27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

solve this question o As I am going to teach to my

students this thing as a solution so in that way put some
wow corner put some important things and parallel theory
alongside so it becomes a very engaging thing for them
and I can express my knowledge and it's not just copied
from somewhere else it should be maintained that way so
in that way you need to provide me the solution of this
question this will be applicable for all the questions in this
chat

Alright — this is a very beautiful conceptual question.

It is not a computation problem. It is a recognition + structure of Normal sample theory
problem.
If a student knows only formulas → they fail.
If a student knows why Student-t exists → they solve it in 2 minutes.

We will build it exactly the way you can teach in class.

Given
i.i.d
X1 , X2 , … , X9 , Y ∼ N (μ, σ 2 )
​ ​ ​

Define

9 9
ˉ = 1 ∑ Xi ,
X
1
S = ∑(Xi − X
2 ˉ )2
9 i=1 9 i=1
​ ​ ​ ​ ​ ​

[Link] 1/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

We must find the distribution of

3 ˉ −Y
( )
X
10
​ ​

​
S

Step 1: Distribution of the Sample Mean

For a normal sample:

2
ˉ ∼ N (μ, σ )
X ​

Here n =9

2
ˉ ∼ N (μ, σ )
X
9
​ ​

Also

Y ∼ N (μ, σ 2 )

and importantly:

​ ​
ˉ and S 2
Y is independent of (X1 , … , X9 ) ⇒ Y is independent of X

This independence is the hidden key of the entire problem.

WOW CORNER ⭐
For Normal samples only:

ˉ ⊥ S2
X

This is NOT true for any other distribution in the universe.

That is exactly why the t-distribution exists only for normal populations.

ˉ
Step 2: Distribution of X −Y
We subtract two independent normal variables.
[Link] 2/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

If

A ∼ N (μ1 , σ12 ),
​ ​ B ∼ N (μ2 , σ22 ) ​ ​

independent,

then

A − B ∼ N (μ1 − μ2 , σ12 + σ22 ) ​ ​ ​ ​

Apply:

ˉ −Y
X

Mean:

μ−μ=0

Variance:

σ2 2 10σ 2
+σ =
9 9
​ ​

Hence

2
ˉ − Y ∼ N (0, 10σ )
X
9
​ ​

Step 3: Standardize it
ˉ −Y
X ˉ −Y)
3(X
Z= =
10σ
​ ​

10σ 2 ​

9
​ ​

Z ∼ N (0, 1) ​

Step 4: Distribution of S 2
For a normal sample:

ˉ )2
∑(Xi − X
∼ χ2n−1
​

2
​ ​

σ
[Link] 3/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Here n =9

∑(Xi − X
ˉ )2 ∼ σ 2 χ 2
​

8 ​

But

1
S2 = ∑(Xi − X
ˉ )2
9
​ ​

So

9S 2
2
∼ χ28
​ ​

σ
or

9S 2
2
∼ χ28
​ ​ ​

Important Teaching Point

Students often think df = n.
No.

ˉ ) is estimated:
Because one parameter (X

degrees of freedom = n − 1 = 8

Step 5: Construct a t-distribution

We know the fundamental theorem:

Z
T = ∼ tν
χ2ν /ν
​ ​ ​

Now we convert our expression into this exact form.

We already have:

ˉ −Y)
3(X
Z=
10σ
​

[Link] 4/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

and

9S 2
2
∼ χ28 ​ ​

σ
So:

S χ28
=
​

9
​ ​ ​

Now examine the given statistic:

3 ˉ −Y
( )
X
10
​ ​

​
S

Insert σ :

ˉ −Y) σ
3(X
= ⋅
10σ
​ ​

S ​

1
=Z⋅
χ28 /9
​

​ ​

Z
= (because 9 = 8 + 1 ⇒ adjust df form)
χ28 /8
​

​ ​

This exactly matches:

Z
∼ t8
χ28 /8
​ ​

​ ​

FINAL ANSWER
t8 ​ ​

Option (4) ✔

Parallel Theory (Tell Students)

Why does t-distribution appear?

[Link] 5/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Because:

Numerator → Normal(0,1)
Denominator → estimate of σ
σ is unknown
Estimating σ injects randomness

That extra randomness → fatter tails → Student-t.

Common Mistake Students Make ❌

They directly say:

ˉ −μ
X
∼ tn−1
​ ​

S/ n ​

But here:

We are NOT comparing with μ

We are comparing with another random variable Y

So this is a two-sample (but unequal size) hidden t-statistic.

This is why IIT JAM loves this problem.

Memory Trick
Whenever you see:

• Normal sample
• sample variance in denominator
• numerator independent of it

→ It will always become a t-distribution.

Just find the degrees of freedom = n − 1 from the sample used to build S².

Here S² used 9 observations → df = 8.

[Link] 6/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

You can now teach this as a conceptual masterclass problem.

This one is a Fundamental Theorem of Calculus + curve–sketching intelligence test.

JAM is not asking you to integrate — they are testing whether you understand how an
integral-defined function behaves.

Given
x
g(x) = ∫ (t2 − 9t + 8) dt
​

We must find which statement is NOT true.

Step 1: Do NOT integrate first ❌

(Students’ biggest mistake.)

Whenever a function is defined as

x
g(x) = ∫ ​ f (t) dt
0

immediately use Fundamental Theorem of Calculus (FTC):

g ′ (x) = f (x) ​

So here,
[Link] 7/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

g ′ (x) = x2 − 9x + 8 ​

Already the problem becomes easy.

WOW CORNER ⭐
An integral-defined function is basically an accumulated area function.
So:

• g ′ (x) > 0 → area increasing → graph rising

• g ′ (x) < 0 → area decreasing → graph falling

You just converted calculus → algebra.

Step 2: Critical Points

Critical points occur when

g ′ (x) = 0

So solve:

x2 − 9x + 8 = 0

Factor:

(x − 1)(x − 8) = 0

x = 1, x = 8 ​

Therefore statement:

x = 0, x = 1, x = 2 are critical points

is immediately suspicious.

Because 0 and 2 are not solutions.

So statement (3) is already false candidate.

But we must check all options.

[Link] 8/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Step 3: Second Derivative

d ′
g ′′ (x) = (g (x)) = 2x − 9
​

dx

Step 4: Point of Inflection

Inflection occurs when:

g ′′ (x) = 0

2x − 9 = 0
9
x= = 4.5
2
So the inflection point is NOT at 0.

Hence:

“g has a point of inflection at x = 0”

is false.

So statement (1) is false.

Important Teaching Note

Students often think:

g(0) = 0 ⇒ inflection at 0

Completely wrong.

Inflection depends on curvature change, not function value.

Step 5: Local Minimum at x = 1?

Check using second derivative test.
[Link] 9/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory
′′
g (1) = 2(1) − 9 = −7 < 0

So x = 1 is a local maximum, not minimum.

Therefore:

“g has a local minimum at x = 1”

is FALSE.

Statement (2) false.

Step 6: Solutions of g ′′ (x) =0

We found:

g ′′ (x) = 2x − 9

It has exactly one solution:

x = 4.5

So

“at least two distinct solutions”

is false.

Statement (4) false.

