Unit 7
Unit 7
7-1 çLrkouk
7-2 mifu"knksa dk ySfVu ,oa vU; vuqokn
7-3 mifu"knksa dk if'peh fopkjksa ij çHkko
7-4 mifu"knksa dk iwohZ fopkjksa ij çHkko
7-5 Hkkjr esa xhrk dk vuqokn
7-6 ;wjksih; ns'kksa esa xhrk dk vuqokn
7-7 baXyS.M esa vuqokn
7-8 Ýkal esa xhrk dk vuqokn
7-9 teZu esa xhrk dk vuqokn
7-10 xhrk dk ik'pkR; fo}kuksa ij çHkko
7-11 lkjka'k
7-12 “kCnkoyh
7-13 dqN mi;ksxh iqLrdsa
7-14 cks/k@vH;kl ç'uksa ds mŸkj
Hkkjrh; n'kZu txr~ esa çLFkku=;h ds uke ls çfl) *mifu"kn~* dks vkfne xzUFk ds
:i esa ekU;rk çkIr gS rFkk lokZf/kd egÙ[Link] xzUFk ds :i esa egRo j[krk gSA
osnkUr n'kZu ds rhu Hkkxksa Jqfr] Le`fr rFkk U;k; esa ls Jqfr ds vUrxZr mifu"knksa
dh [Link] dh tkrh gSA mifu"kn lk{kkr~ dke/ksuq gS rFkk Hkxon~xhrk mifu"kn~ :ih 103
dke/ksuq dk ve`re; iF; gSA xhrk esa fy[kk gS fd "loksZifu"knks xkoks nksX/kk
xksikyuUnu%" vFkkZr~ leLr mifu"kn xkS Lo:i gSa rFkk Xokyksa ds fç; Jh—".k
mudk nksgu djus okys gSaA v/;kRe ç/kku Hkkjrh; laL—fr esa vk/;kfRed Kku ds
çfriknu dk Js; osnkUr vFkkZr~ mifu"knksa dks gh çkIr gS A ekuo thou dk pje
y{; ikjekfFkZd lR; dk Kku çkIr djuk gSA
mifu"kn~ blh dkj.k ç[Link] xzUFk ekus tkrs gSa rFkk blds vUrZxr mifu"kn~
loZçkphu xzUFk ds :i esa ekU;rk çkIr gSA budks osnksa dk vfUre Hkkx ekuk tkrk
gSA vkpk;Z lnkuUn th us osnkUrlkj esa fy[kk gS *osnkUrks uke mifu"kRç[Link]
rnqidkjhf.k 'kkjhjd lw=knhfu p* vFkkZr~ osnkUr 'kCn mifu"kn ds :i esa ç[Link]
ekuk tkrk gS rFkk bldh O;k[;k 'kkjhjd lw=kfn esa dh xbZ gSA mifu"kn~ oLrqr%
Hkkjrh; n'kZu ds ewy vk/kkj gSA
*mi* rFkk *fu* bu nks milxksaZ ds ckn ln~ /kkrq ls fDoi~ çR;; yxkdj mifu"kn~
'kCn fu"iUu gksrk gS A lk/[Link]% bldk vFkZ gksrk gS xq# ds lehi ¼mi½ cSBdj
¼fu"kn~½ çkIr fd;k x;k Kku gSA fQj Hkh ln~ /kkrq ds rhu vFkksaZ ls vk/;kfRed
mRd"kZ okys fuoZpu fd;s x;s gSaA ln~ /kkrq ds rhu vFkZ gSa& fo'kj.k ¼ uk'k½ xfr
¼Kku ;k çkfIr ½ rFkk volknu ¼f'kfFky djuk½ A blhfy, 'kadjkpk;Z us dgk gS
fd *mifu"kk/k;fr lokZuFkZdja lalkja fouk'k;fr] [Link]|ka p
f'kfFky;fr czã p xe;fr* vFkkZr~ lHkh vuFkksaZ dks mRiUu djus okys lalkj ¼ tho
dk ckj&ckj tUe&ej.k gksuk½ dk ;g fouk'k djrh gS] lalkj ds gsrq Lo:i
vfo|k dks f'kfFky djrh gS vkSj czã dh çkfIr ¼voxfr & Kku ½ djkrh gSA
mifu"knksa dk v/;;u ,dkUr esa xq# ds çlkn ls gksrk jgk gS vr% mUgsa
*jgL;fo|k* Hkh dgrs gSaA muesa eq[; :i ls czã] l`f"V] tho] vkRek] çk.k] iqutZUe]
deZ rFkk uSfrdrk dk foospu gSA muesa mins'k dh vusd fof/k;ksa dk ç;ksx feyrk
gSA
'kadjkpk;Z us Hkk"; esa fy[kk FkkA muds fo"k; esa ;g çfl) 'yksd gS&
bZ'k&dsu&dB&ç'u&eq.M&[Link];&frfÙkfj%A
,srjs;a p NkUnksX;a c`gnkj.;da rFkk AA
vFkkZr 'kadjkpk;Z us mifu"knksa dh la[;k eq[;:i ls Č Lohdkj dh gS tks fuEu gSa
ftu ij budk Hkk"; Hkh çkIr gksrk gSA
1½ bZ'kksifu"kn~
2½ dsuksifu"kn~
3½ dBksifu"kn~
4½ ç'uksifu"kn~
5½ [Link]"kn~
6½ [Link];ksifu"kn~
7½ rSfÙkjh;ksifu"kn~
8½ ,srjs;ksifu"kn~
104 9½ NkUnksX;ksifu"kn~
10½ c`gnkj.;dksifu"kn~
106
1½ mifu"knksa ds vuqoknksa dk xgjk vlj 'kksius g‚oj ij gqvkA 'kksisug‚oj dh est
