CAMBRIDGE AS LEVEL

ECONOMICS
9708
Complete Study Notes
with Exam Questions & Model Answers

■ ✍■
Full Syllabus ■ Past Paper ■
Coverage All Key Diagrams Questions Model Answers
6 AS Topics With Labels 2019–2023 A* Standard

Syllabus 9708 · Cambridge International · Covers Topics 1–6 (AS Level Only)
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

Table of Contents
Basic Economic Ideas & Resource Allocation
1 1.1–1.6: Scarcity, PPC, Economic Systems, Goods

The Price System & Microeconomy

2 2.1–2.5: Demand, Supply, Elasticity, Surplus

Government Microeconomic Intervention

3 3.1–3.3: Market Failure, Intervention, Inequality

The Macroeconomy
4 4.1–4.6: National Income, AD/AS, Growth, Unemployment, Inflation

Government Macroeconomic Intervention

5 5.1–5.4: Policy Objectives, Fiscal, Monetary, Supply-Side

International Economic Issues

6 6.1–6.5: Trade, Protectionism, BoP, Exchange Rates

Each chapter includes: Full syllabus notes · Key definitions · Diagrams · Examples · Past paper Q&As;

Page 2
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

CHAPTER 1

Basic Economic Ideas & Resource Allocation

Topics: 1.1 Scarcity & Choice | 1.2 Methodology | 1.3 Factors of Production | 1.4 Economic Systems | 1.5 PPC | 1.6 Cla

1.1 Scarcity, Choice and Opportunity Cost

The fundamental economic problem is that human wants are unlimited while resources are scarce
(finite). This forces individuals, firms, and governments to make choices about how to allocate resources.
Every choice involves a cost — the opportunity cost.

KEY DEFINITION
Scarcity: The condition where limited resources cannot satisfy all unlimited human wants, necessitating choices.

KEY DEFINITION
Opportunity Cost: The value of the next best alternative foregone when a choice is made. E.g., if a government
builds a hospital instead of a school, the opportunity cost is the school.

1.1.1 – 1.1.3 The Basic Economic Problem

• Scarcity: Resources (land, labour, capital, enterprise) are limited; wants are infinite — society must
choose.
• Choice: Choices are made at all levels — households choose what to consume; firms choose what and
how to produce; governments choose how to allocate public funds.
• Opportunity Cost: Every decision has a cost — the sacrifice of the next best option.
• Example: A student who spends time studying Economics forgoes the opportunity to work a part-time job
— that lost income is the opportunity cost.

1.1.4 Basic Questions of Resource Allocation

Every economy must answer three fundamental questions:

<b>Question</b> <b>Explanation</b> <b>Example</b>

What to produce? Which goods/services to make, given scarce

Guns
resources
vs butter (classic trade-off)

How to produce? Which production method to use — labour Use

or capital
machines
intensive?
vs workers in a factory

For whom to produce? Who gets the output? How is it distributed?Determined by income in markets, or by govt in planne

1.2 Economic Methodology

Economics uses the scientific method to study human behaviour. Economists observe the world, form
hypotheses, build models, and test them. Understanding economic methodology helps distinguish facts from

Page 3
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

opinions in economic debate.

Positive vs Normative Statements

POSITIVE STATEMENT
A positive statement is a factual, objective claim that can be tested and verified/falsified with evidence. E.g.
"Unemployment in the UK is 4.2%." or "A rise in income leads to higher demand for normal goods."

NORMATIVE STATEMENT
A normative statement involves a value judgement — it expresses an opinion about what ought to be. It cannot be
proven right or wrong. E.g. "The government should increase the minimum wage." or "Income inequality is unfair."

• Ceteris Paribus: Latin for "all other things being equal." Economists use this assumption when analysing
the effect of one variable while holding others constant. E.g., "An increase in price, ceteris paribus, will
decrease quantity demanded."
• Short Run: A time period in which at least one factor of production is fixed (e.g. capital). Firms can
change output by varying labour but not plant size.
• Long Run: All factors of production are variable. Firms can change scale of production completely.
• Very Long Run: Technology and productive capacity can change; previously fixed parameters can be
altered.
• Economics as a Social Science: Unlike natural sciences, economics studies human behaviour which is
complex and unpredictable. Controlled experiments are rarely possible, so economists rely on models
and observed data.

1.3 Factors of Production

Factors of production are the resources used to produce goods and services. They receive rewards in return
for their use.

<b>Factor</b> <b>Definition</b> <b>Reward</b> <b>Example</b>

Land All natural resources — not just land butRent

also minerals, water,
Oil air
fields, farmland, forests

Labour Human physical and mental effort usedWages/Salary

in production Factory workers, teachers, doctors

Capital Man-made resources used to produce other

Interest
goods (physical
Machinery,
capital) orcomputers,
human skills
tools
(human capital)

Enterprise The ability to combine other factors andProfit

take risks Entrepreneur who starts a business

Human Capital vs Physical Capital

• Physical Capital: Tangible, man-made assets used in production — machines, buildings, vehicles. It
depreciates over time.
• Human Capital: The stock of skills, knowledge, and experience embodied in workers, built through
education and training. Countries with high human capital tend to be more productive.

Division of Labour and Specialisation

Page 4
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

Adam Smith identified that breaking production into separate tasks (division of labour) raises efficiency
dramatically, as famously demonstrated by his pin factory example.

• Advantages: Workers become highly skilled at one task; time saved by not switching tasks; enables use
of specialised machinery; economies of scale.
• Disadvantages: Monotonous work reduces motivation; structural unemployment if a skill becomes
obsolete; interdependence — if one worker is absent, the whole line can fail; limited by size of the market.

The Entrepreneur
• The entrepreneur organises the other factors of production and bears the risk of production.
• In contemporary economies, entrepreneurs drive innovation, create new markets, and respond to
consumer demand.
• Their reward is profit (or they bear the risk of loss).

1.4 Resource Allocation in Different Economic Systems

Different economies use different mechanisms to answer the three basic questions. The main types are
market economy, planned (command) economy, and mixed economy.

<b>Feature</b> <b>Market Economy</b> <b>Planned Economy</b> <b>Mixed Economy</b>

Ownership Private ownership of resources State ownership of all resourcesMix of private and public

Decision-making Price mechanism (supply & demand)

Government planners decide Both market and government

Incentives Profit motive drives efficiency Little profit motive Profit + government objectives

Advantages Allocative efficiency, consumer sovereignty,

Equality, no innovation
wasteful competition,
Corrects
strategic
market
planning
failures while retaining efficiency

Disadvantages Market failure, inequality, public Inefficiency,

goods under-provided
no price signals, poor
Tension
qualitybetween market and govt; depends on balance

Examples USA (relatively free market) North Korea, Cuba (historically USSR)
UK, Germany, most modern economies

The Price Mechanism in a Market Economy:

• Rationing function: When goods are scarce, price rises, rationing demand to those willing and able to
pay.
• Signalling function: Rising prices signal that a product is in high demand, attracting new suppliers.
• Incentive function: High prices incentivise producers to supply more; low prices deter wasteful
production.

1.5 Production Possibility Curves (PPC)

A Production Possibility Curve (PPC) shows all the maximum combinations of two goods an economy can
produce when all resources are fully and efficiently employed. It is a model illustrating scarcity, choice, and
opportunity cost.

Page 5
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

Production Possibility Curve (PPC)

D (unattainable)

A
Good A

C (inefficient)
B

Good B
PPC

Key Points About the PPC

• Points on the PPC (e.g. A, B): Productively efficient — all resources fully employed.
• Points inside the PPC (e.g. C): Productively inefficient — resources are unemployed or underemployed
(e.g. during a recession).
• Points outside the PPC (e.g. D): Currently unattainable — beyond the economy's current productive
capacity.
• Slope (Opportunity Cost): Moving along the PPC means producing more of one good at the cost of the
other. The slope represents the opportunity cost.
• Concave shape: The PPC is normally bowed outward (concave to origin) because resources are not
perfectly substitutable — as we switch resources to produce more of Good B, increasingly more of Good
A must be given up. This reflects increasing opportunity costs.
• Straight-line PPC: If resources are perfectly substitutable between goods, opportunity cost is constant —
the PPC is a straight line.

Shifts in the PPC

• Outward shift (economic growth): Caused by discovery of new resources, improvements in technology,
better education/training (more human capital), immigration of workers, investment in capital goods.
• Inward shift: Caused by natural disasters, war, emigration, disease reducing the workforce, depletion of
natural resources.
• Importance of capital goods: An economy that produces more capital goods today (giving up consumer
goods) will have an outward shift of its PPC in the future — the basis for long-run growth.

Significance of a Position Within the PPC

A point inside the PPC indicates wasted resources — unemployment, underemployment, or inefficiency.
Policies to move the economy from inside to the frontier include stimulating aggregate demand (in the short
run) or improving productivity through supply-side policies (in the long run).

1.6 Classification of Goods and Services

<b>Type of Good</b> <b>Excludable?</b>

<b>Rival?</b> <b>Market Provision?</b>
<b>Example</b>

Private Goods Yes Yes Yes (market works) Food, clothing, cars

Public Goods No No No (free rider problem) National defence, lighthouses, street lighting

Page 6
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

Merit Goods Yes Yes Under-provided Education, healthcare, vaccinations

Demerit Goods Yes Yes Over-provided Cigarettes, alcohol, recreational drugs

Free Goods N/A N/A N/A (no scarcity) Fresh air (broadly), sunlight

• Non-excludable: Once the good is provided, no one can be excluded from benefiting. Creates the free
rider problem — people consume without paying.
• Non-rival: One person's consumption does not reduce availability for others.
• Public Good example: National defence — once provided, all citizens benefit regardless of whether they
pay tax. The government must provide it because the private sector won't (no profit motive).
• Merit Goods: Under-consumed in the free market because of imperfect information. Consumers
underestimate the benefits (e.g. vaccinations protect the community, not just the individual). Government
subsidises or provides them directly.
• Demerit Goods: Over-consumed because consumers underestimate the harmful effects or impose costs
on third parties. Government taxes them (e.g. tobacco tax) or bans them.

