Unit 3
Unit 3
Securities Class Action (Sec.37). This section provides that a suit may be filed by any person(individual private suit)
or groups of persons(class action suit) who have been affected under section34\35\36 by any misleading statement
or inclusion or ommission of any matter in the prospectus. Funding of class action suits could be out of Investor
Education and Protection Fund. A class action allows a number of claimants with a common grievance against a
company to file a lawsuit against it. Claimants can pool their resources, share attorney's services and save time and
costs of litigation. The scale of economies associated with class actions seem especially critical to those individuals
who have limited resources or small claims that render individual lawsuits expensive and unfeasible.
MEANING OF ALLOTMENT
A prospectus issued by a company is merely an invitation to offer. When the potential investor
makes an application for securities, it is an offer from the applicant. The BOD of the company can
accept or reject this offer. When the BOD make an allotment of shares, it implies offer is
accepted and a binding contract takes place between the applicant and the company .
Thus, allotment means the appropriation out of the previously unappropriated capital of the
company, of certain number of share \debentures to an applicant by company. It is for this
reason that reissue of forfeited shares is not regarded as allotment of shares as these shares are
not fresh shares ,rather these are second hand shares.
The provisions governing allotment of securities may be studied under two heads
• General Provisions ( under Indian Contract Act)
• Special Provisions (under the Companies Act)
General provisions(applicable to both private as Special Provisions( applicable to only public companies going for public
well as public companies) offer)
Allotment must be made by proper authority i.e. by resolution of Section 26 (4)- requires Registration of Prospectus with ROC before it is issued to public
BOD or Allotment Committee
Allotment must be made within proper time- i.e specified time or Section29- requires public offer of securities to be in dematerialized form only
otherwise reasonable time
Allotment must be communicated- i.e. communication of Section39 – states allotment requirements
acceptance must be by the prescribed mode or otherwise by Sec39(1) -No allotment unless minimum subscription as stated in prospectus and application
ordinary mode of transmission( like post) money is duly received by the [Link] cheque or other instrument. (SEBI has prescribed that
minimum subscription must atleast be 90% of the offer)
Sec 39(2)- Minimum application money payable shall be 5%of nominal value of security or such
other percentage specified by SEBI (which is minimum 25% of nominal value)
Sec39(3)- If minimum subscription and application money is not received within 30 days from date
of issue of prospectus or such other period as specified by SEBI, the whole amount received shall
be returned within prescribed time i.e. 15 days from closure of issue otherwise interest @15% p.a.
will be charged from the officers in default for the delayed period.
Allotment must be absolute and unconditional-allotment must Section 40- Listing requirements
be made on the same terms as stated in application for shares. If Sec40(1)- Every company , before making public offer ,shall have to apply to one or more
there is a variation , there is no contract. Case- Raman Bhai vs recognised stock exchanges and obtain permission for listing.
Ghasiram-Here the applicant while applying for shares put a Sec40(2)-Prospectus of such company shall also state the names of all such stock exchanges where
condition that he be appointed as cashier for the allotment of it has applied for listing.
shares. Shares were allotted to him but he was not appointed as Sec40(3)-All application money received to be kept in a separate bank account in a scheduled bank
cashier. It was held that this allotment was not valid as and not to be used for any other purpose except adjustment towards allotment, if listing
acceptance was not as per the terms of the offer and the permission granted or repayment of money , if allotment not done.
applicant was not bound by the allotment.
Effect of of non compliance of general provisions Effect of non compliance of special provisions.
Allotment is null and void Non compliance of sec.26 or 29 or 39 - prescribed fine is imposed on co.+ every defaulting officer.
Non Compliance of Sec 40- Listing Requirement) – here the allotment void .Also the company
is punishableUnwivietrhsiftiyne ranging between ₹5 lakhs to ₹ 50 lakhs and every defaulting officer with
Return of Allotment( Sec.39(4))
Whenever any public or private company , makes any allotment of securities, it has to file with the registrar a Return of
Allotment within such time and in such manner as is prescribed by Rule12 of Companies (Prospectus and Allotment of
Securities )Rules,2014-
• The company must file a duly dated and signed Return of Allotment with ROC within 30 days of allotment.
• The Return shall have particulars of allottees viz. names, addresses, occupations, no. of securities allotted, amount paid etc.
• If securities are allotted for consideration other than cash, relevant contracts of sale/services must also be attached to it.
