High-Impedance Differential Protection
High-impedance differential protection is a protection scheme where the relay circuit
has a deliberately high impedance, making the scheme stable during external faults
and CT saturation.
It is mainly used for busbar protection and restricted earth fault (REF) protection.
1. Basic Principle
All CT secondary currents from the protected zone are connected in parallel and feed a
high-impedance relay circuit.
Under normal conditions or external faults:
I1+I2+I3+...=0I_1 + I_2 + I_3 + ... = 0I1+I2+I3+...=0
No spill current flows through the relay.
So:
Irelay≈0I_{relay} \approx 0Irelay≈0
→ No trip
Internal Fault Condition
When a fault occurs inside the protected zone:
Iincoming≠IoutgoingI_{incoming} \neq I_{outgoing}Iincoming =Ioutgoing
The difference is called spill current.
Ispill=I1+I2+I3I_{spill} = I_1 + I_2 + I_3Ispill=I1+I2+I3
This spill current flows through the relay.
V=Ispill×RstabilityV = I_{spill} \times R_{stability}V=Ispill×Rstability
If voltage exceeds relay pickup:
→ Relay operates and trips breakers
2. Why High Impedance Is Used
During external faults, CTs may saturate unevenly, producing false differential current.
High impedance ensures:
• Most of the spill current circulates between CTs
• Only a small current flows through the relay
Thus preventing false tripping.
3. Main Components of High-Impedance Scheme
1. Current Transformers (CTs)
Requirements:
• Same ratio
• Same magnetization characteristics
• Low leakage reactance
2. Stabilizing Resistor
Connected in series with the relay.
Purpose:
• Limits relay current
• Improves stability during CT saturation
Typical value:
Rstab=VkIrelayR_{stab} = \frac{V_k}{I_{relay}}Rstab=IrelayVk
Where:
• VkV_kVk = CT knee-point voltage
3. Non-Linear Resistor (Metrosil)
Protects the relay from high transient voltages.
Metrosil clamps the voltage.
4. High-Impedance Relay
Example: instantaneous overcurrent relay measuring spill voltage.
4. Stability Condition
For external faults, stability requires:
Vstability=If(RCT+Rlead)V_{stability} = I_f (R_{CT} + R_{lead})Vstability=If(RCT+Rlead)
Where:
• IfI_fIf = maximum external fault current
• RCTR_{CT}RCT = CT secondary resistance
• RleadR_{lead}Rlead = wiring resistance
Relay setting must satisfy:
Vsetting>VstabilityV_{setting} > V_{stability}Vsetting>Vstability
5. Knee-Point Voltage Requirement
CT knee-point voltage must satisfy:
Vk≥2×If(RCT+Rlead)V_k \ge 2 \times I_f (R_{CT} + R_{lead})Vk≥2×If(RCT+Rlead)
This prevents CT saturation during external faults.
6. Applications
Busbar Protection
Most common application.
Faults cleared instantaneously.
Restricted Earth Fault (REF)
Used in transformers to detect internal earth faults.
Sensitive detection of low current faults.
Generator Stator Protection
Detects internal ground faults.
7. Advantages
✔ Very stable during external faults
✔ Simple scheme
✔ Very fast operation
✔ Highly sensitive
8. Disadvantages
✖ Requires matched CTs
✖ CT saturation must be carefully considered
✖ Difficult to apply over long distances
9. High vs Low Impedance Differential
Feature High Impedance Low Impedance
Relay Type Simple overcurrent Numerical differential relay
CT Matching Very strict Less strict
Stability Very high High
Applications Busbar, REF Transformer, line
10. Example (Busbar Protection)
Assume:
Maximum external fault current:
If=20kAI_f = 20kAIf=20kA
CT ratio:
2000/12000/12000/1
Secondary current:
Is=10AI_s = 10AIs=10A
Total loop resistance:
R=2ΩR = 2\OmegaR=2Ω
Stability voltage:
V=Is×RV = I_s \times RV=Is×R V=10×2=20VV = 10 \times 2 = 20VV=10×2=20V
Relay setting must be greater than 20 V.