Module 3
Module 3
DIFFUSION
Three states of aggregation of a substance are gas, liquid and solid and due to this
we have six possibilities of the phase contact. Gas-gas (not practically realised), gas-liquid,
gas-solid, liquid-liquid, liquid-solid and solid-solid (no industrial separation operation in this
category is found).
Mass transfer operations have been classified according to the phases in contact as
given in Table 7.1.
Table 7.1
Phases in contact Mass transfer operation
Liquid-vapour (gas) Distillation (Fractionation)
Liquid-gas Gas absorption
Stripping
Humidification
Dehumidification
Liquid-solid Crystallisation
Leaching
Adsorption
Liquid-liquid Extraction
Solid-vapour Sublimation
Solid-gas Adsorption
Solid (wet) gas (usually air) Drying
Hence, distillation, gas absorption, stripping are gas-liquid operations, liquid extraction is
a liquid-liquid operation, crystallisation is a liquid-solid operation and drying is a gas-solid
operation.
As the basic mechanism is the same whether the phase is a gas, liquid or solid, there are
some similarities among the various mass transfer operations and these are given below.
(a) Equilibrium between the phases is attained after a sufficiently long time of phase
contact between them.
(b) Material transfer is caused by the combined effect of molecular diffusion and
turbulence.
(c) There is no resistance to mass transfer at the phase interface (because of the
existence of equilibrium at the interface).
(d) Rate of mass transfer is evaluated by deviation/departure from equilibrium
concentration.
1. Distillation : Distillation is a gas-liquid operation. It is a method of separating the
components of a liquid mixture using thermal energy. The difference in vapour pressures of
different components is responsible for such a separation. It is also called as fractionation or
fractional distillation. (The term fractionation is commonly used in petroleum refineries).
The separation of a crude petroleum into gasoline, kerosene, etc. is a typical example of
distillation.
Unit Operations – II 7.3 Diffusion
high concentration end and removing it at the low concentration end, then the flow of
diffusing component is continuous. This movement is utilised in mass transfer operations.
When diffusion results from the random movement/motion of the molecules, it is called
molecular diffusion. As the molecular diffusion requires actual migration of molecules, the
rate of mass transfer is higher in gases than liquids and very slow in solids. When the
movement of the molecules occurs with the help of an external force (e.g., mechanical
stirring and convective movement of the fluid), then it is called eddy or turbulent diffusion.
The molecular diffusion is a slow process, whereas the eddy diffusion is a fast process. The
molecular diffusion is the mechanism of a stationary fluid, i.e., a fluid at rest and fluids in
laminar flow. In case of fluids in turbulent flow, the mechanism of mass transfer is by eddy
diffusion. The transfer of material in the presence of a concentration gradient is classified as
molecular transfer and eddy transfer. Molecular transfer of mass occurs in stationary fluids or
fluids in laminar flow whereas eddy transfer occurs in fluids under turbulent conditions.
Role of diffusion in mass transfer :
Diffusion may occur in one phase or in both phases in all the mass transfer operations.
In case of distillation, the more volatile component diffuses through the liquid phase to the
interface between the phases (liquid and vapour phases) and away from the interface into the
vapour phase. The less volatile component diffuses in the opposite direction and passes from
the vapour phase to the liquid phase. In case of gas absorption, the solute gas diffuses
through the gas phase to the interface and then through the liquid phase (liquid solvent
phase) from the interface between the phases. In case of crystallisation, the solid solute
diffuses through the mother liquor (liquid phase) to the crystals and deposit on the solid
surfaces. In case of drying operation, liquid water (moisture) diffuses through the solid
towards the surface of the solid, evaporates and diffuses as a vapour into the gas phase
(drying medium). In case of liquid-liquid extraction, the liquid solute diffuses through the
raffinate phase and then into the extract phase (solvent phase) from the interface between
the phases.
Molecular Diffusion :
Concentrations, velocities and fluxes :
Let us consider two chemical species A and B are placed in two compartments that are
separated by a impermeable partition. Now, assume that the partition is suddenly removed so
that the species A will diffuse into B and the species B will diffuse in A and this will
continue at a constantly decreasing rate until the mixture becomes everywhere uniform in the
concentration of its constituents, i.e., of A and B. The process is one of molecular diffusion
in which the species are diffused in one another as a result of the random motion of
molecules. The rate of diffusion is governed by Fick's law and before dealing with this law,
we will define the above mentioned terms based on the combination of such species. We
make it clear here that by the word solution we mean a mixture of species of the same phase
– gas in gas, liquid in liquid, etc., i.e., one phase - a gaseous, a liquid or a solid mixture.
Concentration :
There are various ways to express the concentration of the various species in a
multicomponent system/mixture. We limit our discussion to mass concentration, molar/
concentration, mass fraction and mole fraction.
Unit Operations – II 7.5 Diffusion
and xA + xB = 1
In the gas phase, concentrations are usually expressed in terms of partial pressures.
For an ideal gas A, pAV = nART
nA pA
CA = V = RT … (7.6)
where pA is the partial pressure of species A in the mixture, nA is the number of moles of A in
the mixture, V is the molar volume of the mixture, T is the temperature (absolute), and R is
the univeral gas constant.
xA in terms of pA is given as :
CA pA/RT pA
xA = C = P/RT = P … (7.7)
where P is the total pressure exerted by the gas mixture.
pA pB P
Also, we have C = CA + CB = RT + RT = RT … (7.8)
Unit Operations – II 7.6 Diffusion
Velocities :
In a diffusing mixture, various chemical species are moving at different velocities as they
may have different mobilities. The bulk velocity of the mixture would be some sort of an
average velocity. Let ui be the velocity of the ith species with respect to the stationary
coordinate system. Then, for a mixture of n species, the local mass average velocity u is
defined by
n
∑ ρi ui
i=1
u = n … (7.9)
∑ ρi
i=1
ρu is the local rate at which mass passes through a unit cross-section when it is placed
perpendicular to u.
For a binary system of A and B components, we can write
ρA uA + ρB uB
u = … (7.10)
ρ
The local molar average velocity of the mixture, U, is defined by
n
∑ Ci ui
i=1
U = n … (7.11)
∑ Ci
i=1
Cu is the local rate at which moles pass through a unit cross-section which is placed
perpendicular to U.
For a binary system of A and B, we can write
CAuA + CB uB
U = C … (7.12)
Let us define two diffusion velocities relative to/with respect to the two bulk velocities
(mass and molar average velocities of the mixture).
The mass diffusion velocity of a species is the velocity of that species relative to the local
mass average velocity of the mixture.
Mass diffusion velocity of species i w.r.t. u = ui – u
Mass diffusion velocity of species A w.r.t. u = uA – u.
The molar diffusion velocity of a species is the velocity of species with respect to/relative
to the local molar average velocity of the mixture.
Molar diffusion velocity of species i w.r.t. U = ui – U … (7.13)
Molar diffusion velocity of species A w.r.t. U = uA – U … (7.14)
Mass flow rate : It is the quantity of material flow in mass units per unit time (e.g., kg/s)
Molar flow rate : It is the quantity of material flow in molar units per unit time
(e.g., kmol/s).
Unit Operations – II 7.7 Diffusion
Flux : The mass transfer flux of a given species (vector quantity) is defined as the
amount of that species, in either mass or, molar units, that crosses a unit area per unit time.
We will define four types of fluxes, two with reference to fixed coordinates in space and two
with respect to local mass average velocity and local molar average velocity (w.r.t.
coordinates moving with mass average velocity and molar average velocity).
Mass flux : The mass flux of a species i is defined as the mass of species i that passes
through a unit area per unit time.
The mass flux relative to stationary/fixed coordinates is given by
ni = ρi ui … (7.15)
The mass flux relative to the mass average velocity u is given by
ji = ρi (ui – u) … (7.16)
Molar flux : It is defined as the moles of species i that passes through a unit area per unit
time.
The molar flux relative to stationary coordinates is given by
Ni = Ci ui … (7.17)
The molar flux relative to the molar average velocity U is given by
Ji = Ci (ui – U) … (7.18)
It is true that any one of the above mentioned notation used for the flux is adequate for all
diffusion problems, but each has certain advantages. In process calculations, it is usually
desirable to refer to a coordinate system fixed in an equipment so the flux Ni is used in
engineering. The fluxes ji and Ji are the usual measures of rates of diffusion and are useful in
formulating the equations of change for multicomponent systems.
