Sentence Structure: Constituents
What is Structure
When anything can be analysed in the following way, we
say that it has structure:
(a) It is divisible into parts (called constituents),
(b) There are different kinds of parts (different categories
of constituents),
(c) The constituents are arranged in a specifiable way,
(d) That each constituent has a certain specifiable
function in the structure of the thing as a whole.
Sentence Structure
Complex things often have hierarchical structure.
A sentence is not just a collection of randomly
assembled words.
When a sequence of words fails to constitute a good
expression in the language, it is described as being
ungrammatical (or ill-formed) and marked with an
asterisk (*).
Sentence Structure
Here are some examples:
[1a] *disappears none girls of the students
[1b] *Max will bought a frying pans.
[1c] *Dick believes he to be a genius.
[1d] *Dick believes himself is a genius.
[1e] *Bevis went to the circus and Max did so to the zoo.
Sentence Structure
Ultimately, a full syntactic description of any language
consists in explaining why some strings of words of
the language are well-formed (grammatical)
expressions and why others are ill-formed
(ungrammatical). And this could not be achieved
without recognising structure.
Sentence Structure
What do sentences consist of?
Are words the immediate constituents of the sentences that contain them?
To answer these questions, let us draw a tree diagram for the sentence:
[2] Old Sam sunbathed beside a stream.
If we draw the diagram in the following way, we do not show the sentence structure:
Sentence
Old Sam sunbathed beside a stream
Sentence Structure
[3] *Stream old Sam sunbathed beside a
[4] *Sunbathed old beside stream a Sam
We need to say that sentence [2] is more highly structured than the
tree diagram says it is. The position of words in a sentence is
determined by the fact that the words are not immediate
constituents of the sentence, but belong with other words to form
groups – phrases – which have their own position in the structure
of the sentence. It is these phrases (and further phrases made up of
these phrases) that function as immediate constituents of the
sentence. In short, while sentences certainly contain words, they
don’t consist of words. They consist of phrases.