ij mifu"knksa dh ,d ySfVu çfr jgrh Fkh vkSj os lksus ls igys mlesa ls gh
viuh çkFkZuk,¡ fd;k djrs FksA mifu"knksa ds lUnHkZ esa 'kksiusgkoj ds fopkj gSa
fd &"mifu"knksa ds çR;sd okD; esa ls xgu] ekSfyd vkSj mnkÙk fopkj
fudyrs gSa vkSj lHkh dqN ,d mPp] ifo= vkSj ,dkxz Hkkouk ls O;kIr gks
tkrk gS A leLr lalkj esa mifu"knksa tSlk dY;[Link] vkSj vkRek dks mUur
djus okykdksbZ vkSj xzUFk ugha gSA ;s loksZPp çfrHkk ds çrhd gSaA nsj&losj esa
;s yksxksa dh vkLFkk dk vk/kkj cudj jgsaxsA mifu"kn~ esa loZ= fdruh lqUnjrk
ds lkFk osnksa ds Hkko çdkf'kr gSa] tks dksbZ Hkh mä Qkjlh ySfVu vuqokn dk
/;ku nsdj v/;;u djds mifu"kn~ dh vuqie Hkko/kkjk ls ifjfpr gksxk] mlh
dh vkRek ds xEHkhjre çns'k esa ,d gypy ep tk;sxhA ,d&,d iafä
fdruh –<+] Li"V vFkZ çdV dj jgh gS A [Link] xzUFk dSls mPp] ifo= rFkk
,sdkfUrd Hkkoksa ls vksr&çksr gSA lkjs [Link] esa ewy mifu"kn~ ds leku bruk
QyksRiknd vkSj mPp HkkoksRiknd xzUFk dgha Hkh ugha gSA blus eq>dks thou esa
'kkfUr çnku dh gS vkSj ejus ij Hkh ;g 'kkfUr nsxkA"
mifu"knksa dks le>us ds fy, buds _f"k;ksa ds –f"Vdks.k dks le>uk vko';d gSA
Lokeh foosdkuUn us dgk gS fd Þmifu"knksa dk v/;;u djus ij muds us=ksa ls 107
vJq/kkjk çokfgr gksus yxrh gSAmifu"kn~ 'kfä dk ewy gS A mlesa çokfgr 'kfä ls
cy] 'kkS;Z rFkk uo thou dk lapkj gksrk gSA buds lUns'k ls O;fä LokfJr gksdj
HkocU/kuksa ls eqä gksus dk ç;kl djrk gSA 'kkjhfjd] ekufld rFkk vk/;kfRed
mUeqärk dk ç;kl rFkk vkReksUufr mifu"knksa dk ewy eU= gSA Lokeh foosdkuUn
ds vuqlkj mifu"kn~ Kku dh vko';drk dsoy czã çkfIr ds fy, gh ugha vfirq
nSfud thou ds fy, Hkh mi;ksxh gSA mifu"knksa ls og 'kfä çkIr gksrh gS] ftlds
}kjk ekuo thou laxzke dk /kS;Z rFkk lkgliwoZd lkeuk dj ldrk gSA thou ds
vk/;kfRed rFkk HkkSfrd mHk; {ks= esa mifu"knksa dh vko';drk gSA
fo'odfo jfoUæ ukFk VSxksj ds vuqlkj **p{kq lEiUu O;fä ns[ksaxs fd Hkkjr dk
czãKku [Link] i`Foh dk /keZ cuus yxk gSA çkr%dkyhu lw;Z dh v#[Link] [Link] ls
iwoZ fn'kk vkyksfdr gksus yxh gS] ijUrq tc og lw;Z e/;kà xxu esa çdkf'kr gksxk]
rc ml le; mldh nhfIr ls leLr [Link] nhfIre; gks mBsxkA**
M‚å loZiYyh jk/kk—".ku~ us viuh iqLrd ^^mifu"knksa dk lUns'k** esa fy[kk gS fd
Þmifu"knksa dks tks Hkh ewy laL—r esa i<+rk gS] og ekuo vkRek rFkk ije lR; ds
xqgk rFkk ifo= lEcU/kksa dks mtkxj djus okys rFkk muds cgqr ls mn~xkjksa ds
mRd"kZ dkO; vkSj çcy lEeksgu ls eqX/k gks tkrk gS vkSj mlesa cgus yxrk gSA**
vkpk;Z fcuksok Hkkos us viuh iqLrd *mifu"kn~ ,d v/;;u* esa fy[kk gS fd
Þmifu"knksa dh efgek vusd fnO;kRekvksa us xk;h gS A dfo us dgk gS fd fgeky;
tSlk ioZr ugha rFkk mifu"knksa tSlh dksbZ iqLrd gS gh ugha og rks ,d n'kZu gSA**
bl çdkj mifu"knksa ds vkd"kZ.k esa vf}rh; fofo/krk ds n'kZu gksrs gSaA /kkfeZd
[kkst dh O;kdqyrk rFkk rRijrk buesa fn[kk;h nsrh gSA buds fopkjdksa ds }kjk
[Link] fo"k;ksa esa vkn'kZokfnrk] nk'kZfudrk rFkk lR; ds vuojr vUos"k.k dh
ykylk fn[kk;h nsrh gSA mifu"knksa ds fopkjksa ds }kjk cká vkd"[Link] ls Åij mBus
dh ç[Link] çkIr gksrh gSA blesa [Link] 'kk'or lR; Kku rFkk vkfRed 'kfä ls
vUr–Zf"V rFkk vkUrfjd cy çkIr gksrk gS] ftlesa uo ÅtkZ dk lapkj gksrk gS A
