
dissertation journey, nearly half of the students (46.6%) identified anxiety and stress as the
main challenges that influenced their progress during this journey. The fact that nearly half of
54
the students identified anxiety and stress as the main challenges impacting their self-belief
during the dissertation journey sheds light on the psychological or mental challenges students
face during this academic journey. During the dissertation process, anxiety may arise due to
the strict deadlines and pressure to produce high-quality work. Perfectionism and fear of
failure are also common, as reported by 34.2% of the students. The excessive desire to be
perfect in each aspect of this journey may lead to self-criticism and fear of failure, which can
be obstacles that can impact the progress of their work. Many students want to produce
dissertations that exceed academic standards. This excessive pursuit of perfection can lead to
high anxiety levels, fear of making mistakes and receiving negative criticism, negatively
motivation is also mentioned by 27.4% of the students. When it comes to long-term projects
like dissertations, it is hard to maintain motivation all along the way, and this is a challenge
for students since motivation acts as a push to overcome challenges. Procrastination is another
issue that is common among Master 2 students since it affects around a quarter (27.4%) of
them. Procrastination involves delaying tasks even when deadlines are approaching. This
often happens because of poor planning. Additionally, writing challenges were reported by
another group of students (26%), which include struggles structuring essays, developing ideas
and arguments, and dealing with methodological issues; all these elements can be challenging
for students and can negatively affect their self-belief. Enhancing students’ self-belief during
the dissertation journey is important because it helps them face the challenges they encounter
In this context, students were asked about the main factors that contribute to their self-
belief during the dissertation journey. The results of question 11 show that the feedback and
guidance provided by supervisors is cited as the most influential factor with a significant
majority of 71.2% of respondents. This finding is supported by the results obtained from
55
question 12, in which 89% of the students expressed agreement with the fact that the feedback
and guidance provided by their supervisors positively contribute to their self-belief. The
results align with Bandura’s Social Cognitive Theory, which emphasizes the importance of
Support and encouragement from supervisors, peers, and family were also chosen by
60.3% of students. This finding highlights the importance environmental influences, mainly
the social environment, in boosting students’ self-belief during the dissertation journey. This
aligns with Bandura’s reciprocal determinism within his Social Cognitive Theory, which
emphasizes the role of social support in enhancing self-belief. This also supports the finding
obtained from question 13, in which all the students (100%) agreed that maintaining a positive
relationship with the supervisor and research partner is crucial for fostering a high sense of
self-belief. When students have positive relationships with their supervisors and research
partners, they receive guidance and support, which boost their self- belief. Another
environmental factor that can positively influence students’ self-belief is a supportive learning
environment. Indeed, the results of question 14 revealed that the majorityof students (78.1%)
believe that a supportive environment has a positive impact on their self-belief during the
dissertation journey.
Slightly over half (50.7%) of the students argue that personal determination and
commitment are affecting factors, which means that students’ own motivation, perseverance,
and hard work are crucial components that can affect self-belief during this journey. This goes
in line with the personal factors mentioned in Bandura’s reciprocal determinism. Personal
factors, such as motivation, and perseverance, are key components of reciprocal determinism,
material (46.6%) were identified as further facilitators of self-belief; these factors contribute
56
effectively is a skill that each student should have during this journey because it provides
them with a sense of control over the whole dissertation process. Time management, such as
planning ahead and devoting time to work on the dissertation, is considered as a behaviour
and research material, it is a keyfactor that enhances students’ self-belief and the quality of
their dissertations. In his reciprocal determinism framework, Bandura suggests that the
Based on the factors of reciprocal determinism within Bandura’s theory, which is the
theoretical framework of our research, teachers were asked three questions regarding the
influence of each one of these factors on self-belief during the dissertation journey. When
supervisor feedback and support, the academic environment, and access to academic and
research material, teachers agreed that the environment in which the students work can
significantly shape and impact their self-belief. They affirmed that convenient access to
research material and supervisor support significantly impact students’ motivation and self-
belief. Teachers also claimed that the mixture of all these factors positively influences the
overall self-belief of students. When teachers acknowledge the significance of these factors in
fostering students’ self-belief, they are recognizing the influence and power of environmental
factors on students’ self-belief. This finding supports the results obtained from the online
shared understanding between teachers and students about the importance of environmental
The seventh question is asked to uncover whether teachers think that students’
behaviour (such as managing time effectively, actively seeking feedback, and setting
attainable goals) shapes their self-belief during the dissertation journey since they supervise
students every year, so they have an idea about their behaviour and how it can impact them.