PAST PAPER ESSAY QUESTIONS — CHAPTER 1

PAST PAPER • 2021, Paper 2 Section B Essay Part (a) [8 marks]

Q: Explain why resources are said to be scarce and consider the implications of scarcity for resource
allocation. [8]

MODEL ANSWER

Model Answer:
• Resources are described as scarce because, at any point in time, the total supply of factors of production
— land, labour, capital and enterprise — is finite and limited. However, human wants, which are the
desires for goods and services, are considered unlimited and constantly expanding as incomes rise, new
products emerge and aspirations grow. This mismatch between limited means and unlimited ends is the
fundamental economic problem.
• The implication is that choices must be made. Since not every want can be satisfied, individuals, firms and
governments must decide how to allocate the available resources among competing uses. Every choice
involves an opportunity cost — the value of the next best alternative foregone.
• At the macro level, an economy must decide: what to produce (consumer vs capital goods), how to
produce (labour vs capital intensive methods), and for whom to produce (who receives the output). The
mechanism used depends on the type of economic system — markets use the price mechanism; planned
economies use central planning; mixed economies use both.
• Scarcity also means that all economies operate on or inside their production possibility curve (PPC).
Societies can improve their position (grow) by increasing the quantity or quality of resources, developing
new technology, or improving efficiency. However, even with growth, scarcity is never fully eliminated —
wants simply expand to fill the available resources.

PAST PAPER • 2022, Paper 2 Section B Essay Part (b) [12 marks]

Q: Assess the view that a market economy is better than a planned economy at solving the basic economic
problem. [12]

MODEL ANSWER

Page 7
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

Model Answer:
• Introduction: The basic economic problem — scarcity and the need to choose what, how and for whom to
produce — can be addressed through either the market mechanism or central planning. Each has distinct
advantages and disadvantages.
• Arguments in favour of the market economy: First, markets use the price mechanism to allocate
resources efficiently. Prices act as signals, incentives and rationing devices. When demand for a good
rises, price rises, signalling producers to increase supply. This leads to allocative efficiency — resources
flow to where they are most valued (price = marginal cost in competitive markets). Second, the profit
motive encourages productive efficiency and innovation — firms have incentives to reduce costs and
develop new products. Third, consumer sovereignty means production reflects consumer preferences,
not government planners' judgements. Fourth, markets adapt quickly to changing conditions.
• Arguments in favour of a planned economy: A planned economy can direct resources toward socially
important goods (e.g. healthcare, education, defence) that may be under-produced in markets. It can
reduce inequality by distributing goods according to need rather than ability to pay. It avoids the market
failures that arise in free markets (externalities, public goods, monopoly power). Strategic industries can
be protected and developed.
• Limitations of market economy: Markets fail in numerous ways — negative externalities (pollution),
public goods are not provided, merit goods are under-consumed, monopolies restrict output, income
inequality worsens. These failures mean the price mechanism does not always solve the economic
problem optimally.
• Limitations of planned economy: Central planners lack the information that millions of individual market
transactions would generate — the "knowledge problem" (Hayek). Prices no longer provide signals,
leading to surpluses and shortages. Bureaucracy is slow and inefficient. There is little incentive for
innovation or cost reduction. Historical evidence (Soviet Union) shows persistent inefficiency and
shortages.
• Evaluation/Conclusion: In practice, most economies are mixed — they use markets as the primary
allocation mechanism but have government intervention to correct market failures. The degree to which a
market outperforms planning depends on context: for private goods in competitive industries, markets are
clearly superior. For public goods, externalities, or income redistribution, government intervention is
necessary. The mixed economy, therefore, is widely considered the most effective approach to solving
the basic economic problem.

Page 8
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

CHAPTER 2

The Price System & Microeconomy

Topics: 2.1 Demand & Supply | 2.2 Elasticity of Demand | 2.3 Elasticity of Supply | 2.4 Interaction of D&S | 2.5 Consum

2.1 Demand and Supply Curves

The demand and supply model is the cornerstone of microeconomics. It explains how prices are determined
in markets and how resources are allocated.

Effective Demand
KEY DEFINITION
Effective Demand: The desire for a good backed by the willingness AND ability to pay. Not just wanting something,
but being able to purchase it at the prevailing market price.

Determinants of Demand (shifts in the demand curve)

The demand curve shifts when any factor other than the price of the good changes (mnemonic: PIRATES):

• Price of related goods: If price of a substitute rises → demand for our good rises. If price of a complement
falls → demand for our good rises.
• Income: For normal goods, higher income → higher demand (shift right). For inferior goods, higher income
→ lower demand (shift left).
• Related goods prices (cross-price effects): Covered under PED/XED below.
• Advertising and tastes: Successful advertising or change in fashion → higher demand.
• Taxes and subsidies: Subsidies on goods can increase consumer demand.
• Expectations: If consumers expect prices to rise, they buy more now.
• Size and structure of population: More people → more demand; ageing population changes composition
of demand.

Determinants of Supply (shifts in the supply curve)

• Costs of production: Lower wages, cheaper raw materials, lower energy costs → supply increases
(shifts right).
• Technology improvements: Better technology reduces costs → more supplied at every price.
• Taxes and subsidies: A tax on producers increases costs → supply decreases; a subsidy reduces costs
→ supply increases.
• Prices of related goods in production: If another good becomes more profitable, firms switch
production, reducing supply of the original good.
• Weather and natural events: Particularly relevant for agricultural goods.
• Number of sellers: More firms in the market → market supply increases.
• Expectations of future prices: If future price expected to be higher, firms may withhold current supply.

Page 9
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

Market Equilibrium: Demand = Supply

Price (P) S

E
P*

D
Qd/Qs
Q*

Movement Along vs Shift of Curves

• Movement along the demand curve: Caused ONLY by a change in the price of the good itself. Price
rises → contraction of demand (move up the curve); price falls → extension of demand (move down).
• Shift of the demand curve: Caused by any factor other than the price of the good. Shift right = increase
in demand; shift left = decrease in demand.
• Same principle for supply: Movement along supply curve = change in own price; shift of curve = change
in any other factor.
Increase in Demand — Curve Shifts Right

S
Price (P)

E
P*

D D2
Qd/Qs
Q*

2.2 Price, Income and Cross Elasticity of Demand

2.2.1–2.2.2 Price Elasticity of Demand (PED)

KEY DEFINITION
Price Elasticity of Demand (PED): Measures the responsiveness of quantity demanded to a change in the price of
the good.

PED = % Change in Quantity Demanded ÷ % Change in Price

Page 10
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

• PED is always negative (price and quantity demanded move in opposite directions — law of demand).
We often refer to the absolute value.
• |PED| > 1: Elastic demand — % change in Qd > % change in P. Consumers are responsive to price
changes.
• |PED| < 1: Inelastic demand — % change in Qd < % change in P. Consumers are less responsive.
• |PED| = 1: Unitary elastic — % changes are equal.
• |PED| = 0: Perfectly inelastic — quantity demanded does not respond to price changes (vertical demand
curve).
• |PED| = ∞: Perfectly elastic — any price increase causes demand to fall to zero (horizontal demand
curve).

Price Inelastic Demand (PED < 1) Price Elastic Demand (PED > 1)
P P

D D
Q Q

Factors Affecting PED

• Number and closeness of substitutes: More substitutes → more elastic. E.g. a specific brand of cola is
more elastic than all cola combined.
• Proportion of income spent: Items that take a large share of income tend to be more elastic (consumers
shop around more).
• Necessity vs luxury: Necessities (bread, insulin) are inelastic; luxuries (holidays, sports cars) are elastic.
• Addictiveness: Addictive goods (tobacco, alcohol) tend to be inelastic.
• Time period: Demand becomes more elastic over time as consumers find alternatives.
• Definition of the market: Broadly defined markets are more inelastic than narrowly defined ones.

PED and Total Revenue (TR)

TR = Price × Quantity Demanded

<b>Elasticity</b> <b>Price Rise → TR</b> <b>Price Fall → TR</b>

Elastic (PED > 1) TR falls (% fall in Q > % rise in P) TR rises

Inelastic (PED < 1) TR rises (% fall in Q < % rise in P) TR falls

Unitary (PED = 1) TR unchanged TR unchanged

Income Elasticity of Demand (YED)

Page 11
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

KEY DEFINITION
YED: Measures the responsiveness of quantity demanded to a change in consumer income. YED = % Change in Qd
÷ % Change in Income

• YED > 0 (positive): Normal good — demand rises when income rises. If YED > 1, it is a luxury (income
elastic).
• YED < 0 (negative): Inferior good — demand falls when income rises. E.g. bus travel, value supermarket
brands.
• YED between 0 and 1: Normal necessity — demand rises with income but less than proportionately.
• Implication for firms: In a recession (falling incomes), demand for inferior goods may rise while luxury
goods suffer. Useful for planning product portfolios.

Cross Elasticity of Demand (XED)

KEY DEFINITION
XED: Measures the responsiveness of quantity demanded of Good A to a change in the price of Good B. XED = %
Change in Qd of Good A ÷ % Change in Price of Good B

• XED > 0 (positive): Substitutes — goods are alternatives for each other. E.g. Pepsi and Coca-Cola. If
price of Coca-Cola rises, demand for Pepsi increases.
• XED < 0 (negative): Complements — goods consumed together. E.g. cars and petrol. If price of petrol
rises, demand for cars falls.
• XED = 0: Goods are unrelated.
• Implications: Firms can assess competitive threats (close substitutes have high positive XED) and
complementary marketing opportunities.