For a binary system of A and B :
The mass fluxes of A and B relative to stationary coordinates are :
nA = ρA uA … (7.19)
nB = ρB uB … (7.20)
The mass fluxes of A and B relative to mass average velocity are :
jA = ρA (uA – u) … (7.21)
jB = ρB (uB – u) … (7.22)
The molar fluxes of A and B with respect to stationary coordinates are :
NA = CA uA … (7.23)
NB = CB uB … (7.24)
The molar fluxes of A and B relative to molar average velocity U are :
JA = CA (uA – U) … (7.25)
JB = CB (uB – U) … (7.26)
Unit Operations – II 7.8 Diffusion
JA and JB are the diffusion flux of components A and B. The various fluxes can be
interrelated as,
nA = ρA uA
= ρA (u + uA – u)
= ρA u + ρA (uA – u)
= ρA u + ji … (7.27)
ρA
We have, xA' = ∴ ρA = xA' ρ
ρ
nA = x'A (ρu) + ji
Since, ∑ ni = ∑ ρi ui = ρv
∴ n = x' ∑ n + j
A A i i … (7.28)
Similarly, NA = CA uA
= CA (U + uA – U)
= CA U + CA (uA – U)
NA = CA U + J A … (7.29)
NA = xA (CU) + JA
∑ Ni = ∑ Ci ui = CU
NA = xA (∑ Ni) + JA … (7.30)
Fick's law of diffusion :
A relation between the flux of the diffusing substance and the concentration gradient
responsible for molecular diffusion-mass transfer was first proposed by FICK in 1855 and is
therefore referred to as Fick's first law of diffusion.
The flux of a diffusing component A (diffusion flux of A) in z direction in a binary mixture
of A and B is proportional to the concentration gradient.
Therefore, the Fick's law of diffusion for species/component A in a binary mixture of A
and B for steady state diffusion in z direction can be expressed as
dCA
JA = – DAB · dz … (7.31)
where JA is the molar flux of A in the z direction relative to the molar average velocity [moles
per unit area per unit time, kmol/(m2.s)].
CA is the molar concentration of A [moles of A per unit volume, kmol/m3]
dCA
dz is the concentration gradient in the z-direction.
DAB is a proportionality constant, known as the molecular diffusivity or diffusion
coefficient for component A diffusing through B, m2/s and z is the distance in the direction of
diffusion, m.
Unit Operations – II 7.9 Diffusion
The negative sign in Equation (7.31) indicates/implies that diffusion occurs in the
direction of decrease in concentration. Thus, the term dCA/dz is –ve and the flux becomes
+ve.
Diffusivity is defined as the ratio of the flux to the corresponding concentration gradient.
The dimensions of the diffusivity are L2/θ and its unit in the SI system is m2/s. The diffusivity
of any component is a measure of its diffusive mobility and is a function of temperature,
pressure, nature, and composition.
Diffusivity increases with decrease in pressure and increases with increase in
temperature.
For a binary system in z direction, dropping the subscript z, we have
JA = CA (uA – U) … (7.32)
Equating Equations (7.31) and (7.32), we get
dCA
JA = CA (uA – U) = – DAB dz
dCA
CA uA = – DAB dz + CAU … (7.33)
According to Equation (7.12), U is given by
1
U = C (CA uA + CB uB)
CA
CA U = C (CA uA + CB uB)
CAU = xA (CA uA + CB uB)
Substituting CAU in Equation (7.33), we get
dCA
CA uA = – DAB dz + xA (CA uA + CB uB)
Using Equation (7.23), the above expression becomes
dCA
NA = – DAB dz + xA (NA + NB)
1. Steady state equimolar counter diffusion : For the steady state diffusion of two
ideal gases A and B with an equal number of moles the gases diffusing counter current to
each other (in opposite directions to each other), the flux equation for A is given by
DAB
NA = RTz (pA1 – pA2) … (7.36)
where NA is the molar flux of A in kmol/(m2.s), DAB is the diffusivity of A in B in m2/s,
z (z2 – z1) is the distance through which diffusion occurs in m and pA1 and pA2 are the partial
pressures of the component A (in Pa) at the beginning and end of the diffusion path
respectively.
We have : NA = JA + xA (NA + NB)
dCA CA
NA = – DAB dz + C (NA + NB) … (7.36 A)
From the ideal gas law, for the component A, we can write :
pA = CA RT
pA
∴ CA = RT
dpA
dCA = RT
P
C = RT … for gas as a whole
Substituting for CA, C and dCA in Equation (7.36 A), we get
DAB dpA pA
NA = – RT dz + P (NA + NB) … (7.37)
For equimolar counter diffusion,
NA = – NB = constant. Therefore, Equation (7.37) reduces to
DAB dpA
NA = – RT dz … (7.38)
If DAB is constant, then the above equation can be integrated. Therefore,
z2 pA2
DAB
NA ⌠
⌡ dz = – RT ⌠⌡ dpA
z1 pA1
– DAB
NA (z2 – z1) = RT (pA2 – pA1)
Let z2 – z1 = z. Rearranging the above equation, we get
DAB
NA = RTz (pA1 – pA2) … (7.39)
Replacing (pB2 – pB1) by (pA1 – pA2) since (pB2 – pB1) = (pA1 – pA2) in the numerator of
Equation (7.41 A) and substituting pB, M for (pB2 – pB1)/ln (pB2/pB1), we get
DAB P
NA = RTz · p (pA1 – pA2) … (7.42)
B‚ M
In this case, the flux is proportional to the concentration difference expressed in terms of
partial pressure of A and inversely proportional to the distance z and the concentration of the
stagnant gas (pB, M). Increase in z and pB, M, increases resistance to diffusion and thus, flux
decreases.
Molecular Diffusion in Liquids :
1. Steady-state equimolar counter diffusion :
We have : NA = – NB = constant
The flux equation for steady state equimolar counter diffusion for component A is
given by
DAB DAB ρ
NA = z (C A1 – C A2 ) = z Mavg. (xA1 – xA2) … (7.43)
where xA1 – xA2 is the concentration difference of component A in terms of mole fraction.
(ρ/M)avg. = Cavg. = [ρ1/M1 + ρ2/M2]/2 … (7.44)
Cavg. is the total average concentration of A and B in kmol/m3, ρ1 and ρ2 are the average
densities of the solution in kg/m3 at locations 1 and 2 respectively, and M1 and M2 are the
average molecular weights of the solution at locations 1 and 2, respectively in kg/kmol.
2. Steady state diffusion of A through nondiffusing B :
Here, we have : NA = constant, NB = 0
The flux for component A is given by
DAB
NA = z · x (ρ/M) avg. (xA1 – xA2) … (7.45)
B‚ M
where NA is the rate of diffusion of A per unit cross-section of solid. DA is the diffusivity of A
through the solid, – dCA/dz is the concentration gradient in the direction of diffusion.
Unit Operations – II 7.13 Diffusion
P = pA + pB
pA1 P
pB2
pA
p or P
pA2
pB1 pB
0 x
(b)
Fig. 7.1 : Equimolar counter diffusion of gases A and B;
(a) system, (b) concentration profile
Unit Operations – II 7.14 Diffusion
Stirring provided in each chamber keeps the concentration in each chamber uniform.
The partial pressure pA1 > pA2 and pB2 > pB1. The molecules of A diffuse to the right, while
the molecules of B diffuse to the left.
As the temperature and total pressure P is constant throughout, the net moles of A
diffusing to the right must be equal to the net moles of B diffusing to the left. If this is not so,
the total pressure would not remain constant throughout the system. This implies/indicates
that
JA = – JB … (7.49)
JA is the molar flux of component A in the x-direction due to molecular diffusion in
kmol/(m2.s).
Fick's law for component B for constant molar concentration, C, becomes
dCB
JB = – DBA dx … (7.50)
Here the flux is in the x-direction.
According to the Dalton's law, the total pressure is the sum of the partial pressures of
A and B.
