1

Political violence under state auspices: the future challenges for protection of human rights

in Bangladesh.

Political violence refers to the use of force, coercion, or intimidation by individuals, groups, or

governments to achieve political objectives. It encompasses a spectrum of actions, including

riots, terrorism, state-sponsored repression, and armed conflict. This form of violence is

inherently linked to the pursuit or consolidation of political power, often aiming to influence or

control governmental policies, structures, or ideologies. The impact of political violence extends

beyond immediate physical harm, encompassing psychological and societal repercussions that

can disrupt the fabric of civil order and impede the protection of individual and collective rights.

In the complex tapestry of contemporary Bangladesh, the intertwining threads of politics and

human rights form a critical narrative that demands profound exploration. The nation,

historically characterized by its vibrant cultural heritage, has, in recent times, grappled with the

ominous shadow of political violence under state auspices. This unsettling phenomenon poses a

formidable challenge to the safeguarding of human rights, echoing concerns that reverberate both

nationally and internationally.

The nexus between political power and acts of violence orchestrated or condoned by the state

raises profound questions about the very foundations of a democratic society. Bangladesh, a

country that emerged from a tumultuous struggle for independence, now finds itself at a

crossroads where the ideals of freedom and human rights are subjected to unprecedented

scrutiny. The ramifications of state-sponsored violence extend beyond immediate victims,

seeping into the societal fabric and eroding the foundations of trust in governance.
 2

As we navigate the contours of this multifaceted issue, it becomes imperative to dissect the root

causes and manifestations of political violence within the Bangladeshi context. The trajectory of

the nation's political landscape, marked by a history of power struggles and contested narratives,

sets the stage for a nuanced examination of the challenges that lie ahead. Inherent in this analysis

is the recognition that the protection of human rights cannot be divorced from the broader socio-

political dynamics that define Bangladesh.

This assignment delves into the intricate layers of political violence under state auspices,

shedding light on the intricate web that connects the exercise of political power to the erosion of

human rights. By scrutinizing the historical backdrop, contemporary manifestations, and future

implications, we aim to unravel the complexities that confront those dedicated to upholding the

principles of justice, freedom, and human dignity in Bangladesh.

Forms and Types

Political violence encompasses a range of actions that are intended to achieve political goals

through force or coercion. The forms and types of political violence are diverse, reflecting the

complex nature of conflicts in different regions and historical contexts. In this brief overview, we

will explore several key forms of political violence, considering both conventional and

unconventional manifestations.

Terrorism:
 3

1. Terrorism is a method of political violence characterized by the use of fear and

intimidation to achieve political objectives. It often involves the deliberate targeting of

civilians to create a psychological impact. Terrorist acts can be perpetrated by state or

non-state actors and may involve bombings, hijackings, or assassinations.

Insurgency:

2. Insurgency refers to a protracted, armed struggle by non-state actors against a constituted

authority. Insurgents seek to establish or challenge political control through guerrilla

warfare, often in regions with marginalized populations. Insurgencies can be driven by

various factors, including ethnic, religious, or socio-economic grievances.

Civil War:

3. Civil wars are large-scale conflicts between different groups within a country, often

seeking control over the government or territory. These conflicts can be fueled by ethnic,

religious, or political divisions and result in significant social and economic disruption.

Rebellion:

4. Rebellion involves organized resistance against established authority, and it can take

various forms, including uprisings, revolts, or mutinies. Rebellions can emerge for a

range of reasons, such as opposition to oppressive regimes, economic inequality, or

perceived injustice.
 4

State Repression:

5. State repression involves the use of force by a government against its own citizens to

maintain control. This can include arbitrary arrests, torture, or extrajudicial killings.

Repressive measures are often employed to suppress dissent and opposition.

Proxy Wars:

6. Proxy wars occur when external powers support opposing factions in a conflict, often in

pursuit of their own strategic interests. The Cold War era witnessed numerous proxy

wars, where the United States and the Soviet Union supported rival factions in various

regions to expand their influence.

Genocide:

7. Genocide involves the systematic extermination of a particular ethnic, religious, or social

group. It is a grave form of political violence aimed at eliminating a targeted population.

