Struct Design
Struct Design
4.1 Introduction
This Unit describes the competencies required to Perform Structural Design and Analysis.
It involves analysing structural designs, designing structural elements, preparing structural
drawings interpreting structural drawings and applying structural drawings
151
4.3.2 Learning Outcome No 1: Analyze Structural Elements
[Link] Learning Activities
Learning Outcome No 1: Analyse Structural Elements
Learning Activities Special Instructions
Definition
Building codes: These are laid down standards for any building structure.
Bending moments: These are structural reactions when a structure is subjected to moment
or applied load.
Shear force: This is the reaction imposed by a structure when loads are imposed.
Content/Procedures/Methods/Illustrations
1.1 Determine Methods used in analyses of structural members according to building
codes
Several methods are used in the analysis of structural members. A structural system is made
up of different members and each member is analysed differently. The methods of analysis
used in beams include:
a. Energy methods
Two methods are commonly used i.e.
• Methods of virtual work
• Castigliano’s theorem
152
b. Displacement methods of analysis
• Slope deflection methods
• Moment distribution methods
c. Approximate methods of analysis.
• This method is used in the analysis of statically indeterminate structures.
d. Double integration method
• In this method, sign convention and boundary conditions are well defined. It
is mostly used in determining deflections.
e. Elastic beam theory
• The method relates to slope, displacement as well as the internal moments of
a beam. Its development is fully dependent on this.
f. Moment area methods
• This method is mainly used when checking for deflection. It involves
determining slope and deflection of an elastic curve.
g. Conjugate- beam method
• This method relies mainly on statics for determining deflection in beams.
h. Stiffness method of analysis om
t.c
These are loadings that are subjected to a structure. Different structures are subjected to
tv
sy
a. Dead loads
• These are loads that are permanent in a structure. They include the self-weight
of the structure, finishes, masonry etc.
• During analysis, these loads are taken into considerations to ascertain the
safety of the structure.
b. Live loads
• These are loads that are temporary. They include people, furniture, etc.
• There are other types of live loads such as impact loads (loads imposed by
moving cars), highway bridge loads (caused by traffic), wind loads and snow
loads.
153
1.3 Sketch structural members as per the drawings and support requirements
om
e t.c
iv. Truss
tv
𝑃𝐿
𝑀𝑚𝑎𝑥 = ------ Simply supported beams
8
154
1.5 Draw shear force and bending moments diagram according to structural design
requirements
Drawing shear force and bending diagrams is very essential since it creates an image of
how a structure will fail.
Before doing so, one is required to follow certain procedures as discussed below:
Shear force diagram
a. Determine Shear, V at distance x. Distance x is always the distance from
one load application to another.
b. Plot a graph of V against x
Bending moment diagram
a. Determine moment, M by find the area under shear in the SFD.
b. Plot a graph of moment M, against distance x.
The diagram attached below is an example of how to draw a bending moment diagram
(BMD) as well as the shear force diagram (SFD)
om
et.c
tv
sy
ea
155
Conclusion
This learning outcome covered Analyses of structural elements, Preparation of sketches,
Determination of maximum moments and Structural designs.
Further Reading
[Link] Self-Assessment
Written Assessment
1 Which one of the following is a type of load?
a) Furniture load
b) Rail truck load om
c) Live load
t.c
d) Steel load
e
structure?
ea
156
7 Explain the importance of structural analysis
8 Differentiate between Structural design and structural analysis
9 What is the difference between influence line and shear force and bending moment
diagram?