2.3 Price Elasticity of Supply (PES)

KEY DEFINITION
PES: Measures the responsiveness of quantity supplied to a change in the price of the good. PES = % Change in
Quantity Supplied ÷ % Change in Price. PES is always positive (price and supply move in the same direction).

• Factors affecting PES:

• Time period: Supply is more elastic in the long run (firms can build new factories, train workers, plant
crops). In the very short run (market period), supply is perfectly inelastic.
• Availability of stocks/inventories: If firms hold large stocks, they can respond quickly to price rises —
more elastic.
• Mobility of factors of production: If land, labour and capital can easily move between industries, supply
is more elastic.
• Spare capacity: If factories have unused capacity, they can increase output quickly (more elastic) without
large cost increases.

Page 12
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

• Perishability: Agricultural goods are perishable and cannot be stored — PES tends to be inelastic.
• Time to produce: Products with long production periods (e.g. housing, ships) have inelastic supply.
Implication: Industries with inelastic supply (e.g. housing) see large price rises when demand increases
because supply cannot respond quickly. Understanding PES helps firms and governments design effective
policies.

2.4 The Interaction of Demand and Supply

Equilibrium is the price at which quantity demanded equals quantity supplied. At equilibrium, the market
clears — there are no shortages or surpluses.

• Excess demand (shortage): When price is below equilibrium, Qd > Qs. Price will rise to eliminate the
shortage.
• Excess supply (surplus): When price is above equilibrium, Qs > Qd. Price will fall to eliminate the
surplus.

Relationships Between Markets

• Substitutes (alternative demand): Goods that can replace each other — e.g. butter and margarine. Rise
in price of one → rise in demand for the other. Positive XED.
• Complements (joint demand): Goods consumed together — e.g. coffee and sugar. Rise in price of one
→ fall in demand for the other. Negative XED.
• Derived demand: Demand for a factor of production depends on demand for the final good. E.g. demand
for steel is derived from demand for cars.
• Joint supply: Production of one good necessarily leads to production of another. E.g. beef and leather —
raising cattle produces both.

Functions of the Price Mechanism

• Rationing: Prices ration goods among buyers. When supply is scarce, price rises, pricing out some
consumers until quantity demanded equals the limited supply.
• Signalling: Price changes transmit information. A rising price signals high demand and profit
opportunities; a falling price signals excess supply.
• Incentivising: High prices incentivise producers to supply more and efficient producers to lower costs.
Low prices may deter entry into unprofitable markets.

2.5 Consumer and Producer Surplus

KEY DEFINITION
Consumer Surplus: The difference between the maximum price a consumer is willing to pay and the actual price
paid. It represents the benefit consumers gain from buying at the market price. Graphically, it is the area above the
price line and below the demand curve.

KEY DEFINITION
Producer Surplus: The difference between the minimum price a producer is willing to accept (their marginal cost) and
the actual price received. Graphically, it is the area below the price line and above the supply curve.

Page 13
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

• Changes in consumer surplus: A fall in price (e.g. from technological improvement) increases consumer
surplus — consumers pay less than their willingness to pay. A rise in price reduces it.
• Changes in producer surplus: A rise in price increases producer surplus. A fall reduces it.
• PED and consumer surplus: If demand is elastic, a small price rise causes a large loss in consumer
surplus (consumers reduce consumption significantly). If demand is inelastic, consumer surplus loss is
smaller.
• Total (social) welfare: Consumer surplus + Producer surplus = Total welfare. Government policies that
reduce either surplus create a deadweight welfare loss.

PAST PAPER ESSAY QUESTIONS — CHAPTER 2

PAST PAPER • 2023, Paper 2 (O/N) Section B Essay Part (a) [8 marks]

Q: Explain three reasons, associated with costs of production, why the supply curve for a particular market
may shift to the right, and consider the extent to which government microeconomic policy may also shift the
supply curve to the right. [8]
MODEL ANSWER

Model Answer:
• Reason 1 — Fall in wages: If wage rates in an industry fall (e.g. due to immigration of workers,
weakening of trade union power, or automation reducing skill requirements), the cost of labour — a key
input — decreases. Firms' marginal and average costs fall, so they are willing to supply more at every
price level, shifting the supply curve to the right.
• Reason 2 — Lower raw material costs: If the price of raw materials or energy inputs falls (e.g. falling
global oil prices reduce transport and production costs), firms' costs of production decrease. Profitability
rises at the existing market price, incentivising increased supply. The supply curve shifts right.
• Reason 3 — Improvements in technology: Technological progress (e.g. automation, more efficient
machinery) allows firms to produce more output from the same inputs. This reduces average costs at all
levels of output, shifting supply to the right. Productivity gains mean more can be produced at every price.
• Government policy: Governments can shift supply rightward through subsidies (which reduce producers'
costs), reducing regulation (which lowers compliance costs), or investment in infrastructure (which lowers
transport costs). Supply-side policies such as reducing business taxes or providing training programmes
can also reduce costs and increase supply capacity.
• Consideration/limit: However, the effectiveness depends on the size of the subsidy and market
conditions. In some markets (e.g. housing), supply remains inelastic despite subsidies because planning
regulations restrict building. Overall, government intervention can complement market forces but is
unlikely to be the most significant factor in most competitive markets.

PAST PAPER • 2023, Paper 2 (O/N) Section B Essay Part (b) [12 marks]

Q: Assess the extent to which knowledge of a product's price elasticity of supply is the most useful measure
of elasticity to a firm needing to react quickly to changes in its market. [12]

MODEL ANSWER

Model Answer:
• Introduction: Elasticity measures responsiveness. Firms face changes from multiple directions —
demand shifts, income changes, and competitor pricing. A firm that understands which elasticity matters

Page 14
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

most can respond strategically.

• Usefulness of PES: A firm with highly elastic supply can respond rapidly to price increases — quickly
expanding output to capture profit. Knowing PES tells the firm whether it can realistically increase supply
(e.g. does it have spare capacity, access to inputs, or flexible labour?). If supply is inelastic (e.g.
perishable agricultural goods, long production times), the firm cannot react quickly even if price rises —
awareness of this prevents overcommitting.
• PED is arguably more useful: PED tells a firm how consumers will respond to its pricing decisions. If a
firm knows demand is inelastic, it can raise price to increase revenue with minimal loss of sales — a
directly profitable decision. If demand is elastic, a price cut grows revenue. This is directly actionable and
financially impactful in the short run.
• YED is useful during economic cycles: If income is falling (recession), a firm selling normal goods will
see falling demand. Knowing YED helps the firm forecast sales. If it produces an inferior good, it can
actually expand. YED helps strategic planning over the business cycle.
• XED is useful for competitive response: If a rival cuts its price and XED is high, the firm will lose
significant demand. Knowledge of XED allows quick response — promotional offers or matching price
cuts. In oligopolistic markets, this is critical.
• Evaluation: For a firm needing to react quickly, PED is likely most immediately useful — it directly informs
pricing strategy and revenue outcomes in the short run. PES is useful but relates to supply-side decisions
(investment, hiring) which take time to implement and are less "quick" in their effect. YED and XED inform
medium-term strategy. The "most useful" measure depends on the type of change: if a competitor raises
prices, XED matters most; if consumer income falls, YED is key; if market price rises, PES helps assess
the response. In practice, firms should monitor all elasticities, but for quick day-to-day pricing decisions,
PED is the most directly actionable.

Page 15
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

CHAPTER 3

Government Microeconomic Intervention

Topics: 3.1 Reasons for Intervention | 3.2 Methods & Effects | 3.3 Income & Wealth Inequality

3.1 Reasons for Government Intervention in Markets

Markets fail when the price mechanism does not lead to a socially optimal allocation of resources.
Government intervention is justified on grounds of efficiency (correcting market failure) and equity
(addressing unfair distribution of income and wealth).

3.1.1 Non-provision of Public Goods

• Public goods are non-excludable and non-rival. Because consumers cannot be excluded from
consuming them, they have no incentive to pay voluntarily — the free rider problem.
• Rational individuals free-ride: enjoy the benefit without contributing to the cost. No firm can profitably
provide a public good since it cannot charge those who benefit.
• Solution: Government must provide (e.g. national defence, flood defences, street lighting) and fund it
through taxation.
• Note: Pure public goods are rare. Many goods (e.g. roads) become congested and rivalrous at high usage
levels — these are sometimes called "club goods" or "quasi-public goods".

3.1.2 Merit and Demerit Goods

• Merit goods (e.g. education, healthcare, vaccinations): Under-consumed in free markets due to imperfect
information. Consumers underestimate the private benefits and fail to account for positive externalities
(social benefits to others). The market produces less than the socially optimal quantity.
• Demerit goods (e.g. cigarettes, alcohol): Over-consumed due to imperfect information — consumers
underestimate the harm to themselves and to others (negative externalities). The market produces more
than is socially optimal.

3.1.3 Controlling Prices

• Maximum price (price ceiling): Set below equilibrium to keep goods affordable (e.g. rent controls).
Results in excess demand (shortage). Can lead to black markets, reduced quality, or under-investment.
• Minimum price (price floor): Set above equilibrium to protect producer incomes or labour (e.g. minimum
wage, agricultural price supports). Results in excess supply (surplus). In agriculture, government may
need to buy up surpluses.

3.1.4 Externalities — Market Failure

An externality occurs when the production or consumption of a good affects third parties who are not part of
the market transaction. These effects are not reflected in the market price — causing market failure.

• Negative production externality: e.g. A factory pollutes a river. Private cost < Social cost. Market
overproduces at Qm; optimal quantity is Qs < Qm. Deadweight welfare loss results.
• Positive consumption externality: e.g. Education — you studying benefits society (more skilled
workforce). Private benefit < Social benefit. Market underproduces at Qm; optimal is Qs > Qm.

