Control Chapter 2
Control Chapter 2
Chapter 2
REPRESENTATION OF CONTROL COMPONENTS
To study the performance of control systems, it is necessary to obtain the
mathematical relationship ( ) relating the controlled variable ( ) and the actuating
signal ( ) of the forward elements. This is accomplished by first obtaining the
mathematical representation for each component and then expressing each of these
equations as a block diagram.
Operational Notation:
Operator is a symbol which indicates differentiation with respect to time,
( ) ( )
∫
Representation of Mechanical Components:
1. Mass-Spring Damper:
Mass-spring damper shown in Figure is a mechanical control ⁄
component used to control oscillations and vibrations in ⁄
machines and equipment. In which the applied total force
is input while the displacement is output. The associated
block diagram should be represented by taking the
individual components:
Spring:
The spring force required to resist deflection (distance ) is,
( )
Where, is stiffness or spring rate. Since the spring component behaves as a feedback
component, is input, is output, and is the mechanical impedance ( ). The block
diagram representation is:
Displacement Spring Force
Viscous damper: Damping force required to move X, dX/dt
one end of dashpot at velocity is, ( )
1
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
∑
Mass: Using Newton’s second law of motion, the summation of
external forces acting on a mass,
,
∑ ⁄
Since, ∑ is input, displacement is output and ( ) is mechanical impedance ( ),
∑
The block diagram representation for mass is,
Summation of External ∑ Displacement
Forces
For the whole mass-spring damper combination shown in Figure, input is the applied force
while is output. Then the overall block diagram representation,
∑
⁄
Since feedback signals have the same parallel direction, then they could be added
together (using the rule of combining blocks in parallel). The result should be compared
with the general block diagram representation for the SISO control system:
∑ ( ) ( ) ( )
⁄ ( )
( )
( )
The general mathematical differential equation of operation for SISO control system is:
( )
( ) ( )
( ) ( )
=
Then the mathematical differential equation of operation for the mass-spring damper with
absolute values of the variables is:
⁄
( ) ( )
( )⁄
Where, the total mechanical impedance for the total mass-spring damper is:
The final block diagram representation for the mass-spring damper is:
( ) ( )
2
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
The mathematical differential equation of operation is also valid for the reference
position as for the absolute positions. In which the mathematical differential equation of
operation for the absolute values is:
( )
Whereas, for the reference position is:
( )
Now we should subtract these two equations for absolute and reference positions:
( ) ( )
In which it could be expressed as a variation from the reference values. Variation in
applied force from the reference position is:
∑ ∑
M
( )
Since ( ) is input and is output,
Another way (3): Combination of Mass-spring damper could be easily recognized using the
technique of Grounded-chair Representation as shown in Figure,
Rotating Disk: The summation of external torques ∑ required to rotate a disk with
angular velocity as shown in Figure,
4
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
∑
Where, is the mass moment of inertia. Since, ∑ is input and is output
∑
Block diagram representation of rotating disk is,
∑ ⁄
The Overall block diagram representation for Torsional inertia-spring damper combination:
∑
⁄
∑ ( ) ( )
( )
⁄
( )
When it compared with the single input single output control system SISO, the
mathematical differential equation of operation for the Torsional inertia-spring damper
combination could be obtained as,
⁄
Since, is input and is output, the final block diagram representation is,
While the associated block diagram representation for each individual components are,
Overall block diagram representation for mechanical system in series combination when
force is input and displacement is output whereas springs and dampers behave as
feedback components:
∑
⁄
∑
⁄
6
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
∑ ( ) ( )
⁄ ( )
( )
When it compared with the general single input single output control system SISO, the
mathematical differential equation of operation for the mechanical system is,
2) The equation relating force and displacement and determine the transfer function.
( )
And the transfer function is,
Another way:
Equivalent Grounded-chair Representation is presented for the system to be easily
recognized. For series arrangement,
( )
Since is the total impedance,
3. Total impedance is equal to one divided by the sum of reciprocal of the individual
impedances for each element.
⁄ ⁄ ⁄
7
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
Total impedance,
⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄
Or, ( ) ( ) ( ) ( )
[ ]
⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄
Total Impedance,
⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄
2) Since,
⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄
3) Since is input and is output,
[ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ]
⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄
Final block diagram representation for this system,
⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄
Or,
⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄
To represent the overall block diagram representation, the free body diagram for
individual components,
While the associated block diagram representation for each individual components are,
8
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
⁄ ⁄
⁄ ⁄
Overall block diagram representation for mechanical system in parallel combination when
force is input and displacement is output:
Since, the feed forward signals have the same parallel direction, then they could be added
together (using the rule of combining blocks in parallel):
⁄ ⁄
⁄ ⁄
Also these two feed forward signals should be added together (using the rule of combining
blocks in parallel) to obtain the final block diagram representation for the system:
⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄
Since is input and is output, the mathematical differential equation of operation is:
⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄
Note: In parallel elements, same force is transmitted through each one. Springs and
dampers satisfy this condition because force is same on both sides. But it is not for mass
because difference in forces acting on both sides as shown in Figure a. Thus a mass
located between other elements cannot be in parallel with them. It can be in parallel only
when it is located as a last element as shown in Figure b.