10 Differentiate
1. Column
2. Beam
3. Frame
4. Truss
11 Discuss Displacement methods in details
12 For each of the methods outlined, discuss their shortcomings.
Oral Assessment
1. What is analysis?
2. Why do we need to analyze structures?
Project Assessment
1. Analyze a one-story building.
om
t.c
e
• Computers
sy
• Office equipment
ea
• Calculators
• Scale rule
• Computer software
• Design codes (British Standards)
• Stationery
• Standard design manuals
• Dust coat
• First aid kit
[Link] References
157
4.3.3 Learning Outcome No 2: Design structural elements
[Link] Learning Activities
Learning Outcome No 2: Design structural elements
Learning Activities Special Instructions
om
Introduction to learning outcome
t.c
This learning outcome covers Structural designs, Methods of designs, Design codes,
e
tv
Design tools and equipment, Structural elements designs and Schedules for different
sy
elements.
ea
Structural designs: This refers to the process of undertaking a structural analysis and
selecting materials, member types, configuration and size to safely carry and transfer the
intended loads both in a serviceability and ultimate limit state.
Content/Procedures/Methods/Illustrations
2.1 Gather Design recourses according to standard design requirements
In design, it is said that there is no one way of solving a design problem. Focusing on just
one solution instead of considering other alternatives is almost certain that you are
overlooking other attractive solutions. Generating design options is a phase in project
planning known as conceptual design and it includes producing ideas and taking into
account the advantage and limitations of implementing those ideas.
158
This is done to manage costs, minimize the likelihood of errors, evaluate success and assess
risks of undertaking the intended project. Some of the design recourses undertaken in
project include:
i) Changing the materials.
ii) Changing the member types.
iii) Changing the member configuration and arrangement.
iv) Changing the member sizes.
iii) Beams: These are horizontal members that primarily carry vertical loads and
tv
iv) Walls: A wall is a structure that demarcates the different spaces in a building
ea
as well as the external boundary. Some walls are load bearing and carry the
structural loads of the building.
v) Ties: This is a slender structural element that carries the loads in tension.
vi) Struts: This a structural member that carries the loads in compression only.
vii) Trusses: This a structure that is composed of a series of struts and is used to
carry loads in compression.
viii) Frames: This type of structure is composed of beams and columns that are
either pin or fixed connected.
ix) Slabs: This are horizontal structures built to provide a flat surface in buildings.
159
iii) Rigid design method: Connections are assumed to be capable of transmitting
100% moment required by analysis assuming full continuity.
iv) Experimental verification: The code states that where design of a structure or
elements by calculation in accordance with any of the above methods is not
practical, the strength will be confirmed by loading tests.
160
Table 4: How to calculate bending moment for various types of beams
om
et.c
tv
sy
ea
Source: [Link]
2.6 Identify and gather design tools and equipment according to standard design
manuals
Check the tools, equipment, supplies and materials section.
161
Conclusion
This learning outcome covered structural designs, methods of designs, design codes, design
tools and equipment, structural elements designs and schedules for different elements.
Further Reading
[Link] Self-Assessment
Written Assessment om
1. Which of the following is not a type of foundation?
t.c
a) Mat
e
tv
b) Isolated footing
sy
c) Retaining wall
ea
d) Combined footing
2. Which of the following is not a check done during the design of reinforced concrete
beam?
a) Shear capacity check.
b) Moment capacity check.
c) Web buckling check.
d) Deflection check
3. Which of the following is not a phase during design of structures?
a) Technical design
b) Developed design
c) Conceptual design
d) Handover
4. Which of the following is not a structural element?
a) Ties
b) None
c) Trusses
d) Joists
5. Design a reinforced concrete beam of your choosing according to the design code BS
8110.
162
6. Describe the various type of foundations and when should be used.
7. Describe the design principles that should guide an engineer during the design process.
8. Describe the main design theories.
9. Write an essay describing the how an engineer with poor communication skills can
lead to poor quality construction.
Project Assessment
1. Using a BIM software application of your choice obtain architectural drawings from
the internet and develop a corresponding structural model.
Oral Assessment
1. Describe how you as a student pursuing a diploma of civil engineering can develop
shop drawings for fabrication of steel members when requested by the professional
engineer.
2. What skills have you gained as a result of performing the project assessment described
above.
