Topic 6 - Perfect Markets
Topic 6 - Perfect Markets
Examine the dynamics of perfect markets with the aid of cost and income
curves.
NOTE:
1. Review cost and revenue tables and curves done in Grade 11.
2. Distinguish between the short and long run.
Concepts:
Concept Description
The Competition Appeals Court Should any dispute over the
recommendations arise, it will be
referred to the Competition Appeals
Court.
The Competition Commission An institution that investigates restrictive
business practices, abuse of dominant
positions and mergers to acquire shares
in the South African economy.
The Competition Tribunal An institution with the main function to
approve major mergers, to appeal
against misconduct cases, and to issue
orders on submissions submitted by the
Competition Commission.
Economic loss Total cost is more than total income.
When average income exceeds average
cost, the business makes an economic
loss.
Economic profit Profit that is additionally made to normal
profit. When average income is higher
than average cost, the business makes
economic profit.
Explicit cost Actual expenditure of an enterprise, e.g.
wages and interest.
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
2
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
3
What is a market?
Can be defined as buyers and sellers who influence the price of a good or service.
OR
It is an institution or mechanism that brings together the buyers and sellers of a
good or a service.
OR
It exists as a result of the interaction between buyers (demand) and sellers
(supply). It is also called the market mechanism.
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
4
MC = Marginal Cost
It is the amount by which the total cost increase
when one extra unit of a product is produced.
MR = Marginal Revenue
Marginal revenue refers to the extra amount of
income earned when an additional (extra) unit of
a product is sold.
∆TR ÷∆ Q = MR
AC = Average Cost
Fixed Cost + Variable Cost = Total Cost
Total Cost ÷ Total output = AC.
Also called unit cost.
AR = Average Revenue
Average revenue refers to the amount the
enterprise earns for every unit sold.
TR ÷ Q = AR
Because TR = P x Q,
it follows that AR = PQ ÷ Q
therefore, AR = Price
P = Price
A value that will purchase a definite quantity,
weight, or other measure of a good or service.
Q = Quantity
The extent, size, or sum of countable or
measurable discrete events, objects, or
phenomenon, expressed as a numerical value.
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
5
ECONOMIC COST
Explicit cost
Explicit cost is the actual expenditure of a business on the purchase or hire of the
inputs required for the production process.
Implicit costs
Implicit costs = is the value of inputs that are owned by the entrepreneur and used in
the production process.
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
6
Homogenous product:
All the products sold in the specific market are homogenous, that is, they are
exactly the same regarding quality, appearance, etc.
It makes no difference to a buyer where or from whom he/she buys the product.
Perfect information:
Both buyers and sellers have full knowledge of all the prevailing market conditions.
For example if one business ventured to raise its price above the market price,
buyers would immediately become aware of it and would switch their purchases to
businesses who still charge the lower price.
No collusion:
Collusion between sellers does not occur.
In a perfectly competitive market, each buyer and seller acts independently from
one another.
Collusive practices are illegal in South Africa, according to the Competition Act
1998.
Unregulated market:
There is no government intervention that could affect buyers or sellers.
Decisions are left to individual sellers or producers and buyers.
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
7
Individual businesses form a small part of the market, therefore, they do not
influence market price. Individual business is a price taker.
Market price is determined by the interaction of demand and supply.
DD (demand curve) slopes downwards from top left to bottom right and SS (supply
curve) slopes upwards from bottom left to top right.
The point where demand and supply intersect, is called the equilibrium.
Individual business can offer any quantity on the market at the market price.
Business will not charge a higher price, because buyers will buy elsewhere and
they will not charge a lower price, because they can sell all their goods at the
current market price.
Sketch A Sketch B
Sketch B
Demand curve for individual business is a horizontal line at market price.
For each unit sold, business receives the same price – the market price,
Therefore P1 = AR = MR equals individual demand curve.
The average revenue the business receives is therefore equal to the market
price and the horizontal demand curve represents the average revenue curve
(AR).