( )
( )
9
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
For the system shown in Figure b, in which the force is input and the displacement is
output. To represent the overall block diagram representation, the free body diagram for
individual components,
While the associated individual block diagram representation for each individual
components are,
⁄ ⁄ ⁄
Overall block diagram representation for mechanical system in parallel combination when
force is input and displacement is output:
Using the rule of combining blocks in parallel, the final block diagram representation,
Since the force is input and the displacement is output. The mathematical differential
of operation for the system shown in Figure b,
[ ]
And,
⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄
Also for the system shown in Figure b, since the system is a series combination the
displacement can be written as:
( ) ( )
[ ]
⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄ ⁄
11
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
( )
Final block diagram representation for this system,
( )
But the overall block diagram representation for this system,
To obtain the final block diagram representation and the associated mathematical
differential equation of operation, using the rule of eliminating a feedback loop,
⁄( )
Using the rule of combining blocks in parallel to obtain the final block diagram
representation for the system:
( )
It can be easy to obtain the mathematical differential equation of operation that relating
and from the final block diagram representation,
( )
( )
Note: to determine the relationship between displacements and , for the series portion
of the Ground- Chair Representation,
( )
( )
( )
11
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
Grounded-Chair Representation:
General procedure to construct the Grounded-chair Representation is,
1. Identify the coordinates of the system.
2. Draw coordinates such that coordinate at which force acts is at the top and ground
is at the bottom.
3. Insert each individual element in its correct location with respect to these
coordinates.
Example 3: For mechanical system shown in Figure construct the equivalent Grounded-
Chair Representation and determine equations relate .Then represent the
associated overall and final block diagram.
Solution:
Equivalent Grounded-Chair representation as shown in Figure,
,
( )( )
⁄( ) ⁄( )
⁄( ) ⁄( ) ⁄( ) ⁄( )
( )( )
⁄( ) ⁄( )
[ ]
To represent the overall block diagram representation, the free body diagram for
individual components and their individual block diagram,
∑
⁄
∑
⁄
Overall block diagram representation for mechanical system combination when force is
input and displacement is output:
∑ ( )
∑
⁄
13
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
To obtain the final block diagram representation and the associated mathematical
differential equation of operation, using the rule of eliminating a feedback loop (SISO)
and the rule of combining blocks in Parallel,
∑ ∑ ( )
⁄( )
⁄( )
⁄( )
( )( ) ( )( )
When it compared with the general single input single output control system SISO, the
mathematical differential equation of operation for the mechanical system is,
( )( )
( )( )
[ ]
Whereas,
[ ] [ (
]
)
⁄( ) ⁄
The associated final block diagram representation is,
14
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
( )
⁄( ) ⁄
∑
⁄
∑
⁄
Overall block diagram representation for mechanical system combination when force is
input and displacement is output:
∑ ( )
∑
⁄
∑ ∑
⁄
15
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
To obtain the final block diagram representation and the associated mathematical
differential equation of operation, using the rule of eliminating a feedback loop (SISO),
⁄( )
∑
⁄
Using the rule of eliminating a feedback loop and the associated final block diagram,
⁄( )
( )
( )
⁄ ⁄
Since , then equation relates ,
[ ] [ ]
⁄ ⁄
Since is input and is output,
[ ]
Overall block diagram, take the free body diagram for individual components,
∑
⁄ ⁄
16
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
Using the rule of eliminating a feedback loop, the final block diagram representation for
the system:
( ⁄ )
Whereas the mathematical differential equation of operation that relating and from
the final block diagram representation,
[ ] ( )
Example 6:
For the massless lever shown in Figure, the variation applied force is and spring position
is . The horizontal line represents the reference position of the massless lever.
a) Determine the equation relating and
b) Determine the relationship between and (where is the variation applied
torque and, ).
Solution:
a) Take the moments about the pivot position ( ) (massless lever),
∑ (massless lever(
Since, and,
17
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
and , ,
( )( ) ( )( )
( )( )
And the associated final block diagram is,
( )( )
b) Since, and
( ) Then, ( )
Torque is input while angular displacement is output,
Overall block diagram, take the free body diagram for individual components,
18
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
Using the rule of combining blocks in parallel, the final block diagram representation for
the system:
( )
( )
2) Electric Inductor:
Voltage drop across Inductor with Inductance,
3) Electric Capacitor:
Voltage drop across Capacitor with Capacitance,
∫
19
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
⁄
Representation of Electric Components in Series:
Electric laws for elements arranged in series combination are,
1. Total Voltage Drop.
2. Total Current.
3. Equivalent Electric Impedance.
Mathematical differential equation of operation for circuit in series combination,
Since, ∫ , and, , ( )
Since total voltage drop is input and charge is output,
⁄ ⁄
21
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
⁄ ⁄
[ ] [ ]
⁄( ) ⁄
⁄
Final block diagram representation for circuit in parallel combination,
⁄( ⁄
)
⁄
In which is similar to mathematical mechanical equation in parallel combination,
⁄ ⁄ ⁄
⁄
21
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
The overall block diagram representation for circuit in parallel combination could be
constructed as,
⁄( ⁄ )
[ ]
⁄
⁄
Analogies:
Analogies refer to similarity for different systems like mechanical and electrical in
which their equations of operation have same form as in Table below.