mifu"kn~] O;ofLFkr fpUru ls vf/kd vkfRed çdk'k ds lk/ku çrhr gksrs gSaA buds
}kjk fofo/k çdkj ds vkfRed vuqHko dk lalkj mn~?kkfVr gqvk gSA buds }kjk
O;ä fd;s x;s lR; dh iqf"V dsoy rdZ cqf) ds }kjk gh ugha vfirq LokuqHkwfr ls
gksrh gS A budk mís'; O;kogkfjd gSA
Jhen~Hkkxon~xhrk dks çLFkku=;h ds vUrxZr ekuk x;k gSA xhrk mifu"kn~ vkSj
czãlw= rhuksa xzUFk çLFkku=;h ds vuZ~rxr [Link] gSaA buds ek/;e ls vkRerÙo
ds çR;{khdj.k ,oa euq"; dks vkRek ls lk{kkRdkj djk;k tkrk gSA
Jhen~Hkkxon~xhrk Jh—".k}Sik;u osnO;kl—r egkHkkjr ds Hkh"eioZ dk iPphlosa
v/;k; ls c;kyhlosa v/;k; rd dk laxzg xzUFk gSA bl çdkj bl —fr ds
jpf;rk Jh osnO;kl th gSA blds fo"k; esa Hkh Li"VksYys[k gS fd&
xhrk lqxhrk drZ~rO;k fdeU;S% 'kkL=foLrjS%A
;k Lo;a in~eukHkL; eq[kin~ekf}fu%l`rk AA
108
vf}rh; ,d ijekRek Jh—".k dk opuke`r Jhen~Hkkxon~xhrk Hkh vf}rh; xzUFk ds
:i esa fu:fir gSa&
,da 'kkL=a nsodh iq= xhr&
esdks nsoks nsodhiq= ,o
,dks eU=LR;L; ukekfu ;kfu
dekZI;sda rL; nsoL; lsokAA
uouoksUes"k çKk lefUork lfpUru [Link] ,oa çfr{k.k uohurk ds lfPpnkuan :i
ls lk{kkRdkj djkrh gqbZ ;g ijejE;k ;k [Link];rk dk lq:i gSA
bl ds fy, ;g lwfä lkFkZd gS&
**{[Link] {[Link] ;UuorkeqiSfr rnSo :ia [Link];rk;k%A** ¼ek?kdfo½
1935 ls ysdj 1941 rd nks çdkj ds vuqokn lkeus vk;sA mUgksaus çeq[k Hkkjrh;
vkSj if'peh fo}kuksa dks ,d lkFk ,df=r djus dk ç;kl fd;kA ftls iwoZ dh
vk/;kfRed ç[Link] vkSj Hkxon~xhrk dh lkoZHkkSfed çklafxdrk dks dk;e j[kus
esa cgqr egÙ[Link] ekuk tkrk gSA ;s nksuksa çdkj ds vuqokn çrhdkRed FksA ;s laL—
r ls lh/ks ;wjksih; Hkk"kk esa vuqfnr gksus ds dkj.k eq[; :i ls tkus x;s ikB gksus
dh çfr"Bk vftZr dh vkSj bUgksaus xhrk dh vksj ;wjksi vkSj vU; {ks=ksa esa /;ku
vkdZf"kr fd;kA
bu çkjfEHkd vaxzsth vuqoknksa dh ,d fo'ks"krk ;g Fkh fd bUgksaus xhrk dks fgUnw
/keZ ds Hkhrj mPp vewrZ nk'kZfud fopkjksa dh vfHkO;fä ds :i esa çLrqr fd;k] tks
blds fupys] yksdfç; va/kfo'[Link] :i ls feyh FkhA blds lkFk gh fofYdUl ds
vuqokn ds çdk'ku ds ,d lky ckn lj ,Mfou vukZYM us xhrk dks fjä dfork
“The song celestial’’ ds :i esa 1885 bZå vuqfnr fd;kA blus xhrk ds lcls
egÙ[Link] vkSj lcls O;kid :i esa i<+us okys laLdj.k ds :i esa çflf) gkfly
dhA bUgksus gh xk¡/kh th dks thou Hkj xhrk i<+us ds fy, çsfjr fd;kA
Hkkjr esa vuqokn djus okys fo}kuksa ds fy, Hkxon~xhrk ,d ifo= iqLrd gSA
D;ksafd mudk ;g fo'okl Fkk fd xhrk vHkh Hkh thoar :i ls thfor gS vkSj fuR;
uohu Kku ls [kqn dks iqutZUe djrh jgsxhA xhrk dk vuqokn djuk vkSj
vkUrfjd vFkZ dh O;k[;k djuk ,oa lkFk gh Hkkjrh;ksa dks f'kf{kr djus dk Hkh ,d
dk;Z gSa; vkSj lR; dks QSykus ds fy, ,d drZO; ds :i esa Fkk A ;g xhrk dks
,d lkoZHkkSfed lans'k ds :i esa çLrqr djus dk ç;kl Hkh Fkk vkSj fgUnw /keZ
dk vU; dBksj /kkfeZd /keksaZ ds foijhr thou ds ,d [kqys var–f"Vdks.k ds :i esa
FkkA
vuqokn esa yxs Hkkjrh;ksa dh cgqr cM+h la[;k us Hkxon~xhrk dks loksZPp fgUnw
nk'kZfud fopkjksa ds mnkgj.k ds :i esa çLrqr fd;kA mnkgj.k Lo:i
fr#oyqelqOokjks dh iqLrd "Discourse on the Bhagavad gita’’ ¼1888½ vkSj R.