The revenue from any additional unit the business sells, that is the marginal
revenue, is equal to market price P1, and the horizontal demand curve
therefore also represents the marginal revenue curve (MR).
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
8
REVENUE TABLE
Perfect market
Fixed Cost
Fixed Cost
Total Cost
Total Cost
Product /
Revenue
Revenue
Revenue
Marginal
Marginal
Average
Average
Average
Average
Variable
variable
Output
Profit
Price
Total
Total
Cost
Cost
cost
0 0 40 0 40 -40
1 35 40 28 68 40 28 68 35 28 35 35 -33
2 35 40 48 88 20 24 44 35 20 70 35 -18
3 35 40 64 104 13.33 21.33 34.66 35 16 105 35 1
4 35 40 78 118 10 19.5 29.5 35 14 140 35 22
5 35 40 90 130 8 18 26 35 12 175 35 45
6 35 40 107 147 6.67 17.83 24.5 35 17 210 35 63
7 35 40 129 169 5.71 18.42 24.13 35 22 245 35 76
8 35 40 159 199 5 19.88 24.88 35 30 280 35 81
9 35 40 199 239 4.44 22.11 26.55 35 40 315 35 76
10 35 40 253 293 4 25.3 29.3 35 54 350 35 57
11 35 40 440 480 3.64 40 43.63 35 187 385 35 -95
Profit maximisation
Between 0 and 3 units the firm makes a loss (TC is greater than TR).
At 3 units the firms economic profit is zero.
Between 3 units and 8 units the firm makes economic profit.
At 8 units the firm makes zero profit.
Beyond 8 units the firm is making a loss (TC is greater than TR)
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
9
When
MR ˃ MC (marginal revenue greater than marginal cost) = output should increase
MR = MC (marginal revenue equals marginal cost) = profit is maximized
MR ˂ MC (marginal revenue lower than marginal cost) = output should be reduced
Under perfect competition profits are maximized where SMC = MR and it is used to
derive business’s supply curve
The different market prices are taken to determine how much a business would
produce at each price.
The production determines the supply curve.
Average variable cost (AVC) consists of the per unit value of e.g. labour cost,
material cost, fuel and electricity cost, etc.
Sketch A Sketch B
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
10
Sketch A
The market price rises due to an increase in demand.
The increase in the market demand is shown as a rightward shift of the market
demand curve.
Sketch B
The horizontal demand curve for the business’ product shifts upward: Demand
= AR = MR.
The horizontal demand curve intersects the SMC at point e1, e2 and e3 (to the
right of the previous point)
Each point shows the profit maximisation point where SMC = MR.
Points e1, e2 and e3 plot business’s supply at different market prices – supply
begins at e1.
The firm’s supply starts at e1, where the AR = AVC.
The amount supplied by the business increase as price increase.
Below point e1
To the left of point e1: business cannot even cover its variable cost.
The business should close its doors.
Also known as shutdown point.
Important:
To determine the market supply, the supply curves of all the businesses are
added horizontally.
In the short term the supply curve is also called the market supply curve.
Equilibrium positions:
In a perfect market the individual business faces a perfectly horizontal demand
curve.
The market price is determined by the industry (demand and supply curves).
This means that individual businesses are price takers i.e. they are not able to
influence prices.
An individual business can increase or decrease output in order to maximize
profit.
Profit is maximized where SMC = MR.
This is the point at which profit is maximized; (loss minimized) which is known
as the equilibrium point.
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
11
THE INDUSTRY
The location and shape of the supply curve are determined by technology and the
price of factors of production.
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
12
Considerable
control over the
price of the
product, but
limited by
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
13
market demand
and the goal of
profit
maximization.
Output The demand Demand curve Demand curve Demand curve
demand curve curve for the slopes is downward is downward
for firms’ / perfect downward and sloping. sloping.
businesses competitor is it equals the
product. horizontal - market demand
(Perfectly elastic) curve
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
14
Under perfect competition the demand curve for the individual business is a
horizontal line at the market price.