System [ ]
[ ]
⁄
22
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
Viscous
Translational Spring
Force Velocity Displacement Mass Damping
Mechanical Constant
̇ Coefficient
System
Reciprocal
Electrical Voltage Current Charge Inductance Resistance of
System Capacitance
2. Inverse Analog: In inverse analog, series mechanical elements are replaced by parallel
electrical or parallel mechanical elements are replaced by series electric elements and
vice-versa. An Inverse Force-Current Analog is constructed as in Table 2.
Table 2: Analogous Quantities in an Inverse (Force-Current) Analog.
Viscous
Translational Spring
Force Velocity Displacement Mass Damping
Mechanical Constant
̇ ̇ Coefficient
System
⁄ ⁄( )
( ) ( ) ( )
( )
( ) ( )
̇
23
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
̇
( ) ( )
Final block diagram representation for translational mechanical system,
̇
( ) ( )
a) Direct (Force-Voltage) Analog:
Equivalent electrical system of Direct Force-Voltage Analog is represented as shown in
Figure using Table 1,
( ) ( )
̇
⁄ ⁄( )
Equivalent electrical differential equation of mechanical system using Table1,
( ⁄ )( ) ( ⁄ )( )
⁄( ⁄ ) ⁄( )
⁄( ⁄ ) ⁄( )
( ⁄ )( ) ( ⁄ )( )
⁄( ⁄ ) ⁄( )
Since is input and is output, then
( ⁄ )( )
Equivalent electrical final block diagram representation of direct force-voltage analog,
( ⁄ )( ) ( )
Also it could be represented by current ,
( ⁄ )( )
( ⁄ )( )
Equivalent electrical final block diagram representation of direct force-voltage analog,
̇
( ⁄ )( ) ( )
b) Inverse (Force-Current) Analog:
Equivalent electrical system of inverse force-current analog can be represented as shown
in Figure using Table 2,
24
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
Example 8: Let it be desired to determine the electrical analog for the mechanical
system shown in Figure using:
a) The direct analog.
b) The inverse analog.
Solution:
Equivalent Grounded-Chair Representation can
be constructed and the total impedance,
( )
Since,
( ) ( ⁄ )
̇
25
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
Since,
( ) [ ( ⁄ )]
̇
⁄ ( ⁄ )
( ) ( )
( ) ( )
( )
( )
( ) ( )
( ) ( )
( )
Equivalent electrical final block diagram representation of direct force-voltage analog,
( )
( ) ( )
( )
And final block diagram representation,
( ) ̇
( ) ( )
26
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
Since,
( ) [ ( ⁄ )]
̇
( ) ( )
( )
Since then,
( )
( )
( )
Equivalent electrical final block diagram representation of inverse force-current analog,
( ) ̇
( )
27
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
( )
( ) ( ) ̇
( ) ( )
Final block diagram representation for translational mechanical system,
̇
( ) ( )
Since,
( ) ( ) ̇
( ) ( )
Equivalent electrical differential equation of mechanical system using Table1,
( ) ( )
( ) ( )
28
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
( )
( )
̇
( )
( ) ( ) ̇
( ) ( )
Since,
( )
( )
29
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
̇
( )
اكتبالمعادلةهنا
To simplify the above block diagram some steps should be taken into consideration,
31
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
And the transfer function or the mathematical differential equation of operation is,
The general solution or the dynamic response for the first-order differential equation of
operation for a unit step input ( ) is,
( )
In which the response of the thermal system to a unit step input is shown in the Figure,
( ) ( )
⁄
( )
32
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
To simplify the above block diagram some steps should be taken into consideration,
1) Using the rule of eliminating a feedback loop (SISO),
33
University of Baghdad Control of Mechanical Systems College of Engineering
Mechanical Engg. Dept. 2024-2025 Assist. Prof. Dr. Karim H. Ali
And the transfer function or the mathematical differential equation of operation is,
( ⁄ )
( )
The time constant of the incompressible fluid system is, , also the steady-state
gain is, ( ⁄ ), yields the first order differential equation,
The general solution or the dynamic response for the first-order differential equation of
operation for a unit step input ( ) is, ( ) ( ). And the response is,
( ) ( )
⁄
( ) ( )
35