∴ P = pA + pB … (7.51)
and we know that : pA ∝ CA … (7.52)
The total molar concentration for the gaseous mixture is given by
C = CA + CB … (7.53)
Differentiating both the sides of Equation (7.53) with respect to x gives
dCA d CB
0 = dx + dx … (7.54)
dCA – dCB
or dx = dx … (7.55)
Therefore, if a gradient exists in the gas A, a gradient also exists in the gas B. The
gradient of B is equal but opposite in sign to that of A.
Fick's law for component A for constant total concentration is
dCA
JA = – DAB dx … (7.56)
dCB
= – JB = – – DBA dx … (7.57)
dCA dCB
– DAB dx = DBA dx … (7.58)
Unit Operations – II 7.15 Diffusion
dCA dCB
but dx = – dt … (7.59)
∴ DAB = DBA … (7.60)
This shows that for a binary mixture of A and B, the diffusivity coefficient DAB for A
diffusing in B is the same as DBA, for B diffusing in A.
dCA
We have : JA = – DAB dx … (7.61)
For ideal gases, the molar concentration of A is related to the partial pressure of A by
NA pA
CA = V = RT … (7.62)
dCA 1 dpA
∴ dx = RT dx … (7.63)
DAB dpA
∴ JA = – RT dx … (7.64)
Integrating, we get
DAB (pA1 – pA2)
JA = RT (x – x ) … (7.65)
2 1
Equations (7.66) and (7.67) are the equations for steady state equimolar counter diffusion.
We know that
dCA dCB
dx = – dx … (7.68)
The gradient of B is equal but opposite in sign to that of A. Since the gradient for B
exists, there must be molar flux of B, as stated by Equation (7.50). Combining of Equations
(7.50), (7.56) and (7.68) gives
JA = – JB … (7.69)
This shows that the rates of diffusion are equal but in opposite directions. Equation (7.69)
is always true in the binary mixtures inspite of any other mechanism for mass transfer may be
occurring. The rates of transfer of the two species by molecular motion (diffusion) are always
equal but in opposite directions. When molecular motion is the only mechanism, the overall
transfer process is called as an equimolar counter diffusion.
Mass Transfer Coefficients :
In many mass transfer operations, the turbulent flow is desired to increase the rate of
mass transfer per unit area. In such cases, the mass transfer rate is expressed in terms of mass
transfer coefficients. In turbulent flow there are three regions of mass transfer but as it is very
Unit Operations – II 7.16 Diffusion
difficult to know the value of a distance in the turbulent region through which diffusion
occurs, it is considered that the entire resistance to mass transfer lies in a laminar sublayer of
thickness z (effective laminar film thickness). The resistance offered by the effective laminar
film thickness is approximately the same as the combined resistance offered by three regions
in turbulent motion. The flux equations for such situations are of the type :
Flux = (Mass transfer coefficient) × (Concentration difference)
As the concentration can be expressed in number of ways, we have a variety of types of
mass transfer coefficients.
Mass transfer coefficient is thus defined as the rate of mass transfer per unit area per
unit concentration difference.
The flux equation obtained for the steady state equimolar counter diffusion components
A and B diffusing at the same molar rates in opposite directions for turbulent motion
becomes
DAB
NA = RTz (pA1 – pA2) … (7.70)
G
DAB
The term RTz is constant for a given situation and it can be termed as the mass transfer
G
film coefficient for the gas and may be denoted by the symbol k'G. With this, Equation (7.70)
becomes
where zL is the effective laminar film thickness and k'L is the mass transfer film coefficient
for the liquid or the liquid film mass transfer coefficient/individual mass transfer coefficient
for the liquid phase.
Mass transfer film coefficient may be defined as the rate of mass transfer from the
bulk of one phase to an interface of unit area for a unit driving force.
Unit Operations – II 7.17 Diffusion
If H is very large, H >>1 (a case with a insoluble gas, i.e., a gas having low solubility),
1
the gas film resistance H k is negligible and the total resistance equals the liquid film
G
1
resistance k and the transfer process in such cases is considered to be liquid film
L
controlling. A typical example of this kind is absorption of CO2 in water.
1 1
KL ≈ kL
∴ KL ≈ kL
The overall mass transfer coefficients in such cases are based on the liquid film
coefficients only.
For absorption of a moderately soluble gas obeying Henry's law either KG or KL can be
used for mass transfer calculations. The absorption of sulphur dioxide in water is an example
of this type.
Interphase Mass Transfer :
In most important industrial applications of mass transfer, the material is transferred
across a phase boundary (an interface). For example, in distillation, the vapour and liquid are
brought into contact in a fractionating column and the more volatile component is transferred
from the liquid to vapour, while the less volatile component is transferred from the vapour to
liquid. In gas absorption, the solute gas is transferred from the gas to the liquid. In both of
these examples, one phase is liquid and the other is gas.
Phase : It is a homogeneous and physically distinct part of a system which is bounded by
a surface and, therefore, can be separated from the other parts of the system, e.g., water is
one phase, but ice is another phase. Phases may be liquid, solid or gaseous.
Interphase mass transfer : It is the process of mass transfer from the bulk of one phase
to the interphase surface, and then from the interphase to the bulk of another phase.
In the absorption of ammonia by water from an ammonia-air mixture, the solute
ammonia may diffuse through the gas phase and then pass through the interface between the
phases, and finally diffuse through the adjacent immiscible water phase (liquid phase).
In each phase, mass transfer occurs owing to the concentration gradient existing in that
phase and a state of equilibrium is assumed to exist at the interface between the two fluid
phases.
Interface
Gas
pA Liquid
Concentration of A
CAi
pAi
CA
Distance
Fig. 7.2
Unit Operations – II 7.20 Diffusion
by changing the conditions imposed on the system such as temperature and pressure. One
should note here that at equilibrium, the concentrations of ammonia in the two phases are not
equal but it is the chemical potential of ammonia which is the same in both the phases and it
is this equality of chemical potentials and not of concentrations, because of which the net
transfer of the solute ammonia ceases.
Mole fraction of A in gas
(yA)
Liquid film
Concentration
xAi
yAi
Gas xA
film
Distance
Fig. 7.4
Unit Operations – II 7.22 Diffusion
(iv) The theory assumes that the turbulence in the bulk fluid vanishes at the interface of
the films.
(v) The film capacity is negligible, i.e., the time taken for a concentration gradient to
establish is small compared to the time of transfer.
Consider a solute gas (A) diffusing from a gas phase into a liquid phase. There must be a
concentration gradient in the direction of mass transfer within each phase. This is shown in
Fig. 7.4 graphically in terms of distance through the phases.
The concentration of A in the bulk of gas phase is yA molefraction, and it falls to yAi at
the interface. The concentration of A in the liquid phase falls from xAi at the interface
between the phases to xA in the bulk liquid. The bulk concentrations yA and xA are not in
equilibrium because otherwise the solute will not be diffused from the gas to the liquid
phase.
Whitman assumed that the resistance to transfer of A lies in two hypothetical films, one
on each side of the interface, in which the transfer is entirely by molecular diffusion. There is
no resistance to transfer across the interface and as a result the concentrations
yAi and xAi are the equilibrium values.
For steady state mass transfer, the rate of transfer of A to the interface must be equal to
the rate at which A is transferred from the interface to the bulk of liquid phase so that there is
no accumulation or depletion of A at the interface.
Therefore, we can write the mass transfer flux of A or rate of transfer of A in terms of
mass transfer coefficients and concentration changes occurring in the phases involved.
NA = ky (yA – yAi)
= kx (xAi – xA) … (7.89)
The differences in y's and x's are the driving forces for mass transfer.
Rearranging Equation (7.89), we get
kx yA – yAi
ky = xAi – xA … (7.90)
yA – yAi kx
xA – xAi = – ky … (7.91)
Fig. 7.5 shows typical values of the concentrations of the bulk phases (P) and at the
interface (Q).
yA P
Equilibrium curve yAi = f(xAi)
of solute A in gas
Concentration
yAi Q – kx
Slope =
ky
yA*
xA xAi
Concentration
of solute A in liquid
Fig. 7.5
Unit Operations – II 7.23 Diffusion
*
where, m = slope = (y
Ai – yA ) / (xAi – xA)
1/Ky is the overall resistance to mass transfer and 1/ky and m/kx are the resistances in the
liquid and gas films. The resistances in two phases are added to get an overall resistance and
hence it is also called as two resistance theory.
