Financial Risk Management Notes
Financial Risk Management Notes
Exports > Imports; Accumulate gold/silver; Colonies & Thomas Mun, Jean-Baptiste
Mercantilists 16th–18th C
trade surplus Colbert
Supply creates demand (Say's Law); Free market; Full Adam Smith, David Ricardo,
Classical School 1750–1850
employment; Gold standard J.S. Mill
Concept Definition
Situation where outcomes AND their probabilities are KNOWN to the decision-maker. Linked to
Risk
uncertainty and randomness.
Uncertainty Situation where outcome probabilities are NOT known. Cannot be precisely measured.
Black Swan Unpredictable, unprecedented financial shocks — rare but high-impact. Concept by Nassim Taleb.
Formalised by Kolmogorov (1933): Model = triplet (Ω, F, P) — sample space, events, probability
Randomness
measure.
Best for Emerging risks, strategic & reputational risks Market, credit, liquidity risks
Key Rule Use for 'context' and emerging threats Use for 'precision' and regulatory compliance
■ Best Practice: Use BOTH together — qualitative for identifying & contextualising, quantitative for measuring &
reporting.
LEGEND:
Low Risk
Critical 1,5 2,5 3,5 4,5 5,5
Medium Risk
High Risk
Major 1,4 2,4 3,4 4,4 Critical 5,4
IMPACT →
Step Action
1. Identify List all potential risks: operational, financial, strategic, compliance, reputational
4. Colour-code Green = low risk | Yellow = medium | Red = high | Dark Red = critical
Step Action
5. Prioritise Focus mitigation resources on top-right (high likelihood + high impact) first
B. Delphi Method
A structured expert-consensus technique. A panel of experts answer questionnaires in multiple anonymous rounds.
Feedback is shared between rounds until consensus is reached.
Round 2 Anonymised summary shared; experts revise views Narrowed range of opinions
C. Scenario Analysis
Considers potential risks that may NOT have occurred yet but could significantly impact the organisation in the future.
Unlike pure historical analysis, it uses hypothetical 'what-if' scenarios.
Base Case Most likely outcome under normal conditions GDP grows 6%, inflation at 5%
Worst Case Pessimistic — adverse events occur simultaneously Oil at $150, INR at 95, rate hike 200bps
VaR (95%)
ES/CVaR
Tail Risk
VaR = Maximum loss at confidence level | ES = Average loss BEYOND VaR (captures tail risk)
Parametric
Assume normal distribution. VaR = Portfolio Value × ✓ Fast, mathematically elegant ✗ Fails for
(Variance-
Z-score × Volatility (σ) fat-tail distributions
Covariance)
Monte Carlo Simulate thousands of random scenarios using ✓ Handles complexity & non-linearity ✗
Simulation statistical distributions. Find 5th percentile loss. Computationally heavy; model-dependent
Ignores tail risk Tells you the cut-off loss, NOT how bad things can get BEYOND that cut-off
Assumes normal dist. Real markets have fat tails — extreme events are more frequent than normal dist predicts
Not sub-additive VaR of combined portfolio can be > sum of individual VaRs — violates diversification logic
Historical data bias Fails to capture unprecedented 'Black Swan' events like COVID-19 or 2008 crisis
C. Volatility Models
Volatility = standard deviation of returns = measure of risk. Higher volatility = more uncertainty.