Shivshankar Pandiyaji's dk vuqokn Bhagavad gita sara Bodhini or the
Essential Teaching of the Bhagavad gita ¼1897½ esa vfuok;Z ,oa vko';d f'k{k.k
109
ij vius n'kZu dk v/;;u djus gsrq rFkk Nk=ksa dh enn djus ds fy, fd;k x;k
FkkA
20oha lnh ds çkjEHk esa Hkkjrh;ksa us fo'ks"k :i ls jk"Vªokfn;ksa us vkSifuosf'kd Hkkjr
ds chp xhrk dks mHkjrs gq, Hkkjrh; jk"Vªh; lnkpkjksads dsUæh; dk;Z ds :i esa
c<+kok fn;kA muds vuqlkj u;k ;q){ks= fczfV'k jkT; dk Fkk tks lesfdr
lkekftd vkSj jktuhfrd dk;Zokgh ds fy, [kqyk jgk Fkk tcfd bl rjg dh
dk;Zokgh dk :i cgl dk fo"k; **fgalk cuke vfgalk** Fkk A
xhrk çsl xksj[kiqj us chloh 'krkCnh dh 'kq:vkr ds chp xhrk ds lans'k dks
QSykus dk egku dk;Z fd;k A
dk'khukFk R;aZcd rsyax vkSj xhrk
xhrk dks vaxzsth esa vuqfnr djus okys çFke Hkkjrh; *dk'khukFk R;aZcd rsyax*
¼1858&1893½ Fks] tks ,d laL—r fo}ku~ baMksykftLV vkSj ckEcs gkbZdksVZ esa
U;k;k/kh'k FksA bUgksaus çFke ckj 1875 esa xhrk dks vuqfnr dj i| :i esa çdkf'kr
fd;kA bls ckn esa 1882 esa x|&vuwfnr [k.M ds :i esa lkeus vk;k A
eSDlewyj }kjk laikfnr *n lhØsV cqDl v‚Q n bZLV* ds 8osa okY;we ls 8 dk
'kh"kZd " The Bhagavadgita with the Sanatsugatiya and the Anugita" tks fd
1882 esa *n DysjsaMu çsl vkDlQksMZ* ls çdkf'kr fd;k x;kA
rsyax ds xhrk ds vuqfnr [kaM esa *lukRlqtkfr vkSj vuqxhrk* ds vuqfnr Hkkx Hkh
'kkfey gSA luRlqtkrh; egkHkkjr ds m|ksx ioZ esa _f"k;ksa lur lqtkrk }kjk va/ks
jktk /k`rjk"Vª dks i<+kus ds :i esa çdV gksrk gSA ;g ,d nk'kZfud lkfgR; gS]
ftldh jpuk ik¡p v/;k;ksa esa vFkkZr~ ¼v/;k; 41&46 ½ esa dh xbZ gSA
vuqxhrk &vuqxhrk dk vFkZ gS xhrk dk vuqlj.k djus okyhA egkHkkjr ds v'oes/k
ioZ esa Hkxon~xhrk dh vxyh dM+h ds :i fn[kkbZ nsrh gSA ;g fQj ls —".k vkSj
vtqZu ds chp lEokn gSA ;g lEokn bUæçLFk esa [Link] ds egy esa gksrk gS]
D;ksafd —".k dq:{ks= ds ;q) esa viuh thr ds ckn [Link] dks gfLrkukiqj ds jkT;
dks fnykus djus esa enn djus ds ckn }kjdk okil vk, FksA dk'khukFk R;aZcd
rsyax eSDlewyj }kjk laikfnr ÞThe secred Book of the eastß uked ifo= iqLrd
ds okY;we esa ;ksxnku djus okys nks fo}kuksa esa 'kkfey FksA ,d Lo;a Fks rks nwljs
vkjå thå [Link] FksA fo}rk vkSj fofo/krk dh –f"V ls rsyax dh xhrk vuqokn
dks Hkkjr esa vf/kd yksdfç;rk feyh fdUrq bls baXyS.M esa xEHkhj :i ls [;kfr
ugha feyhA
rsyax ds ckjs esa ,Mfou vukZYM us xhrk ds vius vuqokn ifjp; esa fy[kk gS fd
"Mr- Telang has also published at Bombay a version in colloqulal rhythm]
eminently learned and intelligent] but not conveying the dignity or grace of
the original" vFkkZr~ buds dgus dk vk'k; ;g Fkk fd xhrk dk vke cksypky dh
y; esa ,d laLdj.k çdkf'kr fd;k tks O;kid :i ls çpfyr vkSj fo}[Link] gS
ysfdu ;g ewy dh xfjek dks O;ä ugha djrk gSA
110
xhrk ds çeq[k fopkjksa ij ,d fo}[Link] xw<+ [Link] fFk;kslksfQLV nsrs gSaA eksfguh
eksgu pVthZ ¼1858&1936½ esa caxky fFk;kslksfQdy lkslk;Vh vkSj fFk;kslksfQdy
ewoesaV ds [Link] lnL; FksA bUgksaus xhrk dk vuqokn ‘Bhagavad Gita or the
Lord's Lay' 1887 esa fd;kA fofy;e Doku tt us vius fuca/kksa esa xhrk ¼1890½ esa
egkHkkjr dh iwjh rjg ls ,d rjQk O;k[;k çLrqr dhA
1785 esa xhrk dk vuqokn ;wjksi vkSj vesfjdh ns'kksa esa loZ= QSy x;k vkSj yksxksa
dks ljyrk ls u;s&u;s vuqokn miyC/k gksus yxsA Hkxon~xhrk dk foLrkj gksus
ij ml le; bls vFkksZ vkSj Hkkoksa ds lkFk foLrkfjr fd;kA
Hkxon~xhrk dk O;kid çpkj gks tkus ij bldks çklafxdrk ds lkFk le`) fd;k
x;k rFkk xhrk ds çklafxd igyqvksa dks lkeus yk;k x;kA ftlls blds u;s
Jksrkvksa vkSj fofHkUu ftKklkvksa dk lek/kku gqvkA Hkxon~xhrk ds vuqokn dk
jkspd bfrgkl gSA
Jh fe'kdk flUgk us vius 'kks/ki= " A History of the Gita’s Translational
Reception 1785-1945" esa cgqr gh ;ksX;[Link] lw{e cqf) ls xhrk ds vuqokn vkSj
O;k[;k dks 18oha 'krkCnh ds ckn j[kkA
og vius 'kks/ki= dh Hkwfedk esa fy[krh gS fd – ‘The Gita as a received and
Translated teat was significantly altered (during this period) in certain
specific ways which contines to influence its present understanding both in
the west and in India-
blds i'pkr~ 1809 esa fofYdUl dk vuqokn dqN lq/kkj djds la'kksf/kr
[Link] es Øe'k% 1849] 1985] 1959 vkSj 1970 esa çkIr gqvkA viuh
çLrkouk esa fofYdUl us Lo;a fy[kk dh esjs xhrk dk vaxzsth esa vuqokn djus
dk ,dek= mís'; ;g Fkk fd&
"To Incourage a form of monotheist Unitarianisms and draw Hinduesm
away from the polytheism ascribed to the vedas-""
‘Bhagvada gita : The song of god, writteen by swami Pra Bhavanand &
christofar Introduced by Aduld huxaly Huxlly published by vedanta
113
press U-S-A Hollywood M- Rodd-co-1944.