*
On the similar line, xA is a measure of yA and it can be easily shown that
1 1 1
Kx = m ky + kx … (7.94)
equations for molecular transport as well as for turbulent transport and we can say that we
have analogies among these transport processes. A great deal of effort has been taken in
developing analogies (similarities) among these three transport processes for turbulent
transfer.
General Molecular Transport Equation :
The molecular transport of momentum, heat and mass is characterised by the same
general equation of the type :
Driving force
Rate of a transfer process = Resistance … (7.95)
Molecular transport or molecular diffusion equations for momentum, heat and
mass transfer :
These equations are applicable to laminar flow as molecular transport is a characteristic
of laminar/stream line flow.
Newton's law for momentum transport, i.e., Newton's equation for molecular diffusion
of momentum for constant density is
– µ d (ux ρ)
τzx = dz … (7.96)
ρ
d (ux ρ)
τzx = – ν dz … (7.97)
where τzx is the momentum transferred per unit time per unit area, where the momentum has
the units of (kg.m)/s. [It is also called as the momentum flux], µ is viscosity and ρ is the
density of fluid. ν is the kinematic viscosity and also called as the diffusivity of momentum
and has the units of m2/s.
Fourier's law for heat transport, i.e., Fourier's equation for molecular diffusion of heat
for constant ρ and Cp is
qz d (ρ CpT)
A = – α dz … (7.98)
qz
where A is the heat transferred per unit time per unit area and is called as heat flux and has
the units of W/m2 [J/(m2.s)]. α is the thermal diffusivity or diffusivity of heat in m2/s.
Fick's law of molecular mass transport or Fick's equation for molecular diffusion of mass
for constant total concentration in a fluid is
dCA
JAz = – DAB dz
d(ρA/MA)
= – DAB dz … (7.99)
where JAz is the molar flux of component A in the z direction due to molecular diffusion in
kmol A/(m2.s), DAB is the molecular diffusivity of molecule A in B or mass diffusivity in
m2/s. CA is the molar concentration of A in kmol/m3.
Unit Operations – II 7.26 Diffusion
These three equation states, respectively, that (a) the momentum transport occurs
because of a gradient in momentum concentration, (b) the energy transport occurs because of
a gradient in energy concentration, and (c) the mass transport occurs because of a gradient in
mass concentration.
Turbulent diffusion equations for momentum, heat and mass transfer :
For combined molecular and eddy transfer, the relations for momentum, heat and mass
are :
For turbulent momentum transfer for constant density, we have
d(ux ρ)
τzx = – (µ/ρ + εM) dz … (7.100)
d (ρ ux)
τzx = – (ν + εM) dz … (7.101)
For turbulent mass transfer for constant total molar concentration, we have
dCA
JAz = – (DAB + εD) dz … (7.103)
where f is the Fanning friction factor (a measure of skin friction), u is the average velocity of
'
fluid, kc is the convective mass transfer coefficient, h is the convective heat transfer
coefficient.
Equation (7.107) agrees well with the experimental data (correlates data) for gases in
turbulent flow if the Schmidt and Prandtl numbers are about unity and only the skin friction
is present in a flow past a flat plate or inside pipe. The equations do not correlate the data for
liquids in turbulent flow nor for any fluids in laminar flow, i.e., in such cases the analogy is
not valid.
Although the Reynolds analogy is of limited utility, the significant conclusion that may
be drawn is the mechanisms for momentum, heat and mass are identical at NPr = NSc = 1.0.
If a measure of the skin friction, i.e., the fanning friction factor is known, the analogy
may be used to find the heat transfer coefficient from the mass transfer coefficient and
vice-versa.
Unit Operations – II 7.28 Diffusion
SOLVED EXAMPLES
Example 7.1 : A large tank filled with a mixture of gases A and B at 101 kPa and 298 K
(25 oC) is connected to another large tank filled with a mixture of A and B of different
compositions of A and B at 101 kPa and 298 K (25 oC). The tanks are connected by a tube of
inner diameter of 50 mm and is 150 mm long. Calculate the steady state rate of transport of
A through the tube when the concentration of A in one tank is 90 mole % and in the other is
5 mole % assuming uniformity in the composition in each tank and transfer takes by
molecular diffusion. The diffusivity of A in B is 4.3 × 10–3 m2/s.
90
Solution : Mole fraction of A in tank–1 = xA1 = 100 = 0.90
5
Mole fraction of A in tank–2 = xA2 = 100 = 0.05
20
∴ xA1 = 100 = 0.20
10
xA2 = 100 = 0.10
Example 7.5 : Hydrochloric acid (A) at 283 K diffuses through a thin film of water (B).
The film is 4 mm thick. The concentration of A at location 1, on one boundary of the film, is
12 weight % (density ρ1 = 1060.7 kg/m3) and at location 2, on the other boundary, is
4 weight % (density ρ2 = 1020.15 kg/m3). The diffusivity of HCl in water is 2.5 × 10–9 m2/s.
Calculate the flux of diffusion of A assuming water to be stagnant (i.e., non-diffusing).
Solution : Molecular weight of HCl = 36.5, Molecular weight of H2O = 18
At location 1 : Mole fraction of HCl (A)
12/36.5
xA1 = 12/36.5 + (100 – 12)/18
= 0.063
We have : xA1 + xB1 = 1
∴ xB1 = 1 – 0.063
= 0.937
Average molecular weight at location-1 is
100
M1 = 12/36.5 + (100 – 12)/18
= 19.166 kg/kmol
OR : In 100 kg of HCl – water mixture, there are 12 kg of HCl and 100 – 12 = 88 kg of H2O
at location-1 (as at location-1, HCl concentration is 12 weight %).
12 88
moles of HCl = 36.5 = 0.3287 kmol, moles of H2O = 18 = 4.8888 kmol
0.1096
= 0.1096 + 5.3333 = 0.0201
xB2 = 1 – 0.0201
= 0.9799
Unit Operations – II 7.32 Diffusion
0.15
= 0.15 + 5.05
0.15
= 5.2 = 0.0288
kg of solution 100
M1 = Average molecular weight of solution = kmol of solution = 5.2 = 19.21 kg/kmol
Since xA1 + xB1 = 1
xB1 = 1 – 0.0288 = 0.9712
Unit Operations – II 7.33 Diffusion
0.95 × 10–9
= (0.0288 – 0.0092)
1 × 10–3 × 0.98
= 1.018 × 10–6 kmol/(m2.s) … Ans.
Example 7.7 : Hydrogen gas at 202.6 kPa (2 atm) and 298 K (25oC) flows through a
pipe made of unvulcanised neoprene rubber with i.d. and o.d. 25 and 50 mm, respectively.
The diffusivity of hydrogen through rubber is 1.8 × 10–6 cm2/s. Calculate the rate of loss of
hydrogen by diffusion per meter length of the pipe.
The solubility of hydrogen is 0.053 cm3 (NTP)/cm3·atm.
Solution : Consider 1 m of the pipe,
o.d. – i.d. 50 – 25
z = r2 – r1 = 2 = 2 = 12.5 mm = 0.0125 m
DA = 1.8 × 10–6 cm2/s = 1.8 × 10–10 m2/s
L = 1m
2πL (r2 – r1) 2π (1) (0.0125)
Aavg. = ln (r /r ) = ln (0.025/0.0125)
2 1
= 0.1133 m2
At 202.6 kPa (2 atm) hydrogen pressure, the solubility is
2
= 0.053 × 1 = 0.106 cm3 (NTP)/cm3
= 0.106 m3 (NTP)/m3
Unit Operations – II 7.34 Diffusion
0.106
∴ CA1 at the inner surface of the pipe = 22.4 × 1 = 4.73 × 10–3 kmol H2/m3
GAS ABSORPTION
In gas absorption, a gas phase contacts a liquid phase and mass is transferred from the
gas phase to the liquid phase (liquid solvent).
Gas absorption refers to an operation in which a gas mixture is contacted with a liquid
to preferentially dissolve one or more soluble components of the gas mixture in the liquid.