Page 16
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

Negative Production Externality

MSC
P
MPC=S

Ps
Pm
DWL

MPB=MSB

Q
Qs Qm

Positive Consumption Externality

P
MPC=MSC=S

Pm
Ps
DWL

MPB
MSB
Q
Qm Qs*

3.2 Methods and Effects of Government Intervention

Indirect Taxes (Specific and Ad Valorem)

• Specific (unit) tax: A fixed amount per unit of output (e.g. £2 per packet of cigarettes). Shifts supply curve
upward by the amount of the tax. Creates a parallel upward shift.
• Ad valorem tax: A percentage of the price (e.g. 20% VAT). Shifts supply curve upward by a larger
amount at higher prices — the gap between S and S+tax widens as price increases.
• Effect: Price rises (by less than the full tax if demand is not perfectly inelastic), quantity falls. The tax
incidence (who bears the cost) depends on PED and PES. If demand is inelastic, consumers bear more;
if elastic, producers bear more.
• Example (tobacco tax): Government taxes cigarettes both to reduce consumption (demerit good) and to
raise revenue. Because demand is inelastic (addictive), revenue is substantial.

Subsidies
• Effect on supply: A subsidy reduces producers' costs, shifting the supply curve downward (to the right).
Price falls, quantity increases.
• Purpose: Used to encourage consumption of merit goods (e.g. subsidising public transport, solar panels,
education), to support domestic industries (industrial policy), or to help low-income consumers.

Page 17
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

• Problems: Costly to government (opportunity cost of public spending); may lead to overproduction; may
not reach intended beneficiaries; distorts markets; can cause trade disputes (WTO rules on subsidies).

Price Controls
<b>Type</b> <b>Set</b> <b>Immediate Effect</b>
<b>Problem</b> <b>Example</b>

Maximum Price Below equilibrium Excess demand Black markets, under-investment,

Rentqueue
controls,
rationing
food price caps
(Ceiling) (shortage)

Minimum Price Above equilibrium Excess supply Govt must buy surplus; inefficiency
Minimum wage, EU Common Agricultural Policy
(Floor) (surplus)

Regulation, Direct Provision, Tradable Permits, and Other Measures

• Regulation: Government sets legal limits on behaviour — e.g. pollution limits, minimum safety standards,
bans on certain substances. Effective but difficult to enforce, can impose compliance costs, may be
lobbied against.
• Direct provision: Government provides the good itself (e.g. NHS, state education). Ensures access
regardless of ability to pay; avoids profit motive in essential services. Can be inefficient (no competition).
• Tradable pollution permits (cap-and-trade): Government sets a cap on total emissions. Firms receive
permits and can trade them. Efficient — emission reductions happen where they are cheapest.
Market-based solution to negative externality.
• Property rights (Coase Theorem): Clearly defined property rights allow affected parties to negotiate. If
the polluter owns the river, victims can pay them to reduce pollution; or if victims own the right to clean
water, the polluter must compensate. Works in theory but high transaction costs in practice.
• Provision of information: Government can correct imperfect information — e.g. food labelling, health
warnings, financial product disclosure requirements.
• Behavioural nudges: Using behavioural economics to change behaviour without banning — e.g. making
organ donation opt-out rather than opt-in, placing healthy food at eye level in canteens.

3.3 Addressing Income and Wealth Inequality

Free markets generate inequality — those with more human/physical capital earn more. Governments
intervene to redistribute income and wealth through taxation and transfer payments.

Causes of Income and Wealth Inequality

• Differences in wages: Linked to productivity, education, skill scarcity, bargaining power.
• Unequal wealth: Inheritance, property ownership, financial assets — wealth generates further income
(dividends, rent, interest).
• Unemployment: Those without work earn no market income.
• Discrimination: Gender, racial, or age discrimination leads to lower pay.
• Geographical differences: Regional productivity and cost of living vary.

Measures of Inequality
• Lorenz Curve: Plots cumulative share of income against cumulative share of population. Greater the bow
away from the line of perfect equality, greater the inequality.
• Gini Coefficient: A number between 0 (perfect equality) and 1 (perfect inequality). Calculated from the
Lorenz curve. A Gini of 0.3 is relatively equal; 0.6 is very unequal.

Government Policies to Reduce Inequality

Page 18
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

• Progressive taxation: Higher earners pay a higher marginal rate (e.g. income tax, capital gains tax).
Reduces post-tax income inequality.
• Wealth taxes: Inheritance tax, wealth tax on assets — directly reduces wealth inequality but politically
controversial.
• Transfer payments: Benefits such as state pension, housing benefit, unemployment benefit, tax credits
— redistribute income to lower earners.
• Minimum wage: Raises the floor on earnings; reduces income inequality at the bottom of the distribution.
Risks include unemployment if set too high above equilibrium.
• Public services: Free healthcare, education, and social housing provide benefits in kind to lower-income
groups, effectively raising their real standard of living.
• Trade-offs (equity vs efficiency): High redistribution may reduce incentives to work and invest (efficiency
costs). Excessive taxation can cause brain drain, tax avoidance, and reduced economic dynamism.
Policymakers must balance equity and efficiency objectives.

PAST PAPER ESSAY QUESTIONS — CHAPTER 3

PAST PAPER • 2022, Paper 2 Section B Essay Part (a) [8 marks]

Q: With the help of examples, explain the difference between public goods and free goods and consider
whether a market economy can ever produce public goods. [8]

MODEL ANSWER

Model Answer:
• Free goods vs Public goods: A free good has no opportunity cost — it is so abundant that consuming
one unit does not reduce availability for others. Air and sunlight in most contexts are examples. They do
not require allocation since they are not scarce.
• Public goods: A public good is non-excludable (impossible to prevent non-payers from benefiting — e.g.
you cannot stop a non-taxpayer from benefiting from national defence) and non-rival (one person's
consumption does not reduce availability for others — one more citizen does not weaken the defence
system). Examples include lighthouses, flood defences, street lighting.
• The free rider problem: Because non-payers cannot be excluded, individuals have no incentive to
voluntarily pay. No firm can make profit providing the good since it cannot charge users effectively.
Therefore, private markets will not supply public goods — a classic case of market failure.
• Can markets ever provide public goods? In theory, private provision is possible if consumption can be
made excludable through technology (e.g. private roads with toll booths convert roads from
non-excludable to excludable, making them "club goods"). Subscription-funded services like private
security or private lighthouses have historically existed. However, these are impure public goods. For
pure public goods (true non-excludability and non-rivalry), the free rider problem is insurmountable and
market provision fails. Government provision financed by compulsory taxation remains the only reliable
solution.

PAST PAPER • 2022, Paper 2 Section B Essay Part (b) [12 marks]

Q: Assess the extent to which a government can ensure that both merit and demerit goods are produced in
desirable quantities. [12]
MODEL ANSWER

Model Answer:

Page 19
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

• Merit goods (under-consumption): In free markets, merit goods are under-consumed because
consumers underestimate benefits and/or positive externalities are not priced in. Government can use
subsidies to lower price and increase consumption, direct provision (NHS, state schools) to guarantee
access, regulation (compulsory education laws), or positive advertising to correct information failures.
• Demerit goods (over-consumption): Consumers overconsume demerit goods (cigarettes, alcohol) due
to imperfect information and negative externalities. Government can use indirect taxes to raise price and
reduce consumption, bans or quotas, regulation (advertising restrictions), and negative information
campaigns.
• Government success — merit goods: Compulsory schooling laws are highly effective — near 100%
enrolment in developed countries. NHS ensures healthcare is produced at social optimum regardless of
ability to pay. Vaccination programmes successfully address under-consumption with high participation
rates.
• Government success — demerit goods: Tobacco taxes have significantly reduced smoking in many
countries. Bans on advertising to children reduce demand. Alcohol minimum unit pricing (Scotland) has
reduced harmful consumption.
• Limitations and evaluation: Governments face the challenge of measuring the "socially optimal" quantity
— this requires accurate data on external costs and benefits, which is difficult to quantify. Tax levels may
be incorrect — set too low and consumption barely changes (inelastic demand for addictive goods); set
too high and black markets emerge. Direct provision may be inefficient (no competition). Subsidies have
high fiscal costs. Behavioural nudges are low-cost but may have limited impact on entrenched habits.
Cultural and individual freedom considerations limit the extent of intervention — banning alcohol entirely
has historically led to unintended consequences (U.S. Prohibition in the 1920s led to organised crime).
Overall, governments have significant tools available but achieving the precise socially optimal quantity is
difficult in practice. A combination of taxation, subsidies, regulation, and information provision is most
effective, though perfect correction of all merit and demerit good market failures remains unattainable.

Page 20
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

CHAPTER 4

The Macroeconomy
Topics: 4.1 National Income | 4.2 Circular Flow | 4.3 AD & AS | 4.4 Economic Growth | 4.5 Unemployment | 4.6 Price S

4.1 National Income Statistics

National income statistics measure the economic output and income of a country. They are essential for
assessing economic performance, comparing living standards, and informing policy.

Three Measures of National Income (all equal in theory)

• Output (GDP) method: Add the value of all goods and services produced by all industries. Use value
added at each stage to avoid double-counting.
• Income method: Add all factor incomes — wages, rent, interest, profit. Includes only income from
productive activity.
• Expenditure method: GDP = C + I + G + (X – M). Consumption + Investment + Government spending +
(Exports – Imports).
GDP = C + I + G + (X – M)

Key National Income Concepts

• GDP (Gross Domestic Product): Total value of all goods and services produced within a country's
borders in a given period, regardless of who owns the factors.
• GNP (Gross National Product) / GNI: GDP + net factor income from abroad. Includes income earned by
citizens abroad minus income earned by foreigners domestically.
• Net National Product (NNP): GNP – Depreciation (capital consumption). A more accurate measure of net
income.
• Nominal vs Real GDP: Nominal GDP is measured at current prices. Real GDP adjusts for inflation — a
better measure of actual output change.
• GDP per capita: GDP divided by population — a measure of average living standards. Better for
international comparisons.