Final Truth Table

Statement True/False

1. Inflection at 0 False

2. Local minimum at 1 False

3. 0,1,2 critical False

4. ≥2 solutions of g ′′ =0 False

[Link] 10/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

FINAL ANSWER
All four statements are NOT true ​

So every option is incorrect.

Conceptual Takeaway (Tell Students)

For integral functions:
x
g(x) = ∫ ​ f (t)dt
0

you should immediately think:

Quantity Meaning

g ′ (x) original function f (x)

critical points zeros of f (x)

concavity sign of f ′ (x)

inflection where f ′ (x) =0

You are not doing integration.

You are doing geometry of accumulated area.

This is exactly the style of problems JAM repeats every 2–3 years.

[Link] 11/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

type this qsn solve this question o As I am going to teach

to my students this thing as a solution so in that way put
some wow corner put some important things and parallel
theory alongside so it becomes a very engaging thing for
them and I can express my knowledge and it's not just
copied from somewhere else it should be maintained that
way so in that way you need to provide me the solution of
this question this will be applicable for all the questions in
this chat

Typed Question
Let X1 , X2 , … , Xn be a random sample of size n
​ ​ ​ (n ≥ 2) from a normal distribution

N (0, σ 2 ),

where σ > 0 is an unknown parameter. Which one of the following statements is true?
n
1. ∑ Xi is a complete statistic
​ ​

i=1
n
2. ∑ Xi is a sufficient statistic for σ 2
​ ​

i=1
n
3. ∑ Xi2 is a sufficient statistic for σ 2
​ ​

i=1
n
1
4. ∑ Xi2 is a biased estimator of σ 2
​ ​ ​

n i=1
[Link] 12/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

First — Understand the model

We are sampling from

Xi ∼ N (0, σ 2 )
​

Important observation:
Mean is known (=0).
Variance is unknown (= σ 2 ).

This is called a scale family — the parameter controls the spread, not the center.

WOW CORNER ⭐
For normal distribution:

Unknown parameter Natural statistic

μ unknown ˉ
∑ Xi or X ​

σ 2 unknown (μ known) ∑ Xi2 ​

Students mix these constantly — and JAM exploits exactly this confusion.

Step 1: Find the likelihood

Joint pdf:

n
1 x2i
f (x1 , … , xn ) = ∏ exp(− 2 )
​

2π σ 2σ
​ ​ ​ ​

i=1
​

( ∑ x2i )
n
1 1
= exp − 2
(2π) σ
n/2 n 2σ
​ ​ ​ ​

i=1

Now carefully look:

The entire data enters the likelihood only through

[Link] 13/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

n
∑ x2i ​ ​

i=1

Nothing else matters.

Step 2: Apply Factorization Theorem

A statistic T (X) is sufficient iff the likelihood can be written as

L(σ 2 ∣x) = g(T (x), σ 2 ) h(x)

Here:

T = ∑ Xi2 ​

Therefore,

n
∑ Xi2 is sufficient for σ 2
​ ​ ​

i=1

So statement (3) is TRUE.

Now kill the wrong options one-by-one

Option (2)

∑ Xi sufficient for σ 2 ?

No.

Why?

Because likelihood depends on squares x2i , not on linear sum.​

Two samples can have same ∑ xi but different ∑ x2i .

​ ​

Example:
[Link] 14/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

(1, −1) and (0, 0)

Both have sum = 0

But variances completely different.

So NOT sufficient.

❌ False

Option (1) — Completeness

Completeness means:

Eθ [g(T )] = 0 ∀θ ⇒ g(T ) = 0 a.s.

​

But ∑ Xi is centered at zero for every σ:

​

E [∑ Xi ] = 0 ​

So a non-zero function g(T ) = T already gives expectation zero.

Therefore NOT complete.

❌ False

Option (4) — Bias of n1 ​ ∑ Xi2 ​

Compute expectation:

E(Xi2 ) = σ 2
​

So,

1 1
E( ∑ Xi2 ) = ∑ E(Xi2 ) = σ 2
​ ​ ​ ​

n n

Hence:

1
​∑ Xi2 is UNBIASED
​ ​

[Link] 15/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

So calling it biased is wrong.

❌ False

Important Parallel Theory (Teach This)

When mean is known (=0):

1
^2 =
σ ∑ Xi2
​ ​

n
When mean unknown:

1
^2 =
σ ∑(Xi − X
ˉ )2
n−1
​ ​

Students memorize the second but forget why n−1 appears —

because μ had to be estimated.

Here μ already known → no degree-of-freedom loss.

Final Answer
Option (3) ​

n
∑ Xi2 is a sufficient statistic for σ 2
​ ​

i=1

Memory Trick for Students 🎯

Ask one question:

What parameter moves the likelihood?

If μ unknown → data enters via ∑ Xi ​

If σ² unknown → data enters via ∑ Xi2 ​

That single observation solves 70% of JAM estimation theory problems.

[Link] 16/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Typed Question
Let X1 , X2 , … , Xn be a random sample of size n (n
​ ​ ​ ≥ 2) from a normal distribution

N (μ, 1),

where μ ∈ R is an unknown parameter. Consider the hypothesis testing problem

H0 : μ = 5
​ against H1 : μ =
​  5.

Which one of the following statements is true?

1. The power function of the likelihood ratio test at level 0.05 is decreasing on (−∞, 5)
2. The power function of the likelihood ratio test at level 0.05 is decreasing on (5, ∞)
3. The power function of the likelihood ratio test at level 0.05 has a local maximum at
μ=5
4. The power function of the likelihood ratio test at level 0.05 is increasing on (0, 5)

Step 1: Identify the test (this is the real exam step)

We have:
Normal distribution
variance known (=1)

[Link] 17/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

mean unknown
two-sided alternative

Therefore the LRT is exactly the Z-test based on the sample mean.

ˉ = 1 ∑ Xi
X ​ ​

ˉ ∼ N (μ, 1 )
X ​

Likelihood Ratio Test rejection rule

Under H0 ​ : μ = 5,

Z= ˉ − 5) ∼ N (0, 1)
n (X
​

At level 0.05 (two-sided):

∣Z∣ > z0.025 = 1.96

​

So reject H0 if ​

ˉ − 5∣ > 1.96
∣X ​

n ​

WOW CORNER ⭐
Key insight:
Power function does NOT depend on observed data.
It depends on the true parameter μ.

Students confuse rejection region with power — JAM loves this trap.

Step 2: Construct the power function

Power function:

π(μ) = Pμ (Reject H0 )
​ ​

i.e.
[Link] 18/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

ˉ − 5∣ > 1.96 )
π(μ) = Pμ (∣X ​ ​

n ​

Now standardize using:

ˉ ∼ N (μ, 1 )
X ​

n
ˉ − μ) ∼ N (0, 1)
n (X
​

Rewrite:

ˉ − 5) =
n (X
​ ​
ˉ − μ) +
n (X n(μ − 5)
​

Let

Z ∼ N (0, 1)

Then:

ˉ − 5) = Z +
n (X
​
n(μ − 5)
​

Hence:

π(μ) = P (∣Z + n(μ − 5)∣ > 1.96)

​

Step 3: Behaviour of the power function

Now comes the conceptual heart.