• In case of bonus issue, a copy of resolution authorizing issue of bonus shares should be attached to the Return of Allotment.
• Incase of default in above provisions ,the company and its defaulting officer shall be liable to prescribed penalty.
Payment of Underwriting Commission (Sec.40(6))
An underwriting contract is an agreement entered before the shares are brought before the public , that incase the public does
not take up the whole of them or the number mentioned in the agreement, the underwriter , will for an agreed commission, take
an allotment of such part of the shares as public has not applied for. Underwriting is a device used by companies to make sure
that the necessary capital comes forth even if the proposed issue gets a poor public response. Further, underwriting of securities
instils confidence into the mind of prospective investors as they know that underwriters underwrite only when they find that the
company is sound and has good prospects. Underwriting is paid on all shares covered under the contract even if there is
oversubscription. As per Rule 13 of Companies (Prospectus and Allotment of Securities )Rules,2014 the following conditions
must be satisfied before paying underwriting commission-
• The payment of commission must be authorised by AOA.
• Rate of commission can not exceed 5% in case of shares and 2.5% in case of debentures, of the price at which they are issued.
• Further, the rate of commission cannot exceed the rate of underwriting commission ( if any) specified in AOA
• The rate of commission agreed must be disclosed in the prospectus.
• A copy of underwriting contract should be delivered to the registrar at the time when prospectus is delivered for registration.
SHARES (ISSUE, BUYBACK etc.)
SHARE- As per Sec.2(84),Share means 'share in the share capital of a company and includes a stock'. A share in a company
is one of the units into which the total capital of the company is divided. A share secures to its owner certain rights and
liabilities e.g. right to dividend, right to vote etc., liability to pay call etc. A share is regarded as' goods' in India i.e.
moveable and marketable but these are transferable in a manner provided in the Companies Act.
STOCK- A stock is different from share in the sense that a company cannot originally issue stock. Only fully paid up shares,
if authorized by AOA, can be converted into stock. The benefit of this conversion is that stock can be transferred in
fractional value whereas fractional transfer is not possible in case of shares. Eg. 10 shares of face value of Rs. 100 each if
converted into stock of Rs.1000 can now be transferred in any amount say as stock of Rs.625 or stock of 450 or 760 etc.
There may be different kinds of shares in any company - Equity Shares and Preference Shares.
Equity Shares are the shares which have residual right in the matter of dividend and repayment of capital at the time of
winding up. They get dividend only after the preference shareholders have been paid their fixed dividend and similarly at
the time of the winding of the company, they are entitled to return of capital only after preference holders have been paid.
A company may issue the following types of equity shares-
✓ Equity Shares with voting rights ( Ordinary Equity)- These shares carry normal voting rights on them .
✓ Equity Shares with differential rights ( Special Equity)-These carry differential rights as to dividend, voting or otherwise.
Preference shares are those which enjoy preferential rights (a) as to payment of dividend at a fixed rate during the life of a
company and (b) as to return of capital on the winding up of the company. The preferential shareholders do not enjoy
normal voting rights like the equity shareholders with voting rights. They are entitled to vote only in the following cases-
(a) When any resolution directly affecting their rights is to be passed. e.g. resolution for winding up of the company
(b) When the dividend due on their preference shares has remained unpaid for 2 years or more ,then they become entitled
to vote on ALL the resolutions placed before general meeting.
Equity Shares with differential rights
Conditions that must be satisfied-
• The AOA of the company must authorize the issue of shares with differential rights
• An Ordinary Resolution authorizing issue of such shares must be passed by shareholders in the general meeting.
• Resolution passed by shareholders must specify a) the rate of voting right and b) rate of additional dividend on them
• Holders of equity shares with differential voting rights shall be entitled to bonus/rights shares of the same class only.
• The company should not have defaulted in filing financial statements and annual returns in the last 3 FYs
• The company should not have defaulted in the payment of declared dividends to shareholders \ interest obligation on
debentures\ interest on deposits\payment of interest on term loans borrowed from banks or financial institutions\
redemption of preference shares or debentures\ repayment of matured deposits\ repayment of term loans etc.
• The company should not have defaulted in payment of statutory dues relating to its employees to any authority etc.
Example- Tata Motors in 2008 introduced equity shares with differential voting rights .In this issue every 10 of such shares
carried only one voting right but would get 5 percentage points more dividend than declared on each of the ordinary shares.