9- tså ,ohå cqbVsu }kjk vuqokfnr ,oa tsEl ,y fQVtjxkYM }kjk lEikfnr
,oa xhrk]“The Bhagavadgita in the Mahabharata : A Bilingual Edition
Translated by J-A- B- Van Buitcenen- Edited by James L- Fitzerald. The
university Chicago Press, Chicogo, 1981'.
xhrk dk vuqokn 50 ls vf/kd Hkk"kkvksa esa fd;k x;k gS A iwohZ vkSj if'peh Hkk"kkvksa
esa bl ij lSdM+ksa fVIif.k;k¡ gSA Hkkjr ds ckgj xhrk dks fgUnw /keZ dks le>us dk
igyk ek/;e vkSj lcls çFke dk;Z ekuk tkrk gSA
1. Richard H- Davis
“The Bhagavad Gita : A Biography, Princeton university" esa fy[krs gS fd
"The work has lived a Vivid and contentious existence over the centuries
since, through readings and recitations translations and commentaries
that have transcribed this classic into many currents and disputes-
115
Thus the medival Hindu Gurus, British colovial scholars, German
romantics, Globetrotting spiritual speakers, Indian anticalonial Freedom
fighters, western students and spritual seekers all have engaged in
dialogue with the Gita, each in his/her own manner-
116
vBkjgoha vkSj mUuhloha 'krkCnh ds 'kq#vkr esa Hkxon~xhrk dks dkO;xhr ;k
ifo='kkL= ds :i esa ekuus ds vis{kk nk'kZfud ç—fr ds lkfgR; ds :i esa
ekuk tkus yxkA fofYdUl ds bl dk;Z us lkekU; ikBdksa ds vfrfjä bZlkbZ
fe'kujh dk /;ku vkdZf"kr fd;k rFkk fgUnw fl}kUrksa dk lkeuk djus ds fy,
bldk bLrseky fd;kA
3- fofy;e CySd
fofy;e CySd us 1809 esa viuh rLohj *n jksfeu* esa jksekafVd dkO; crk;k
vkSj vuqokn ij dk;Z dj jgs fofYdUl vkSj fo}ku~ czkã.kksa dks fpf=r fd;kA
Cysd ds fp= us lq>ko fn;k fd xhrk dk egRo xqIr Kku ds :i esa
ckSf)d Je vkSj 'kkgh fot; ds ek/;e ls igys ls fNih gqbZ ijEijk ds Hkhrj
vius vKkr :i ls çkIr gqvkA
dkQh vuqdwy ifjfLFkfr;ksa ds okotwn Hkh fofYdUl ds vuqokn us vius
çkjfEHkd n'kdksa esa T;knk egÙo çkIr ugha fd;kA /khjs&/khjs ftKklk Lo:i
fo}kuksa }kjk bls xEHkhj v/;;u ds fy, txg nh xbZA fofy;e tksUl us mu
yksxksa dks vk'khokZnkRed ;g lykg nh fd Þ from a correct idea of Indian
religion and literature to forget all that has been written on the subject,
by ancients and moderns, before the publication of Gita (Jones 1799-
363) " fofYdUl ds vuqokn us iwjs ;wjksi ds lkFk vVykafVd esa viuk jkLrk
cuk fn;kA tgk¡ ;g vesfjdh Vªkl
a dsMsVfyLrkS ds fy, ,d çeq[k xzUFk cu
x;kA
4- Fkkel dkykbZy
Fkkel dkykbZy us xhrk ds fofYdUl ds vuqokn dh ,d çfr jkYQ okYMks
,elZu dks çLrqr dhA tks muds ç[Link] dk lcls cM+k lzksr lkfcr gqbZA blls
dkudkMZ Hkh çHkkfor FkkA vesfjdk vU; lHkh lkeku vkUnksyuksa ds fy,
dkudkMZ dk _.kh FkkA
mUuhloha vkSj chloha 'krkCnh ds çkjEHk esa Hkxon~xhrk ds çk;% lHkh vuqokndksa
us bls lkfgfR;d dk;Z] ,d dkO; ;k nk'kZfud dkO; ds :i esa ekuk ysfdu
'kkL= ds :i esa ugha ekukA
5- tså tså dkdcuZ FkkEilu] ,Mfou vukZYM vkSj tku Msfol
tså tså dkdcuZ FkkEilu 1853 esa Hkxon~xhrk ;k Þ The saered Lay – A
Sanskrit philosophical poem" rFkk tku Msfolus 1882 esa fgUnw n'kZu
Hkxon~xhrk ;k "The sacred lay & A Sanskrit philosophical poem. rFkk
,Mfou vukZYM us ¼1900½ esa n lkax lsysfLV;y ;k Hkxon~xhrk Þ The song
celestial or Bhagavad-Gita Famous Marvellous Sanskrit" dks çfl)
vn~Hkqr laL—r dkO; ds :i esa lUnfHkZr djrs gSaA ftlesa ljy ,oa vkn'kZ
Hkk"kk ds :i esa nk'kZfud ç.kkyh dks çLrqr djrk gS A