Uses and Limitations of National Income Statistics

• Uses: Measure economic growth; compare living standards over time; compare countries; inform
government policy.
• Limitations: Ignore income distribution (high GDP with extreme inequality ≠ high welfare); exclude
hidden/informal economy; ignore unpaid work (household labour, volunteering); do not account for
environmental degradation; purchasing power differs across countries (use PPP-adjusted figures); quality
of services not captured.

4.2 Introduction to the Circular Flow of Income

Page 21
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

Circular Flow of Income

HOUSEHOLDS INCOME (wages, rent, profit, interest)

Factor services →

← Goods & services

EXPENDITURE (consumption)
FIRMS

Injections: G, I, X Withdrawals: T, S, M

The circular flow model shows how money flows between households and firms. Households provide factor
services (labour, land, capital, enterprise) and receive income. Firms produce goods/services and receive
expenditure.

Injections and Withdrawals (Leakages)

<b>Injections (J)</b> <b>Withdrawals/Leakages (W)</b>

Investment (I) — firms buying capital Saving (S) — households save income

Government spending (G) Taxation (T) — income taken by government

Exports (X) — foreign spending on domestic goods Imports (M) — spending on foreign goods

• Equilibrium condition: J = W, i.e. I + G + X = S + T + M

• If J > W: National income is rising (expansionary).
• If W > J: National income is falling (contractionary).
• The Multiplier: An initial injection into the circular flow has a multiplied effect on national income. If the
government increases spending by £1bn, total GDP may rise by more — the extra spending becomes
income for others who then spend part of it. The multiplier (k) = 1 / MPW (where MPW = marginal
propensity to withdraw = MPS + MPT + MPM).
Multiplier (k) = 1 / (1 – MPC) = 1 / MPW

4.3 Aggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply Analysis

Page 22
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

AD/AS Model

LRAS SRAS
Price Level (P)

P*

AD
Real GDP
Y*

Aggregate Demand (AD)

KEY DEFINITION
Aggregate Demand (AD): The total planned spending on goods and services in an economy at different price levels
in a given time period. AD = C + I + G + (X – M). AD curve is downward sloping.

• Why does AD slope downward? (1) Wealth effect: higher price level erodes real value of savings → less
consumption. (2) Interest rate effect: higher prices may raise interest rates → less investment. (3)
International competitiveness: higher domestic prices → exports fall, imports rise → net exports fall.
• Determinants of AD (shifts): Changes in C (consumer confidence, real incomes, interest rates, wealth,
inflation expectations); changes in I (business confidence, interest rates, corporate tax); changes in G
(fiscal policy); changes in (X–M) (exchange rates, foreign incomes, relative inflation).

Aggregate Supply (AS)

• Short-Run AS (SRAS): Upward sloping — as price level rises, firms are incentivised to produce more
(profits rise as factor costs are sticky in the short run). Shifts left if: input costs rise (wages, energy),
supply-side shocks. Shifts right if: lower input costs, improved technology, deregulation.
• Long-Run AS (LRAS) — Classical view: Vertical at the full-employment level of output (Yf). The
economy's productive capacity is determined by supply-side factors (quantity/quality of factors,
technology). LRAS shifts right with economic growth.
• Keynesian LRAS: Has three sections: (1) horizontal at low output (spare capacity, unemployment —
output can rise without inflation); (2) upward sloping as bottlenecks emerge; (3) vertical at full capacity.
Important during recession — AD stimulus is non-inflationary.

Macroeconomic Equilibrium
• Equilibrium is where AD = SRAS. This determines the equilibrium price level and real GDP.
• AD increase: Shifts AD right → higher price level + higher real GDP (in SRAS model). If at full
employment (LRAS), only price level rises — pure demand-pull inflation.
• SRAS decrease (supply shock): Cost-push inflation — price rises while output falls (stagflation).

Page 23
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

• LRAS increase (supply-side growth): Output rises, price level falls or stays constant. Sustainable
non-inflationary growth.

4.4 Economic Growth

KEY DEFINITION
Economic Growth: An increase in the productive capacity of the economy (long-run growth) or an increase in real
GDP (short-run growth). Usually measured as annual % change in real GDP.

• Short-run growth: Movement from inside to the boundary of the PPC — using idle resources. Achieved
via demand-side policies (increasing AD).
• Long-run (trend) growth: Outward shift of the PPC — increasing the productive capacity. Achieved via
supply-side policies, investment in capital, R&D;, education.
• Benefits of economic growth: Rising living standards (higher real incomes), reduced unemployment,
greater tax revenues (allows public spending), poverty reduction.
• Costs/drawbacks of growth: Environmental damage (pollution, resource depletion), increased inequality
(gains may not be evenly distributed), structural unemployment (some industries decline), inflation if
growth is too rapid, resource exhaustion.
• Actual vs potential growth: Actual growth is the year-on-year change in real GDP. Potential growth is
the growth in productive capacity. If actual growth exceeds potential → inflationary pressure (positive
output gap).

4.5 Unemployment

KEY DEFINITION
Unemployment: When people who are willing and able to work at prevailing wage rates cannot find employment.
Usually measured as the ILO measure — those actively seeking work and available to start within 2 weeks, as a %
of the labour force.

Types of Unemployment
<b>Type</b> <b>Definition</b> <b>Cause</b> <b>Policy Solution</b>

Cyclical Due to lack of aggregate demand

Recession,
in the fall
economy
in consumer/business
Expansionary
confidence
fiscal/monetary policy
(demand-deficient)

Structural Mismatch between skills of workers

Deindustrialisation,
and jobs available
technological
Retraining,
changeeducation, regional policy

Frictional Between jobs — temporary unemployment

Imperfect information,
as workers
job-search
search
Job centres,
takes time
improved information

Seasonal Demand for labour varies with

Agriculture,
the seasontourism, retail (Christmas)
Diversification, flexible labour markets

Classical Wages set above market-clearing

Minimum
levelwage above equilibrium,
Flexibletrade
wages,
unions
labour market reform
(real-wage)

Costs of Unemployment

Page 24
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

• Individual costs: Loss of income and living standards; psychological harm (stress, depression); skill
deterioration ("hysteresis").
• Firm costs: Smaller pool of skilled workers; reduced consumer demand.
• Government costs: Higher spending on benefits; lower tax revenues → fiscal deficit.
• Macroeconomic costs: Output below potential (negative output gap); reduced economic growth.

4.6 Price Stability and Inflation

KEY DEFINITION
Inflation: A sustained rise in the general price level. Measured by the Consumer Price Index (CPI) — a weighted
average of prices of a representative basket of goods and services consumed by households.

Types of Inflation
• Demand-pull inflation: Caused by excess aggregate demand — economy growing faster than productive
capacity. Firms respond to high demand by raising prices. Associated with boom conditions, low
unemployment, and a positive output gap.
• Cost-push inflation: Caused by rising production costs — e.g. oil price shocks, rising wages, supply
chain disruptions. Firms raise prices to protect margins. Can cause stagflation (inflation + recession
simultaneously).
• Built-in (wage-price spiral): Workers demand higher wages to compensate for past inflation; firms pass
higher wage costs as higher prices; fuelling further inflation.
• Imported inflation: A depreciation in the exchange rate raises the price of imports, feeding through to
domestic prices.

Costs of Inflation
• Shoe leather costs: People spend time and effort managing money (frequent bank visits) to avoid holding
depreciating cash.
• Menu costs: Firms spend resources updating prices frequently.
• Redistribution: Inflation benefits borrowers (debt erodes in real terms) and harms lenders/savers.
• Uncertainty: High and variable inflation creates uncertainty — firms delay investment; long-term contracts
difficult to price.
• International competitiveness: If domestic inflation is higher than trading partners, exports become less
competitive, worsening the current account.

Page 25
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

Short-Run Phillips Curve

Inflation (%)

SRPC
Unemployment (%)

PHILLIPS CURVE
The Phillips Curve shows the short-run trade-off between inflation and unemployment. When unemployment is low,
the labour market is tight and wages rise, pushing up inflation. When unemployment is high, wage inflation falls.
However, in the long run, the Phillips Curve is vertical at the NAIRU (Non-Accelerating Inflation Rate of
Unemployment) — there is no permanent trade-off.

PAST PAPER ESSAY QUESTIONS — CHAPTER 4

PAST PAPER • 2023, Paper 2 (O/N) Section C Essay Part (a) [8 marks]

Q: With the help of an AD/AS diagram, explain one demand-side and one supply-side cause of deflation, and
consider which is likely to be more damaging to an economy. [8]

MODEL ANSWER

Model Answer:
• Deflation: A sustained fall in the general price level (CPI falling). Can be caused by demand-side or
supply-side factors.
• Demand-side cause (AD falls): If consumer confidence collapses (e.g. following a financial crisis),
households reduce spending. AD shifts left on the AD/AS diagram. At the existing price level there is
excess supply — firms reduce prices and output. The price level falls and real GDP falls (recession).
Example: Japan in the 1990s following the asset price bubble collapse.
• Supply-side cause (AS increases): Improvements in technology or productivity increase SRAS (shifts
right). More output is produced at lower cost, so the price level falls. However, real GDP rises. This is
"benign deflation." Example: Falling prices of electronics due to technological progress.
• Which is more damaging? Demand-side deflation is far more damaging. It creates a "deflationary spiral":
falling prices → consumers delay purchases expecting further falls → AD falls further → more deflation →
businesses cut investment and jobs → unemployment rises → further falls in AD. Debt deflation also
becomes a problem — the real burden of debt rises as prices fall, increasing defaults. Supply-side
deflation, by contrast, raises real incomes and output simultaneously — it is generally beneficial.
Demand-side deflation is clearly the greater threat to macroeconomic stability.