Advantages of equity shares with differential voting rights
• Small shareholders, who hardly exercise voting rights, find such shares attractive as these offer more rate of dividends.
• Management of the co. also finds it attractive as it can raise capital without diluting/reducing its control in the company .
Issue of Shares at Premium(Sec.52), at Discount (Sec.53)
When a company issues shares at a price higher than their face value, it is called issue of shares
at premium. The company is free to make such an issue but there are certain restrictions on use
of the premium amount so collected. The Securities Premium Account may be used for-
✓ Issue of fully paid Bonus shares
✓ Writing off the preliminary expenses of the company
✓ Writing of commission/discount/expenses on any issue of shares or debentures of the company
✓ Buyback of shares
✓ Providing Premium payable on redemption of preference shares or debentures of the company.
Similarly, when a company issues shares for consideration less than their par value, it is called
issue of shares at a discount. Sec.53 prohibits issue of shares( except sweat equity shares) at a
discount. Thus , except sweat equity shares, no shares can be issued at a discount.
Sweat equity shares (Sec.54) are such equity shares which are issued by the company to its
employees\ directors at a discount\for consideration other than cash for providing their
knowhow \ IPRs \ value additions. The company may issue sweat equity if the following
conditions are satisfied -
• The shares must be of a class already issued.
• Passing of SR authorising such issue in the general meeting .
• The resolution must specify the number of shares, their current market price, consideration, discount
offered, names of directors\ employees who would be issued such shares.
• The issue of sweat equity must also conform to SEBI Guidelines ( in case of listed shares) or prescribed
CG Rules (in case of unlisted shares)
ESOPs( Employee Stock Option Plans)Sec.62(1)(b)
A company can make further issue of shares to its employees under the scheme of ESOPs. It is an
instrument used by companies to attract, retain and motivate its employees. Here option is given to the
directors, officers and employees of a company which gives them a right to purchase or subscribe for, the
shares of a company at a future date at a predetermined price which is usually lower than the market
price .
• The scheme of ESOPs must conform to SEBI Guidelines( in case of listed companies) or prescribed CG
Rules (in case of unlisted companies)
• ESOPs are given to permanent employees( whether working in India or abroad) and to directors(
whether whole- time or part- time) of the company
• Independent Directors or employees who are promoters or belong to promoters group are not
eligible for ESOPs
• The company should get Special Resolution passed by shareholders for approval of ESOP Scheme.
• The explanatory statement annexed to the notice for general meeting shall contain particulars like
total no. of stock options granted, exercise price, lock in period etc.
• The option granted shall not be transferable to any other person
• The employees will not have right to dividend or right to vote etc .until option is exercised by them
and shares are issued.
• The company shall maintain an ESOP Register to enter the particulars of options granted in it.
• The details of ESOPs must also be disclosed in Directors Report
Sweat Equity vs Employees Stock Option Plans
SWEAT EQUITY SHARES EMPLOYEE STOCK OPTION PLANS
Covered u/s 54 of Companies Act,2013 Covered u/s 62(1)(b) of Companies Act, 2013
Here shares are allotted to the directors/ employees of the co. Here options are granted to the employees/ directors. If option
is exercised by them, then only shares are allotted to them
These shares can be issued at a discount (i.e. price lower than Shares under an ESOP scheme can be purchased at a
face value) . predetermined price which is generally lower than the market
price.
Sweat equity may be issued for consideration other than cash Consideration for purchase of shares under ESOP scheme is
eg. making available value addition, IPRs, knowhow only cash/ money
Sweat equity can be issued to promoters ESOPs cannot be issued to promoters or promoters group
Rights Issue and Bonus Issue
RIGHTS ISSUE\SHARES( Sec.62) BONUS ISSUE\SHARES(Sec.63)
Whenever a company, proposes to increase its subscribed capital by Whenever a company having large undistributed profits issue fully paid
allotment of further shares, the offer must first be made to the present up shares to their existing shareholders ,free of charge, they are known
equity shareholders. Such shares are called Rights Shares as Bonus Shares.
Rights Shares are to be paid for by existing shareholders . Shareholders don't have to pay anything on bonus shares .
Rights shares are offered at a price decided by the directors of the Bonus shares are totally free of charge. No price is charged on them.
company.
Rights shares bring cash into the company. Bonus shares don't bring any cash into co.