They emphasized that students’ behaviour can significantly impact their self-belief and their
importance of having a well-defined outline from the beginning of the dissertation process,
which involves preparing a structured framework to follow, that outlines the main chapters
and key points to be covered in the dissertation. Moreover, they emphasized the importance of
managing time effectively, stating that it allows students to set realistic goals and divide their
work into manageable tasks. Effective time management helps students stay focused and meet
deadlines. The importance of time management was also highlighted by Master 2 students,
indicating its importance in shaping self-belief during the dissertation process and achieving
success.
Regarding personal factors, teachers think that these personal qualities enable students
the objective of completing their master’s dissertations, students can reinforce their self-belief
and remain motivated throughout the journey. As stated in the literature review chapter,
Schunk and DiBenedetto (2019) highlight the significant role of personal influences in
The ninth question is asked to determine the challenges that students face during the
negative feedback from the dissertation supervisor. This aligns with what students reported in
58
the online questionnaire. This similarity shows that both teachers and students agree that
receiving negative feedback from supervisors is a major hurdle to students’ self-belief when
working on their dissertations. The supervisor’s feedback impacts students’ self-belief, either
Limited time can create pressure to meet deadlines, causing anxiety and self-doubt if students
feel that they might not finish and submit their dissertations on time. In this case, effective
time management is crucial because it helps students face the challenges posed by time
themselves and their abilities. This can make it harder for them to finish their
All the answers provided by students and teachers addressed the second research
question, which focused on identifying the factors that contribute the development and
maintenance of students’ self-belief during the dissertation process. Their answers, in turn,
confirmed the second hypothesis, which states that “Personal, environmental, and behavioural
factors contribute to the development and maintenance of students’ self-belief during the
dissertation journey.”
IV.3. Discussion of the Strategies from Students and Teachers to Enhance Self-Belief
The fourth section of the questionnaire aimed to identify which strategies students
believed could enhance their self-belief during the dissertation journey. Based on their
answers to question 17, which asked them about the strategies they use to enhance their self-
belief, setting attainable goals emerged as the top-ranked strategy with a percentage of 67.1%.
59
Setting achievable goals is essential because it helps students maintain motivation, track their
progress, reduce anxiety, and enhance their self-belief. Another important strategy mentioned
by students is seeking support and feedback from their supervisors. Indeed, around 52.1% of
students considered seeking their supervisor’s support and feedback crucial to boosting their
self-belief. The feedback and support provided by the dissertation supervisor provide
monologue helps them maintainhigh sense of self-belief. Positive self-talk helps students
affirm their strengths and abilities to achieve success. Furthermore, 32.9% celebrate small
achievements along the way, acknowledging each small progress to maintin motivation and
boost self-belief. Setting attainable goals, seeking supervisor’s support and feedback, and
dissertation journey, it is important to learn about how teachers and educational institutions
can help students develop and maintain self-belief. That is why question 18 was asked. The
results showed that the majority of students, or 69.9%, highlighted the importance of creating
a supportive academic environment. This involves ensuring that students have access to the
necessary resources and experienced people to offer feedback and guidance, and fostering
positive and respectful relationships between teachers and [Link], 65.8% of Master
2 students stressed the significance of direct support from supervisors in promoting their self-
belief. This means that constructive feedback, encouragement, and mentorship are crucial to
maintaining a high sense of self-belief and facilitating the dissertation process. Moreover,
30.1% of students suggested the organization of workshops on self-belief; this could include
60
providing students with tools and skills to manage their self-belief. Furthermore, students
(39.7%) stressed the need for open discussions about self-belief. Promoting open dialogue
about self-belief can encourage students to share their experiences and seek and receive
advice, which can foster their self-belief. Overall, these insights highlight the pivotal role that
supervisors and universities play in supporting and building students’ self-belief through the
dissertation journey. More specifically, the findings stress the importance of environmental
Question 10 in the interview was asked with the aim to find out how teachers or
dissertation supervisors foster their students’ self-belief during the dissertation journey. One
their dissertations, students can maintain a positive mindset and boost their belief in their
abilities. Additionally, teachers emphasized the importance of offering guidance and support;