,Mfou vukZYM us Hkxon~xhrk ds vius vuqokn dh çLrkouk esa fy[kk gS fd
'Bhagavad Gita as famous mavelous sanskrit poem in which in Plan and
noble language- it unflods a philosophical systems.' vkSj mldk fo'okl
117
Fkk fd tc ;g vuqfnr gksxk rks vaxzsth lkfgR; dks c<+k;sxkA
6- Jh iqjksfgr Lokeh
Jh iqjksfgr ¼1882&1946½ esa fgUnw fHk{kq FkkA og 1931 esa fczVus ls Hkkjr vk;kA
bUgksaus Hkkjrh; n'kZu vkSj Hkxon~xhrk ij O;k[;ku nsus dh J`a[kyk ls dk;Z
'kq: fd;kA
iqjksfgr Lokeh ,d çfl) vk;fj'k dfo] ukVddkj vkSj lkfgR; ds {ks= esa
ukscy iqjLdkj ds fotsrk (W-B- yets½ MCyw] chå ,Vl ds lEidZ esa vk;sA
ftudks vk/;kfRedrk ls xgjk yxko FkkA bUgksaus fFk;kslksfQdy lkslk;Vh ds
ek/;e ls 1886 esa fgUnw n'kZu dks çLrqr fd;k FkkA
iqjksfgr Lokeh dh nks iqLrdksa ds ckjs esa MCY;w chå ;‚V~l us crk;k çFke
iqLrd 1932 esa eSdfeyu yanu ls çdkf'kr gqbZ ftldk gS& 'kh"kZd "An
Indian monk with introduction by W. B. yeats- f}rh; iqLrd 1934 esa
QSoj ,.M QSoj yanu ls çdkf'kr gqbZ A ftldk 'kh"kZd " Bhagwan Shri
Hamsa, The Holy mountain, Translated by Shri Purohit Swami with
Introduction-"
118
8- ,å ohå oSu oqbVsu
,å ohå oSu oqbVsu ,d ikjEifjd fo}ku o vuqoknd FksA ;s f'kdkxks
fo'ofo|ky; ds (South Asian Languages and civilizations) nf{k.k ,f'k;kbZ
Hkk"kkvksa vkSj lH;rkvksa ds foHkkx esa laL—r ds ,d [Link] vkSj çksQslj
FksA vius LoYi thou ds vUr esa bUgksaus eq[; :i ls egkHkkjr ds v/;;u ij
/;ku dsfUær fd;kA tsElå ,yå fQV~ tjxkYM }kjk lEikfnr ,å ohå oSu
oqbVsu }kjk Hkxonxhrk dk vuqokn vkSj muds [Link] 1981 esa xhrk ds
fo}kuksa vkSj mRlkgh Nk=ksa }kjk cgqr vf/kd ewY;kafdr fd;k x;kA egÙ[Link]
vuqokn ds vk/kkj ij mldk vuqokn vkSj xgjkbZ ls fo}kuksa ds }kjk ifjp;
vkSj dbZ mi;ksxh ikn fVIif.k;ksa ds lkFk v/;;u fd;k x;kA bldh ç[Link]
çLrqfr vkSj Li"Vrk dks Li"V djus ds fy, ç'kalk dh tkrh gSA ;g vius
'kq) çfriknu vkSj ewyikB dh çR;{krk dks cuk,¡ j[kus ds fy, ç'kaflr gSA
9- ,dukFk bZ'oju
,d ukFk bZ'oj ,d fo}ku vkSj vk/;kfRed f'k{kd FksA ftUgksaus /;ku ij dbZ
iqLrdsa fy[khaA mUgksaus Hkxon~xhrk] mifu"kn~ vkSj /kEein dk Hkh vuqokn fd;kA
dgk tkrk gS fd bZ'oju us xhrk esa xk¡/kh ds çHkko esa :fp fodflr dh ftls
;g viuh NksVh mez esa feys FksA Hkxon~xhrk dk ,dukFk bZ'oju dk vuqokn
Li"V ,oa lqUnj 'kCnksa esa vaxzsth esa çLrqr fd;k tks i<+us esa ljy gSA ,dukFk
bZ'oju us rhu [[Link] esa [Link] Hkh nh 'The Bhagavad Gita for Daily
living’ rFkk lkFk esa Hkxon~xhrk ds lkj ds fy, Hkxon~xhrk ds lkj uked
,d ljy [Link] Hkh dhA
bZ'oju us xhrk dh f'k{kkvksa dks vk/kqfud lUnHkZ esa mi;ksxh crk;kA ç—fr dh
okLrfodrk] vyko dk Hkze] igpku dh [kkst] ;ksx dk vFkZ vkSj Hkfä dks
O;ofLFkr djus ds rjhds ds ckjs esa xhrk ij fopkj fd;k x;k gSA ;g iqLrd
xhrk ds eq[; lans'k dks /;ku esa j[krh gS fd /;ku vkSj vk/;kfRed fo"k;ksa ds
vH;kl ds ek/;e ls gekjs la?k"kZ dks dSls gy fd;k tk, vkSj thou dh xgjh
,drk ds cuk, j[ks A
10- fØLVksQj bZ'ojoqM
fØLVksQj bZ'ojoqM ,d vaxzsth miU;kldkj] ukVddkj vkSj ys[kd FkkA 1925
esa ØSfEczt ;wfuoflZVh NksM+us ds ckn bUgksua s vius Ldwy ds nksLr MCY;w MîwMu
ds lkFk ¼1907&1973½ rd ;wjksi vkSj fQj phu ¼1938½ esa ;k=k dhA
bZ'ojoqM vkSj MîwMu us bXyS.M esa okeiaFkh lkfgR; ds rhloha ih<+h ds
'kq:vkrh dksj dk xBu fd;k A
