Corporate Issuers
Capital Structure Theories
Capital Structure Theories
Modigliani-Miller (MM) Propositions
MM I: value of a firm is unaffected by its capital structure
Levered and unlevered firm have same value
Assumptions
No taxes, transaction costs, bankruptcy costs
Homogeneous expectations
Borrowing and lending at risk-free rate
No agency costs
Investment decisions unaffected by financing decisions
© Kaplan, Inc. 1
1
Capital Structure Theories
Modigliani-Miller (MM) Propositions
MM II: WACC is unaffected by capital structure
rd < re because cash
Cost of capital
flows to debtholders are
less risky D
re = r0 + (r0 – rd )
re increases as E
proportion of debt
increases WACC
r0
Same assumptions as
Cost of debt
MM I, including no taxes
© Kaplan, Inc. Debt/equity 2
Capital Structure Theories
Modigliani-Miller (MM) Propositions
MM with taxes: debt financing creates a tax shield that
increases company value
Cost of capital
Cost of capital minimized D
re = r0 + (r0 – rd ) 1 – TC
and value of the firm E
maximized at 100% debt
WACC
rd After-tax
cost of debt
% of debt in
3
© Kaplan, Inc.
capital structure
2
Capital Structure Theories
Modigliani-Miller (MM) Propositions
In practice, firms do not use 100% debt due to costs of
financial distress:
Legal and administrative fees from bankruptcy
Loss of trust, foregone investment opportunities
Agency costs of debt: managers represent equity owners
© Kaplan, Inc. 4
Capital Structure Theories
Static Trade-Off Theory
Cost of capital
Cost of equity A firm’s optimal capital
structure is the proportion
of debt at which the value of
WACC
the tax shield from additional
borrowing just offsets the
increase in costs of financial
After-tax cost of debt distress.
with financial distress
Optimal % of debt in
capital structure capital structure
© Kaplan, Inc. 5
3
Capital Structure Theories
Agency Cost and Asymmetric Information
Firm insiders have a better quality of information.
Outsiders look for signals from managers.
Agency cost (of separation of ownership and control)
Monitoring cost
Bonding cost
Residual losses
© Kaplan, Inc. 6
Capital Structure Theories
Pecking Order Theory
Managers want to send the least amount of negative signal.
Accordingly, their preferred sources of capital (highest to
lowest) are as follows:
Retained earnings
Debt
New equity
The pecking order theory states that the observed capital
structure is the result of the manager’s choices over time.
© Kaplan, Inc. 7