this includes providing resources, answering questions, and helping students during the
writing process. Providing guidance and support contributes to students’ self-belief and
success in completing their dissertations. This finding supports students’ emphasis on the
technique is setting deadlines. Deadlines help students break down their dissertations into
manageable tasks. This can reduce stress, motivate them to stay focused, and enhance their
belief in their ability to complete their research projects step by step. Moreover, teachers
encourage their students to focus on putting the necessary effort. By doing so, students can
understand that success is achieved through hard work, persistence, and dedication.
Furthermore, teachers remind students that other students before them have successfully
61
accomplished the same task. By highlighting past successes of others in completing their
In addition, teachers were asked to provide some advice to supervisors and educational
institutions to help students build and maintain a high sense of self-belief throughout the
dissertation process. They gave significant suggestions, for instance, encouraging students to
enjoy the process by appreciating the journey, providing continuous support and guidance,
nurturing self-belief early on, and avoiding any action that undermines students’ self-belief or
When teachers were asked to add anything else about the topic, they claimed that inner
strength is the key to success. They emphasized the importance of not neglecting the
addressing students’ emotional well-being throughout the dissertation process. This includes
acknowledging the responsibility of the dissertation supervisor accentuates his/her crucial role
All these insightful responses answered the third research question about the strategies
teachers and Master 2 students use to enhance self-belief during the dissertation journey. In
addition, they confirmed the third hypothesis that “Teachers and Master 2 students likely use
Conclusion
This chapter has discussed the findings of the study conducted in the department of
English at the University of Tizi-Ouzou in relation to the three objectives initially stated in the
general introduction of this dissertation. Based on Banduras’ Social Cognitive Theory, this
62
discussion has answered all the questions stated in the general introduction and tested the
evident that both Master 2 students and dissertation supervisors view that self-belief
positively influences the dissertation journey and plays a pivotal role throughout this process.
That is why they highlighted the importance of enhancing self-belief during this challenging
This study aimed to explore teachers’ and Master 2 students’ views on the impact of
contributing to the development and maintenance of self- belief throughout the dissertation
journey. Moreover, it sought to uncover the strategies employed by teachers and students to
To reach the aforementioned objectives, address the research questions, and test the
hypotheses, a mixed-method approach for data collection and analysis was used; this enabled
consisting of nineteen questions was designed and addressed to all Master 2 students enrolled
supervisors. These interviews aimed to gather qualitative data and gain a deeper
understanding of teachers’ viewpoints on the topic. The study relied on Bandura’s reciprocal
determinism within his broader framework of social cognitive theory. By applying this
framework, the study aimed to understand how behavioural, personal, and environmental
In terms of analyzing the data, the quantitative data obtained from the closed-ended
questions of the questionnaire were analyzed using descriptive statistics, such as percentages,
and presented in diagrams and tables. On the other hand, the qualitative data were analyzed
using Qualitative Content Analysis (QCA), which allowed us to identify the key themes and
patterns. The findings of the study highlighted the important role that self-belief plays during
the dissertation journey. Both teachers and students recognized the importance of self-belief
research. That is to say, they stressed the positive influence of self-belief on the dissertation
64
journey. Moreover, both teachers and students emphasized that some factors like time
management, supervisor support and feedback, and the availability of resources can positively
teachers highlighted that incorporating some strategies can promote students’ self- belief,
such as providing constructive feedback, setting achievable goals, and creating a supportive
learning environment. The same point was shared by students, who asserted that applying
some strategies helps to sustain self-belief in themselves. The findings from both the
provided evidence about the factors that could affect students’ self- belief and suggested
strategies to maintain self-belief during the dissertation journey. These outcomes validate all
It is important to mention that the current study encountered several limitations. The
first limitation concerns the small sample size and the interview procedure. Due to the
teachers’ busy schedule, the interview questions were sent via email, and only five teachers
us to rely on note-taking during the conversations. This made it challenging to capture all the
necessary responses accurately. The second limitation is that when the questionnaire was
obtaining a sufficient number of participants. Since the questionnaire was distributed online
and not in person, the students responded only after receiving multiple reminders.