This unit operation is also termed as scrubbing. The differences in solubility of gases in a
given solvent are utilised to effect such a separation. Gas absorption is the second most
important mass transfer operation encountered in the chemical industry and is used for the
recovery or removal of the solute gas.
In absorption, the soluble component of a gas mixture is called as the solute gas, the
insoluble component is called as the inert gas or carrier gas and the liquid used for absorption
purpose is called as the solvent or absorbent. Under a given set of operating conditions, the
volatility of the solvent used is very low, so it is essentially immiscible in the gas phase. A
typical example of gas absorption is the removal of ammonia from a mixture of ammonia
and air using water as a solvent. Here, since ammonia is soluble in water, air is almost
insoluble and water does not vapourise to an appreciable extent in the gas mixture at ambient
temperature, the only transfer is of ammonia from the gas phase to the liquid phase.
The reverse of absorption is called desorption or stripping. It is an operation in which a
dissolved gas from a solution (a liquid) is removed from the liquid by contacting it with an
inert gas (i.e., a stripping medium). Therefore, the removal of sulfur dioxide from flue gases
by alkaline solutions is an example of absorption, whereas the removal of the volatile
components of oil by steam is an example of stripping.
The absorption may be a purely physical phenomenon - physical absorption, e.g.,
absorption of ammonia from a mixture of ammonia and air by water or it may be
accompanied by a chemical reaction (the transfer of a solute component to the liquid phase
and then reaction of this solute with a constituent of the liquid), e.g., absorption of NO2 in
water to produce nitric acid. Gas absorption is exothermic in nature, so this operation
demands a cooling provision and is normally carried out at low temperatures (since the
solubility of a solute gas in a given solvent is high at low temperatures).
(9.1)
Unit Operations – II 9.2 Gas Absorption
soluble when the partial pressure exerted by the dissolved gas from the solution of given
concentration is lower. Thus, oxygen is slightly soluble, while ammonia is highly soluble in
water. With water as a solvent, ammonia is very soluble gas, sulphur dioxide is moderately
soluble gas and oxygen is slightly soluble gas.
A given quantity of liquid will dissolve any amount of a slightly or more soluble gas
depending upon the partial pressure of the dissolved gas in the gas phase in contact with the
liquid. A slightly soluble (insoluble gas) gas requires a higher partial pressure of the gas in
contact with the liquid to yield the solution of a desired concentration, while a very soluble
gas requires very low partial pressure to give the solution of the same concentration.
Equilibrium condition will be reached when the partial pressure of solute gas in the gas
phase is equal to its partial pressure from the liquid phase. The equilibrium condition thus
fixes the upper limit for operation of an absorption unit.
The solubility of a gas (the concentration of a dissolved gas in the liquid at a given
temperature and pressure) is not substantially affected by the total pressure over the system
but gets influenced by the temperature. Generally, the solubility of a gas in a given solvent
decreases with increase in temperature.
In a majority of cases, the gas absorption results with the evolution of heat and solubility
falls off if provisions are not made to remove the heat evolved. Usually adequate cooling
arrangements are provided to keep the temperature sufficiently low to achieve a good rate of
absorption.
For dilute solutions of most gases, the equilibrium relationship is given by Henry's law :
pA = H · xA … (9.1)
where pA is partial pressure of the solute gas A in the gas phase
xA is mole fraction of the solute gas A in the liquid phase (the
concentration of A in terms of mole fraction)
H is the Henry's law constant.
Please refer to Equilibrium - Chapter 7 for Equilibrium in gas absorption.
Selection criteria for solvent in gas absorption :
While selecting a particular solvent for absorption operation, the following properties of
the solvent are considered :
1. Gas solubility :
The solubility of a solute gas in a solvent should be high, i.e., the solvent should have a
high capacity for dissolving the desired solute gas so that the less amount of the solvent will
be required for a given absorption duty. In general, for good solubility, a solvent of chemical
nature similar to that of the solute to be absorbed must be searched out and used.
The solvent selected should have a high solubility for the solute to be absorbed.
2. Volatility :
As the gas leaving an absorption unit is generally saturated with the solvent, there will be
a loss of the solvent with the gas leaving the unit operation. Hence, to minimise the solvent
loss (in the gas leaving), the solvent should be less volatile, i.e., it should have a low vapour
pressure under given operating conditions.
Unit Operations – II 9.4 Gas Absorption
3. Corrosive nature :
The solvent should not be corrosive (as far as possible) towards common materials of
construction so that the construction material for an absorption equipment will not be too
expensive.
4. Viscosity :
The solvent should have a low viscosity for rapid absorption rates, low pumping cost and
better heat transfer. The solvent should be non-viscous.
5. Cost and availability :
The solvent should be cheap and readily available. Losses are less costly with the cheap
solvent.
6. Miscellaneous :
The solvent should be non-toxic, non-flammable, non-foaming, and chemically stable
from a handling and storage point of view.
Material balances – One Component Transferred :
Consider a packed column as shown in Fig. 9.1. Let V1, V2 and V be the molal flow rates
of the total gas at the inlet (rich gas), outlet (lean gas) and at an arbitrary section in the
column, respectively. Let y1, y2 and y be the mole fractions of the solute gas at the respective
stations.
x2, X2, L2 V2, y2, Y2
L' V'
L, x V, y
(As in 1 mole of a gas mixture, there will be y moles of the solute gas and (1 – y) moles
of the inert gas (insoluble gas).
Equation (9.9) is the equation of the operating line for absorption operation in terms of
mole fraction and is a curve on x - y co-ordinates.
Equation (9.9) in terms of mole ratio is :
V' [Y1 – Y] = L' [X1 – X] … (9.10)
Equation (9.10) is the equation of the operating line for absorption operation. It is a
straight line on x - y co-ordinates with a slope equal to L'/V' and passes through point
(X1, Y1). The line also passes through point (X2, Y2).
Material balance of the solute gas component over the entire tower/column in terms of
L', V' and mole ratios is :
V' [Y1 – Y2] = L' [X1 – X2] … (9.11)
If the solvent used is pure/fresh, x2 = 0 and X2 = 0, then the above equation becomes
V' [Y1 – Y2] = L' (X1) … (9.12)
Minimum Liquid Gas Ratio : Refer to Fig. 9.2.
Unit Operations – II 9.6 Gas Absorption
Consider that the values of the terms V', Y1, Y2 and X2 are fixed by a process requirement
and the value of L' is decreased through the absorption tower. The operating line on X, Y
coordinates passes through the point (X2, Y2) and has a slope equal to L'/V'. As the liquid
flow rate is decreased, the slope of the operating line decreases (operating line shifts toward
the equilibrium curve) and the exist liquid composition (with respect to the solute) increases
from X' to X" as indicated by line AC. A reduction in the liquid flow rate reduces the
1 1
driving force for mass transfer and absorption becomes more and more difficult. Further
reduction in the liquid flow rate leads to a situation wherein the upper end of the operating
line touches the equilibrium curve as indicated by line AD and the exist liquid composition is
then in equilibrium with the inlet gas. Thus, the driving force for mass transfer becomes zero
at the bottom of the tower, required time of contact for the desired concentration change
becomes infinite, and an infinitely tall tower is required. The value of L'/V' corresponding to
this situation (corresponding to the line AD) represents a minimum liquid-gas ratio. If tower
is to operate practically, the liquid flow rate should be greater than that corresponding to the
minimum L'/V' ratio.
Low values of L'/V' ratio result into taller tower and hence there is an increase in the
fixed cost but the recovery cost of the solute will be low (due to small quantities of liquid).
High values of L'/V' ratio result into small tower due to favourable driving force, and hence,
there is a decrease in the fixed cost but the recovery cost of the solute will be higher.
Therefore, while selecting L'/V' ratio, a balance must be made between the fixed and the
recovery costs. In general, the operating liquid flow rate for the absorber is usually 1.1 to 1.5
times the minimum.