Page 26
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

PAST PAPER • 2021, Paper 2 Section C Essay Part (b) [12 marks]

Q: Assess the extent to which the costs of unemployment are greater than the costs of inflation for an
economy. [12]

MODEL ANSWER

Model Answer:
• Costs of unemployment: Loss of real output (economy below PPC — negative output gap); reduced tax
revenues and higher welfare spending (worsens government deficit); individual suffering — loss of
income, psychological harm, skill atrophy (hysteresis); regional deprivation and social problems (crime,
health issues); skill hysteresis can permanently reduce productive capacity.
• Costs of inflation: Shoe leather costs; menu costs; reduced international competitiveness (if inflation is
higher than trading partners); redistribution from lenders to borrowers; investment uncertainty reduces
long-run growth; severe hyperinflation destroys savings and economic activity (e.g. Zimbabwe 2008).
• Unemployment is more costly in deep recessions: During severe recessions (e.g. the 2008 Global
Financial Crisis), high unemployment caused lasting damage — youth unemployment scarred a
generation, regional inequalities deepened, and hysteresis permanently removed workers from the labour
force. The human cost of mass unemployment (depression, family breakdown) is enormous and difficult
to reverse.
• Inflation is more costly when severe: Hyperinflation (e.g. Germany 1923, Zimbabwe 2008) completely
destroys economic activity, wipes out savings, and collapses trust in money. Even moderate high inflation
(above 5%) creates significant uncertainty and harms investment.
• At low rates, inflation may be preferred: Most central banks target 2% inflation — this "lubricates" the
labour market (allows real wage cuts without nominal cuts, easing unemployment). Low unemployment
(3–4%) combined with low inflation is seen as the ideal macroeconomic state.
• Evaluation/Conclusion: The relative costs depend on the rates and duration involved. Mass
unemployment (e.g. 25% as in the Great Depression) causes greater suffering and output loss than
moderate inflation. However, high inflation (above 10–20%) can be equally or more destructive. For
developed economies targeting price stability, sustainable unemployment is typically the greater and
more persistent policy concern. Overall, the costs of unemployment are generally considered greater at
the macroeconomic level, though this conclusion depends critically on the severity of each. A balanced
policy approach addressing both is superior to accepting high levels of either.

Page 27
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

CHAPTER 5

Government Macroeconomic Intervention

Topics: 5.1 Policy Objectives | 5.2 Fiscal Policy | 5.3 Monetary Policy | 5.4 Supply-Side Policy

5.1 Government Macroeconomic Policy Objectives

Governments typically pursue four main macroeconomic objectives simultaneously, though these often
conflict with one another.

<b>Objective</b> <b>Definition/Target</b> <b>Measurement</b> <b>Conflict with</b>

Economic Growth Increase in real GDP; long-run: expand

Annual %
productive
change incapacity
realPrice
GDPstability (growth may cause inflation)

Price Stability Low and stable inflation (UK: 2%CPI,

CPIRPI
target) Growth and employment (reducing inflation may cause unemploy

Full Employment Unemployment at the "natural" rate

ILO (NAIRU);
unemployment
zero cyclical
rate Price
(%) stability (lower unemployment → higher inflation — Phillips
unemployment

Balance of Payments Equilibrium

Sustainable current account position
Current
(noaccount
large persistent
balanceGrowth
deficit) GDP growth → more imports → worsens current accou
as % of(higher

5.2 Fiscal Policy

KEY DEFINITION
Fiscal Policy: Government decisions about taxation and government expenditure to manage the economy. Changes
in taxes and spending affect AD and thus output, employment and inflation.

Types of Fiscal Policy

• Expansionary fiscal policy: Increase G and/or reduce T → increases AD. Appropriate during recession
to reduce unemployment and stimulate growth. Creates or increases a fiscal deficit.
• Contractionary (restrictive) fiscal policy: Reduce G and/or increase T → reduces AD. Appropriate
when inflation is too high. Reduces or eliminates a fiscal deficit (austerity).
• Automatic stabilisers: Built-in mechanisms that automatically dampen economic fluctuations without
active policy. In a recession: unemployment benefits rise (G increases automatically) and tax revenues
fall → AD is partly maintained. In a boom: tax revenues rise, benefits fall → AD is restrained.

Direct Taxes vs Indirect Taxes

• Direct taxes (e.g. income tax, corporation tax): Levied on incomes and profits. Progressive income tax —
higher earners pay higher marginal rates. Effective at redistribution.
• Indirect taxes (e.g. VAT, excise duties): Levied on spending. Generally regressive — lower-income
earners spend a higher proportion of income on consumption.

Government Expenditure
• Capital expenditure: Investment in infrastructure (roads, hospitals, schools) — affects long-run AS as
well as short-run AD.
• Current expenditure: Day-to-day spending — public services, welfare payments.

Page 28
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

• Transfer payments: Benefits and pensions — not counted in G in AD formula (no goods/services
produced), but affect household income and consumption.

Budget Position
• Budget deficit: G > T. Government borrows to fund the shortfall. Accumulated borrowing = National Debt.
• Budget surplus: T > G. Government repays debt or builds reserves.
• Cyclical deficit: Caused by the economic cycle — normal during recession. Disappears as economy
recovers.
• Structural deficit: Exists even at full employment — indicates government is spending more than it can
sustainably fund. Requires structural reforms.

Evaluation of Fiscal Policy

• Advantages: Can be targeted at specific regions/groups; has a multiplier effect; automatic stabilisers
operate quickly; effective in liquidity trap (when monetary policy is ineffective).
• Disadvantages: Time lags (policy formation to implementation can take 12–18 months); crowding out
(government borrowing raises interest rates, displacing private investment); political constraints; may
worsen current account; large deficits raise debt sustainability concerns.

5.3 Monetary Policy

KEY DEFINITION
Monetary Policy: Government (or independent central bank) actions affecting money supply and interest rates to
influence AD, inflation, and output.

Interest Rates
• Central bank interest rate (e.g. Bank of England base rate): The rate at which commercial banks borrow
from the central bank. Affects all borrowing costs in the economy.
• Cut in interest rates (expansionary): Cheaper borrowing → increased consumption and investment (C+I
rise) → AD shifts right → economic growth and employment rise. Risk: if at full employment, causes
inflation.
• Rise in interest rates (contractionary): Borrowing more expensive → less C and I → AD shifts left →
reduces inflationary pressure. Risk: causes recession if rates are too high.
• Effect on exchange rate: Higher UK interest rates attract foreign capital (hot money flows) → pound
appreciates → exports more expensive, imports cheaper → net exports fall → AD falls (dampens inflation
further).

Quantitative Easing (QE)

• Definition: Central bank creates new money electronically and uses it to purchase financial assets
(typically government bonds) from commercial banks. Increases money supply.
• Effect: Commercial banks have more reserves → lending increases → investment rises → AD increases.
Also lowers long-term interest rates and raises asset prices (wealth effect on consumption).
• Used when: Interest rates are already at or near zero ("zero lower bound") — conventional monetary
policy is ineffective. Used extensively after 2008 GFC and during COVID-19.
• Limitations: May not stimulate lending if banks prefer to hold excess reserves; risk of future inflation; can
increase inequality (asset prices rise, benefiting wealthy).

Evaluation of Monetary Policy

Page 29
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

• Advantages: Quick to implement (Bank of England sets rate monthly); politically independent central
bank avoids short-termism; targets inflation precisely.
• Disadvantages: Time lags before effect (6–18 months); if rates already near zero, ineffective (liquidity
trap); cannot target specific sectors; exchange rate effects can harm exporters; may cause asset bubbles.

5.4 Supply-Side Policy

KEY DEFINITION
Supply-Side Policy: Policies aimed at increasing the productive capacity of the economy — shifting LRAS to the
right. Focused on improving efficiency, flexibility, and incentives in labour and product markets.

Types of Supply-Side Policies

<b>Policy</b> <b>Mechanism</b> <b>Example</b> <b>Potential Issue</b>

Labour market reforms Reduce trade union power, increase

UK Employment
wage flexibility,
Actsmake
(1980s),
hiring/firing
Reduced
zero-hours
worker
easier
contracts
protection, lower wages

Investment in education/training
Increase human capital — productive,
Apprenticeship
flexible workers
programmes,Long
university
time lag;
expansion
not all training is productive

Privatisation & deregulation

Remove govt ownership; increase
UKcompetition → efficiency
railway privatisation, financial
Natural
deregulation
monopoly problem; loss of social objectives

Reducing income tax & corporation

Increase work
taxincentives; encourage
Reaganomics
investment
(US 1980s), UK
May
corp.
not tax
trickle
cutsdown; worsens inequality

Investment in infrastructure
Improves productivity; lowers transport
HS2, Broadband
costs rollout Expensive; long-term investment needed

protection innovation → productivity

R&D support and patentEncourages Tax credits
growth
for R&D, patent law
Benefits uncertain and long-term

PAST PAPER ESSAY QUESTIONS — CHAPTER 5

PAST PAPER • 2023, Paper 2 (O/N) Section C Essay Part (b) [12 marks]

Q: Assess the extent to which using fiscal policy would be the best way to reduce a high rate of inflation. [12]

MODEL ANSWER

Model Answer:
• Fiscal policy to reduce inflation: Contractionary fiscal policy reduces AD by raising taxes or cutting
government spending. Lower AD reduces pressure on prices — especially effective against demand-pull
inflation. Higher income taxes reduce household disposable income → less consumption. Higher
corporation tax reduces investment. Cuts to G directly reduce components of AD.
• Effectiveness: In theory, precise control of AD is possible. If the government knows the size of the
inflationary gap, it can calculate the exact tax increase needed (accounting for the multiplier). Fiscal
policy has direct demand effects — particularly powerful in large economies where government spending
is a major share of GDP.
• Limitations of fiscal policy for inflation: Time lags: legislation and implementation take 12–24 months
— by which time the economic situation may have changed. Political constraints: raising taxes is
unpopular; governments may resist contractionary policy before elections. "Crowding in" effect: if fiscal
tightening coincides with private sector weakness, the policy may cause recession rather than just
reducing inflation. Not effective against cost-push inflation: if inflation is driven by rising oil prices or
supply chain disruption, reducing AD does not address the cause and may cause stagflation.