The present study investigated teachers’ and students’ views on the impact of self-
belief on the dissertation journey in the Department of English at the University of Tizi-
Ouzou. For further research, we recommend conducting comparative studies across different
disciplines and universities to identify any specific difference in self-belief and its impact on
65
Akbari, O., & Sahibzada, J.(2020). Students’ self-confidence and its impact on their learning
Process. American International Journal of Social Science Research, 5(1), pp. 1-15.
of Saudi Arabia.
Arab & Abdelmalek (2018). Students’ Anxiety in the Preparation of their Dissertation: Case
Arumugam, A. et al. (2021). The Importance of Time Management For The Successful of
Bandura, A. (1977b). Social learning theory. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall.
Bandura, A., Adams, N. E., Hardy, A. B., & Howells, G. N. (1980) . "Tests of the generality
Barnes, B. J., &; Austin, A. E. (2009). The role of doctoral advisors: A look at advising
[Link]
learners of English as a foreign language: The case of first year pupils at Fatma
Bouhadad and Oukaci. (2022). Students’ Self-confidence during the COVID-19 Pandemic:
The case of third-year EFL students in the Department of English at Mouloud Mammeri
University Press.
Creswell, J. W., & Plano Clark, V. L. (2018). Designing and conducting mixed methods
Devi, B., Khandelwal, B., & Das, M. (2017). Application of Bandura’s social cognitive
Gardner, R.C.( 1985). Social psychology and second language learning: The role of attitudes
Gillham, B. (2000). Case study research methods. New York, USA: Bloomsbury Publishing.
Hailikari, T., Nevgi, A., & Komulainen, E. (2008). Academic self‐ beliefs and prior
Henderson, M., Finger, G., & Selwyn, N. (2016). What’s used and what’s useful? Exploring
digital technology use (s) among taught postgraduate students. Active learning in
In, J. (2017). Introduction of a pilot study. Korean Journal of Anesthesiology, 70(6), 601-605.
[Link]
Jensen, K., & Austin, M. J. (2017). The doctoral adviser-advisee relationship: Its critical
International.
Kutasi, R. (2023). Feedback: Unveiling its impact and enhancing its effectiveness in
[Link]
Linnenbrink, E. A., & Pintrich, P. R. (2003). The role of self-efficacy beliefs in student
engagement and learning in the classroom. Reading & Writing Quarterly, 19(2), 119-
137. [Link]
Malureanu, A., Panisoara, G., & Lazar, I. (2021). The relationship between self- confidence,
Mhunpiew, N. (2013). A supervisor’s roles for successful thesis and dissertation. US-China
Murray, R. (2011). How to write a thesis (3rd Ed). Maidehead ; Open university Press-MC
Graw-Hill.
Nabavi, R. T., & Bijandi, M. S. (2011). Bandura’s social learning theory & social
[Link]
g_Theory_Social_Cognitive_Learning_Theory/citation/download
Odiri, O. E. (2021). Students’ self-belief about their mathematics capability and achievement
70
Pajares, F., & Schunk, D. H. (2001). Self-beliefs and school success: Self-efficacy, self-
Pilot, D. F., & Beck, C. T. (2004). Nursing research: Principles and methods. Lippincott
Pintrich, P. R., & Schunck, D. H. (2002). Motivation in education: Theory, research, and
Cliffs.