The Holocaust during World War II is a notorious example of genocide.

Cyber Warfare:

8. In the contemporary era, political violence has extended into cyberspace. Cyber warfare

involves the use of digital tactics to disrupt or damage the operations of a state or

organization. This can include hacking, spreading disinformation, or launching cyber-

attacks on critical infrastructure.

Political Assassinations:

9. Political assassinations are targeted killings of individuals for political reasons.

Perpetrators may seek to eliminate key figures who represent a threat to their objectives

or ideologies. These acts can have profound effects on the course of political events.

In conclusion, political violence is a multifaceted phenomenon that manifests in various forms,

ranging from traditional conflicts like civil wars and insurgencies to modern cyber warfare. The

motivations behind political violence are diverse and complex, often rooted in historical, social,

and economic factors. Understanding these different forms is essential for policymakers,

scholars, and the general public to address the root causes and work towards sustainable peace

and stability.

Human rights conception

Human rights refer to the fundamental rights and freedoms that every individual is entitled to,

simply by virtue of being human. This concept has evolved over centuries, shaped by historical

events, philosophical ideals, and legal developments. The foundation of modern human rights

can be traced back to various sources, including philosophical discourse, religious teachings, and

legal frameworks.

In ancient times, philosophical thinkers like Aristotle and Cicero explored the idea of natural

law, asserting that certain rights were inherent to human beings. However, it wasn't until the
 6

Enlightenment period in the 17th and 18th centuries that the concept gained significant traction.

Enlightenment philosophers, such as John Locke and Jean-Jacques Rousseau, laid the

groundwork for the idea that individuals possess inherent rights that cannot be arbitrarily taken

away by rulers.

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), adopted by the United Nations General

Assembly in 1948, stands as a landmark in the codification of human rights principles. Drafted in

the aftermath of World War II, the UDHR aimed to establish a common standard of human

rights for all people and nations. Its 30 articles cover a wide range of rights, including civil,

political, economic, social, and cultural rights.

The core principles of human rights encompass the belief in inherent dignity, equality, and

inalienable rights of all members of the human family. These principles have been further

elaborated and reinforced through subsequent international treaties and conventions, such as the

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) and the International Covenant on

Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR).

Human rights are often categorized into two main types: civil and political rights, and economic,

social, and cultural rights. Civil and political rights include the right to life, liberty, and security

of person; freedom of expression and assembly; and the right to a fair trial. Economic, social,

and cultural rights encompass the right to work, education, and an adequate standard of living.

The realization and protection of human rights depend on the rule of law, democratic

governance, and a robust legal framework. National and international institutions play a crucial

role in upholding and enforcing these rights. Human rights advocacy and awareness also

contribute to fostering a culture of respect for human dignity and equality.

However, the universal application of human rights faces challenges, including cultural

relativism, political ideologies, and economic disparities. Debates persist regarding the balance
 7

between individual rights and collective interests, as well as the cultural context in which rights

are interpreted. Additionally, issues such as discrimination, gender inequality, and the impact of

new technologies on privacy pose ongoing challenges to the human rights framework.

In conclusion, the conception of human rights has evolved over centuries, shaped by

philosophical, religious, and legal developments. The UDHR, as a foundational document,

established a universal standard for human rights, but challenges persist in ensuring their full

realization. The ongoing dialogue around human rights reflects the dynamic nature of this

concept and its relevance in addressing contemporary global challenges.

Bangladesh, a South Asian country with a rich cultural heritage, has made progress in various

areas, including human rights. However, challenges persist, and a comprehensive understanding

requires examining the nation's historical context, legal framework, and contemporary issues.

Historical Perspective:

Bangladesh emerged as an independent nation in 1971 following a war of independence. The

struggle for autonomy and subsequent liberation was marked by widespread human rights

abuses, including the infamous 1971 Bangladesh Liberation War. The trauma of that period has

influenced the nation's commitment to human rights.