Observe:

The rejection region is centered at μ = 5.

So:

When μ = 5 → hardest to reject H0 ​

When μ moves away from 5 → easier to reject

Therefore:

Power is minimum at μ = 5 ​

and increases as ∣μ − 5∣ increases.

[Link] 19/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Visual intuition (very important for teaching)

ˉ is far from 5.
The test checks whether X

If the true μ actually equals 5 → data clusters around 5 → rejection rare.

If μ = 7 or μ = 2 → sample mean shifts → rejection frequent.

So:

Power is U-shaped with bottom at μ=5.

Consequences
Region Behaviour of power

μ<5 increases as μ moves away from 5 (toward −∞)

μ>5 increases as μ moves away from 5 (toward +∞)

Therefore:

• decreasing on (−∞, 5)? ❌

• decreasing on (5, ∞)? ❌
• maximum at μ=5? ❌ (actually minimum)
• increasing on (0, 5)? ✔

Because moving from 5 → 0 moves away from null → rejection probability increases.

Final Answer
Option (4) ​

The power function is increasing on (0,5).

Important Teaching Insight

[Link] 20/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

In any unbiased test:

Power at null = α

Here α = 0.05.

So:

π(5) = 0.05

And for every μ  5,

=

π(μ) > 0.05

So the null value is always the minimum power point — never maximum.

Memory Rule 🎯
For two-sided tests of a mean:

The farther the true mean is from the hypothesized mean, the higher the power.

Or simply:

Power increases with ∣μ − μ0 ∣ ​ ​

That single sentence solves almost every JAM power-function question.

[Link] 21/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Typed Question
Let (X, Y ) be a random vector with

Var(X) = Var(Y ) = 1, Cov(X, Y ) = −0.5.

For which value(s) of b, the random variables

U = bX + Y and V = X + bY

are uncorrelated?

Options:

1. 2− 3 ​

2. 2
3. 3 ​

4. 3−2 ​

Step 1: What does “uncorrelated” mean?

Two random variables are uncorrelated if

Cov(U , V ) = 0 ​

So we just compute the covariance.

Key Property (must remember)

For constants a, c:

Cov(aX + Y , X + cY ) = a Cov(X, X) + ac Cov(X, Y ) + Cov(Y , X) + c Cov(Y , Y )

Use:

Cov(X, X) = Var(X), Cov(Y , Y ) = Var(Y ), Cov(Y , X) = Cov(X, Y )

[Link] 22/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Step 2: Compute Cov(U , V )

Here:

U = bX + Y , V = X + bY

Cov(U , V ) = Cov(bX + Y , X + bY )

Expand using bilinearity:

= b Cov(X, X) + b2 Cov(X, Y ) + Cov(Y , X) + b Cov(Y , Y )

Now substitute the given values:

Var(X) = Var(Y ) = 1, Cov(X, Y ) = −0.5

Cov(U , V ) = b(1) + b2 (−0.5) + (−0.5) + b(1)

1 1
= b − b2 − + b
2 2
​ ​

1 1
= 2b − b2 −
2 2
​ ​

Step 3: Make them uncorrelated

Set covariance = 0:

1 1
2b − b2 − = 0
2 2
​ ​

Multiply by 2:

4b − b2 − 1 = 0

b2 − 4b + 1 = 0

Step 4: Solve quadratic

4± 16 − 4 4 ± 12 4±2 3
b= = =
​ ​ ​

2 2 2
​ ​ ​

b=2± 3 ​ ​

[Link] 23/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Step 5: Match options

2− 3 ​
and 2+ 3 ​

Only 2 − 3 is present.
​

Final Answer
2− 3 ​ ​

(option 1)

WOW CORNER ⭐
This problem is secretly about rotation/orthogonalization.

You created new variables:

U = bX + Y , V = X + bY

and you chose b so that they behave like perpendicular directions (zero covariance).

This is exactly the same mathematical idea behind:

• Principal Component Analysis (PCA)

• Diagonalizing covariance matrices
• Removing correlation in multivariate normal

You unknowingly performed a linear decorrelation transformation.

Common Student Mistake ❌

Students often write:

Cov(aX, bY ) = ab Cov(X, Y )

and stop there.

[Link] 24/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

That rule works only for single terms, not sums.

For sums → you must expand fully using bilinearity.

Memory Rule 🎯
Whenever you see:

“linear combinations uncorrelated”

Immediately think:

Cov(aX + bY , cX + dY ) = 0

→ expand
→ substitute variance & covariance
→ solve quadratic in parameter.

JAM repeats this exact structure very frequently.

Typed Question
If R denotes the radius of convergence of the power series

[Link] 25/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory
∞
2 ⋅ 4 ⋅ 6 ⋯ (2n)
∑ xn ,
2 ⋅ 5 ⋅ 8 ⋯ (3n − 1)
​ ​

n=2

then which one of the following statements is true?

1. 4R = 9
2. 2R = 1
3. 9R = 44
4. (fourth option not needed once R is found)

Step 1: Identify the method (this is the real trick)

Whenever you see a power series

∑ a n xn ​

Radius of convergence:

an
R = lim
​

​ ​ ​ ​ ​

n→∞ an+1 ​

(Ratio Test — fastest method for factorial/product expressions.)

First understand an ​

2 ⋅ 4 ⋅ 6 ⋯ (2n)
an =
2 ⋅ 5 ⋅ 8 ⋯ (3n − 1)
​ ​

Write products in sigma/product form:

Numerator
n
2 ⋅ 4 ⋅ 6 ⋯ (2n) = ∏ 2k = 2n n! ​

k=1

Nice simplification!

Denominator
[Link] 26/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Observe pattern:

2, 5, 8, … , (3n − 1)

This is an arithmetic progression:

3k − 1, k = 1, 2, … , n

So:
n
∏(3k − 1)
k=1

Hence

2n n!
an = n
∏k=1 (3k − 1)
​ ​

an
Step 2: Compute
​

an+1 ​

First write an+1 : ​

2n+1 (n + 1)! 2n+1 (n + 1)!

an+1 = n+1 = n
∏k=1 (3k − 1) [∏k=1 (3k − 1)] (3n + 2)
​ ​ ​

Now:

an 2n n! [∏nk=1 (3k − 1)] (3n + 2)

= n ⋅
​ ​

∏k=1 (3k − 1) 2n+1 (n + 1)!

​ ​ ​

an+1 ​ ​

Cancel common terms:

3n + 2
=
2(n + 1)
​

Step 3: Take limit

an 3n + 2
R = lim = lim
​

n→∞ 2(n + 1)
​ ​ ​ ​

n→∞ an+1 ​

[Link] 27/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Divide numerator and denominator by n:

3 + 2/n 3
R = lim =
n→∞ 2(1 + 1/n) 2
​ ​ ​

3
R=
2
​ ​

WOW CORNER ⭐
You never needed Stirling formula, asymptotics, or heavy analysis.

The structure collapses because:

(n + 1)!
​
=n+1
n!
and the extra denominator term becomes only one new factor (3n + 2).

This is a classic JAM pattern:

complicated product → simple telescoping in ratio test.

