SBL Chapter 3
SBL Chapter 3
Chapter 3 -
Innovation, Performance & Change Mgt
Process Improvement & Strategy
Terminologies
Business Process Automation: Manual tasks are automated using machinery or IT
Business Process Rationalization: Already automated tasks are further improved by using latest machinery
or IT. This is part of continuous improvement strategy
Business Process Re-Engineering: Fundamental rethinking and radical redesigning of processes in order to
achieve dramatic results. BPR adopts a ‘clean sheet’ approach whereby the entire process is redesigned
from scratch. - fundamental rethinking - questioning the logic of whole process (why we do this)
- radical redesign - completely restructuring workflows, removing unnecessary steps,
combining tasks, using technology to automate or simplify steps.
Problems Solutions
Process High B D
Complexity
Low A C
Low High
Strategic Importance
LOW PROCESS COMPLEXIT Y, LOW STRATEGIC IMPORTANCE
A: Simple / straight forward process but not contributing to company’s core strategy
Strategy: Simple automation using off-the-shelf softwares or outsource (e.g. payroll, office cleaning)
B: Complex process but not contributing to company’s core strategy. Hard to automate.
Strategy: Outsource to a specialist vendor (e.g. taxes, legal)
D: Complex, high value process which generates competitive advantage for the organization
Strategy: Careful process designing, employee best experts, best IT solution, etc. (e.g. research and
product development, marketing)
Projects
▪ Project: a one-off non-routine activity that has a
Beginning and end
Clear objectives
Within time, cost and quality
▪ Project Stakeholders: people, departments or external parties either involved in the project OR effected
by the project. It includes internal as well as external stakeholders such as:
Project sponsor
Project manager
Project team
Users / concerned department (s)
Customers
Suppliers
Government
Society / community
Project Lifecycle
Project lifecycle is all the stages through which a project passes from start till end.
1. PROJECT INITIATION
This stage covers basic information to enable the Board to approve or reject the proposed project. It
includes the following:
▪ Scope and objective
APPROVAL PHASE
▪ Cost and benefit analysis
▪ Key stakeholders (e.g. project sponsor, project manager, project team, users, etc.)
▪ Project duration / timelines
▪ Risks and constraints
▪ Feasibility, investment appraisal techniques, etc.
▪ Documents used in this phase:
Project Initiation Document / Business Case
Project charter
Benefit realization plan
Contents of a PID
▪ Current situation or problem
▪ Project scope and objective
▪ Cost and Benefit Analysis
▪ Key stakeholders:
Project Charter
A Project Charter is a formal approval of the business case and gives authorization for the work to be started
and allocation of funds and resources to be made. It is signed-off by all key stake holders of the project, based
on the Project Initiation Document.
2. PLANNING
Once the project is approved by the Board, detailed / technical planning is done in order to execute the
project. It includes the following:
DETAILED PLANNING
▪ Detailed planning for all activities within the project
▪ Project is broken down into many tasks and then detailed planning is done for each task, covering
resources, costs, quality, risks, timing, duration, etc.
▪ Document used in this phase: PROJECT PLAN
Project Plan
A project plan is a document which contains detailed planning about the project, covering resources, timing,
costs, risks, duration, etc. The project is broken down into many tasks and then detailed planning is done for
each task. Detailed project planning is normally done once the Business case is approved.
4. COMPLETION
This stage covers the handing over process, user feedbacks as well as assessment whether the project
objectives were met or not. It includes:
▪ Training of users
▪ Testing by users
▪ Formal handing over / sign off procedures
▪ Taking feedback from users
▪ Assessment whether project objectives are met or not
▪ Documents used in this phase:
Post Project Review
Post Implementation Review
Benefit Realization Review (covered above)
Difference between a PIR and a Benefit Realization Review is that a PIR focuses on the product or outcome of
the project whereas Benefit Realization Review focuses more on the financial benefits as a result of that
project. E.g. if the project was to design and implement an online e-commerce website, a successful launch of a
good quality website will be covered under PIR and whether the increases sales revenue are achieved or not
will be covered under Benefit Realization Plan.
Types of Benefits
▪ Observable Benefits:
These are intangible benefits which cannot be quantified in financial terms, e.g. improvement in staff
morale. These should not be part of cost benefit analysis and can only be included under ‘qualitative’
benefits if important.