Rights shares may be partly paid. Bonus Shares are always fully paid up.
The shareholder has right of renunciation of the rights offer in favour of There is no right of renunciation in case of bonus shares.
his nominee.
Rights Issue must comply with minimum subscription requirements. Bonus Issue need not comply with minimum subscription requirements.
Rights issue is made when a company needs funds to meet the growth Bonus issue is made when a company doesn't want to distribute its
and diversification requirements of the company. profits and reserves by way of dividends but retains them and converts
them into shares.
I
It is also known as RIGHT OF PRE-EMPTION. It is known as CAPITALISATION OF UNDISTRIBUTED PROFITS
Rights Issue and Bonus Issue
RIGHTS ISSUE ( Sec.62) BONUS ISSUE(Sec.63)
CONDITIONS TO BE SATISFIED CONDITIONS TO BE SATISFIED
• Approval by shareholders not required for rights [Link] • Bonus issue must be authorised by AOA, resolution of BOD
must be made to present equity shareholders on a pro rata and ordinary resolution of shareholders in a general
basis. meeting
• Notice must be issued to shareholders specifying the • Fully paid bonus shares can be issued by company out of its
number of shares offered and the period of offer (time free reserves or securities premium account or the capital
limit for exercising this right must be not less than 7 days redemption reserve account
and not more than 30 days from date of offer) • The company issuing bonus shares must not have defaulted
• If offer is not accepted during this period ,it will be deemed in payment of debts ( eg. interest ,principal) or statutory
to be declined. In case the members declines or is deemed dues of employees ( eg. gratuity, bonus, contribution to PF)
to have declined the offer, the board of directors can • If on the date of allotment of bonus shares, company has
dispose them off as they think most beneficial to the partly paid up shares, they must be first of all made fully
company. paid.
• The member shall be given the right of renunciation of
• Listed companies must also comply SEBI ( Issue of Capital
offer in favour of his nominee
and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2009 for bonus
• Listed companies must also comply SEBI(Issue of Capital issue
and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2009 for rights issue
Buyback of shares (Sec.68,69, 70)
It means repurchasing of shares by the company that issued them. The Companies
Act through Sec.68 to 70 permits companies to buyback its shares subject to
certain restrictions.
Rationale for Buyback
• Enhancement of shareholders wealth- When shares are bought back and
cancelled, it reduces the outstanding number of shares thus improving earning
per share, EPS
• Better investment alternative- A cash rich company looking for investment
alternatives may prefer to buyback its own shares at the market rate rather than
investing in shares of some unknown company.
• Ownership consolidation- Through buyback, the existing management can
increase its percentage stake and thereby avert any hostile takeover bid.
Provisions relating to Buyback
Funds out of which buy back can be financed [Sec.68(1)] - A company may buyback its shares\ securities out of
• a) its free reserves or
• b) securities premium account or
• c) proceeds of issue of any shares or specified securities (but not of same kind of shares/securities)- This implies
that equity shares can be redeemed out of an earlier preference shares or debentures issue but not out of earlier
equity shares issue.)
Conditions to be fulfilled before resorting to buyback [Sec. 68(2), 68(3),68(4)]
• The AOA must authorise buyback of securities
• Passing of SR by shareholders in general meeting- ( However no SR is required where buyback is up to 10% of (
total paid up capital + free reserves of co.) and is authorised by Boards' Resolution)
• The notice convening general meeting to contain explanatory statement containing details of buyback
including justification for buyback, securities to be purchased, amount involved and time limit for completion of
buyback
• The shares or securities to be bought back should be fully paid up.
• The amount involved in buyback must not exceed 25% of ( total paid up capital + free reserves of co.)
• After the buy back, the ratio of( debt) to (capital + free reserves) should not exceed 2:1.
• The buyback operations must be completed within 12 months of passing of SR.
• The time gap between two buybacks must be minimum 1 year.
• Buyback must be in accordance with SEBI regulations in case shares are listed or with CG rules (in case shares
are unlisted).
Methods of buyback [68(5)]
1. From existing shareholders or securities holders on a proportionate basis- Tender
Method - Here the company fixes and announces the price and quantity of shares
which it wishes to buyback. If number of shares offered by shareholders at that
stated price exceeds the required quantity, shares will be bought on pro rata basis.
2. From open market under
✓ Stock Exchange Purchase Method -Here, the company buys shares through stock
exchange till it reaches maximum number of shares it had originally decided to buyback
and the market price does not exceed the predetermined maximum price for buyback.