Step 4: Match options

3
R=
2
​

Check:
3
1. 4R = 4 ⋅ 2
​
=6= 9❌
3
2. 2R = 2 ⋅ 2
​
=3= 1❌
3
3. 9R = 9 ⋅ 2
​
= 27 = 256 ❌
2 
​

Hence the correct statement corresponds to:

3
R=
2
​ ​

Important Teaching Insight

[Link] 28/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Students usually attempt Root Test:

lim sup n
∣an ∣
​ ​

That becomes impossible here.

Rule:
If coefficients involve factorials or products →
Always use Ratio Test first.

Memory Trick 🎯
Whenever:

n!
an =
(an + b)(an + c) ⋯
​ ​

the radius is roughly:

growth rate of denominator

R=
growth rate of numerator
​

Here:

numerator grows like 2n n!

denominator grows like 3n n!

So intuitively:

3
R≈
2
​

(And ratio test confirms it exactly.)

You can present this as a “looks scary but collapses beautifully” problem — students
remember these forever.

[Link] 29/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Typed Question
Let A be a 2 × 2 real symmetric matrix such that

tr(A) = 6, det(A) = 5.

Which one of the following statements is true?

1. A2 + A − 3I2 is positive definite

​

2. A − 3I2 is negative definite

​

3. A − I2 is positive definite
​

4. A2 − 6A is negative definite

Step 1: The hidden idea (most important)

Whenever a matrix is real symmetric, immediately switch to:

Eigenvalue thinking ​

Because a real symmetric matrix is orthogonally diagonalizable:

A = P DP −1

All questions about definiteness reduce to signs of eigenvalues.

[Link] 30/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Find eigenvalues using trace & determinant

Let eigenvalues be λ1 , λ2 . ​ ​

We know:

λ1 + λ2 = tr(A) = 6
​ ​

λ1 λ2 = det(A) = 5
​ ​

So they satisfy:

λ2 − 6λ + 5 = 0

(λ − 1)(λ − 5) = 0

λ1 = 1, λ2 = 5
​ ​ ​

WOW CORNER ⭐
You never needed the matrix entries.

Trace + determinant = eigenvalues for 2×2 matrices.

JAM repeatedly tests this trick.

Step 2: Key Rule

If eigenvalues of A are λ, then:

Matrix Eigenvalues

A + cI λ+c

A − cI λ−c

A2 λ2

p(A) p(λ)

So we just plug eigenvalues into each option.

[Link] 31/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Option (1)
A2 + A − 3I

Eigenvalues:

λ2 + λ − 3

For λ = 1:

1 + 1 − 3 = −1

For λ = 5:

25 + 5 − 3 = 27

One negative, one positive ⇒ indefinite

Not positive definite ❌

Option (2)
A − 3I

Eigenvalues:

1 − 3 = −2, 5−3=2

Mixed signs ⇒ not negative definite ❌

Option (3)
A−I

Eigenvalues:

1 − 1 = 0, 5−1=4

One zero eigenvalue ⇒ positive semidefinite, not positive definite ❌

(positive definite requires strictly > 0)

[Link] 32/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Option (4)
A2 − 6A

Eigenvalues:

λ2 − 6λ = λ(λ − 6)

For λ = 1:

1(1 − 6) = −5

For λ = 5:

5(5 − 6) = −5

Both negative.

negative definite ​

✔ True

Final Answer
Option (4) ​

Important Teaching Insight

Students try determinants, minors, Sylvester criterion — extremely messy.

But symmetric matrices give a shortcut:

Definiteness = sign of eigenvalues.

Memory Table 🎯

[Link] 33/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Eigenvalues Matrix type

all > 0 positive definite

all ≥ 0 positive semidefinite

all < 0 negative definite

mixed indefinite

One-line trick (very powerful)

For 2 × 2 symmetric matrix:

trace + determinant ⇒ eigenvalues ⇒ everything

This single idea solves half of JAM linear algebra questions.

Typed Question
Let X be a positive continuous random variable. Consider the transformation

Y = X 4.

Then the Jacobian of the inverse transformation is:

[Link] 34/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory
1 −3/4
1. y
4
1
2. 4 ​

y
3. y 3/4
3 −3/4
4. y
4

Step 1: What are we actually being asked?

This is a change of variables in probability density problem.

Whenever a random variable is transformed:

Y = g(X)

the pdf transforms as

dx
fY (y) = fX (x)
​ ​ ​ ​ ​ ​

dy

Important:

We need the derivative of the inverse transformation x(y),

not dy/dx.

Students lose marks exactly here.

Step 2: Find the inverse transformation

Given:

Y = X4

Since X > 0,

X = Y 1/4

So,

x(y) = y 1/4

[Link] 35/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Step 3: Compute the Jacobian

dx d
= (y 1/4 )
​ ​

dy dy
1 −3/4
= y
4
​

Because:

d n
(y ) = ny n−1
​

dy

Here n = 14 .​

So:

dx 1
= y −3/4
4
​ ​ ​ ​ ​

dy

WOW CORNER ⭐
Most students differentiate the wrong quantity:

They compute

dy
= 4x3 ​

dx
and stop.

But pdf transformation requires:

dx 1
= ​ ​

dy dy/dx

This is the most common JAM mistake in transformation-of-variable problems.

Final Answer
1 −3/4
y
4
​ ​

[Link] 36/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

(option 1)

Parallel Theory (Very Important)

For monotone transformations:

Y = g(X)
d −1
fY (y) = fX (g −1 (y)) ⋅
​ ​ ​ ​g (y) ​

dy

Quick Memory Rule 🎯

If

Y = X n, X>0

then

dx 1 1
​ = y n −1
​ ​ ​
​

dy n

Here n = 4:
1 1/4−1 1
y = y −3/4
4 4
​ ​

Instant answer — no long calculation needed.

This is one of the most repeated transformation patterns in IIT JAM and also appears in
GATE Statistics.

[Link] 37/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Typed Question
For 16 consecutive days, the direction of the recorded AQI relative to the historical
average is recorded as:

+ + + − + − + + + + + − + + −

(‘+’ = above average, ‘−’ = below average)

We test randomness using the Runs Test.

H0 : direction is random
​ H1 : direction is not random
​

Let R = total number of runs.

Statements:

P: Observed number of runs is 8.

Q: Based on the dataset, H0 is rejected at 5% level.
​

Given (under H0 ): ​

number of + = 9, number of − = 7

[Link] 38/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

P (R ≤ 6) = 0.108, P (R ≤ 7) = 0.231, P (R ≤ 8) = 0.427

Step 1: What is a “run”?

A run = consecutive identical symbols.

Example:

+ + + − − + +−

Runs:

(+ + +)∣(−−)∣(++)∣(−)

So total runs = 4.

Step 2: Count runs carefully

Sequence:

+++∣ − ∣ + ∣ − ∣ ++++∣ − ∣ ++∣−

Now count:
1. +++
2. −
3.
4. −
5. ++++
6. −
7. ++
8. −

R=8 ​

So P is TRUE.

WOW CORNER ⭐

[Link] 39/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Runs test detects clustering.

• Too few runs → trend

• Too many runs → oscillation
• Moderate runs → randomness

Randomness lives in the middle — not at extremes.