Reska, N., & Taufik. (2019). Relathionship of self confidence and academic procrastination
students S1 guidance and counseling FIP UNP. Jurnal Neo Konseling, 1(3), 1-6.
Ryan, R. M., & Deci, E. L. (2000). Self-determination theory and the facilitation of
55(1), 68–78.
Schunk, D. Meece, I., & Pintrich, P. (2014). Motivation in education: Theory, research and
Schunk, D. H., & DiBenedetto, M. K. (2019). Motivation and social cognitive theory.
[Link]
[Link]
Taherdoost, H. (2021). Data collection methods and tools for research; A step-by-step guide
to choose data collection technique for academic and business research projects.
Wiggins, J. D., Schatz, E. L., & West, R. W. (1994). The relationship of self-esteem to
grades, achievement scores, and other factors critical to school success. The School
Zhao, Y., Zheng, Z., Pan, C., & Zhou, L. (2021). Self-esteem and academic engagement
[Link]
Students’ Questionnaire
This questionnaire aims to gather data about your views regarding the impact of self-
belief during the dissertation journey. You are kindly requested to fill out this questionnaire.
Your honest responses are crucial in helping us gain a deeper understanding of the topic. Your
answers will be treated anonymously and will be used for research purposes only.
Instructions: please select the right answer(s) or give full answers when necessary.
University of Tizi-Ouzou
Male
Female
DissertationJourney
Yes
No
4. How would you describe your overall experience working on your dissertation so far?
Very bad
Bad
Average
Good
Very good
Very low
Low
Average
High
Very high
6. Do you think that high levels of self-belief positively influence your progress during the
dissertation journey?
Yes
No
7. If the answer is yes, on a scale of 1 to 4, how much do you think that high levels of self-
Slightly
Moderately
Significantly
Extremely
Yes
No
Section Three: Factors Affecting Students’ Self-belief during the Dissertation Journey
9. Have you faced any challenges that negatively impacted your self-belief during your
dissertation journey?
Yes
No
10. If the answer is yes, what are the main challenges you faced? (Select all that apply)
11. According to you, what factors contribute to your self-belief during the dissertation
Effective time-management
12. The feedback and guidance provided by my supervisor significantly affect my self-belief
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
13. My relationship with my supervisor and research partner is important to maintain a high
sense of self-belief.
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
impacts my self-belief.
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
my self-belief.
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
16. My skills in research methodology and writing abilities contribute to my self-belief in the
dissertation process.
Agree
Neutral
Disagree
Journey
17. What strategies do you use to develop and maintain your self-belief throughout
18. In your opinion, how can supervisors and universities help students to build and maintain
19. Please feel free to add any additional insights about the role and impact of self-belief on
the dissertation journey ?
…………………………………………………………………………………………………
Appendix B:
Dear teachers,
The present interview aims to collect data about your views on the impact of self-belief
duringMaster Two students’ dissertation journey. Your answers will be treated with
confidentiality and used only for academic purposes. We will be really thankful if you could
Q2. How long have you been teaching in the Department of English? ..........................
Q3. How long have you been supervising master’s dissertations? …………………..
dissertation?
…………………………………………………………………………………………………..
…………………………………………………………………………………………………...
…………………………………………………………………………………………………...
Q5. From your perspective, what impact does self-belief have on students’ overall success in
completing their dissertations journey? Please describe observed instances where self-belief
…………………………………………………………………………………………………..
…………………………………………………………………………………………………...
…………………………………………………………………………………………………...
supervisor feedback and support, the academic environment, and access to academic and
…………………………………………………………………………………………………..
…………………………………………………………………………………………………...
……………………………………..…………………………………………………………...
[Link] can students’ behaviours (such as managing time, actively seeking feedback, and
…………………………………………………………………………………………………..