Legal Framework:

The Constitution of Bangladesh, adopted in 1972, enshrines several fundamental rights, such as

equality before the law, freedom of speech, and the right to life. Despite these constitutional

guarantees, challenges arise from the lack of effective enforcement mechanisms and instances of

executive overreach.
 8

Civil and Political Rights:

Freedom of expression faces occasional challenges, with reports of journalists and activists

facing harassment or legal action. Political instability has, at times, strained the democratic

process. The judiciary plays a crucial role in upholding human rights, but concerns about its

independence have been raised.

Economic and Social Rights:

Bangladesh has made strides in economic development, particularly in sectors like textiles and

garments. However, issues like income inequality and labor rights persist. Ensuring fair wages,

safe working conditions, and addressing child labor are ongoing challenges.

Women's Rights:

Progress has been made in women's rights, with improved access to education and employment.

However, gender-based violence remains a concern. Efforts to combat child marriage and

promote gender equality are ongoing.

Minority Rights:

Bangladesh is home to diverse ethnic and religious communities. While the constitution

guarantees minority rights, instances of discrimination and violence have been reported.

Safeguarding the rights of minorities remains a key challenge.

Rohingya Crisis:

The Rohingya refugee crisis, stemming from Myanmar, has placed immense pressure on

Bangladesh. The government has provided refuge, but this has strained resources. The
 9

international community's role in addressing this crisis and ensuring the rights of Rohingya

refugees is crucial.

Human Rights Activism:

Civil society and human rights organizations play a vital role in advocating for justice and

accountability. Despite challenges, these groups continue to work towards creating awareness

and holding authorities accountable for human rights violations.

Challenges and Future Outlook:

While Bangladesh has made progress in various aspects of human rights, challenges persist.

Addressing issues like political instability, corruption, and ensuring the effective implementation

of legal provisions are crucial for further improvement. International cooperation and support

can contribute to strengthening human rights mechanisms in the country.

In conclusion, Bangladesh has made strides in protecting and promoting human rights since its

independence. However, persistent challenges require ongoing efforts to strengthen the legal

framework, ensure accountability, and address social and economic inequalities. The nation's

commitment to human rights will be a key determinant of its future trajectory.

Human rights and political violence

Human rights and political violence are two interconnected realms that shape the fabric of

societies worldwide. The relationship between them is complex and multifaceted, reflecting the

intricate interplay between governance, individual freedoms, and societal dynamics.

At its core, human rights encompass the inalienable entitlements and liberties that every

individual inherently possesses. These rights, often enshrined in national constitutions and

international treaties, serve as the bedrock of a just and equitable society. They span a spectrum

from the right to life and personal security to freedom of expression, association, and

participation in political processes. However, the realization of these rights is not uniform across

the globe.

Political violence, on the other hand, emerges as a dark undercurrent in societies marked by

conflict, dissent, or authoritarian rule. It encompasses a range of actions, from state-sponsored

repression and extrajudicial killings to terrorism and civil unrest. The roots of political violence

are often entwined with the violation of human rights, creating a cyclical relationship where one

begets the other.

In oppressive regimes, where autocratic leaders wield unchecked power, political violence

becomes a tool to suppress dissent and maintain control. Citizens, deprived of their basic human

rights, find themselves on the receiving end of state-sponsored brutality. Arbitrary arrests,

torture, and censorship become commonplace, eroding the very foundations of a rights-based

society.

Conversely, political violence can also be fueled by a quest for justice and the protection of

human rights. Movements advocating for social change and equality may resort to protest and

resistance when confronted with systemic oppression. The Arab Spring, for instance, stands as a

testament to how people, yearning for their basic rights, can mobilize against authoritarian rule,

even if it means confronting violence.

The connection between human rights and political violence is accentuated in conflict zones,

where the fabric of civil society is torn apart. War and internal strife often lead to the mass

violation of human rights, with civilians caught in the crossfire. Displacement, discrimination,
 11

and atrocities become the grim reality, highlighting the fragility of human rights during times of

upheaval.

The international community plays a pivotal role in shaping the relationship between human

rights and political violence. Global institutions, such as the United Nations, strive to uphold a

universal standard for human rights through conventions and resolutions. Yet, their effectiveness

is contingent on the political will of member states and the geopolitical landscape.