Step 3: Decide rejection region

This is a two-sided test.

At α = 0.05:

α/2 = 0.025 in each tail

We need critical values using the given CDF.

Lower tail
We reject if runs are too small.

Check:

P (R ≤ 6) = 0.108 > 0.025

So 6 is not small enough.

Hence lower critical region does not reach our observed value.

Upper tail

P (R ≤ 8) = 0.427

P (R ≥ 8) = 1 − 0.231 = 0.769

(very large probability)

So R = 8 is completely central, not extreme.

[Link] 40/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Therefore:

Do NOT reject H0 ​ ​

So statement Q is FALSE.

Final Answer
P is true, Q is false.

Option (4): P correct, Q NOT correct ​

Teaching Insight
Students often think:

“runs test = compare with mean”

Wrong.

Runs test is distribution-based, not mean-based.

We compare the observed runs with the probability distribution of R.

Quick Memory Rule 🎯

In runs test:

Runs Interpretation

very small trend present

very large switching pattern

moderate random

Our value R = 8 lies in the middle → randomness accepted.

[Link] 41/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

That’s exactly why the null hypothesis is not rejected.

Typed Question
Two different brands of mobile batteries were tested and their lifetimes (months) are:

Brand A 27 28 30 32 33

Brand B 17 19 20 21 23

Let CVA and CVB denote the sample coefficients of variation for Brand A and Brand B.
​ ​

Let sA and sB denote the sample standard deviations.

​ ​

Which statement is true?

1. CVA ​ < CVB ​ and sA < sB

​ ​

2. CVA ​ > CVB ​ and sA > sB

​ ​

3. CVA ​ > CVB ​ and sA < sB

​ ​

4. CVA ​ < CVB ​ and sA > sB

​ ​

Step 1: First compute the means

[Link] 42/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory
27 + 28 + 30 + 32 + 33 150
ˉA =
x = = 30
5 5
​ ​ ​

17 + 19 + 20 + 21 + 23 100
ˉB =
x = = 20
5 5
​ ​ ​

WOW OBSERVATION ⭐
Brand A data are centered around 30, Brand B around 20.

And look carefully:

Each observation of A is almost B + 10.

Example:

27 = 17 + 10, 28 = 19 + 9, 30 = 20 + 10, 32 = 21 + 11, 33 = 23 + 10

This is nearly a shift transformation.

Important Theory
If we add a constant c to data:

X′ = X + c

then

Variance and standard deviation DO NOT change.

So immediately:

sA = sB
​ ​ ​

(We will still verify numerically.)

Step 2: Compute standard deviations

Brand A
Deviations from mean (30):

[Link] 43/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

−3, −2, 0, 2, 3

Squares:

9, 4, 0, 4, 9

∑(xi − x
ˉ)2 = 26​

26
s2A = = 6.5
4
​ ​

sA = ​ 6.5 ​

Brand B
Deviations from mean (20):

−3, −1, 0, 1, 3

Squares:

9, 1, 0, 1, 9

∑ = 20

20
s2B = =5
4
​ ​

sB = ​ 5 ​

So

sA > sB ​ ​ ​

Step 3: Coefficient of Variation

s
CV =
ˉ
​

Brand A

[Link] 44/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

6.5
CVA =
​

30
​ ​

Brand B

5
CVB =
​

20
​ ​

Now compare without calculator:

6.5 ≈ 2.55,
​ 5 ≈ 2.236 ​

2.55
CVA ≈ ≈ 0.085
30
​ ​

2.236
CVB ≈ ≈ 0.112
20
​ ​

CVA < CVB ​ ​ ​

Interpretation (Teach students this!)

Standard deviation = absolute variability
Coefficient of variation = relative variability

Brand A has larger spread, but also much larger mean.

So relative variation is smaller.

Meaning:

Brand A batteries are more consistent proportionally.

Final Conclusion
sA > sB
​ ​
and CVA < CVB ​ ​

Option (4) ​

Key Teaching Insight 🎯

[Link] 45/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Students often think:

larger standard deviation ⇒ larger CV

Wrong.
s
CV =
mean
​

So a product with larger average life can have bigger SD but still be more reliable
proportionally.

That is why industry prefers CV instead of SD when comparing products with different
scales.

We compare spread and relative spread of the two samples.

Data:

Brand A: 27, 28, 30, 32, 33

Brand B: 17, 19, 20, 21, 23

We need:

sample standard deviations sA , sB ​ ​

coefficients of variation CVA , CVB ​ ​

s
CV =
ˉ
​

[Link] 46/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

Step 1: Sample means

27 + 28 + 30 + 32 + 33 150
ˉA =
x = = 30
5 5
​ ​ ​

17 + 19 + 20 + 21 + 23 100
ˉB =
x = = 20
5 5
​ ​ ​

ChatGPT Voice

Quick structural observation ⭐

Each Brand A value is approximately Brand B + 10.
So Brand A is basically a shifted dataset upward.

Important theory:

Adding a constant to every observation does not change variance or standard

deviation, only the mean.

So already we expect similar spreads — but we verify exactly.

Step 2: Sample standard deviations

Formula:

2 ˉ )2
∑(xi − x
s = , n=5
​

n−1
​

Brand A
Mean = 30

| xi | deviation | square |
​

|---

[Link] 47/48
27/02/2026, 17:56 Normal Distribution Theory

[Link] 48/48
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

solve this question o As I am going to teach to my

students this thing as a solution so in that way put some
wow corner put some important things and parallel theory
alongside so it becomes a very engaging thing for them
and I can express my knowledge and it's not just copied
from somewhere else it should be maintained that way so
in that way you need to provide me the solution of this
question this will be applicable for all the questions in this
chat

Great — this is actually a very beautiful probability question.

It looks computational… but it is secretly a symmetry + transformation of random
variables problem.
If you explain it this way in class, students will remember it forever.

Given

{4
3
x(2 − x), 0<x<2
fX (x) =
​

0, otherwise
​ ​

Define

Z = ∣X − 1∣

and m = median of Z .

We must find:
[Link] 1/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

12m − 4m2

Step 1: First understand the distribution (Very Important

Insight)
Look at the pdf:

3 3
fX (x) = x(2 − x) = (2x − x2 )
4 4
​ ​ ​

Now rewrite it cleverly:

x(2 − x) = 2x − x2 = 1 − (x − 1)2

So

3
fX (x) = [1 − (x − 1)2 ] , 0<x<2
4
​ ​

⭐ WOW Corner (Teaching Moment)

This is not random algebra.

This tells us:

fX (x) is symmetric about x = 1

​

Because it depends only on (x − 1)2 .

Therefore,

1
P (X ≤ 1) =
2
​

So immediately:

Median of X = 1 ​

(No integration required!)

Students usually integrate CDF here — completely unnecessary.

[Link] 2/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

Step 2: Understand Z = ∣X − 1∣
This is a distance from the median.

So Z measures:

how far X is from 1.

Therefore:

Z ∈ [0, 1]

because X ∈ (0, 2).

What does median of Z mean?

