0% found this document useful (0 votes)
7 views36 pages

Problem Attachment Disharmonies Rajiv Week11

The document discusses the importance of problem-solving in entrepreneurship, contrasting modernist and postmodernist approaches to planning and control. It emphasizes the need for sensitivity to disharmonies in everyday practice to identify opportunities and highlights the historical context of problem-solving through examples like Einstein's theory of relativity. The text also touches on the concept of 'disclosive space' as a framework for understanding our interactions with the world.

Uploaded by

agnesgejl
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
7 views36 pages

Problem Attachment Disharmonies Rajiv Week11

The document discusses the importance of problem-solving in entrepreneurship, contrasting modernist and postmodernist approaches to planning and control. It emphasizes the need for sensitivity to disharmonies in everyday practice to identify opportunities and highlights the historical context of problem-solving through examples like Einstein's theory of relativity. The text also touches on the concept of 'disclosive space' as a framework for understanding our interactions with the world.

Uploaded by

agnesgejl
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

RECAP

@rajiv_VB
Image creator: TanushkaBu

@rajiv_VB
At the heart of it – We love
problem-solving

@rajiv_VB © Klipspringer - [Link]


Source: [Link]

@rajiv_VB
@rajiv_VB
ENTREPRENEURIAL *

• Experience the same problems

• Hold on to these problems – with


intense focus on facts and details
– until they can see:

– What is Wrong –what is


”Really” the problem

– How we could be doing


things instead

* DISCLAIMER: Not every “Entrepreneur” is Entrepreneurial nor


@rajiv_VB thoughtful nor necessarily problem-centric
@rajiv_VB
• French Philosopher, Mathematician
& Writer
• Cartesian co-ordinate system –
Cartesian ROBOTS
• Academic Detachment
• Objectivity – objectification
• Uses given methods & theories to
explain causal relationships
Image Source: Wikipedia
• Modernism: E.g. in city planning –
Rene Descartes top down approaches, ”one-size-fits-
Cogito ergo sum – all” approach & movement towards
”I think, thereore I am” homogenous landscapes
• No Entrepreneurial opportunities –
only ”optimization
@rajiv_VB
• “Postmodernism is a rejection of 'totality', of the notion that
planning could be 'comprehensive', widely applied regardless of
context, and rational” – Wiki
 i.e. it is a rejection of Modernism

• Change for the sake of change –


Improvising, Surfing

• Change agent – ”Just do-it


Entrepreneurship” – it tries to
highlight the anything goes
mentality, flexibility

@rajiv_VB
Two opposing thought processes

POST-MODERN PRACTICE
Academic Detachment Anything Goes
”Just do-it” Entrepreneurship
Complete Planning / Anti-Planning /
Control Control

@rajiv_VB
@rajiv_VB © Klipspringer - [Link]
Entrepreneurship

Individual / Group Opportunity


@rajiv_VB
“If I had only one hour to solve a problem, I would
spend up to two-thirds of that hour in attempting to
define what the problem is.”

OK, what he is really famous for is his Special


Theory of Relativity and his simple equation:
[Link] E=mc2
Understanding a problem has long been considered as the
fundamental task in solving it (Einstein & Infeld, 1938)
@rajiv_VB
A short history/science lesson

@rajiv_VB
Maxwell (late 1800s) predicted that the
speed of light in a vacuum is a constant –
approx. 300,000 km/sec.

Experiments prove speed of light is true regardless of the state of motion of the observer

Anomaly: If Maxwell’s theory is to be consistent with classical mechanics, the speed of


light ought to depend on the speed of the observer. While many experiments were
devised to detect such a dependence, none was ever found.
Einstein realized that either Newton or Maxwell had to be wrong and held on to the anomaly…
@rajiv_VB
He doesn’t give up and holds on to the
problem. In 1905 while working as a patent
office clerk he comes up with the theory of
relativity.

He figured out that the prob. was not


Maxwell’s theory but that it was classical
mechanics that was wrong (something that
has worked for 200 years) – i.e. classical
mechanics do not work at the speed of light!

He had deep sense of the past (i.e. others knowledge – Newton,


Maxwell, etc.) and used it to make history without being bound to it
(that history is always right) – thus a ahistorical history maker

@rajiv_VB Background image (Credit: NASA) - Einstein's theory of general relativity predicted that the space-time around Earth would
be not only warped but also twisted by the planet's rotation. Gravity Probe B showed this to be correct.
”Opportunities originates
from our sensitivity toward
disharmonies in our
everyday practice”
* Who is a Discloser? - All of us are…
”We call any organised set of practices for dealing with
oneself, other people, and things that produces a relatively self
contained web of meanings a disclosive space” – S, F & D

The reference to the act of disclosure, The reference to a space is interesting in


is an attempt to recover an that it evokes a sense of the physicality of
understanding of ourselves as the locus our access to the world. Our understanding
of an opening onto the world. This of the world is an embodied understanding.
opening allows aspects of the world to We must always adopt a particular vantage
show up for us in particular ways. The point. The space of the world can only ever
reference to disclosure is an open up to us from a particular point of
acknowledgment of the fact that we are view. Space is not mere emptiness. It is
always already oriented towards the dependent on some form of articulation.
world.
Source: [Link]
 Design/Change of anything
• Oganizations & technology:
Entrepreneurship
• Politics: Democratic action
• Culture: Cultivation of solidarity
• Society, technology, personal identity
”Opportunities originates from
our sensitivity toward 'This book does not present a theory of
disharmonies in our everyday entrepreneurship, democratic action, and solidarity
practice” production. Nor is it a manual that will tell you
how to succeed in these domains‘ (p.1.)
”Opportunities originates from our sensitivity toward disharmonies in
our everyday practice” – S.F.D
What does this have to do with Tesla? Making electric cars mass market requires
all of Edison’s tricks to make a radical technology look normal. Tesla is already
doing this. Why does charging a Tesla look like putting gas in a regular car -
skeuomorphs!
Dispassionate
Approach

Intense
engagement
”We call any organised set of
practices for dealing with oneself,
other people, and things that
produces a relatively self contained
web of meanings a disclosive space”

”Opportunities originates from our


sensitivity toward disharmonies in
our everyday practice”

You might also like