✓ Dutch Auction Method- Here, the company announces the quantity of shares to be
purchased and offer price range ,say ₹80 to ₹100 . The company then invites bids from
shareholders within that price range and analyses those bids. The company selects the
offered price from lowest price onwards at which the cumulative number of shares
offered equals or exceeds the required quantity of shares it announced to buyback. This
is the final buyback price and is paid to all shareholders whose shares have been
accepted for buyback.
3. From employees of the company whom it had issued securities under the' scheme of
stock option' or 'sweat equity '
OTHER PROVISIONS RELATING TO BUYBACK
• Declaration of Solvency [Sec.68(6)] - Before buyback, the company is required to file with ROC and SEBI a declaration of
solvency duly signed and verified by an affidavit from the board of directors that the company is capable of meeting its
liabilities and will not be rendered insolvent within a period of one year.
• Physical destruction of securities[ 68(7)]- After completion of buyback operations, the securities must be extinguished and
physically destroyed within 7 days of completion of buyback.
• Restriction on further issue after buyback [68(8)]- Where a company has bought back its securities it cannot make a further
issue of same kind of securities within a period of six months from date of completion of buyback.
• Register of bought back securities [Sec.68(9)]- The company has to maintain a register containing the following particulars
relating to buyback such as consideration paid, date of cancellation or physical destruction of shares etc.
• Return of Buyback[68(10)]- Within 30 days of completion of buyback, the company has to file a return in prescribed form
with ROC and SEBI containing all relevant information regarding buyback .
• Transfer of certain sum to Capital Redemption Reserve [Sec.69] - In case a company purchases its own shares out of its free
reserves or securities premium account, an amount equal to nominal value of shares purchased must be transferred to CRR
.The CRR is a special type of reserve which is treated as share capital for reduction of capital purposes and can be utilised only
for issue of bonus shares.
• Prohibition for buyback in certain circumstances[Sec.70] - A company is prohibited from buying back in cases below
✓ through any subsidiary company \ or its own subsidiary company \or any investment company
✓ if it has defaulted in repayment of its deposits\term loan\ redemption of preference shares or any interest\ dividend thereon.
✓ it has not complied with provisions relating to filing of annual return (Sec.92) or declaration of dividend (Sec.123), timely
payment of dividend(Sec.127) or preparation of Financial Statements in prescribed form (Sec.129)
• Penalty- In case of non compliance of the above provisions, the company shall be punishable with fine ranging from ₹ 1 lakh to
3 lakh and officers in default shall be punishable with imprisonment up to 3 years and\or fine ranging from 1 lakh to 3 lakh .
CALLS & SHARE FORFEITURE
Companies generally instead of demanding the full face value of shares in one go, demand it in instalments as per
their capital requirements i.e. on application, on allotment, on first call and on second or final call.
A call may be defined as a ' demand made by the company on its shareholders, to pay whole or part of the balance
remaining unpaid on each share, after the allotment of shares, at any time, during its lifetime.‘
The unpaid amount of the share is like a debt due from a member to the company but the liability to pay it does
not arise until a valid call has been made by the company.
REQUISITES OF A VALID CALL-
• Call must be authorised by a valid resolution of BOD-The call resolution must specify the amount, the date and
the place of payment.
• Call must be made on uniform basis on all shares of same class- Discrimination should not be made between
shareholders of same class as regards the amount and time of payment of call.
• Call must be made bonafide in the best interest of company-Call must be made only when the company is in
need of funds . The directors should not misuse the power to make calls for their personal benefits.
• Call must conform to the provisions of AOA- Call must be made strictly as per the provisions of AOA of the
company. But incase AOA are silent on this issue, then Regulation 13 of Table F shall apply which states that
✓ The maximum amount per call shall be 25% of face value of share
✓ Atleast 1 months' gap should be there between two successive calls
✓ Members be given atleast 14 days' prior notice stating amount, time & place of call
✓ The directors have the discretion to revoke or postpone a call
Forfeiture of shares
Forfeiture means confiscation of the shares of a shareholder by way of penalty for
the nonpayment of any call . Instead of taking a legal action against the defaulter to
recover the call money, companies prefer to resort to forfeiting the shares. A company
does not have a statutory right to forfeit shares and so they expressly insert a clause
on forfeiture in their AOA to get the authority. If the AOA permit for forfeiture of
shares, then it shall be as per the AOA. If Articles are silent, then forfeiture shall be as
per the relevant Regulations (i.e. Regulations 28-34) of Table F of Schedule I -
• Shares are generally forfeited against nonpayment of call but AOA can provide for
any additional ground for forfeiture.