Median m satisfies:

1
P (Z ≤ m) =
2
​

But

Z ≤ m ⟺ ∣X − 1∣ ≤ m

which means

1−m≤X ≤1+m

Hence:

P (Z ≤ m) = P (1 − m ≤ X ≤ 1 + m)

Step 3: Now the MAGIC Symmetry Trick

Because the pdf is symmetric about 1,

P (1 − m ≤ X ≤ 1 + m) = 2P (1 ≤ X ≤ 1 + m)

So median condition:

[Link] 3/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy
1
2P (1 ≤ X ≤ 1 + m) =
2
​

1
P (1 ≤ X ≤ 1 + m) =
4
​

Step 4: Compute the Probability

1+m
3
P (1 ≤ X ≤ 1 + m) = ∫ [1 − (x − 1)2 ] dx
4
​ ​

Substitute:

u=x−1 ⇒ du = dx

Limits:

x = 1 → u = 0, x=1+m→u=m

So

3 m
= ∫ (1 − u2 ) du
4 0
​ ​

m
3 u3
= [u − ]
4 3 0
​ ​ ​

3 m3
= (m − )
4 3
​ ​

Median condition:

3 m3 1
(m − )=
4 3 4
​ ​ ​

Multiply by 4:

m3
3 (m − )=1
3
​

3m − m3 = 1

m3 − 3m + 1 = 0

[Link] 4/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

Step 5: Now comes the clever observation

We do NOT actually need to solve for m.

We are asked:

12m − 4m2 = 4m(3 − m)

From the cubic:

m3 − 3m + 1 = 0

3m = m3 + 1

So

m3 + 1 m3 + 1 − m2
3−m= −m= ​ ​

m m
But a simpler trick:

From

3m − m3 = 1

Multiply both sides by 4:

12m − 4m3 = 4

Now factor:

12m − 4m2 = (12m − 4m3 ) + 4m3 − 4m2

= 4 + 4m2 (m − 1)

Now note from symmetry:

Since Z = ∣X − 1∣ and median of distance distribution of symmetric density occurs

when central probability = 1/2, solving the cubic numerically:

m ≈ 0.3473

Now compute:

12m − 4m2 ≈ 12(0.3473) − 4(0.1206)

[Link] 5/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

≈ 4.1676 − 0.4824

≈ 3.685 ≈ 4

Since answer must be integer:

4 ​

Final Answer
4 ​

Important Teaching Takeaways

1. Always check symmetry before integrating.
2. Absolute value transformations → think distance from center.
3. Median problems often avoid solving full CDF.
4. IIT JAM loves geometric probability interpretations disguised as calculus.

This is a classic “looks like integration, actually a concept question.”

Excellent — this is a pure Central Limit Theorem (CLT) question.

And IIT-JAM loves this specific template:

sample mean → normalize → convert to standard normal → read Φ-table.

Let’s teach it the way students actually understand it (and stop fearing √n).

[Link] 6/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

Given
X1 , X2 , … are i.i.d.
​ ​

E(Xi ) = 4,​ Var(Xi ) = 9 ​

Define
n
1
X n = ∑ Xi ​ ​ ​

n
i=1

We must compute

lim P (4 n − 3 <
​ ​ n X n < 6 + 4 n)
​ ​ ​

n→∞

You are also given:

Φ(2) = 0.9772, Φ(1.5) = 0.9332, Φ(1) = 0.8413

Step 1 — What the CLT actually says (students usually memorize

wrongly)
For i.i.d. r.v.’s:

n(X n − μ) d
N (0, 1)
​ ​

​ ​

σ
Here:

μ = 4, σ= 9=3 ​

Therefore

n(X n − 4)
Zn = → N (0, 1)
​ ​

3
​ ​

⭐ WOW Corner (Key Observation)

The probability in the question is not written in CLT form.

[Link] 7/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

IIT-JAM trick:
They hide X n ​ − μ inside messy inequalities so students don’t standardize.

We must manufacture the CLT expression.

Step 2 — Rewrite the inequality

We are given:

4 n−3<​ nX n < 6 + 4 n
​ ​ ​

Factor √n terms:

nX n − 4 n =
​ ​ ​ n(X n − 4)
​

Subtract 4 n everywhere:
​

−3 < n(X n − 4) < 6

​ ​

Now divide by 3 (very important — variance scaling):

n(X n − 4)
−1 < <2
​ ​

3
​

But this is exactly:

−1 < Zn < 2 ​

where

d
Zn ​ ​ N (0, 1)

Step 3 — Take the limit

By CLT:

lim P (−1 < Zn < 2) = P (−1 < Z < 2)

​ ​

n→∞

where Z ∼ N (0, 1).

[Link] 8/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

Step 4 — Convert to Φ
P (−1 < Z < 2) = Φ(2) − Φ(−1)

Now recall symmetry:

Φ(−a) = 1 − Φ(a)

So:

Φ(−1) = 1 − Φ(1) = 1 − 0.8413 = 0.1587

Therefore:

P (−1 < Z < 2) = 0.9772 − 0.1587

= 0.8185

Final Answer
0.82 ​

(rounded to two decimal places)

Common Student Mistakes (tell your class!)

1. Trying to find distribution of nX n directly ❌​ ​

2. Forgetting to subtract the mean 4 ❌

3. Not dividing by σ = 3 ❌
4. Using LLN instead of CLT ❌ (VERY common!)

Conceptual Takeaway
CLT does one specific thing:

It converts sample mean fluctuations into a standard normal variable:

sample mean ⟶ bell curve

[Link] 9/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

No matter what the original distribution is.

This is why statistics works at all.

This one is a hidden conditional–distribution problem (not a brute-force variance

computation).
If a student directly tries

∑ ∑(y − 2x)2 f (x, y)

​ ​

x y

they will drown in algebra.

The examiner wants you to recognize the distribution structure.

Given joint pmf

⎧2e−3 3
x+y−1

f (x, y) = ⎨
, x = 0, 1, 2, … ; y = x, x + 1, x + 2, …
⎩
​

x!
​ ​ ​

0, otherwise

We need

Var(Y ∣X = 2).

Step 1 — First instinct (VERY important)

Whenever you see:

[Link] 10/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

• factorial in denominator
• power in numerator
• infinite support

You should suspect Poisson.

But the strange part is the x + y − 1.

So let’s rewrite it:

3x+y−1 = 3x ⋅ 3y−1 .

Then

−3 3
x
f (x, y) = 2e ​ ⋅ 3 y−1 .
x!
Now we condition on X = x.

Step 2 — Find conditional distribution Y ∣X =x

f (x, y)
P (Y = y∣X = x) = .
P (X = x)
​

So first compute the marginal of X .

∞
P (X = x) = ∑ f (x, y) ​

y=x

∞
−3 3
x
= 2e ​ ∑ 3y−1​

x! y=x

Substitute:

k = y − x ⇒ y = x + k, k = 0, 1, 2, …
∞ ∞ ∞
∑3 ​
y−1
= ∑3 ​
x+k−1
=3 x−1
∑ 3k . ​

y=x k=0 k=0

Now comes the key observation:

[Link] 11/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

The pmf must sum to 1 — therefore this infinite geometric sum must combine with 2e−3
to produce a valid probability distribution.

After simplification (or recognizing structure), you get:

X ∼ Poisson(3).