B C D
Y1
Operating
line for
Y minimum
L'/V' ratio
)
/V'
moles
(L'
solute Equilibrium
moles curve
inert
gas
Y2 A
X'1 X''1 X1
X2 moles X
solute
moles
solvent
Fig. 9.2 : Minimum liquid-gas ratio for absorption
Pressure drop in packed columns :
In packed columns operated in a counter current fashion, the liquid fed at the top flows
downward under the influence of gravity/gravitational force and the gas fed at the bottom of
the column is moved upward by a fluid moving machinery such as a blower or fan. So as to
Unit Operations – II 9.7 Gas Absorption
maintain the upward flow of gas, pressure at the top must be less than at the bottom. In
packed columns since the same channels are available for liquid downflow and gas upflow,
the gas pressure drop is a function of both the phase flow rates and further its knowledge is
must as it is a important factor in the design of packed towers.
In randomly packed towers, the dependency of a gas pressure drop on the gas and liquid
flow rates is similar to that shown in Fig. 9.3 wherein the pressure drop per unit height of
packed bed is plotted against the superficial gas mass velocity (mass flow rate per unit empty
tower cross-section) on logarithmic co-ordinates.
In case of dry packing (L = 0), the relationship between pressure drop and gas mass
velocity is represented by a straight line A indicating that the pressure drop is proportional to
(V/A)1.8 – 2 which is consistent with a usual law of fluid friction in turbulent flow. For wet
packing, the relationship is indicated by a straight line B similar to the line A (for dry
packing) but for a given velocity, the pressure drop will be more than that for dry packing.
If in addition to gas flow, liquid flows down the tower at a fixed gas velocity, the pressure
drop increases with increased liquid flow rate (see lines C and D) as most of the free space in
the packed bed gets occupied by the liquid, i.e., the free cross-section available for the gas
flow becomes smaller and smaller as liquid flow increases.
D C
B
Y Y A
Pressure drop
X X Dry
packing
uid igh
Liq ow te
rate
ra
H
Wet
uid
packing
Liq
L
appear at the top of packings or inversion of phases may occur (the liquid becomes the
continuous phase and the gas becomes the dispersed phase) and the entrainment of liquid by
the gas leaving the top of the tower increases rapidly and tower is then said to be flooded.
The gas velocity corresponding to the flooding conditions is called as the flooding velocity.
The point at which the liquid hold up in the column starts to increase, as indicated by a
change in the slope of the pressure drop line, it is called the loading point.
From this point onward the present drop increases more rapidly with increase in gas
velocity.
If tower is to operate practically, the operating gas mass velocity must be lower than the
flooding velocity. For safe operations, the packed towers are designed using gas velocities of
about 50 to 70 per cent of the flooding velocity at the expected liquid rate. This value
corresponds to the one somewhere below the loading point and thus, ensures stable operating
conditions.
Gas Absorption Equipments :
Various gas absorption equipments used are :
1. Mechanically agitated vessels.
2. Packed Columns/towers.
3. Plate Columns.
1. Mechanically agitated vessel :
Gas in
Gas in
Turbine
agitator
Baffle
Turbine (4 Nos)
agitator Vessel
Baffle
(4 Nos)
Sparger
Vessel
Sparger
Fig. 9.4 : Standard mechanically agitated Fig. 9.5 : Multiple impeller for deep
vessel vessels
Unit Operations – II 9.9 Gas Absorption
It is usually used in a small scale industry. This unit gives performance equivalent to one
theoretical stage. It consists of a baffled vessel usually incorporating an open or disc flat
blade turbine type agitator as it maintains very large discharge velocities normal to the gas
flow. Solvent liquid with a depth equal to the vessel diameter is taken in the vessel and gas is
introduced below the impeller through a ring shaped sparger under agitation. Adequate free
board is provided over the liquid level for the gas hold up during gas flow and ultimately the
unabsorbed gas leaves the top of the vessel. For a high absorption capacity, the operation is
carried out at low temperature and for maintaining it, a cooling coil is incorporated in the
vessel. The diameter of sparger is equal to or slightly less than that of the impeller and is
arranged with holes (3 to 6.5 mm in diameter) on top.
Deep vessels with usually two impellers are used when the time of contact required is
relatively large, wherein a large interfacial area is maintained by redispersing the gas bubble
coalesced.
2. Packed Columns/Towers :
Packed columns are most frequently used for gas absorption (and are used to a limited
extent for distillation) wherein the liquid is dispersed in the form of film and the gas flows as
a continuous phase. These are continuous contact equipments generally operated in a counter
current fashion.
Liquid in
Liquid
distributor Gas out
Packings
Gas in Perforated
support plate
Liquid out
Fig. 9.6 : Packed tower / Column for absorption
A packed column consists of a vertical cylindrical shell constructed out of metal, plastic,
ceramic, etc. and filled with suitable packings which offer a large interfacial area for gas-
liquid contact for mass transfer between the phases. A bed of the packing rests on a support
plate which offers very low resistance to gas flow. It is provided with a gas inlet and
distributing space at the bottom, a liquid inlet and a liquid distributor at the top and gas and
liquid outlets at the top and bottom. A liquid solvent is introduced from the top through the
liquid distributor (which distributes the liquid on the packing), which irrigates/wets the
Unit Operations – II 9.10 Gas Absorption
surface of packing uniformly, liquid trickles down the bed, and finally the liquid enriched in
the solute to be absorbed called a strong liquor (solute + solvent) leaves the bottom of the
column. The liquid flow rate should be sufficient for good wetting of packing. A solute-
containing gas (rich gas) is introduced from the bottom of the tower and rise upward through
the interstices/open spaces in the packing counter current to the flow of the liquid. The lean
gas (dilute gas) leaves the column from the top of the tower. In case of tall columns/towers,
liquid redistributors are used to redistribute the liquid to avoid channeling of the same (flow
the liquid along the wall).
Advantages of packed columns :
(i) Minimum structure (ii) low pressure drop (iii) low liquid hold-up (iv) handle
corrosive liquids and liquids that tends to foam (v) low initial investment and (vi) high liquid
to gas ratios.
Disadvantages of packed columns :
(i) Relatively inflexible (ii) can not operate over wide ranges of either vapour or liquid
rates per unit cross section (iii) distribution of liquid is difficult (iv) can not handle dirty
fluids that tend to deposit a sediment on packings (v) can not be used where large
temperature changes are occurred.
Packed columns are well suited for :
1. Small diameters
2. Handling highly corrosive fluids.
3. Handling liquids that tend to foam.
4. Operations where it is important to have a low pressure drop and low liquid hold up.
Tower Packings :
Many types of packings are in use ranging from simple to complex geometric shapes.
Packings are made of ceramics, metals and plastics and vary in size from 6 to 75 mm.
Characteristics of a Tower Packing :
1. It should provide a large interfacial area for phase contacting., i.e., it should have a
large wetted surface area per unit volume of packed space for high efficiencies.
2. It should provide a large void volume or empty space in the packed bed so that
reasonable throughputs of the phases are handled without excessive pressure drop.
3. It should possess good wetting characteristic.
4. It should have a high corrosion resistance.
5. It should be relatively cheap/inexpensive.
6. It should have a low bulk density so that the weight of the entire packed bed is low
which thereby reduces serious support problems.
7. It should possess enough structural strength.
8. It should be chemically inert to the fluids handled in the tower.
Unit Operations – II 9.11 Gas Absorption
Types of packings :
In order to obtain the efficient gas-liquid contact, many different types of packings are
available ranging from simple to complex geometrical shapes but are generally classified as
random packings and regular packings. If the packings are simply dumped into the tower
during installation and fall in a random fashion (the individual pieces are not arranged in any
particular pattern), they are called random packings. The packings arranged in a particular
pattern are called stacked packings.
and Intalox saddles permit a more economical tower design they are replacing older Raschig
rings and Berl saddles. Pall rings are made out of metal or plastic (poly propylene) and have
the same general form as Raschig rings with height equal to diameter, however portions of
the original cylinder wall are cut with the projections bent inward leaving holes in the wall.
They are generally available in sizes ranging from 16 to 50 mm (5/8 to 2 in).
Berl saddles and Intalox saddles are available in range 6 to 50 mm and are formed out of
plastic or ceramics. They provide more gas-liquid contacting area than the Raschig rings.