• The defaulting member should be served proper notice giving him reasonable time
to pay due call together with interest for the delayed period and informing him that
incase he fails to pay by the certain date, his shares will be forfeited.
• If the member still does not comply with the notice, the BOD will pass a formal
resolution of forfeiture and his shares will be forfeited. The forfeited shares shall be
sold / reissued on such terms and manner as the Board thinks fit.
• The power of forfeiture is a power of trust which must be exercised bona fide for the
good of the company and not for personal reasons like relieving a friend from
liability or settling scores with the shareholder whom directors dislike.
Effects of forfeiture
• On forfeiture, the defaulting shareholder ceases to be the member of the company
and his name is removed from the register of members
• He loses his claim to the paid up amount on his shares.
• If AOA so provide, he will also remain liable for the unpaid calls ( just like an ordinary
debtor of the company) for a period of 3 years from the date of forfeiture as articles are
in the nature of contract between company and member. But the company cannot
recover from him more than the difference between the amount payable on such
shares at the time of forfeiture and the amount received from its subsequent holders .
• Forfeiture of shares does not result in reduction of capital as these shares are reissued
Reissue of Forfeited Shares
• Forfeited shares can be issued at par, premium or discount. But discount on reissue of a
share cannot exceed the amount forfeited on such shares
• Reissue can be done only after suitable resolution of the board of directors .
• After the reissue, the new holder becomes the shareholder of the company and his
name will be entered in register of members
• Reissue of forfeited shares is regarded as sale and not as allotment and therefore there
is no need to file Return of Allotment with the ROC with respect of reissued shares.
Surrender of shares
Surrender of shares means the return of shares by the shareholder to the
company for cancellation voluntarily. The legal effects of surrender as well as
forfeiture are similar. The amount already paid on such shares is also confiscated
and these can also be reissued in same way. There is no provision for surrender in
the Companies Act or Table F. However , AOA may allow surrender of shares . But
in that case ,BOD can accept surrender of only partly paid shares and that too
where their forfeiture is justified i.e where a call has been made and amount
remains unpaid after the due date. Surrender of fully paid shares is out of
question.
SURRENDER VS FORFEITURE
• Surrender is a shortcut to forfeiture, which is a lengthy process.
• Surrender involves the initiative of the shareholder whereas forfeiture is at the
initiative of the company.
Transfer of securities
A transfer of securities takes place where the registered security holder transfers by sale or otherwise his
securities to another person voluntarily. Securities shall be moveable goods transferable in the manner
prescribed by the Companies Act and the Articles of Association (and not by mere delivery as in case of
furniture etc.)
Procedure of transfer of securities through Transfer deeds
• Provisions of AOA relating to transfer of shares must be followed. Transfer of securities can be done by
registered shareholder or a legal representative of the deceased.
• Oral transfers are not recognised by the Act. An instrument of transfer, in prescribed form, should be
executed. It should be duly filled, dated, stamped and signed by both the transferor and transferee.
• Along with the transfer form attach - the relative share certificate + copy of PAN cards
• The complete set of transfer form should be delivered at company's head office for registration within
60 days from the date of execution
• In case the transfer relates to partly paid up shares, the company must give notice of this fact to the
transferee and can register the transfer only if transferee makes no objection .
• The transfer form is then presented to the BODs for approval . If approved. the company registers the
transfer i.e. strikes off the transferor's name from Register of Members and enters the name of
transferee in its place
• An endorsement is made on the back of the shares, recognising the transferee as the new holder of it
and the same is issued to transferee within one month of the date of lodgement of transfer.
Transmission of shares
It means transfer of property\ title in securities by operation of law i.e. in case of death\
insolvency\ lunacy of a security holder , the securities get assigned respectively to the legal
representative\ official receiver\ guardian appointed by court . The person becoming entitled to
shares on transmission shall have the same rights as to dividend and other privileges as were
there with original member.
There are two alternatives open to the legal representative. He can opt for any of them. If he
does not opt any of these alternatives the company will send a notice to him asking about his
choice and unless he intimates his decision, the company will freeze these shares and withhold
the payment of dividend, bonus etc on them.