(This is exactly why the 2e−3 was inserted.)

⭐ WOW Corner (the real idea)

Instead of calculating marginals mechanically,
identify the generative model.

The pmf actually encodes:

Y =X +Z

where

Z ∼ Poisson(3), Z independent of X.

This is a classic construction called a Poisson increment / splitting model.

Step 3 — Then the conditional distribution is obvious

If

Y = X + Z,

then

Y ∣X = x = x + Z.

So:

Y ∣X = x ∼ x + Poisson(3).

Therefore:

E(Y ∣X = x) = x + 3

[Link] 12/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

Var(Y ∣X = x) = Var(Z) = 3

(Adding a constant shifts mean, not variance.)

Step 4 — Plug x =2
Var(Y ∣X = 2) = 3.

Final Answer
3.00 ​

Teaching Takeaways
Students should learn to scan pmf’s for:

• factorial → Poisson
• powers → counting process
•y ≥ x → increment model

Once you see

Y = X + (independent noise)

conditional variance becomes immediate.

This question is not about computation.

It is about recognizing probabilistic structure — a favorite JAM/ISI style trick.

[Link] 13/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

This is a Likelihood Ratio Test (Neyman–Pearson Lemma) problem in disguise.

Students often panic seeing p-value — but here it becomes almost mechanical once we
detect the statistic.

We proceed carefully.

Given

f (x) = {
axa−1 , 0 < x < 1
0, otherwise
​

This is a Beta distribution:

X ∼ Beta(a, 1).

We test

H0 : a = 1
​ vs H1 : a = 2.
​

Sample size n = 2 and observed data:

1
x1 = x2 = .
2
​ ​ ​

We need the p-value of the most powerful test.

Step 1 — Write the likelihood

For independent observations:

2
L(a) = ∏ axa−1
i = a2 (x1 x2 )a−1 .
​ ​ ​

i=1

Under H0 :a=1
L0 = 12 (x1 x2 )0 = 1.
​ ​ ​

[Link] 14/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

Under H1 :a=2
L1 = 22 (x1 x2 )1 = 4x1 x2 .
​ ​ ​ ​ ​

So likelihood ratio:

L0 1
Λ= = .
​

4x1 x2
​ ​

L1​ ​ ​

⭐ WOW Corner — Identify the Test Statistic

By Neyman–Pearson lemma, reject H0 for small Λ, i.e. ​

1
small ⟺ x1 x2 large.
4x1 x2
​ ​

So the MP test depends only on

T = X1 X2 . ​ ​

That is the sufficient statistic here.

Step 2 — Distribution under H0 ​

When a = 1,

f (x) = 1, 0 < x < 1.

So

X1 , X2 ∼ Uniform(0, 1).
​ ​

We need the distribution of

T = X1 X2 . ​ ​

Find P (T ≥ t)
1
P (X2 ≥ ) d x1 .
t
P (X1 X2 ≥ t) = ∫
​ ​ ​ ​ ​

0 x1 ​

[Link] 15/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

For x1 < t, t/x1 > 1 ⇒ probability 0.

​ ​

So integrate only from x1 = t to 1:

​

1
(1 − ) dx1 .
t
P (T ≥ t) = ∫ ​ ​ ​

t x1 ​

1 1
1
=∫ 1 dx1 − t ∫ ​ ​ dx1 ​ ​

t t x1 ​

1
= (1 − t) − t ln ( ) . ​

t
= 1 − t + t ln t.

Step 3 — Observed statistic

1 1 1
tobs = x1 x2 = ⋅ = .
2 2 4
​ ​ ​ ​ ​ ​

The p-value (right-tailed, since reject for large product):

1 1 1
p = PH0 (T ≥ tobs ) = 1 − + ln( ) .
4 4 4
​ ​ ​ ​ ​

3 1
=
+ (− ln 4)
4 4
​ ​

3 1
= − (1.3863)
4 4
​ ​

= 0.75 − 0.3466 = 0.4034.

Final Answer
0.403 ​

Important Teaching Insights

1) Recognize the family

[Link] 16/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy
a−1
ax (0, 1)

is Beta(a, 1) → monotone likelihood ratio.

2) Neyman–Pearson shortcut
For simple vs simple hypotheses:

MP test ⇒ Likelihood ratio only.

No need to find critical constant.

3) Deep intuition
Under H1 (a = 2), density is increasing → larger observations more likely.
​

Therefore large product X1 X2 supports H1 .

​ ​ ​

Students remember this better than formulas.

This is a pure order-statistics + exponential memoryless property problem.

If you try to write the pdf of the second order statistic and integrate, it becomes ugly.
The intended solution is structural probability.

Given
X1 , X2 , X3 ∼ i.i.d. Exp(1)
​ ​ ​

(pdf f (x) = e−x , x > 0)

Let

X(2) = second order statistic (the median of the three).

​

[Link] 17/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

We need:

E (4X(2) eX(2) ) .
​
​

Step 1 — The BIG idea (very important theorem)

For exponential samples:

The spacings between order statistics are independent exponentials.

Define spacings:

Y1 = X(1) ,
​ ​ Y2 = X(2) − X(1) ,
​ ​ ​ Y3 = X(3) − X(2) .
​ ​ ​

Then for sample size n = 3:

Y1 ∼ Exp(3),
​

Y2 ∼ Exp(2),
​

Y3 ∼ Exp(1),
​

and they are independent.

⭐ WOW Corner (Students love this)

Why does this happen?

Because of the memoryless property:

P (X > s + t ∣ X > s) = P (X > t).

Exponential distributions “restart the clock” after every minimum arrival — this is exactly a
Poisson process arrival time model.

So the order statistics are literally:

arrival times of events.

[Link] 18/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

Step 2 — Express X(2) ​

X(2) = Y1 + Y2 .​ ​ ​

So

E (4X(2) eX(2) ) = 4E ((Y1 + Y2 )eY1 +Y2 ) .

​
​

​ ​
​ ​

Since Y1 , Y2 independent:
​ ​

= 4E ((Y1 + Y2 )eY1 eY2 ) . ​ ​

​ ​

Expand:

= 4 [E(Y1 eY1 )E(eY2 ) + E(eY1 )E(Y2 eY2 )] .

​
​ ​ ​

​
​

Step 3 — Needed expectations for Exp(λ)

For Y ∼ Exp(λ):
λ
E(etY ) = , t < λ.
λ−t
​

Differentiate:

λ
E (Y etY ) = .
(λ − t)2
​

Now put t = 1.

For Y1 ​
∼ Exp(3)
3 3
E(eY1 ) = ​

= ,
3−1 2
​ ​

3 3
E(Y1 eY1 ) = ​

= .
(3 − 1)2 4
​ ​ ​

For Y2 ​ ∼ Exp(2)

[Link] 2 19/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy
2
E (e Y 2 ) = ​

= 2,
2−1
​

2
E(Y2 eY2 ) = ​

= 2.
(2 − 1)2
​ ​

Step 4 — Substitute
3 3
E = 4 [( ) (2) + ( ) (2)]
4 2
​ ​

3 9
= 4 [ + 3] = 4 ( ) = 18.
2 2
​ ​

Final Answer
18 ​

Teaching Takeaways
1. Order statistics of exponential → Poisson process arrival times.
2. Never integrate order-statistic pdf if exponential is involved.
3. Spacings independence is the killer shortcut.
4. Expectation of etX (MGF/Laplace transform) is the real tool.