Page 30
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

• Monetary policy may be more effective: Raising interest rates through monetary policy is quick to
implement (Bank of England MPC meets monthly) and doesn't require parliamentary legislation. It directly
targets borrowing costs — reducing both consumption and investment. Most central banks primarily use
interest rates rather than fiscal policy to control inflation for these reasons. Independent central banks
also have more credibility (avoiding political short-termism).
• Supply-side policies: If inflation is cost-push, improving productivity (supply-side) is more appropriate —
shifting SRAS rightward reduces prices without the output loss of contractionary demand-side policy.
• Evaluation/Conclusion: Fiscal policy is a valid tool against demand-pull inflation but faces significant
limitations — especially time lags and political constraints. Monetary policy (interest rate rises) is
generally considered the more effective primary anti-inflation tool in modern economies, which is why
most central banks have been given inflation mandates using interest rates as their main instrument. For
supply-side inflation, neither fiscal nor monetary policy is ideal. The "best" approach depends on the type
and cause of inflation: fiscal restraint is useful to complement monetary tightening, but is rarely the best
standalone anti-inflation tool.

PAST PAPER • 2019, Paper 2 Section C Essay Part (a) [8 marks]

Q: Explain the distinction between fiscal policy and monetary policy and consider whether they can work
together to achieve macroeconomic objectives. [8]

MODEL ANSWER

Model Answer:
• Fiscal policy: Involves government decisions on taxation and public expenditure to influence AD, income
distribution, and the level of economic activity. Tools: changes in income tax, VAT, government capital
spending, welfare benefits.
• Monetary policy: Central bank management of interest rates (and sometimes money supply/QE) to
influence borrowing costs, AD, inflation and exchange rates. In the UK, the Bank of England MPC sets
the base rate to target 2% CPI inflation.
• Key distinction: Fiscal policy is government-operated and involves direct changes to expenditure and
taxes (political decisions). Monetary policy is typically operated by an independent central bank, targeting
inflation through interest rates.
• Can they work together? Yes — policy mix. During a recession: expansionary fiscal policy (tax cuts,
spending rises) + lower interest rates (monetary easing) — both shift AD right, stimulating growth. During
inflation: contractionary fiscal (tax rises, spending cuts) + higher interest rates work together to reduce
demand. Complementary use can reinforce each other's effectiveness and avoid the risk that one
instrument counteracts the other (e.g. fiscal expansion while rates are too high).
• Limitations of coordination: Institutional separation (independent central bank vs elected government)
may create conflict — government may want looser fiscal policy for electoral reasons while the Bank
raises rates to control resulting inflation. During the pandemic, unprecedented fiscal and monetary
coordination (massive fiscal deficits + QE) showed effective synergy but also raised long-term inflation
concerns.

Page 31
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

CHAPTER 6

International Economic Issues

Topics: 6.1 Reasons for Trade | 6.2 Protectionism | 6.3 Balance of Payments | 6.4 Exchange Rates | 6.5 Correcting Bo

6.1 The Reasons for International Trade

International trade allows countries to consume beyond their domestic production possibility curve by
specialising in what they produce most efficiently.

Theory of Comparative Advantage

KEY DEFINITION
Comparative Advantage: A country has a comparative advantage in producing a good if it can produce it at a lower
opportunity cost than another country. Even if one country has an absolute advantage in producing all goods, both
countries gain from specialisation and trade according to comparative advantage.

Numerical Example:

<b>Output per worker: Wheat (tons)</b>

<b>Output per worker: Cloth (metres)</b>

UK 10 5

USA 20 10

• USA has an absolute advantage in both goods (produces more of each). But:
• UK's opportunity cost of 1 ton of wheat = 0.5 metres of cloth. USA's opportunity cost of 1 ton of wheat =
0.5 metres of cloth. In this case, opportunity costs are equal — no comparative advantage. But if they
differ, gains from trade exist.
• General principle: Each country should specialise in the good with the lower opportunity cost and trade.
Both can then consume more than without trade.

Benefits of International Trade

• Increased consumption: Countries consume beyond their PPC by specialising and trading.
• Lower prices: International competition and specialisation reduce costs — consumers benefit from lower
prices.
• Economies of scale: Producing for world markets allows larger scale of production → lower average
costs.
• Access to new technologies: Trade facilitates technology transfer.
• Economic growth: Export-led growth (e.g. South Korea, China) can drive rapid development.
• Variety: Trade allows access to goods not domestically produced (e.g. tropical fruits in the UK).

Limitations of the Comparative Advantage Theory

• Assumes free trade and no transport costs: In reality, trade is subject to tariffs, quotas, and significant
transport costs.

Page 32
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

• Assumes constant opportunity costs: In practice, opportunity costs rise as more resources are devoted
to specialisation.
• Ignores externalities: Specialisation in polluting industries may not be socially beneficial.
• Factor immobility: Workers may not be able to move from declining to expanding industries easily —
structural unemployment.
• Terms of trade risk: Countries specialising in primary commodities face volatile prices and declining
terms of trade (Prebisch-Singer hypothesis).
• Dynamic comparative advantage: A country's comparative advantage can change over time — a new
country may develop lower opportunity cost industries. Infant industry argument justifies temporary
protection.

6.2 Protectionism

KEY DEFINITION
Protectionism: Government policies that restrict imports to protect domestic industries from foreign competition.

Methods of Protectionism
<b>Method</b> <b>How It Works</b> <b>Effect on Price</b> <b>Revenue to Govt?</b>

Tariff (import duty) Tax on imported goods Price of import rises; domestic firms
Yes protected

Import quota Limit on quantity of imports allowed Domestic price rises due to restricted
No (unless
supplyauctioned)

Reduces domestic firms' costs → they

Subsidy to domestic producers Domestic
undercut
price
imports
falls; import priceCosts
unchanged
govt money

Embargoes Total ban on imports from a country Eliminates imported good entirely
No

Voluntary Export Restraints

Exporting
(VERs)
country voluntarily limits exports
Domestic price rises No

Administrative barriers Excessive paperwork, safety/health Increases

standards import cost indirectly No

Arguments For and Against Protectionism

<b>Arguments FOR</b> <b>Arguments AGAINST</b>

Infant industry protection — new industries need time to develop

Reduces
scaleglobal
economies
efficiency
before
— resources
competingnot
globally
allocated to lowest opportunity cost produ

Strategic industries — defence, food security require domestic

Higher
production
consumer
regardless
prices —
of trade
comparative
barriersadvantage
reduce consumer surplus

Prevent dumping — foreign firms sell below cost to gain market

Retaliation
share (unfair
— trading
competition)
partners impose counter-tariffs, reducing trade for all

Protect employment — import competition causes structural Protection

unemployment
may entrench inefficiency — domestic firms have no incentive to improve

Correct balance of payments deficit — reduce imports to improve

Harmscurrent
developing
account
countries whose exports are blocked from rich markets

National security — maintain capability in key sectors WTO rules generally prohibit unjustified tariffs — legal risks

6.3 Current Account of the Balance of Payments

Page 33
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

KEY DEFINITION
Balance of Payments: A record of all financial transactions between a country and the rest of the world in a given
period. Includes the current account, capital account, and financial account.

Components of the Current Account

• Trade in goods (visible trade): Exports minus imports of physical goods. UK typically has a deficit
(imports more goods than it exports).
• Trade in services (invisible trade): Financial services, insurance, tourism, education. UK typically has a
surplus (strong financial services sector in London).
• Income: Primary income: returns on investments abroad (dividends, interest, profits) minus payments to
foreign investors in the UK. Secondary income: transfers (e.g. foreign aid, migrant remittances).
• Current account balance: Sum of all four components. A deficit means the country spends more on
imports (goods, services, transfers, investment payments) than it earns from exports.

Causes of a Current Account Deficit

• Uncompetitive exports (high costs, poor quality, overvalued exchange rate).
• High domestic consumption driving strong import demand.
• Low domestic savings rate → high consumption → high imports.
• Loss of manufacturing sector (deindustrialisation) → reliance on imported goods.
• Cyclical factors — fast economic growth increases import demand.

Consequences of a Persistent Deficit

• Debt accumulation: Deficit must be financed by inflows on financial account (foreign borrowing or selling
assets).
• Downward pressure on exchange rate: Excess demand for foreign currency (to buy imports)
depreciates the currency.
• Loss of foreign exchange reserves: If the central bank intervenes to support the currency.
• Reduced investor confidence: May raise risk premium on sovereign debt.
• Potential benefit: A deficit may reflect strong growth and investment (attracting capital inflows) — not
always a problem.

6.4 Exchange Rates

KEY DEFINITION
Exchange Rate: The price of one currency in terms of another. E.g. £1 = $1.25. Determined by demand and supply
of currencies in the foreign exchange (forex) market.

Systems of Exchange Rates

• Floating exchange rate: Determined freely by market forces (supply and demand). No government
intervention. Rate fluctuates constantly.
• Fixed exchange rate: Government/central bank fixes the rate against another currency (or gold). Must
intervene (buying/selling currency, adjusting interest rates) to maintain the peg.

Page 34
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

• Managed float (dirty float): Broadly market-determined but central bank intervenes occasionally to
prevent excessive volatility or undesirable movements.

Factors Affecting Exchange Rate (Floating)

• Interest rate differentials: Higher UK rates attract foreign capital → demand for £ rises → £ appreciates.
• Inflation differentials: Higher UK inflation → exports less competitive → demand for £ falls → £
depreciates.
• Balance of payments: Current account surplus → demand for £ rises (foreigners buy UK exports) → £
appreciates. Deficit → £ depreciates.
• Speculation: Forex markets are dominated by speculative flows — expected changes in rates drive
significant movements.
• Economic performance: Strong growth attracts FDI → demand for £ rises.