…………………………………………………………………………………………………...
…………………………………………………………………………………………………...
[Link] can personal factors (such as resilience, determination, research skills, and writing
…………………………………………………………………………………………………..
…………………………………………………………………………………………………...
…………………………………………………………………………………………………...
[Link] to you, what are the common challenges students face in developing and
.......................................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................................
Q10. How do you foster self-belief in your students during the dissertation journey?
…………………………………………………………………………………………………..
…………………………………………………………………………………………………...
Q11. What piece of advice would you give to supervisors and educational institutions to help
students build and maintain a high sense of self-belief throughout the dissertation process?
.......................................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................................
....................................................................................................................................
[Link] there anything else you would like to add about the impact of self-belief on the
.......................................................................................................................................................
.......................................................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................................
Appendix C
Interview Transcripts
Teacher A: Magister
Teacher C:PhD
Teacher D:Doctorate
Teacher E: Professor
Teacher F:PhD
Teacher G:Magister
Teacher H:PhD
Q2. How long have you been teaching in the Department of English?
Teacher H:
Teacher E:10 years, since 2014 when the first group was launched
Q4. According to you, how important is self-belief for students preparing a master’s
dissertation?
influences their motivation. When students believe in their abilities to tackle the challenges of
their dissertation, they are more likely to do their best even when faced with obstacles. Also,
completing a masters’ dissertation requires perseverance and tenacity. Self- belief provides
the strength needed to persevere through the long hours of research, writing, and revision that
Teacher B:Self-belief is important in all endeavours and all fields. However, in the academic
domain, where research work is dotted with obstacles, self-belief is the core ingredient for
success. Many a student give up after a short period of time because they lack self-belief and,
Teacher C:A Master dissertation is an academic work. Therefore, this has nothing to do with
Teacher E:I guess it can help them shape their vision of themselves and of their academic
environment
Teacher F:I think it is very important, because the more you believe in yourself the better the
Q5. From your perspective, what impact does self-belief have on students’ overall success in
completing their dissertations journey? Please describe observed instances where self-belief
Teacher A: Self-belief plays a significant role in students; overall success in completing their
dissertation journey because it makes them conduct their dissertation journey with enthusiasm
and confidence. Also, throughout the dissertation process, students can meet various
challenges, such as difficulty with research methods, data analysis, or literature review. Those
with self-belief are better equipped to face these challenges because they view them as
Teacher B:Theimpact of self-belief is that when the student really believes that the project
can completed, they will find the ways to overcome potential obstacles. As a supervisor for
more than 15 years, I noticed that most of the Master’s students who handed in their final
version of the dissertation after ten months of work lacked self-belief. This happened to them
because they mistrusted their abilities. In sum, when a student lacks self-belief, they rely on
the supervisor for every trivial difficulty, and this prevents them from achieving things in
time.
Teacher C:I am not sure what self-belief is but I can recall the case of one of my students
who alone had struggled to fulfil his master research. Many times, his work was rejected but
Teacher D:Teachers can orient their students to have this inner strength in order to survive
beliefcontributes a lot to students’ self-image and influence their achievements. When they
have high self-belief, they are more motivated and achieve better.
Teacher F:I have to say that the students who believe more in themselves, they are going to
succeed or the journey itself is going to be much easier and enjoyable, and you know the more
you enjoy doing something, the better are going to be the results, unlike anxious students who
Teacher G:For example, in Literature fields, it is very subjective, i always tell them that it is
better for them to bring themes than me, it is important to defend your view, they know that
they master their field, and that has a huge impact on their self-belief
Teacher H:Actually,we are at the university, so every student reaching this level is supposed
Q6. According to you, how can external factors or environmental influences (such as
supervisor feedback and support, the academic environment, and access to academic and
Teacher A: Positive and constructive feedback from supervisors can help students feel more
confident by validating their efforts and progress. Thus, Students can develop confidence in
themselves when they have a supervisor who is encouraging and helpful, who can reassure
them of their skills and help them overcome obstacles. Lack of support could damage their
self-esteem.