▪ Measurable Benefits:
These benefits are measurable but it is difficult to predict by how much they will increase once the
project is completed. For e.g. by how much market share will increase if company implements an online
ecommerce website? These benefits involve high degree of assumptions or estimations.
▪ Quantifiable Benefits:
These benefits are relatively easy to predict by how much they will increase once the project is
completed. For e.g. by how much wastages will reduce if a new machine is installed.
▪ Financial Benefits:
Once the measurable and quantifiable benefits are quantified, it becomes easy to convert them into
financials. (e.g. increase in sales revenue as a result of increase in sales volume)
Costs
ALL direct and relevant costs should be considered in the business case, including:
Investment Appraisals
Once all costs and benefits of the project have been listed, then these are compared to see if the investment in
project is financially beneficial (investment appraisal). In a typical project, there would be substantial cash
outflow in the start in anticipation of long-term cash inflows. Hence careful investment appraisal is done as
huge amounts are involved and it becomes difficult to pull out in the middle.
Project Stakeholders
Project Sponsor
Project sponsor is normally a senior person from the management team, responsible for the successful
outcomes of the project. He is the person who will gain the most from the success of the project and who will
lose the most if the project is a failure. He is the person who had initially requested the Board to approve the
project.
Project Manager
Project manager is the person responsible for the entire project and all its activities. i.e. it is his job to ensure
that the project is completed on time, budget and quality
▪ Reason: The reason / justification for bringing a change should be clear, i.e. why the change is being made
and what will be the benefits
▪ Time: How quickly the change is needed? How much time is available to implement the change? Is there
any urgency to implement this change (Big Bang) or can it be implemented gradually (Incremental)
▪ Capacity / Resources: What kind of resources is required to implement the change. It includes financial
resources, manpower, technology, etc.
▪ Capability: Do we have expertise for ‘change management’, i.e. expertise to manage and implement the
change, e.g. past experience of various change projects, change agent
▪ Power: How much power does the change leader has. It also involves in identifying people in the
organization who has the ‘real’ power to affect to the change
▪ Diversification: is there diversity (variety) of experience or strategy in the ‘current environment’? Change
will be difficult to implement (hampered) if the organization has been perusing the same strategy for years
▪ Readiness: Are the employees ready to accept the change or will there be significant resistance
▪ Resistance: Who will be the people or stake holders who will resist the change, reason for resistance, how
you would handle those people / stake holders
Nature of
Incremental Adaptation Evolution
change
(Speed Of
Change)
Big Bang Reconstruction Revolution
Realignment Transformational
Scope of Change
(Size Of Change)
As compared to existing culture, business model or
core business strategy)
▪ Adaptation: most common, step-by-step gradual speed of change, small size of changes (reallignment)
▪ Evolution: new mindset, re-engineering, step-by-step gradual speed of change, (transformational) size of changes
▪ Reconstruction: rapid and extensive faster speed of change (big bang) and small size of change (reallignment)
▪ Revolution: in case of extreme crisis, very obvious faster speed of change (big bang), transformational size of change
3. REFREEZE: ensuring that new system or process or new change is now part of the routine through
reinforcement techniques, such as rewards, appreciation, monitoring, etc.
Organizational Structures
Types of Structure
▪ Functional structure (departments)
Disadvantage: creates “Silo” effect i.e. each department focuses on their own performance /
objectives and does not coordinate with other departments
▪ Divisional structure (divisions and then departments)
▪ Tall / Flat structure (span of control, i.e. number of subordinates reporting to you)
▪ Matrix / Transnational (see below)
Matrix Structure
▪ Used where there are multiple branches / offices (either in same country or across countries i.e.
multinationals)
▪ Matrix structure develops cross functional coordination
▪ Matrix structure means an employee has two bosses (dual reporting)
▪ Primary reporting (e.g. to functional head such as CFO)
▪ Secondary / dotted reporting (e.g. to administrative head such as branch manager)
▪ Advantages:
▪ Availability of functional expertise and guidance at branches employees can get guidance from experts,
▪ Level of control required if tight monitoring and central control is needed - more centralized structure is suitable.
▪ Quality of the team highly skilled and experienced teams can work in more decentralised structures.
▪ Speed of decision making required decision making is faster in flatter and decentralised strcutures.
▪ Accountability increased responsibility, less confusion and more accountability in functional or divisional or tall
structures.
▪ Flexibility
if the environments changes more frequently, flexible structures like matrix structures are better.