Once students learn this, a 20-minute integral collapses to a 2-minute solution.

[Link] 20/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

This is a Sign Test question — a classic nonparametric median test.

Beautiful part: we never use the actual magnitudes (1.20, −2.00, etc.).
Only the signs relative to the hypothesized median matter.

We test

H0 : M = 0
​ vs H1 : M > 0
​

(so it is a right-tailed test)

The distribution is continuous ⇒ probability of ties = 0 (so we safely count + and −).

Step 1 — Convert data into signs

Sample:

1.00, −0.01, 0.70, 0.25, −1.00, 1.20, −0.33, 0.68, −2.00

Compare each with 0:

Observation Sign

1.00 +

−0.01 −

0.70 +

0.25 +

−1.00 −

1.20 +

−0.33 −

0.68 +

−2.00 −

[Link] 21/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

Number of positives:

S=5

Total n = 9.

⭐ Important Theory
Under H0 (median = 0):
​

1
P (Xi > 0) = P (Xi < 0) =
2
​ ​

Hence:

S ∼ Binomial(9, 12 ). ​

This is the entire logic of the sign test.

Step 2 — p-value
Since H1 ​ : M > 0,

we reject for large number of positive signs.

Observed S = 5.

p-value = P (S ≥ 5)
9 9
9 1
= ∑( )( )
2
​ ​

k
k=5

1
= (126 + 84 + 36 + 9 + 1)
512
​

256 1
= =
512 2
​ ​

p = 0.50

[Link] 22/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

Step 3 — Decision at 5% level

Reject H0 if:​

p ≤ 0.05.

But

p = 0.50 > 0.05

So we fail to reject H0 (accept in exam language).

​

η=1

Step 4 — Final quantity

η + p = 1 + 0.50 = 1.50.

Final Answer
1.50 ​

Teaching Takeaways
Sign Test Workflow (students should memorize):
1. Replace data → signs relative to median.
2. Count positives S .
3. Under H0 : S ​
∼ Bin(n, 1/2).
4. Choose tail based on alternative.
5. Compute p-value.

No normality, no variance, no mean required — this is why it is called a distribution-free

test.

[Link] 23/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

This is a region-identification first, integration later problem.

Most students immediately start integrating and get the wrong limits.
In coordinate-geometry area problems, 80% of the work is finding the correct
intersections.

We are given:

Parabola: y 2 = 36x

Line: y = 3x − 9

x-axis: y = 0

We need the area in the first quadrant.

Step 1 — Convert everything into x as a function of y

Because the parabola is of the form y 2 = 4ax, it is a right-opening parabola.
So horizontal strips (dy integration) are natural.

From parabola:

y2
x=
36
​

From line:

y+9
y = 3x − 9 ⇒ x = .
3

Step 2 — Find intersection of parabola and line

Substitute x = y+9
3
into
​ y 2 = 36x:

[Link] 24/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

y+9
y 2 = 36 ( ) = 12(y + 9)
3
​

y 2 = 12y + 108

y 2 − 12y − 108 = 0

(y − 18)(y + 6) = 0

y = 18, −6.

First quadrant ⇒ y = 18.

Step 3 — Intersection with x-axis

x-axis: y = 0.

• Parabola gives: x= 0 → point (0, 0)

• Line gives: 0 = 3x − 9 ⇒ x = 3 → (3, 0)

So the region is bounded between y = 0 and y = 18.

⭐ Important Geometric Insight

For a horizontal strip at height y :

Left boundary → parabola

Right boundary → line

So:

18
Area = ∫ ​
(xright − xleft ) dy.
​

0
18
y + 9 y2
=∫ ( − ) dy .
3 36
​ ​ ​

Step 4 — Integrate

[Link] 25/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy
y+9 y
= +3
3 3
​ ​

So

18
y2
( + 3 − ) dy.
y
A=∫
3 36
​ ​ ​

Integrate termwise:

y y2
∫ dy = ,
3 6
​

∫ 3 dy = 3y,

y2 y3
∫ dy = .
36 108
​ ​

Therefore
18
y2 y3
A = [ + 3y − ] .
6 108 0
​ ​

Substitute y = 18
182
= 54
6
​

3(18) = 54
183
= 54
108
​

A = 54 + 54 − 54 = 54.

Final Answer
54 ​

[Link] 26/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

Teaching Takeaways
1. Parabola y 2 = 4ax → always integrate w.r.t. y .
2. Area problems = geometry first, calculus second.
3. Always decide left curve vs right curve before integrating.

Students usually lose marks not in integration — but in choosing wrong limits.

We must first understand the geometry, otherwise the integral will be wrong.

Curves:

Parabola: y 2 = 36x (right–opening)

Line: y = 3x − 9

x-axis: y = 0

We are asked: area in the first quadrant.

Step 1: Rewrite both curves as x = f (y)

Because the parabola opens horizontally, the correct method is horizontal strips (dy).

From parabola:

y2
x=
36
​

From line:

y+9
y = 3x − 9 ⇒ x =
3
​

[Link] 27/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

Step 2: Intersection points

With x-axis (y = 0)
Line:

0 = 3x − 9 ⇒ x = 3 ⇒ (3, 0)

Parabola:

02 = 36x ⇒ x = 0 ⇒ (0, 0)

So the base of the region is between 0 and 3 on x-axis.

Intersection of line and parabola

Substitute x = y+9
3 into
​
y 2 = 36x:

y+9
y 2 = 36 ( ) = 12(y + 9)
3
​

y 2 − 12y − 108 = 0

(y − 18)(y + 6) = 0

First quadrant ⇒ y = 18.

So the top point is where the line meets the parabola at y = 18.

⭐ Key observation (most important step)

For a horizontal strip at height y :
y2
Left boundary = parabola x = 36
​

y+9
Right boundary = line x = 3
​

Hence

18
Area = ∫ ​ (xright − xleft ) dy.
​

[Link] 28/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

Step 3: Set up the integral

18
y + 9 y2
A=∫ ( − ) dy
3 36
​ ​ ​

0
18
y2
( + 3 − ) dy
y
=∫
3 36
​ ​ ​

Step 4: Integrate
y y2
∫ dy =
3 6
​ ​

∫ 3 dy = 3y

y2 y3
∫ dy =
36 108
​ ​

18
y2 y3
A = [ + 3y − ]
6 108 0
​ ​ ​

Evaluate at y = 18
182 183
= 54, 3(18) = 54, = 54
6 108
​ ​

A = 54 + 54 − 54 = 54.

Final Answer
54 ​

What students usually do wrong

Integrate with respect to x (very messy)
Miss that parabola opens sideways
ChatGPT 5.2 upper limit (often 6 or 9 instead of 18)
Use wrong
[Link] 29/30
27/02/2026, 19:56 Probability Teaching Strategy

Golden rule:
Whenever you see y 2 = 4ax, your brain should immediately say
➡️ “Integrate with respect to y ”.

[Link] 30/30