• Office equipment
e
tv
• Calculators
sy
• Computer software
ea
[Link] References
163
4.3.4 Learning Outcome No 3: Prepare Structural Drawings
[Link] Learning Activities
Learning Outcome No 3: Prepare structural drawings
Learning Activities Special Instructions
Drawing resources: This refers to the various resources required in order to produce the
complete set of structural drawings.
Structural members: Structural members have to do with the part of the building that is
concerned with preserving the physical integrity.
Content/Procedures/Methods/Illustrations
3.1 Identify and gather drawing resources according to structural elements designed
• Computers
• Office equipment
• Calculators
• Computer software
• Design codes (British standards)
• Stationery
• Standard design manuals
164
3.2 Determine methods of drawing for structural members as per the designs
Structural drawings confine themselves to the load-carrying members of a structure.
The following outlines the methods for drawing structural members:
i) Structural plan. These drawings show the floor, foundation and roof plan of a
building and provide information like location and size of different elements
present in the plans.
ii) Elevations. These shows the exterior walls of a building or structure and the
structural properties of elements present in the walls and cannot be seen in plan
drawings.
iii) Sections. These are referenced in the plan drawings and provide more
information about elements that may not be seen in plan drawings.
iv) Detail drawings. These provides particular information on how to connect or
construct the structural elements.
3.3 Prepare standard working structural drawings for various elements as per
designs
Structural drawings have to be produced as the design process evolves since the drawings
om
are required in construction of the structure. Production of structural drawings takes place
as follows:
et.c
ii) The engineer determines the loadings applied to the structure based on the
ea
drawings and performs design to size the members according to the forces
applied to the building. (Developed design phase)
iii) As the design process evolves the engineer produces more detailed drawings,
bar bending schedules, notes, specifications, details and at the end of this stage
we have construction ready documents. (Technical design phase)
iv) The drawings are included in a tender pack to be tendered together with
drawings from other disciplines during the bidding and tendering process.
165
Conclusion
This learning outcome covered drawing tools and equipment, methods of drawing, standard
structural drawings and preparation of material schedules.
Further Reading
1. [Link] Raju (1992) Structural design and drawing: Reinforced concrete and steel.
Universities Press.
2. Leonard Koel. (1999) Construction print reading. Delmar Cengage Learning.
[Link] Self-Assessment
Written Assessment om
1. Which of the following is not a method of drawing structural members?
t.c
a) Specifications
e
b) Structural plans
tv
sy
c) Elevations
ea
d) Details
2. Which of the following is not among the drawing resources required to produce
structural plans?
a) Computers
b) Computer software
c) Standard design manuals
d) Office equipment
3. Which of the following is not a phase during design of structures?
a) Technical design
b) Developed design
c) Conceptual design
d) Handover
4. State the various computer software required in the production of structural drawings.
5. Explain the procedure of developing shop drawings.
6. Describe what is detailing of structural drawings.
7. Write an essay describing Building Information Modelling (BIM) and its impact on the
production of structural drawings.
166
Project Assessment
Obtain a set of structural drawings for a project from the internet and interpret them to draw
up a material schedule.
Oral Assessment
1. Explain the skills required to competently interpret structural drawings.
2. Explain the steps followed in interpreting structural drawings.
167
4.3.5 Learning Outcome No 4: Interpret structural drawings
[Link] Learning Activities
Learning Outcome No 3: Interpret structural drawings
Learning Activities Special Instructions
Steel schedules: This is a list that explains the location, mark, type, size, length and number
of each steel bar in a reinforcement drawing of a structure.
Structural drawings: These are plans illustrating in detail how a structure or building
should be constructed. Engineers come up with structural drawings from performing
checks using the loads that the structure is to carry, co-currently with standard codes.
Content/Procedures/Methods/Illustrations
4.1 Identify project according to the contract document
Project Identification is one of the major stages of a project cycle
Steps taken in identifying a project:
• Preliminary stakeholder analysis
• Analyzing the problem
• Setting of Objectives
• Analyzing alternatives
• Analyzing accountability
• Logical framework thinking
• Analyzing assumptions and associated risks
• Definition of Progress indicator
168
4.2 Identify and obtain structural drawings as per design manuals
Structural drawings
These are plans illustrating in detail how a structure or building should be constructed.