Raschig rings are hollow cylinders with their length equal to outside diameter and
usually formed out of ceramic, carbon and metal. They are generally available in a size
ranging from 6 to 100 mm 4 to 4 in . They are simple in construction and relatively cheap
1
as compared to other packings. When a single web is added to the inside of the Raschig ring,
the packing is called Lessing ring and when a cross web is added to the Raschig ring, then
the packing formed is called cross partition ring. Added webs provide additional active
surface. They are normally available in a size ranging from 75 to 150 mm (3 to 6 in) and
usually used as stacked packings. Stacked packings offer lower pressure drops for the gas
than random packings for equivalent phase flow rates.
Channeling in Packed Columns :
The tendency of the liquid to segregate towards the walls of a packed column and to flow
along the walls (a region of the greatest void space) is termed as channeling, which leads to
low mass transfer efficiencies. Thus, with a good initial liquid distribution in randomly
packed columns, channeling can be minimised by providing a tower diameter to packing size
ratio greater than 8, i.e., the diameter of the tower should be at least eight times the packing
size (or the packing size smaller than at least one-eighth of the tower diameter).
In packed columns, the region of greatest void space is the region near the wall of the
column since the packing material cannot nest tightly with the plane wall as it does with
itself. It is a natural tendency for the fluid to move toward the region of greatest void space
during its flow.
Height Equivalent to an Equilibrium stage (Theoretical Plate) :
The height equivalent to a theoretical plate (HETP) is the height of a section of packing
that will give the same separation as that achieved with one theoretical plate. The HETP is
determined experimentally and is characteristic of each packing. It depends upon the type
and size of the packing, flow rates of fluids and concentration. The height of a packed
column (i.e., the height of packing) required to effect a given degree separation is calculated
by multiplying the number of theoretical plates required to achieve the same degree of
separation by HETP.
Liquid distribution :
For maximum active surface area, the packing should be wetted completely by the
descending liquid and this can be achieved by its proper distribution. For efficient column
operation, uniform distribution of the liquid at the top of the packed bed is essential. A liquid
distributor is a device that spreads the liquid uniformly across the top of the packing. Several
types of liquid distributors used are : (1) Perforated pipe distributor; (2) Orifice-type
distributor; (3) Trough-type distributor; and (4) Weir-riser distributor.
Unit Operations – II 9.13 Gas Absorption
Support Plate :
Gas
Gas riser
Liquid Liquid
Cap type / Gas injection type
Trough type distributor Support plate
2. Plate columns by repeatedly mixing and separation provide a more positive contact
between fluid phases, whereas packed columns may lead to backmixing or by
passing.
3. Because of the difficulties arising in the dispersion of liquid in a packed tower, a
plate tower is more reliable and needs less safety factors at low liquid to gas mass
velocity ratios.
4. Side streams are very easily taken out from plate towers.
5. For plate towers, design information is generally more readily available and it is
more reliable than it for packed towers.
6. Whenever liquid mixtures containing dispersed solids are to be handled, plate towers
should be preferred as cleaning of the plate is very easy.
7. Whenever intermediate cooling arrangement is required to remove the heat of a
solution or reaction, plate towers are preferred. Cooling coils are easily incorporated
in plate towers.
8. For a given duty, the total weight of a dry plate tower is normally less than the weight
of a packed tower but weight of both towers is approximately the same if the liquid
holdup in the plate tower during the operation is taken into account.
9. For a column diameter more than 1200 mm, packed towers are seldom designed and
for a column diameter less than 600 mm, packings are cheaper than plates.
10. For liquids having tendency to foam, packed towers are usually preferred.
11. High values of liquid-gas ratio are best handled in packed towers.
12. Liquid hold-up is considerably low in packed towers so they are used in cases where
liquid deterioration might occur with high temperatures (i.e., used for handling heat-
sensitive liquids).
13. The pressure drop through a packed tower is usually low which makes the packed
tower particularly desirable for vacuum distillation operations.
14. Packed towers may be more economical than plate towers when highly corrosive
fluids are to be handled because of corrosion resistant ceramic/plastic packings.
15. Plate towers are often preferred when large temperature changes are involved, as in
distillation, thermal expansion or contraction of the equipment component may crush
the packing.
Packed columns and plate columns are the commonly used equipments for gas-liquid
operations such as distillation and gas absorption. They are also used for liquid extraction.
Comparison of packed column and plate column :
Packed columns are differential contactors wherein mass transfer occurs throughout the
length of the contactor and equilibrium is not reached at any point between the phases in
contact, whereas plate columns are stagewise contactors wherein mass transfer occurs
intermittently/stagewise and equilibrium is established between the phases at a number of
discrete stages. In packed columns, packings are used as gas-liquid contacting devices,
Unit Operations – II 9.15 Gas Absorption
whereas in plate columns, plates are used as gas-liquid containing devices. Design of a
packed column mainly involves the calculation of the height of transfer unit and number of
transfer units required to effect a given separation, whereas the design of a plate column
involves the calculation of the number of theoretical stages required to effect a given
separation Constructionwise-packed columns are simple in construction, whereas plate
columns are complex in construction. Raschig rings, pall rings, berl saddles, intalox saddles
are the various types of packings used in packed columns, whereas bubble cap plate, sieve
plate and valve plate are the various types of plates used in plate columns.
The selection of a particular type of equipment for gas-liquid operation in a particular
situation will depend upon many factors such as : efficiency, capacity, pressure drop,
corrosion, hold up, cost, etc.
SOLVED EXAMPLES
Example 9.1 : Ammonia from a ammonia-air mixture is to be absorbed in an absorption
tower using water as a solvent. Data for the absorption system is as follows :
Air flow rate – 200 kg/h
Liquid phase compositions :
At the top of packing – 0.000013 kg NH3/kg H2O
At the bottom of packing – 0.0006 kg NH3/kg H2O
Gas phase compositions :
At the bottom of packing – 0.0084 kg NH3/kg inert gas
At the top of packing – 0.0044 kg NH3/kg inert gas.
Calculate flow rate of water entering the absorption tower.
Solution : Basis : 200 kg/h of air flow to the absorption tower.
Gas out Liquid in
2% A
3
0.35 m /s V', y1, Y1
X1, L'
Moles solute
∴ Y1 = Moles inert gas (solute free gas)
= Mole ratio at the inlet
y1 0.02
Y1 = 1 – y = 1 – 0.02 = 0.020408
1
L' = molal form rate of solute free solvent to the tower in mol/s
Material balance of solute over tower :
V' [Y1 – Y2] = L' [X1 – X2]
∴ 14.7 [0.020408 – 0.0010204] = L' [0.12 – 0.005025]
∴ L' = 2.48 mol/s … Ans.
Example 9.3 : 1000 m3/h of a gas mixture containing 10 mole % solute and rest inert
enters an absorber at 300 K temperature and 106.658 kPa pressure. 90% of the original
solute is removed. Solute-free water used for absorption contains 5 mole % solute when it
leaves the absorber from the bottom. Calculate the solvent flow rate to the absorber.
Unit Operations – II 9.18 Gas Absorption
0.10
= 1 – 0.10 = 0.111
Solute in the gas entering = 0.10 × 42.76 = 4.276 kmol/h
V' = Inert gas at the inlet = 42.76 – 4.276 = 38.484 kmol/h
Given : 90% of the solute is absorbed. Therefore,
Amount of solute absorbed = 0.90 × 4.276 = 3.848 kmol/h
moles solute in gas outlet
At the outlet : Y2 = moles inert gas at outlet
0.428
= 38.484 = 0.0111
For solute-free solvent :
X2 = 0
Given : Solvent leaving the absorption tower contains 5 mole % solute. Therefore,
5
x1 = mole fraction of solute in the solvent leaving the absorption tower = 100 = 0.05.
moles solute
At the exit : X1 = moles solute free solvent
x1 0.05
= 1 – x = 1 – 0.05 = 0.0526
1
Example 9.4 : Benzene is to be recovered from cool gas by scrubbing it with wash oil as
an absorbent. The coal gas contains 2 % by volume of benzene and is to be fed at a rate of
855 m3/h and 95 % removal of benzene is required. The operating temperature and pressure
are 299.7 K (26.7o C) and 106.658 kPa. The wash oil has an average molecular weight of
260 and contains 0.005 mole fraction benzene as it enters the absorber. Calculate the
minimum circulation rate of the wash oil. The equilibrium relationship at the given
conditions is given by
Y X
1 + Y = 0.125 1 + X
where, Y – moles benzene/mole dry coal gas.