The accountability for human rights violations often becomes a contentious issue in the

aftermath of political violence. Truth and reconciliation processes, international tribunals, and

transitional justice mechanisms aim to address past atrocities and pave the way for a more rights-

respecting future. However, achieving justice in the aftermath of political violence is intricate,

often requiring a delicate balance between accountability and national reconciliation.

Political violence emerges from a complex interplay of socio-economic, ideological, and

historical factors. Understanding its occurrence requires an examination of diverse elements that

contribute to the escalation of tensions and the resort to violent means in the political realm.

At its core, political violence often stems from deep-seated ideological differences. Conflicting

beliefs about governance, societal values, and the distribution of resources can create a volatile

environment. These differences may be fueled by historical grievances, fostering resentment and

a desire for retribution. For example, disputes over territory, resources, or historical injustices

may serve as catalysts for political violence, turning ideological clashes into physical

confrontations.

Socio-economic disparities also play a significant role in the genesis of political violence. When

a society experiences economic inequality, with a concentration of wealth among a select few, it
 12

can lead to widespread dissatisfaction. This discontentment may manifest in protests or uprisings

as marginalized groups seek to address their grievances. Governments that fail to address these

socio-economic disparities adequately may find themselves facing heightened tensions and, in

extreme cases, violent opposition.

Ethnic and religious factors further complicate the landscape, providing additional fault lines

along which political violence can erupt. In regions with diverse ethnic or religious populations,

power struggles often take on a communal dimension. Politicians may exploit these divisions for

their gain, deepening societal rifts and escalating tensions. The manipulation of ethnic or

religious identity for political purposes can serve as a potent catalyst for violence, as seen in

numerous historical and contemporary conflicts.

The quest for power and control within political structures is another driver of political violence.

As individuals or groups vie for dominance, the competition can escalate into open conflict.

Authoritarian regimes, unwilling to relinquish power, may employ violence to suppress dissent

and maintain control. Similarly, power struggles within opposition groups can result in internal

strife, leading to fragmentation and the potential for violence.

The media and communication landscape also contribute to the occurrence of political violence.

Misinformation, propaganda, and the manipulation of public opinion can create a climate of fear

and distrust. This, in turn, can escalate tensions and push individuals or groups towards violent

actions as a perceived means of self-defense or resistance.

International dynamics, including geopolitical interests and foreign interventions, can further

exacerbate political violence. External actors may support specific factions, either directly or

indirectly, influencing the course of conflicts and prolonging violence. Economic interests,

strategic alliances, and historical allegiances can all contribute to the complexity of political

violence on a global scale.

In conclusion, political violence is a multifaceted phenomenon that arises from a confluence of

ideological, socio-economic, ethnic, and power-related factors. Understanding its roots requires a

nuanced examination of historical context, societal dynamics, and the intricate interplay of

various elements. Efforts to mitigate political violence must address these underlying causes,

working towards fostering inclusive governance, reducing socio-economic disparities, and

promoting dialogue to bridge ideological divides.

Political violence in Bangladesh has been a concerning issue, leading to severe violations of

human rights. These incidents encompass a range of activities, from protests and clashes to more

organized acts of violence, impacting the citizens' fundamental rights in various ways.

One of the primary ways political violence breaks human rights in Bangladesh is through the

suppression of freedom of expression. Citizens often fear expressing dissenting opinions due to

the risk of retaliation. Political opponents, journalists, and activists face intimidation, harassment,

and even physical harm for speaking out against the government or powerful political entities.

This curtailment of free speech directly contradicts the principles outlined in international human

rights agreements.

The right to peaceful assembly is another human right that is frequently violated during episodes

of political violence in Bangladesh. Protests and demonstrations are met with excessive force by

law enforcement agencies, leading to injuries and sometimes fatalities among peaceful

demonstrators. The government's failure to ensure a safe environment for citizens to express their

grievances undermines the right to assembly and association.

Furthermore, instances of extrajudicial killings and enforced disappearances have been reported

in the context of political violence. Activists and individuals critical of the government often
 14

vanish without a trace or are found dead under suspicious circumstances. These incidents not

only violate the right to life but also erode the trust citizens place in their government to protect

their fundamental human rights.