Engineers come up with structural drawings from performing checks using the loads that
the structure is to carry, co-currently with standard codes.
Reinforcement Drawing
These are drawings describing the location, number, size, type of reinforcement and
illustrate the direction in which the reinforcement is to be laid.
Standard Details
om
This is a description of certain standard details that keep recurring in several structural
t.c
• Notes
sy
ea
Record Drawings
This is a drawing that has been revised to cater for unforeseen challenges. A revision letter
is normally included in the revised drawing to indicate that it is a revision.
4.3 Obtain and prepare steel schedules and materials schedules according to
construction procedures
Factors to be considered when preparing a Steel Schedule
• Location of reinforcement
• Mark of reinforcement
• Type of reinforcement
• Size of reinforcement – diameter of steel
• Length of reinforcement
Factors to be considered when preparing a Materials Schedule
• Type of material
• Amount of material
169
Conclusion
This learning outcome covered identification of project, structural drawings, steel and
material schedules preparation and standard construction procedures.
Further Reading
[Link] Self-Assessment
Written Assessment
1. Structural drawings should basically include the following information. Which one is
not among them? om
a) Setting out dimensions
t.c
d) Amount of material
ea
2. While developing a steel schedule, the site engineer left out one crucial detail
necessary. Which one of the following is it?
a) Color of reinforcement
b) Location of reinforcement
c) Dimensions of structure
d) Height of the structure
3. Define the term Structural drawings
4. State three types of construction drawings
5. Discuss in detail the steps taken in project identification
Oral Assessment
Why is it necessary to master the art of interpreting structural drawings?
Practical Assessment
Get construction drawings of a given structure and point out the different structural element
present and come up with a steel schedule for the reinforcement
170
[Link] Tools, Equipment, Supplies and Materials
• Computers
• Office equipment
• Calculators
• Scale rule
• Computer software
• Design codes (British standards)
• Stationery
• Standard design manuals
• Dust coat
• First aid kit
[Link] References
McCormac. (2007). Structural Steel Design. Prentice Hall, 4th edition. ISBN:013221816X
om
Segui (2006). Steel Design. Cengage-Engineering, 4th edition. ISBN: 0495244716
et.c
tv
sy
ea
171
4.3.6 Learning Outcome No 5: Apply and use Structural Drawings
[Link] Learning Activities
Learning Outcome No 5: Apply and use Structural Drawings
Learning Activities Special Instructions
[Link] Information Sheet No5/ L05 Apply and use structural drawings
om
Introduction to learning outcome
t.c
Steel schedules: This is a list that explains the location, mark, type, size, length and number
of each steel bar in a Reinforcement Drawing of a Structure.
Content/Procedures/Methods/Illustrations
5.1 Identify and obtain construction resources as per the tender documents
Construction resources – this is basically the materials and personnel necessary for the
construction process from start to finish.
172
b) Materials – Construction materials are a great resource since they sum up the
ingredients necessary to have a finished structural work. These include but are not
limited to building blocks, cement, sand, water, ballast etc.
c) Labour – this includes human personnel, from the manual worker to the
construction experts such as engineers.
d) Plant and Machinery – These are necessary in order to have some finished
products such as concrete which requires a concrete mixer.
e) Health and safety equipment – This is whereby we have guard rails at the edge
of high-rise buildings under construction, the use of bright coloured tape
surrounding shafts, presence of fire extinguishers on site and health and safety
training for all personnel.
f) Technology – technology such as a crane which is necessary for lifting heavy
construction materials such as steel, scaffolding, shuttering, buckets of concrete etc.
g) Works Requirement – This comprises of the working drawings and specifications
required for the construction project.
h) Construction site – This is the very place where the proposed structure is to be
constructed.
om
5.2 Gather statutory documents as per the project requirements
et.c
Statutory documents
tv
This refers to documents with instructions or requirements which are applicable by virtue
sy
of law enacted by the government. Almost every proposed development project has
ea
statutory obligations that do not arise out of the contract, but are imposed by law. These
obligations are applicable to the design, construction and operation of buildings and will
depend on the specific nature of the proposed development.