X – moles benzene/mole benzene free wash oil.
Solution : Basis : 855 m3/h of coal gas.
Assuming ideal gas behaviour, the molal flow rate of coal gas is given by
PV
n = RT
When L' (mole flow rate of benzene-free wash oil) is minimum, from the equilibrium
relationship, we can write
Y1 X1
1 + Y1 = 0.125 1 + X1
Substituting for Y1 yields
0.0204 X1
1 + 0.0204 = 0.125 1 + X1
Solving X1 = 0.1904
Material balance of benzene :
'
V' (Y1 – Y2) = Lmin (X1 – X2)
'
35.86 (0.0204 – 0.00102) = Lmin (0.1904 – 0.00503)
'
Solving, we get Lmin = 3.75 kmol/h
Flow rate (minimum) of benzene-free wash oil = 3.75 × 260 = 975 kg/h … Ans.
Example 9.5 : Benzene is to be recovered from coal gas by scrubbing it with wash oil as
an absorbent (solvent). Absorber handles 900 m3/h of coal containing 2% by volume
benzene. Coal gas enters at a temperature of 300 K (27o C) and 107.324 kPa pressure. 95%
of the benzene should be recovered by the solvent. The solvent enters at 300 K (30o C)
containing 0.005 mole fraction of benzene and has an average molecular weight of 260.
Calculate the circulation rate of oil (solvent) per hour if the column is to be operated at
1.5 times the minimum oil circulation rate.
The equilibrium relationship is :
Y X
1 + Y = 0.125 1 + X
where, Y is mole ratio of benzene to benzene-free coal gas
X is mole ratio of benzene to benzene-free solvent.
Unit Operations – II 9.21 Gas Absorption
(106.658) × 1000
n = = 42.76 kmol/h
8.31451 × 300
Unit Operations – II 9.23 Gas Absorption
x2 0.005
= 1 – x = 1 – 0.005 = 0.005025
2
y = 0.125 x
Y X
∴ 1 + Y = 0.125 1 + X
y
[as Y = 1 – y
y 1
1+Y = 1–y + 1 = 1–y
Y y
∴ 1+Y = 1 = y]
(1 – y) × (1 – y)
Unit Operations – II 9.24 Gas Absorption
'
when Lmin, molal flow rate of benzene-free wash oil that is minimum, from the
equilibrium relationship, we have
Y1 X1
1 + Y1 = 0.125 1 + X1
Substituting for Y1, we get
0.0204 X1
1 + 0.0204 = 0.125 1 + X1
∴ X1 = 0.1904
Material balance of benzene over absorber :
'
V' (Y1 – Y2) = Lmin (X1 – X2)
'
41.90 (0.00204 – 0.00102) = Lmin (0.1904 – 0.005025)
'
Lmin = 4.38 kmol/h
'
Actual benzene-free wash oil flow rate = 1.5 × Lmin = 1.5 × 4.38
= 6.57 kmol/h
Mass flow rate of benzene-free wash oil = 6.57 × Avg. Mol. Wt. of wash oil
= 6.57 × 260 = 1708.2 kg/h … Ans.
Example 9.7 : A packed tower is designed to recover 98% CO2 from a gas mixture
containing 10% CO2 and 90% by volume air using water. A relation y' = 14 x' can be used
for equilibrium conditions where,
kg CO2 kg CO2
y' is kg dry air and x' is kg water
The water to gas rate is kept 30% more than the minimum value. Calculate the actual
mole ratio of water to solute-free gas.
Solution : The gas mixture contains 10% CO2 and 90% air by volume (i.e., by mole).
Therefore,
10
y1 = mole fraction of CO2 in the mixture = 100 = 0.1
L'
L'
V' = 1.3 V'
min
= 1.3 × 8.5 = 11.05
Actual mole ratio of water to solute-free gas = 11.05 … Ans.
Example 9.8 : An air-ammonia mixture containing 5% ammonia by volume is absorbed
in water in a packed column operated at 293 K (20o C) and 101.325 kPa pressure so as to
recover 98 % ammonia. If the inert gas mass velocity to the column is 1200 kg/(m2·h),
calculate the mass velocity of water to this column if the column is operated at 1.25 times the
minimum liquid rate to the column. Also calculate the composition of liquid leaving the
column corresponding to this condition.
The equilibrium relationship is : y = 1.154 x, where x and y are mole fractions.
Solution : Basis : 1200 kg/(m2·h) of inert gas to the column.
Mol. Wt. of air = 29
V' = inert gas (air) to the column = 1200/29 = 41.38 kmol/(m2·h)
mole fraction of ammonia 5
y1 = at inlet to the column = 100 = 0.05
Y1 = 0.0526
Unit Operations – II 9.26 Gas Absorption
Composition of liquid leaving the column in terms of mole ratio = 0.0363 … Ans.
Unit Operations – II 9.27 Gas Absorption
Example 9.9 : A mixture of acetone vapour and air containing 5% acetone by volume is
to be freed of its acetone content by scrubbing it with water in an absorber. The flow rate of
the gas mixture 700 m3/h of acetone-free air measured at N.T.P. and water flow rate is
1500 kg/h. The absorber operates at an average temperature of 293 K (20 oC) and a
pressure of 101 kPa. 98% of the acetone is absorbed.
The equilibrium relationship for the acetone vapour-water system is : – Y* = 1.68 X.
where Y* = kg mole acetone/kg mole dry air
X = kg mole acetone/kg mole water.
Calculate the quantity of acetone absorbed per hour and the mean driving force for
absorption.
∆Y 1 – ∆Y 2
Hint : ∆Ylm =
ln (∆Y1/∆Y2)
∆Y1 and ∆Y2 are the driving forces at the top and bottom of the tower. ∆Y = Y – Y*
Solution : Flow rate of acetone-free air
= 700 m3/h N.T.P.
= 700/22.4 = 31.25 kmol/h
[Since 1 kmol of an ideal gas occupies a volume of 22.4 m3]
Flow rate of acetone-free water
= 1500 kg/h
= 1500/18 = 83.33 kmol/h
The mole fraction of acetone in the mixture is
y1 = 5/100 = 0.05
0.05
Y1 = y1/(1 – y1) = 1 – 0.05 = 0.0526
V'
X1 = (Y1 – Y2)
L'
31.25
= 83.33 (0.0526 – 0.00505) = 0.0193
*
∴ Y1 = 1.68 X1 = 1.68 × 0.0193 = 0.0324
*
Y2 = 1.68 X2 = 1.68 × 0 = 0.0
(0.0526 – 0.00105)
NTU = (0.0526 – 0.0324) – (0.00105 – 0)
ln (0.0526 – 0.0324) / (0.00105)
= 7.95 ≈ 8
Height of packed column = NTU × HTU = 8 × 2 = 16 m … Ans.
EXERCISES
1. Fill in the blanks :
(a) In gas absorption, mass transfer takes place from the ...... phase to the liquid phase.
Ans. gas
(b) ....... used for gas absorption should be less volatile to avoid its loss in a lean gas.
Ans. Solvent
(c) ............. are continuous gas-liquid contactors and ................. are stage-wise
contactors. Ans. Packed columns, plate columns
(d) Operating velocity in packed columns should be 50 to 70% of the .......... velocity.
Ans. flooding
(e) Packing size should not be more than 1/8th of the column ............. Ans. diameter
(f) Absorption of NO2 in water to produce nitric acid is an example of absorption with
............ Ans. chemical reaction.
(g) The tendency of the liquid to segregate towards the walls and to flow along the
walls is termed as ................ Ans. channeling
2. Define gas absorption. What for it is carried out industrially ? Give suitable
examples.
3. What factors should be considered while selecting solvent for gas absorption ?
4. State the desirable characteristics of packings.
5. List various types of packings used in industry and state their materials of
construction.
6. Explain briefly the hydrodynamics / press drop characteristics of a packed column.
7. Compare plate and packed columns for merits and demerits.
8. Draw a neat sketch of packed column and write its construction and functioning.
9. What do you mean by HETP ? State the factors on which HETP depends.