The right to a fair trial is also jeopardized in the wake of political violence. Arrests of political

opponents may be arbitrary, and detainees may be held without proper legal representation or

access to a fair judicial process. Political interference in the judiciary further compounds these

issues, hindering the delivery of justice and compromising the rule of law.

In addition to the direct impact on individual rights, political violence can lead to broader

societal issues. Economic and social rights are often neglected during periods of unrest, with

citizens facing disruptions to their livelihoods and essential services. This situation

disproportionately affects vulnerable populations and exacerbates existing inequalities, violating

the principles of equality and non-discrimination.

The rights of minority groups are also at risk in the midst of political violence. Minorities may

become targets of violence or discrimination based on their perceived political affiliations. The

government's failure to protect minority rights contributes to a climate of fear and insecurity

among these communities.

International human rights organizations and the global community play a crucial role in

addressing these issues. Advocacy for accountability, transparency, and adherence to human

rights principles is essential. Pressuring the Bangladeshi government to investigate and prosecute

those responsible for human rights abuses is crucial in preventing further violations.

In conclusion, political violence in Bangladesh has far-reaching consequences on human rights.

From the suppression of freedom of expression to violations of the right to life and a fair trial,

these incidents undermine the foundation of a just and democratic society. Addressing these
 15

issues requires a concerted effort from both domestic and international actors to ensure the

protection and promotion of human rights for all citizens.

Challenges

The protection of human rights in Bangladesh faces several challenges, reflecting a complex

interplay of historical, political, and socio-economic factors. As of my last knowledge update in

January 2022, the situation may have evolved, but some persistent challenges include:

1. Political Instability:

Bangladesh has experienced periods of political turmoil, leading to instability that can undermine

the protection of human rights. Political conflicts and changes in leadership may divert attention

and resources away from human rights issues.

2. Freedom of Expression:

Despite constitutional guarantees, there have been concerns about restrictions on freedom of

expression. Journalists, activists, and bloggers have faced harassment, censorship, and even

violence, impacting the ability to express dissenting opinions.

3. Extrajudicial Killings and Impunity:

Cases of extrajudicial killings by law enforcement agencies have been reported, raising concerns

about impunity. A lack of accountability can erode trust in the justice system and hinder efforts

to ensure the protection of citizens' rights.

4. Gender-based Violence:
 16

Violence against women and girls remains a significant challenge. Despite legal measures,

including the Domestic Violence Act, implementation gaps and cultural factors contribute to the

persistence of gender-based violence.

5. Worker Rights and Safety:

The ready-made garment industry, a vital sector for Bangladesh's economy, has faced scrutiny

for poor working conditions and safety standards. Ensuring the rights and safety of workers is an

ongoing challenge, with the need for better enforcement of labor laws.

6. Rohingya Refugee Crisis:

The influx of Rohingya refugees from Myanmar has created a humanitarian and human rights

crisis. Bangladesh has provided refuge, but the situation poses challenges related to living

conditions, access to education, and healthcare for the displaced population.

7. Religious and Ethnic Minorities:

Minority communities, both religious and ethnic, may face discrimination and violence.

Safeguarding the rights of these communities requires addressing systemic issues and promoting

inclusivity.

8. Cybersecurity and Digital Rights:

The digital landscape poses new challenges, with concerns about surveillance, online censorship,

and the misuse of digital technologies. Balancing security measures with the protection of

citizens' digital rights is an evolving challenge.

9. Climate-induced Displacement:
 17

Bangladesh is vulnerable to climate change, leading to displacement and migration. Protecting

the rights of those affected by climate-induced changes, particularly vulnerable communities, is a

growing concern.

10. Access to Justice:

Limited access to justice, particularly for marginalized groups, remains an obstacle.

Strengthening the judicial system, improving legal aid, and addressing corruption are essential

for ensuring that all citizens can seek and receive justice.

In addressing these challenges, a comprehensive approach involving government commitment,

civil society engagement, and international collaboration is crucial. Efforts to strengthen

democratic institutions, enhance the rule of law, and promote a culture of respect for human

rights are integral to overcoming these challenges and fostering a more just and equitable society

in Bangladesh.
18