To obtain maximum profits for the business, only the given market price and its
own cost structure are taken into account when determining its production output.
At point e
Horizontal demand curve represents MR and AR.
Maximum profit at point e. This is the point where SMC = MR.
It is known as the equilibrium point.
Point e = profit maximization = equilibrium
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
15
At point g
Profits are not maximized.
Businesses render revenue that is greater than the marginal cost.
MR lies above SMC.
Business Expand its production up to a point where SMC = MR on the
ascending part of the SMC.
At point h
The business makes a loss on each product when producing here and it
reduces it profits.
At point h, SMC ˃ MR (SMC more than MR)
The output unit produced at point q3 costs more to produce than the price that
will be received for it.
It does not benefit the business to produce here, because it makes a loss on
that particular unit.
At point j
Maximum losses are made here.
The business will not produce here.
It is on the descending part of the SMC.
Normal Profit
The business makes normal profit which is the minimum earnings required to
prevent the entrepreneur from closing the business and using his factors of
production elsewhere.
Equilibrium is at point e1. The business will produce at this point where SMC = MR.
At point e1, Q1 goods are produced at a price of P1.
Point e1 is the Profit Maximisation point of the business.
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
16
At point e:
Average cost is equal to price.
The SAC curve is tangent to the demand curve which means that P/AR = SAC (TR
= TC).
The firm makes only normal profits.
Economic Profit
This is a profit which is made in addition to normal profits.
This is the difference between Total Revenue and Total Cost.
E.g.
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
17
The minimum point of the SAC curve is higher than the market price P 3.
The business (firm) is in equilibrium is at point e3. The firm will produce
where SMC = MR.
At point e3, Q3 goods are produced at a price of P3.
At equilibrium (point e3) Price/AR is less than Average Cost.
The AC lies above the demand curve which means that P/AR < AC (TR < TC)
The business makes an economic loss.
E.g.
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
18
SHUTDOWN POINT
The rising part of the businesses’ MC curve above the minimum of its average
variable cost curve represents the supply curve of the business.
The supply curve starts at point A (shutdown-point) and slopes upward from there
due to the marginal cost that increases as output increases.
At a market price of P1 the business is only able to pay its variable costs.
If the market price drops below P1 the business will be forced to close down and
this point (A) is known as shutdown-point.
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
19
2. Economic profit
Suppose the business's short-term plant is represented by SAC1.
If the market price is P1 the business is making an economic profit of
P1E1FP2 with the short-term plant-size represented by SAC1.
At a price of P1 the business will maximise profit in the short-term at point E 1
where the profit maximisation (MR=MC) applies, and the quantity q 1 will be
produced.
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
20
5. Initial losses
Individual firms can be in equilibrium in the short run where it makes an
economic profit or an economic loss.
These positions, however, are not sustainable in the long run under
conditions of perfect competition.
If the market price is below the minimum point of the long-term average cost
curve, the adjustment process simply works the other way around.
Eventually the LAC curve will also form a tangent with the demand curve
and the businesses that have remained in the industry will be making
normal profit.
7. Equilibrium
Once long-term equilibrium has been achieved, and provided that there are
no changes in the technology or the factors of production, there will be no
further entry or exit of businesses.
COMPETITION POLICY
Definition
Competition policy wants to promote competition and prevent the abuse and
exploitation of economic power and instead exploit the advantages of healthy
competition to benefit the society as a whole.
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
21
The result of the above developments was the adoption of a new law, the
Competition Act 89 of 1998.
This act makes provision for a:
o Competition Commission
o Competition Tribunal
o Competition Appeals Court
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018
22
1. Competition Commission
2. Competition Tribunal
If there are any disputes over the recommendations, they are referred to the
Competition Appeal Court.
Compiled by A. Green – Metro North Education District Adapted by Economics Subject Advisers 2018