Random Forest / XGBoost Credit scoring, default prediction — better than traditional logistic regression
Neural Networks (LSTM) Time-series forecasting of stock prices, volatility, and macro variables
NLP (Sentiment Analysis) Analyse news/social media to detect reputational or market risk early
Anomaly Detection Detect fraud, cybersecurity threats, unusual trading patterns in real-time
① IDENTIFY Risk registers, Delphi method, Scenario analysis Comprehensive risk inventory
② MEASURE VaR, ES/CVaR, Volatility models, Stress testing Quantified risk exposure
③ MONITOR Dashboards, Key Risk Indicators (KRIs), Heat maps Real-time risk tracking
Stage Tools Used Output
④ REPORT Regulatory filings, Board reports, Basel/RBI disclosures Compliance & transparency
1 10 5
2 12 15
3 8 -2
4 11 20
5 9 -3
E S G
ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIAL GOVERNANCE
ORIGIN
Concept introduced by the United Nations in 'Who Cares Wins' Global Compact Report (2004)
ESG requires companies to implement environmental, social, and governance principles
Source: S&P Global Ratings (2021) — 3 dimensions of sustainability in corporate affairs
3.2 India-Specific: SEBI's BRSR Mandate
Item Details
Mandatory for Top 1000 listed companies by market cap (w.e.f. FY 2022-23)
Indian Example L&T; raised ■500 Cr through India's first listed ESG bond under new SEBI norms (2025)
Workforce, Human Rights, Community, Product Employee turnover, diversity ratios, CSR
■ Social
Responsibility spend, safety incidents
Earn credits by cutting emissions below baseline; sell Rajasthan wind farm → Tata Steel buys
Carbon Credits
credits to polluters. credits
GREENIUM INSIGHT
Greenium = the 'green premium' — issuers pay LESS interest on green bonds than regular bonds
Why? ESG-focused investors accept lower yield in exchange for green certification
If Green Allocation % < 95%, bond may be 'greenwashing' — not genuinely green
Currency Mismatch Earn INR, repay USD → FX risk permanently baked into debt
Amplifies Crises When EM currencies crash, ALL USD-debt holders suffer simultaneously
Limits RBI Policy Can't cut interest rates freely — risks capital flight and rupee depreciation
Pro-cyclical Flows Capital rushes IN during boom, rushes OUT in bust — amplifying economic swings
■ NO MISMATCH
Earn USD, Owe USD Infosys, TCS — earn $25B+ in USD, borrow in USD. Safe.
(Natural Hedge)
■■ DANGEROUS Hotel in Mumbai with USD lease; Jet Airways (paid USD leases,
Earn INR, Owe USD
MISMATCH earned INR)
Earn INR, Owe INR ■ NO MISMATCH Domestic firm, domestic loan — fully matched
Currency Mismatch Ratio: = FX Liabilities / FX Assets [>1 = exposed | <1 = naturally hedged]
Tata Motors Example: USD debt $3.5B, JLR USD revenue $4.2B → ratio = 3.5/4.2 = 0.83 → Hedged ✓
Hedging Ratio: = Hedged FX Exposure / Total FX Exposure × 100% [100% = fully safe]
FX Loss (unhedged): Extra Rupee Cost = Unhedged USD Debt × Depreciation% × Spot Rate
Numeric Example: $40M unhedged, INR falls 5% from ■83 → Loss = 40M × 0.05 × 83 = ■166 Cr!
Why it looks attractive: INR bond yield: 8.5% | USD rate (SOFR + spread): 5.5% | Apparent saving: 3.0%
The catch (hedging cost): Forward premium (cost to hedge INR/USD): ~2.5%
Net saving if HEDGED: 3.0% - 2.5% = only 0.5% saving (small but real)
Risk if NOT hedged: If INR depreciates 5% → net LOSS of ~2% despite lower USD rate!
Net FCB Cost formula: = USD Rate + Spread + Forward Premium [compare with INR rate]
Large firms only Only large export/FDI-linked firms access ECBs. SMEs practically excluded.
Low hedging rate Only 30-40% of firms fully hedge. Rest are exposed to INR movements.
Natural hedgers safe IT exporters (TCS, Infosys) earn USD + borrow USD → no mismatch. Safe.
Import firms vulnerable Earn INR, pay USD for imports + debt → double exposure to FX risk.
TCS Smart Move $1B bond at 1.75% USD vs 7%+ INR rate. Earns $25B+ in USD → natural hedge.
Highest Safety AAA AAA AAA Lowest risk; strongest capacity to repay
Moderate Safety BBB BBB BBB Moderate risk; lowest investment grade
Business Risk Industry outlook, market position, competitive advantages, product diversification
Financial Risk Debt/Equity ratio, DSCR, interest coverage, cash flows, profitability
Management Quality Track record, corporate governance, succession planning, strategy clarity
Liquidity Current ratio, cash reserves, access to bank lines, debt maturity profile
Sovereign Factor Company rating cannot exceed country sovereign rating (India = BBB- by S&P;)
Standardised, exchange-traded
Commodity price risk, equity MCX Gold futures; NSE Nifty
Futures Contract contract. Marked-to-market daily.
portfolio risk 50 futures
Margin required.