Statutory documents are required for the following areas when drafting construction
contracts:
Labour
• The Employment Act 2007
• The Labour Institutions Act
• The Labour Relations Act
Tax
• The Income Tax Act
All workers in any construction project must be subject to the payment of income tax
173
Environment and Pollution
• Environmental Management and Coordination Act
Noise
• Legal Notice No.61 (NEMA)
Traffic
• The Road Traffic Act
Building
• Building Regulations
Planning
• The Urban Planning Act
Public Procurement
• The Social Value Act om
t.c
5.3 Determine setting out activities according to the approved drawings and standard
construction processes
Setting Out – the act of establishing the location points of site boundaries, columns,
foundations, center-lines of walls and any other necessary structural part.
174
Steps undertaken in Setting out a building
• Clearing the site
• Obtain the working drawing of the proposed building
• Ensure that the materials for construction are ready
• A parallel line is then established
• The 3-4-5 setting out method is then used for setting out
• Profiles are then established
• The points of excavation on the profiled are nailed
• The points of the column on the profile are then nailed.
5.4 Establish foundation as per the working drawings and standard construction
procedures
Factors to be considered when establishing the foundation
• Excavation depth and volume
• Soil bearing capacity
• Base area of foundation
• Proximity to property lines om
t.c
Structural Members
sy
These are simple structural elements that when viewed or put together, make up the
ea
175
5.6 Develop and adhere to working drawing, steel schedules and materials schedules
according to standard construction processes
Factors to be considered in developing Working Drawing
• Internal forces – Moment and Shear (ULS – Ultimate limit state)
• Safety Checks on deflection, cracking, corrosion and fire resistance
• Loads – dead loads and imposed loads
• Partial Safety factors – On dead loads a partial safety of 40% (1.4Gk) and a partial
safety factor of 60% on imposed loads (1.6Qk)
• Moment distribution
• Type of material
e
• Amount of material
tv
sy
ea
Conclusion
This learning outcome covered interpretation of drawings, statutory requirements,
foundation engineering, preparation of structural elements and development of working
drawing, steel schedules and materials schedules.
Further Reading
176
[Link] Self-Assessment
Written Assessment
1. Sophia is a student undertaking a diploma course in civil engineering. While arranging
a bookshelf at her home, she came across structural drawings to their proposed new
home in Ruai. Which of the following was not a structural member in the drawings?
a) Columns
b) Beams
c) Slab
d) Steel reinforcement
2. Victor a recently graduate civil engineer was asked to come up with a steel schedule
back at work. Which of the following is not a factor he should consider while
developing the steel schedule?
a) Location of reinforcement
b) Size of reinforcement
c) Color of reinforcement om
d) Length of reinforcement
t.c
3. In an interview for a civil engineering job, an interviewee was asked to state the steps
e
tv
undertaken when setting out a building. Which of the following should have been his
sy
first step?
ea
Practical Assessment
Given a 4 by 5 two-way spanning solid slab, with the aid of a structural drawing, develop
a steel schedule for the slab.
177
[Link] Tools, Equipment, Supplies and Materials
• Computers
• Office equipment
• Calculators
• Scale rule
• Computer software
• Design codes (British standards)
• Stationery
• Standard design manuals
• Dust coat
• First aid kit
[Link] References
McCormac. (2007). Structural Steel Design. Prentice Hall, 4th edition. ISBN:013221816X
om
Segui (2006). Steel Design. Cengage-Engineering, 4th edition. ISBN: 0495244716
et.c
tv
sy
ea
178