Internal Relationships
▪ Centralization
▪ Advantages: control, standardization, lower overheads, strong leadership
▪ De-centralization
▪ Advantages: local knowledge, flexibility, speed, higher accountability, reduces workload at
corporate level
▪ Formal procedures
▪ Strict hierarchy
▪ Standardized work processes through technology
▪ Suitable for simple and repetitive task environment
Professional Bureaucracy
▪ Standardized skills of individuals (e.g. doctors, lawyers)
▪ Suitable for service-oriented organizations
Divisional Form
▪ Standardized outputs (of divisions)
▪ Gives autonomy (i.e. independence) to middle level management to run their own divisions
Adhocracy
▪ No standardized processes
▪ Complex and disorderly
▪ E.g. project based teams, etc.
▪ Suitable for research and innovations
Missionary Organizations
▪ Standardized ideology
▪ E.g. NGOs
Talent Management
Talent management means to identify, recruit, engage, retain, and develop the most talented and superior
employees within by the organisation. Key elements of talent management include:
Advantages Disadvantages
▪ Getting specialized expertise ▪ Dependency on 3rd party
▪ Org can focus on its core activities ▪ Loss of direct control
▪ Cheaper ▪ Confidentiality issues
▪ Ease of budgeting ▪ Poor service / quality
▪ Reduces fixed overheads ▪ Chances of disputes
Shared Services
Shared services refer to the centralization of back office / support functions at one location, which were
previously carried out by each business unit independently. Common shared services functions includes IT,
finance, admin, procurement, HR, legal, etc.
Unlike outsourcing, shared services are carried out within the organization and will not require the use of a
third party. The shared service is treated as a separate business unit and its services are charged to other
business units at arm’s length prices. It will have its own targets to achieve and will be expected to produce
continuous improvements.
resistance coz individual business units will
Advantages Disadvantages loose control over their support functions.
difficult to standardize.
Collaborative working is when two or more organizations work together in a variety of ways, such as JIT,
strategic alliance, joint ventures, networking, joint projects, sharing of resources, etc. It could be a one-off
arrangement or it could be a long-term permanent arrangement.
For e.g. [Link]: it only manages online website and e-marketing and heavily relies on various vendors,
courier companies, credit card company, etc. to deliver rest of the customer experience. The customer feels
that he/she is dealing with one organization but in reality, several organization are collaborating behind the
scene.
Advantages Disadvantages
▪ Sharing of expertise and resources ▪ High dependency on each other
▪ Synergies ▪ Conflict of interest
▪ One stop solution for customers ▪ Weak partner may affect all
Disruptive Technologies
Disruptive technology means when technology is used to create a new market or value network and ‘disrupt’
the existing / traditional / physical business model in an Industry, displacing the established market leaders and
alliances. E.g. includes Uber, Netflix, Airbnb, Block Chain, Crypto currencies, etc.
FINTECH: one of the fastest growth sector in disruptive is financial services. Financial Technology (known as
Fintech) is disrupting the traditional banking industry dominated by giant banks. Fintech provides investment
advices, portfolio management, mortgages, exchange currencies, make payments.
- Existing Business model sufficient - Hardware & software systems have appropriate
which steps add value, which are change is happening, benefits it will
redundant and how will the chnage bring, how it will affect their roles.
imoact each stage of the value chain. change fails if people are not ready or trained properly.
identifies opprtunities to automate steps, further automate already automated steps and
▪ Financial: whether org is achieving its financial targets and shareholder needs e.g. ROCE, ROI
▪ Customer: whether org is meeting customer needs e.g. customer satisfaction, feedbacks, complaints
▪ Innovation: whether org is continuing to improve and develop e.g. research, innovation, training
▪ Business Process: whether internal processes are efficient and employees are motivated
▪ Customers: building long lasting relationships with customers and meeting their expectations
▪ Workforce: how organization enables and empowers its employees, skilled, motivated, high
performance
Practice Questions
P3 – Dec 2009 Q3: Project Management | Harmon Process Strategy (Lowland Bank)
P3 – Dec 2010 Q1B: Contextual Features of Change (Shoal Plc)
P3 – Dec 2011 Q3: Post Project Review and Post Implementation Review (Home Deliver)P3 – Mar/Jun
2017 Q4: Harmon | Off the Shelf S/W (Deeland Housing)