SELL the asset at strike Market price < Strike price (In the Buyer: Limited loss (premium) | High gain
Put Option
price Money) Seller: Limited gain | High potential loss
Call Option Payoff: Max(S - K, 0) - Premium [where S = spot price, K = strike price]
Put Option Payoff: Max(K - S, 0) - Premium
Hedging Example: Exporter fears INR appreciation → Buy USD Put Option (right to sell USD at ■83)
Importer hedges: Fears INR depreciation → Buy USD Call Option (right to buy USD at ■83)
6.3 Interest Rate Swap — Hedging Example
A company with a floating-rate loan fears interest rates will RISE. It enters an Interest Rate Swap: pays FIXED rate,
receives FLOATING rate. Net effect: converts floating exposure to fixed — removes uncertainty.
Company B (swap
Floating SOFR+2% Fixed 7% from Company A Benefits if rates fall below 7%
party)
VaR (Parametric) VaR = Portfolio Value × Z-score × σ × √T 95% → Z=1.645 | 99% → Z=2.326
Expected Shortfall
ES = Average of all losses exceeding VaR ES > VaR always | Basel III uses ES
(ES)
Greenium Yield(Normal) - Yield(Green Bond) Positive = green bond cheaper for issuer
Green Allocation % Green Project Amount / Total Proceeds × 100 Must be > 95% to avoid greenwashing
Original Sin Index OSI = 1 - (Own-CCY bonds / Total bonds) 0 = no sin | 1 = full sin | India ≈ 0.8
Currency Mismatch
FX Liabilities / FX Assets >1 = exposed | <1 = naturally hedged
Ratio
Hedging Ratio Hedged $ / Total $ Exposure × 100% 100% = fully safe | 0% = fully exposed
FX Loss (Unhedged) Unhedged USD Debt × Depreciation% × Spot Rate In rupees — extra cost from INR fall
Net FCB Cost USD Rate + Spread + Forward Premium Compare vs INR rate to find true saving
Keynesian vs Classical Classical = market heals itself. Keynesian = market needs a doctor (govt).
VaR vs ES VaR = fence. ES = how deep is the pit beyond the fence.
You earn rupees, owe dollars. Dollar rises → you suffer more (you didn't spend more, just rate
Original Sin
changed).
Masala Bond Indian spice served abroad — rupee bond sold to foreign investors. THEY take FX risk, not us.
Greenium Green bond = discount for being eco-friendly. Issuer pays lower interest.
BRSR SEBI's report card on ESG — mandatory for top 1000 companies from FY23.
Heat Map Top-right = panic zone. Bottom-left = relax zone. Color tells the story.
Delphi Anonymous experts, multiple rounds, reach consensus. Like a secret committee vote.
Currency Mismatch Match your income currency with your debt currency. Jet Airways didn't. They collapsed.
Forward Contract Lock tomorrow's price today. No flexibility, but full protection.
Topic One-liner Memory Aid
Option Insurance policy for investors. You pay premium, you get right but not obligation.
Credit Rating AAA Safest borrower. Below BBB = junk = banks can't invest. D = already defaulted.
OSI India = 0.8 India is 80% sinful on Original Sin scale. Solution: issue more Masala Bonds.
■ History: Classical = Say's Law + full employment | Keynesian = demand, deficit, short-run
■ 9 Types of risk + one real example for each (market, credit, liquidity, operational, legal, strategic, reputational, systemic, model)
■ ES (CVaR): average loss beyond VaR, Basel III required, better than VaR for tail risk
■ Numerical: Calculate mean, variance, std deviation, CV for stocks — know which is riskier
■ ESG = UN 2004, SEBI BRSR mandatory top 1000 from FY23, 3 pillars E/S/G
■ Original Sin: OSI formula + India = 0.8 + Asian Crisis 1997 + Masala Bond solution
■ Currency Mismatch: formula + Jet Airways case + Tata Motors (hedged) case
■ FCB: Net cost = USD rate + spread + forward premium. Fully hedge or face FX loss.
■ Credit Ratings: AAA to D scale, 3 Indian CRAs, IL&FS; failure case, investment grade = BBB+
MBA Finance | MANIT Bhopal | Financial Risk Management & ESG / Green Finance
Prepared from: Lec 1 Intro to FRM | ESG Lecture 1 | Measurement of Risks | Green Finance Notes
Credit Ratings in India | Risk Mitigation using Financial Derivatives | Numerical Question Set