Teacher B:When a student really believes that they can succeed in spite of obstacles,
setbacks or mistakes, they will work hard to attain their final objective. On the contrary, when
a student suffers from the lack of self-confidence and self-fulfilment, they have a tendency to
find the reason for their failure in the external factors such as the academic environment, the
supervisor, etc.
Teacher C:Nowadays, academic environment and access to research material are easy. As for
the supervisor feedback, it can be said to be of some importance but I personally think that
theory would dictate the plan, and when the plan is designed, writing the dissertation is easier
Teacher D:All the external factors can help a lot, we can mention the teachers,parents,
Teacher E:What a complex question!!! I think that all what you call external factors have
impacts on students’ achievements. Contexts that are more cooperative help students to
succeed.
Teacher F:The environment has an important role, if you have and easy access to different
works, documentation, supervisor, even to the lab of the university or institution, I think that
all these factors would help and have an impact that can be both negative and positive, when
you can easily access to all those and that the environment is helping you to do the research of
course your self-belief is going to be higher, and when the environment does not help or push
you to do the work, you can be very motivated at the beginning but you can become less
Teacher G:It is very important to have a spirit of a supervisor to help, guide, and support
students during the dissertation journey, all external factors matter, they can impact students’
Teacher H:I have been supervising students for 14 years, i have noticed that the more you are
very helpful to students, the more you make students at ease, the more respectful you are, the
more... the more students become confident. It is the mixture of all these factors that can
[Link] can students’ behaviours (such as managing time, actively seeking feedback, and
journey. Students who manage their time by setting realistic goals,dividing work into
manageable tasks, and adhering to deadlines are more likely to experience a sense of
Teacher B:Up to you to find an answer to this question . . . This is part of your research
work!
Teacher C:Do not seek feedback if you have theory assimilation and comprehensiveness is
mastered
Teacher D:Time management can help the students, they need to have a preliminary outline
to divide tasks with their project partners, regular discussions with their supervisor are going
Teacher E:Well, I guess this is different from one person to another. Students have different
learning styles and working strategies. But still, self-discipline and good time management
always help.
Teacher F:Well, it depends on the students how they do perceive things, because some
students who perceive this as a challenge and others will perceive this as an obstacle
Teacher G:When you know you have the right topic, you will do it and whenever students
Teacher H:I had experience of supervising and I have noticed that whenever students who
are less motivated, do not only lose their self-confidence, but also their time, and it is very
disturbing for the supervision process, while on the other hand, students who are really
motivated, finish at appropriate time and they do listen to the positive feedback and improve
themselves
Q8. How can personal factors (such as resilience, determination, research skills, and writing
belief. This means that strong writing abilities gives confidence in students, allowing them to
Teacher B:Up to you to find an answer to this question . . . This is part of your research
work!
Teacher C:Student must only pursue that objective of fulfilling one’s master dissertation
Teacher D:Research skills and strategies help a lot in addition to their motivation that can
Teacher E: I can’t tell for sure as this is different from one student to another but a good
Teacher F:This is very important, because you cannot believe in yourself on the basis of
nothing, if you want to have much more self-esteem, much more self-confidence you need to
Teacher G:Poor methodology or writing skills are real barriers to some students, sometimes
students do not accept critics and this is problematic, when i say that you have to believe me,
to improve yourself, when i have a student who is aware of his lack of self-belief, it facilitates
the touch
Teacher H:Actually, I am supervising four binomials, and I have noticed that those who have
really good writing skills are more confident because they are never afraid of my own
feedback, they are open to criticism and they do improve themselves each day
Q9. According to you, what are the common challenges students face in developing and
discouragement.
Teacher B:Up to you to find an answer to this question . . . This is part of your research
work!