Effects of Exchange Rate Changes

If £ depreciates (falls in value):

• Exports: Cheaper for foreigners → quantity of exports rises (if demand is elastic) → export revenue in £
rises → improves current account.
• Imports: More expensive for domestic consumers → quantity of imports falls → reduces import bill →
improves current account.
• Inflation: Import prices rise → cost-push inflation (especially for imported raw materials).
• Growth: Higher net exports (X–M) → AD increases → positive effect on growth.
J-Curve Effect:

• In the short run, depreciation may worsen the current account before it improves. Why? Contracts are
already in place (PES and PED are inelastic in the short run). Import costs rise immediately; export
volumes take time to respond.
• Over time, as trade responds to new price incentives, the current account improves — hence the J-shape.
• Marshall-Lerner Condition: Depreciation improves the current account ONLY if PED(exports) +
PED(imports) > 1. If elasticities are very low, depreciation worsens the current account.

6.5 Policies to Correct Imbalances in the Current Account

• Expenditure-switching policies: Redirect spending from imports to domestic goods. E.g. currency
depreciation (makes imports more expensive), tariffs (taxes on imports), subsidies to domestic exporters.
Require elastic demand for effect.
• Expenditure-reducing policies: Reduce overall spending → less import demand. E.g. contractionary
fiscal or monetary policy. Risk: may cause recession and unemployment.
• Supply-side policies: Improve international competitiveness by raising productivity — lower costs →
exports more competitive → improving current account sustainably over the long run.
• Direct controls: Import quotas, exchange controls. WTO generally prohibits these except in limited
circumstances.
• Trade-offs: Policies to reduce deficit may conflict with growth and employment objectives. Expenditure
reduction causes recession; depreciation causes inflation. Structural current account deficits (e.g. loss of
manufacturing) require supply-side solutions, not short-run demand management.

PAST PAPER ESSAY QUESTIONS — CHAPTER 6

Page 35
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

PAST PAPER • 2023, Paper 2 (O/N) Section C Essay Part (a) [8 marks]

Q: With the help of a diagram, explain two ways in which a fall in the balance of trade in goods may affect the
value of a floating exchange rate, and consider the extent to which a change in the relative rate of interest
between two countries may have a greater impact on the exchange rate. [8]

MODEL ANSWER

Model Answer:
• Effect 1 — Reduced demand for the currency: A fall in the balance of trade in goods (trade deficit
worsens) means the country is importing more and exporting less. To buy imports, domestic residents
must exchange their currency for foreign currency → supply of domestic currency on forex market rises.
Simultaneously, fewer foreigners need to buy domestic exports → demand for the domestic currency
falls. Both effects cause depreciation.
• Effect 2 — Reduced investor confidence: A worsening trade deficit may signal macroeconomic
weakness — uncompetitive industries, excessive consumption, or slowing productivity growth. This
reduces investor confidence → capital outflows increase → supply of domestic currency rises further →
depreciation.
• Diagram (Forex market): Show supply of £ shifting right and demand for £ shifting left → exchange rate
falls from E1 to E2.
• Relative interest rates may have GREATER impact: If Country A's interest rates rise relative to Country
B, hot money flows (short-term speculative capital) move to A in search of higher returns. This is a
massive component of modern forex markets — daily forex trading volume far exceeds the value of trade
flows. A 0.25% interest rate rise can cause a 1–2% exchange rate change within hours, whereas trade
flow effects build over months. Post-2022, the USD appreciated significantly as the Federal Reserve
raised rates faster than other central banks — demonstrating the dominant role of interest rate
differentials in modern exchange rate determination. However, in the long run, trade competitiveness and
purchasing power parity (PPP) are more fundamental determinants.

PAST PAPER • 2022, Paper 2 Section C Essay Part (b) [12 marks]

Q: Assess whether an improvement in the terms of trade or a surplus on the current account of the balance
of payments is of more benefit to an economy. [12]

MODEL ANSWER

Model Answer:
• Terms of Trade (ToT): Defined as index of export prices ÷ index of import prices × 100. An improvement
(ToT rises) means export prices rise relative to import prices — the country can buy more imports for the
same volume of exports (better purchasing power in trade).
• Benefits of improved Terms of Trade: Higher export prices improve real income for domestic producers.
Country can import more goods/services for a given level of exports — higher real national income.
Particularly beneficial for commodity exporters (e.g. Saudi Arabia when oil prices rise). May attract FDI as
export revenues rise.
• Limitations: If improvement is due to rising export prices (rather than falling import prices), domestic
inflation may worsen. If a country's ToT improves because it has monopoly pricing power, trading
partners may retaliate or find substitutes, reducing export volume. "Immiserising growth" — rising export
prices may reduce volume so much that total export revenue falls (if demand for exports is price elastic).
• Benefits of current account surplus: Export revenues exceed import spending → net inflow of foreign
exchange → currency likely to appreciate. Helps fund government spending. Indicates strong
international competitiveness. Builds foreign exchange reserves. Countries like Germany and China with
persistent surpluses have accumulated significant reserve assets.

Page 36
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

• Limitations of current account surplus: A large persistent surplus may indicate excessive saving and
underconsumption domestically (e.g. Germany's surplus has been criticised for suppressing domestic
demand in the Eurozone). May cause currency appreciation which eventually erodes competitiveness.
Trading partners may label the country a "currency manipulator" or impose retaliatory tariffs.
• Evaluation: An improvement in the terms of trade directly raises real living standards (the country gets
more for what it sells — real income rises). A current account surplus demonstrates competitiveness but
does not directly raise living standards if export earnings are not consumed or invested domestically.
However, both are superior to their alternatives (deteriorating ToT and current account deficit). For an
economy at AS level, a favourable current account reduces external debt reliance and exchange rate
vulnerability. Overall, an improvement in the terms of trade is arguably the more direct benefit to living
standards, but a current account surplus is more sustainable as a long-term sign of economic strength.
The answer depends on the cause — if the ToT improves due to commodity price shocks, it may be
unsustainable.

PAST PAPER • 2020, Paper 2 Section C Essay Part (a) [8 marks]

Q: Explain the benefits of international trade and consider whether the infant industry argument provides a
convincing case for protectionism. [8]
MODEL ANSWER

Model Answer:
• Benefits of international trade: Countries can specialise according to comparative advantage —
producing goods at lower opportunity cost → more efficient global resource allocation. Consumers benefit
from lower prices and greater variety. Economies of scale: producing for world markets allows firms to
grow beyond domestic limits, lowering average costs. Technology transfer: exposure to global best
practice raises productivity. Export-led growth: countries like South Korea used export expansion to drive
rapid economic development.
• Infant industry argument: New industries in developing economies cannot initially compete with
established foreign firms that have scale economies and accumulated experience. Temporary protection
(tariffs or subsidies) allows domestic firms to grow, achieve scale economies, and eventually become
competitive internationally. Classic example: South Korean electronics (Samsung) benefited from initial
protection before becoming globally competitive.
• Strengths of the argument: Economically coherent — temporary protection can correct a market failure
(inability of capital markets to fund long-term investment in new industries). Historical evidence: many
now-successful industries (US steel in the 19th century, Asian electronics) benefited from initial
protection. Particularly relevant for developing economies lacking capital markets to fund industrial
development.
• Weaknesses and evaluation: Protection is often not "temporary" — industries lobby to keep it
permanently, preventing market discipline. Governments may protect the wrong industries (they cannot
accurately predict which will develop comparative advantage). Consumers pay higher prices during the
protection period. Retaliation by trading partners. WTO rules limit the use of protectionist measures. In
practice, the infant industry argument is often misused as a cover for rent-seeking by established
domestic producers. Overall, while theoretically valid in limited circumstances, infant industry
protectionism has a poor track record in practice compared to alternative industrial policy instruments
(e.g. subsidies to R&D;, investment grants).

Page 37
Cambridge AS Level Economics 9708 Complete Study Notes & Past Paper Answers

EXAM TECHNIQUE & FINAL TIPS

8-mark questions Define key terms (1–2 marks). Explain 2–3 relevant points with
structure (Part a): economic theory (4–5 marks). Use a diagram if relevant. Include a
brief consideration/evaluation point at the end. Aim for 200–250
words. Spend approximately 12–15 minutes.

12-mark questions This is an "assess" question — you MUST evaluate. Structure:

structure (Part b): Introduction (define the issue). Arguments FOR the statement (2–3
substantive paragraphs with theory + example). Arguments
AGAINST / limitations (2–3 paragraphs). Conclusion with justified
judgement. Aim for 350–450 words. Spend approximately 20–25
minutes.

Diagrams: Always label axes (Price/P on Y-axis; Quantity/Q on X-axis OR

Price Level/Real GDP for macro). Label curves (D, S, AD, SRAS,
LRAS). Show and label equilibrium. Show shifts with arrows. Mark
equilibrium values (P*, Q*, P1, Q1). Reference your diagram
explicitly in your answer.

Key evaluation "The effectiveness of this policy depends on..." | "However, in the
phrases: short run / long run..." | "This assumes ceteris paribus, but in
reality..." | "The extent to which... depends on the price elasticity
of..." | "Evidence from [country/year] suggests..." | "On balance, the
most significant factor is..."

Common mistakes to 1. Confusing a shift of a curve with a movement along it. 2. Using
avoid: "increase" for both a shift and a movement. 3. Forgetting to
evaluate in 12-mark answers. 4. Drawing diagrams without labels.
5. Confusing nominal and real values. 6. Not applying economic
theory to the specific context of the question.

Revision priority: Practise past papers under timed conditions. For each essay, plan
for 2 minutes before writing. Know the key diagrams perfectly:
Demand/Supply, AD/AS, Externality diagrams, Phillips Curve,
J-curve. Learn at least 3 real-world examples for each topic.

Good luck with your AS Level Economics exam! ■

You have everything you need to achieve an A*.

Page 38