OPTIONS
1. He may get himself registered as a security holder. For this ,he has to make a Request
Application + attach relevant Share Certificates+ copy of Death Certificate + attach Succession
Certificate to the company. In case company is satisfied with the genuineness of the documents,
it will delete name of deceased security holder from Register and enter the name of legal
representative in the Register + issue new share certificate in his name .
2. He may decide to transfer the securities. For this he will have to follow the usual procedure of
transfer i.e fill Instrument of Transfer + attach relevant Share Certificates+ copy of Death
Certificate + attach Succession Certificate to the company. If the company is satisfied with the
documents, it will register the transfer.
Distinction between transfer and transmission
• Transfer of securities is deliberate act of parties where as transmission takes place by operation of law on death\ insolvency\
lunacy of a security holder.
• Transfer of securities requires execution of a formal instrument of transfer whereas transmission requires an evidence of
entitlement ( succession certificate).
• Except when transfer is by way of gift, there must be presence of adequate consideration whereas no consideration is required
in case of transmission
• In case of transfer, stamp duty on market value of securities is payable whereas no stamp duty is payable in case of
transmission of shares.
RESTRICTIONS ON TRANSFER IN CASE OF PRIVATE COMPANIES- Shares of a public company are freely transferable and BOD
cannot refuse to register transfer of their shares but in case of private companies, right to transfer shares must necessarily be
restricted by its AOA. However, absolute restriction , even in case of private companies ,is void and inoperative. Actually the
purpose behind restrictions on transferability of shares of private companies is to maintain personal contact among members.
Therefore, AOA of private companies usually contain restriction in the form of pre-emption clause which states that the
intending transferor must in the first instance offer shares to the existing members of the company . Under the AOA, the BOD of
a private company can also refuse to register a transfer on the following grounds eg. partly paid up shares are to be transferred
to a pauper/minor /unsound mind person or that transferee is a person with whom directors of company have personal
animosity or where call is unpaid against shares to be transferred or where company has lien on the shares as the transferor is
indebted to it or instrument of transfer contains some irregularity i.e not signed\ stamped etc.
If a company refuses to register the transfer \ transmission of securities, it must send a notice of refusal to the parties
concerned and state in it the reasons for refusal. The parties may then file an appeal with the Tribunal against such refusal ,
within prescribed time. The Tribunal after hearing them, may either dismiss the appeal or may order the company to register the
transfer \ transmission within 10 days of receipt of order. Further, it may direct the company to rectify the register and also
damages to the aggrieved party.
D-MAT\Depository System
The transfer of securities in physical form suffers from many limitations such as
• Huge cost because of postal charges, stamp duty, paper- work, stationery, odd lots
• Inconveniences associated with transportation , despatch ,safe custody of securities
• Bad deliveries due to faulty compliance of paperwork ,mismatch of signatures etc.
• Risks involved due to theft, forgery, mutilation of certificates
• Undue delays due to procedural lags , frequent following up with company\ brokers etc.
In order to remove the above shortcomings associated with physical delivery of securities
,the Government of India has enacted the Depositories Act, 1996 to provide for legal
framework for setting up of Depositories and effecting transfers of securities through
book entry only.
Depository System - It is a system whereby the transfer of securities takes place by
means of book entry in the ledgers of the Depository and not through transfer deeds and
physical movement of [Link] is also known as" Scripless Trading System ". The main
objective of this system is is to minimize paperwork involved with the ownership, trading
and transfer of securities. The depository system works very much like a banking system.
Similarities between a banking system & depository system
BANK DEPOSITORY
• Holds funds in accounts • Holds securities in accounts
• Transfers funds between accounts on the instruction of • Transfers securities between accounts on instruction of
account holders account holders
• Facilitates transfer of funds without having to handle • Facilitates transfer of securities without having to handle
money securities
• Accountable for safe keeping of the money • Accountable for safe keeping of securities
• Eg. PNB, SBI • Eg. NSDL, CDSL
Depository- It is an organisation where securities of an investor are held in electronic form and securities transactions are
carried out by means of book entry through the medium of a Depository Participant. The depository must be formed and
registered as a company under the Companies Act and must also seek registration with SEBI by fulfilling prescribed conditions.
Following are the important Depositories in India and companies can enlist their shares with either or both of them-