tuojh 1939 esa vkMu vkSj bZ'ojoqM us ,MDl gDlys ls fe=rk dh] ftldk
mUgksaus dHkh&dHkh lg;ksx fd;kA ;s gDlys ds ek/;e ls nf{[Link] dSfyQksfuZ;k
ds osnkUr lkslk;Vh ds çeq[k Lokeh çHkokuUn ds lEidZ esa vk;s vkSj muds
f'k"; cu x;sA Lokeh çHkokuUn ds lkFk dj feydj bZ'ojoqM us Hkxon~xhrk
dk ,d u;k vaxzsth vuqokn fd;k ftls ckn esa çdkf'kr fd;k x;k A
bZ'ojoqM iwjh rjg ls fHk{kq ugha ou ik;s fQj Hkh çR;sd lIrkg eafnj esa vius
thou ds ckdh fgLlksa esa] çkFkZuk djus vkSj O;k[;ku djus ds fy, fgUnw cuk
119
vkSj dbZ dke Hkh fd;sA ftlesa thouh ds :i esa Ramkrishna &Disciples
1965 esa fy[kkA viuh vfUre iqLrd " My Guru & Disciples " 1980 esa vius
fgUnw /keZ ds ifjorZu Lokeh çHkokuan ds leiZ.k dks vafdr fd;k gSA
11- bZlkbZ e'khujh vuqoknksa dh –f"V
bZlkbZ e'khujh vuqokndksa dh –f"V esa dsoy ;g nk'kZfud Kku Fkk ftls tkuus
dh t:jr gS ysfdu fuf'pr :i ls ;g ifo= xzUFk ugha gSA bUgksaus fuf'pr
:i ls Hkxon~xhrk ds vewrZ n'kZu vkSj nsorkvksa dh [Link] dFkkvksa esa fufgr
fgUnw va/kfo'oklksa ds chp vUrj fd;k tks Øwjrk vkSj okluk ls fyIr FkkA
tkuMsfol us 1882 esa fy[kk gS fd&
"This while the high philosophy of Bhagavad gita might approximates
some where near to Christian principles. it would not be adequate to
redeem the lost souls of the Hindu. bl çdkj fgUnw /keZ vkSj xhrk ij
fe'kujh ys[ku dk çkFkfed mís'; ;g Fkk fd ;g mu dk;ksaZ dh ekU;rkvksa dks
tku lds ftUgsa os cnyuk pkgrs Fks ftlls Hkfo"; ds fe'kuj bZlkbZ /keZ dh
j{kk djus ds fy, rS;kj gks ldsA
;|fi fe'kujh vkSj lkezkT;oknh fgr ges'kk esy ugha [kkrs Fks] ysfdu bl rjg
dh vuqokn&xfrfof/k us Hkkjrh; laL—fr ds çeq[k igyqvksa ds ckjs esa Kku dk
,d ek/;e cukus esa enn dh] tks nksuksa vius&vius mís';ksa ds fy, vkdf"kZr
vkSj mi;ksx dj ldrs FksA O;k[;k ds lk>k rjhds] Hkk"kkvksa ds çfr lk>k –
f"Vdks.k] muds vUrlZEcU/kksa vkSj lk>k vuqokn rduhdksa us muds xSj ;wjksih;
,oa vU; dh lk>k le> esa ;ksxnku fn;kA
mifu"kn~ ,oa xhrk nksuksa gh ekuo lekt vkSj thou dks O;ofLFkr :i ls pykus ds
fy, [Link] gSA Hkkjrh; lekt ij rks mifu"kn~ ,oa xhrk dk çHkko lk{kkr~ :i
ls ns[kk gh tk ldrk gSA blds lkFk gh if'peh ns'kksa ds lekt ij Hkh budk
çHkko Li"V:i ls fn[kkbZ nsrk gSA blh dkj.k fdlh us bUgsa jgL;kRed Kku dh
dq¡th dgk gS rks dksbZ eks{k çkfIr ds vfUre lk/ku ds :i esa Lohdkj djrk gSA
mifu"kn~ vkSj xhrk nksauks gh Hkkjrh; Kku ds [Link] gSa vr% nksauks dk LFkku
vf}rh; gSA mifu"knksa dh la[;k yxHkx ƒåŠ Lohdkj dh tkrh gSA ftuesa ls ƒå
mifu"knksa ij vkpk;Z 'kadj dk Hkk"; çkIr gksrk gSA bu mifu"knksa esa tho] txr]
vkRek] ijekRek] czã] ijk] vijk vkfn fo|kvksa dh ckj&ckj ppkZ dh xbZ gSA bu
fo|kvksa dks –"VkUrksa ds ek/;e ls ekuo thou ds okLrfod lR; dks le>kus dk
ç;kl fd;k x;k gSA ftldk if'peh lekt ij Hkh xgjk çHkko fn[kkbZ nsrk gSA
xhrk&Hkkjrh; ,oa if'peh nksauks lektksa ij xhrk dk xgjk çHkko gqvk gSA
v/;kRe–çcU/ku ls ysdj lkekU; thou ds NksVs&NksVs o [Link] fo"k;ksa ds ysdj
xhrk esa 'kyksdksa ds ek/;e ls mudk [Link] o lek/kku fn;k x;k gSA fo'o dh 121
yxHkx ‡å Hkk"kkvksa esa xhrk dk vuqokn gks pqdk gSA ftlls blds egRo o
mi;ksfxrk dks le>k tk ldrk gSA xhrk vkSj mifu"kn~ nksuksa gh if'peh lekt ds
fy, Hkh ,d vkn'kZ cudj mHkjs gSaA vr% bu nksuksa ds çHkko dks if'peh lekt esa
Li"V:i ls ns[kk tk ldrk gSA