Teacher D:The time constraints can help a lot and teach all the skills of research in addition
to the spirit of competition and team work because they share these challenges with their
project partner
Teacher E:.I guess it all depends on the research experience itself, whether it’s straight
Teacher F:It can be related to the question talking about environment, if the environment is
Teacher G:They are their own challenges, try not to lose the connection, motivation,
everyday life is about challenges, so just go with the flow of life, I believe in discipline not
motivation.
Teacher H:This journey is very short, as English people say “when there is a will, there is a
way” so, when you are will to take the lead of those who are good, the way becomes very
clear and easy, whenever you face difficulties, you have just to remember that you need just
Q10. How do you foster self-belief in your students during the dissertation journey?
Teacher A: Offer guidance to students. Equip them with the tools, knowledge, and support
they need to succeed academically and personally during the dissertation journey.
Teacher B:I usually try to foster self-belief in my students by giving positive feedback even
when the work they hand in for correction is not satisfying. I think that the purposes of
feedback are to motivate students, to encourage student autonomy and to help students
understand what their problems are and how they can improve their work. Here is an example
of feedback that I give to my students: “Well done. That’s much better than last time. You
really thought about how to write an introduction, but there are a few problems with
punctuation...”
Teacher D:Using the technique of projection (they see themselves as future graduates) in
Teacher E:I just let them be themselves knowing that they have different personalities and
different learning styles. I try however to motivate them and make the research experience an
Teacher F:I try to use some strategies and i do set deadlines, i try to explain for them right
the beginning that this journey must be enjoyable and enjoy the learning process, it is through
the difficulties and challenges that we can learn, and once you do it, you will be satisfied
experiencing this
Teacher G:You can do it, people before you did it, it takes work that is all
Q11. What piece of advice would you give to supervisors and educational institutions to help
students build and maintain a high sense of self-belief throughout the dissertation process?
constructive feedback.
Teacher B:Up to you to find an answer to this question and include it in the conclusion of
your dissertation.
Teacher F:I keep saying to my students, that you must enjoy the process, whatever the
challenges you may face and whatever the difficulties you can cross, it is the learning process
Teacher G:I am fan believer that self-belief comes before dissertation journey, i wish it is
done at the level of high school, some students are victims of some teachers, it is not allowed
to hurt students in my opinion it is a sense of relationship for me, never ever break the
students’ spirit
Teacher H:Every high level comes from reading, means that whatever they are surrounded
with, make positive use of it, it will contribute to the reaching of their level, but if they take it
negatively, it will affect them, I do believe that it is the contribution of the supervisor and the
student, we all know that mutual respect and contribution can do a lot
[Link] there anything else you would like to add about the impact of self-belief on the
Teacher B:I may add that your questions in this ‘interview’ do not address the supervisor’s
experiences with students conducting a research work. The answers to your questions can be
found in your review of the literature + theoretical underpinnings . . . They can be found in
the literature that revolves around educational psychology. You should, for example, ask
supervisors about the number of students they have supervised, the discussions they have had
with their students, percentages of success/failure/lack of self-confidence, etc... And then you
interpret those practical things to inform your dissertation. In a word, the teachers are not
forcibly psychologists, and their job is to help students to write properly, but not to study their
personality features.
Teacher E:Well, I always tell my students to do their best and be honest with their research.
Teacher F:There are some teachers who neglect the psychological aspect at the university
level, thinking that students are old enough, mature enough to manage themselves but they are
Teacher G:Always go smoothly, students should be accept critics, leave some space to
Teacher H:I will just say that one of the most difficult things I did and I try to do is
supervision, because I am not the kind of teachers taking pride at the end of the viva if the
students get 17 or 16, I believe that it is my own duty to leave them through the clearest way
possible to the end of it, I tell them in your free time you are a Tik-tok and YouTube user so
try to use them positively and learn from them. I tell them to look for previous dissertations.
General Introduction
Chapter One :
Review of the Literature
Chapter Two:
Research Design and Methodology
Chapter Three:
Presentation of the Findings
Chapter Four:
Discussion of the Findings
General Conclusion
References
Appendices