African nationalism in South Africa did not appear in the twentieth century
ex nihilo‚ but had its origins in earlier experiences of conflict‚ land
dispossession and resistance․ Donovan Williams's explanation of 1950s
militancy as the result of "150 years of turbulent history" (Williams‚ 1970:
371) remains a foundation of this debate․ A comparative history of the
Eastern Cape‚ one of the main areas of contact between Africans and
settlers‚ shows how experiences of the nineteenth-century frontier were
central to the development of later nationalisms․ The historical
importance of the Eastern Cape‚ frontier conflict and land
dispossession‚ and the diversity of African resistance contributed to the
development of an including African political consciousness manifested in
twentieth-century nationalisms․
The Eastern Cape was one of the most meaningful as the focus of the
long-term contact and conflict of Xhosa and European colonizers․ Williams
(1970: 372) has described the Eastern Frontier as a place where Black and
White attitudes towards each other were formed and hardened․ In the
twentieth century Port Elizabeth‚ East London and the Xhosa town of Alice
became the principal center of nationalism․ The combination of rural and
urban black populations‚ and the presence of mission schools such as
Lovedale and Fort Hare‚ which trained numerous African leaders‚ had
made the area particularly politically active (Williams‚ 1970: 373)․ It was
from these institutions that an educated African elite arose to play a
leading role in the formation of the ANC.
With this history‚ the Eastern Cape was seen by the ANC and other African
nationalists as a particularly important part of South Africa․ Williams called
it a "traditional area of resistance"‚ highlighting the continuity from
nineteenth-century struggles in the region‚ and the importance of its
history for twentieth-century nationalists (Williams‚ 1970: 374)․ This
suggests that nationalism was an extension of existing opposition to
colonial control rather than solely a new political development