mifu"kn~ vkSj xhrk ds vuqokn çpkj&çlkj dk dk;Z Hkkjr lfgr ;wjksih; ns'kksa esa
vuojr :i ls gksrk jgk gSA Hkkjrh; fo}ku~ Lokeh foosdkuUn] johUæ ukFk VSxksj]
vkpk;Z fouksck Hkkos] Mk̆- loZiYyh jk/kk—".ku~ ,oa ik'pkR; fo}ku~ eSDlewyj] Mh-
áwe] 'kksiugkoj] pkyZ~l tkuLVj] vkVks oksV fyad] jkcVZ vusZLV] iky Mk;lu vkfn
xhrk ds HkkSfrd vkSj vk/;kfRed egRo dh ppkZ djrs gq, mldh Hkwjh&Hkwjh ç'kalk
dh gSA xhrk dks ysdj Hkh ik'pkR; vkSj Hkkjrh; fo}kuksa dk er xzg.k djus ;ksX;
gSA nksuksa gh izdkj ds fo}ku xhrk dks ysdj cgqr gh mRlqd fn[kk;h nsrs gSaA dqN
Hkkjrh; vkSj ik'pkR; fo}ku jgsa gSa ftUgksaus xhrk ds çfr viuh KkufyIlk dh
vfHkO;fä dh gSA Hkkjrh; fo}ku~ dk'khukFk R;aZcd rsyax xhrkçsl xksj[kiqj us
chloha 'krkCnh dh 'kq#vkr esa vke yksxksa ds chp xhrk ds lUns'k dks QSykus dk
egku dk dk;Z fd;kA Mk̆- vkj th- [Link]] Vh- vkj- Jhfuokl v;axj vkfn
fo}kuksa us Hkh xhrk dk vuqokndk;Z fd;k ftlls Hkkjr lfgr if'peh txr esa
xhrk ds Kku dk çokg rst+ gks ldkA
ik'pkR;ksa esa fFk;ksfQLVksa }kjk 1785 esa xhrk dk vaxzsth vuqokn fd;k x;kA ftlds
ckn bldk foLrkj ;wjksi vkSj vesfjdk rd QSykA
Jh fe'kdk flUgk] pkyZ~l fofYdUl] gsujh MsfoM Fkksjks] ts- jkcVZ] 'kksisugkoj vkSj
,YMl gDlys vkfn us vius 'kks/ki=ksa ,oa vuqoknksa ds ek/;e ls xhrk ds nk'kZfud
Kku ls fo'o dks —rkFkZ fd;kA Msfol us ;g irk yxk;k fd egkRek xk¡/kh vkSj
Lokeh foosdkuUn us fdl çdkj Hkkjrh; LorU=rk laxzke esa xhrk dk ç;ksx fd;kA
Ýkalhlh vuqoknd thu Msfol ykatqukbl] vCcs ijkans] teZu vuqoknd 'ysxy]
Ýkat FkVZeSu gsufld fgedj] iqjksfgr Lokeh o vU; ik'pkR; fo}ku~ Richard H
Davis] fofy;e Cysd] Fkkel dkykbZy] ts ts dkdcuZ] FkkEilu] ,M+fou vukZYM]
fØLVksQj bZ'oj oqM vkfn fo}kuksa us viuh cqf) ds vuq:i xhrk n'kZu ij vius
fopkj vkSj vuqokn dk;Z fd;s] ftlls if'peh lkfgR; le`) gqvk rFkk lekt dh
l`tukRedrk esa Hkh o`f) gqbZA
122
1. Gita https:/htm wikipedia org/wiki/ Srimat Bhagvat [Link]
-com/Tag/Travlcution of the bitainto-europeah Language.
2. The Bhagavad Gita and the west: The Esoteric Significance of the
Bhagavad gita and its pelatior to the Epistles of poul by Rudolf Steeiner-
3. Bhagavad Gita & world Religions
4. Impact of Bhagvad Gita on west/Arise Bharat
5. Influence of Bhagavad Gita Wikipedia the free encyclopaedia
6- Jones A- Hijiya. The gita of Robert oppunheimer Proceeding of the
American Philosophy Society
7. The Gita of Ji Robert Oppenhinver by Jams a Hijiya.
8. Prof- of History University of massachusetts-
9- Jhen~Hkkxon~xhrk] e/kqlwnu ljLorh—r xwBkFkZnhfidk laL—rVhdk rFkk
çfrHkkHkk"; fgUnh lfgr
10- Jhen~Hkkxon~xhrk] ,lå jk/kk—".ku] —r O;k[;k dk fgUnh vuqokn jktiky
,.M lUl ƒ‹ˆ‹
11- 'kkgtknk eqgEen nkjkf'kdksg —r fljsZ vuqokn] ‡å mifu"knksa dh Qkjlh dk
vuqokn lfgr lkuqokn] Hkqou okuh VªLV y[kuÅ] ƒ‹‰‡
12- Introduction to Sirr 1 Akbar, or the Persian Translation of the
upanishadas by Dara Shukoh, Tara Cand, Taban Printing Press 1957
13- [Link] mifu"knksa dk Qkjlh vuqokn
14- Jhen~Hkkxonxhrk O;k[;kdkj enu eksgu vxzoky] pkS[kEck laL—r çfr"Bku]
[Link]] ƒ‹Š†
15- Deussen, The Philosophy of the Upanishads
1- 10
2- vkSifu[kr ];g 1809 esa çdkf'kr gqvkA
3- ftczk,y] ehdkby vkSj bL=kthyA
4- dB] ç'u vkSj NkUnksX; A
5- Mh- áwe A
1- lR;
2- vlR;
3- lR;
4- lR;
5- lR;
124